Discussion
For own personal use - basic is that I want to upload a DVD to my phone so I can watch it wherever. I'm not interested in copying to upload to the internet and will never do this - or allow anybody else to have access to this. It will sit on my hard drive until I copy it to the memory card in my phone.
Is this illegal?
Is this illegal?
nipsips said:
For own personal use - basic is that I want to upload a DVD to my phone so I can watch it wherever. I'm not interested in copying to upload to the internet and will never do this - or allow anybody else to have access to this. It will sit on my hard drive until I copy it to the memory card in my phone.
Is this illegal?
Strictly speaking it's not legal, but none of the agencies I've worked for would bother about it. They're more interested in large-scale distribution without permission.Is this illegal?
You are hardly likely to be caught, since you would not be sharing it with anybody.
I have done this several times with my netbook, so I could watch films while on holiday.
I know several people who now do this with a USB stick so they can plug it into their TV rather than use a DVD player.
I have done this several times with my netbook, so I could watch films while on holiday.
I know several people who now do this with a USB stick so they can plug it into their TV rather than use a DVD player.
nipsips said:
For own personal use - basic is that I want to upload a DVD to my phone so I can watch it wherever. I'm not interested in copying to upload to the internet and will never do this - or allow anybody else to have access to this. It will sit on my hard drive until I copy it to the memory card in my phone.
Is this illegal?
There have been a number of changes to the law since it was of concern to me, so it 'used to be' that:Is this illegal?
If you buy a DVD you can make a copy of the DVD for your own use as a back-up. You cannot distribute it either by selling it or giving it away.
If you sell/give away the original you have to give the copy or destroy it as possession would be seen as illegal.
However, if it is copy-protected it is illegal to copy the DVD despite you having a legal right to do so. If someone else copies it for you (whether you knew or not is another matter) possession a copy of a DVD you bought yourself is not illegal.
What the previous poster said is, or rather was, to my knowledge quite correct. Those who own the copyright to DVD and such are only interested if you sell such stuff on, or give it away. Even then, it is only big time dealers.
I was told that they would not want to explain to a court why they are blocking a person from making a copy of something he is legally entitled to.
Possession of DVD ripping software is an offence I believe.
My shift discovered a chap who was copying CDs of a boyband (that should have been an offence for a start). We were called by the stars' management to this chap who was selling DVDs and (better quality) logoed T-shirts outside the hall where they were playing to a capacity audience.
After arrest we found in his rooms banks of copying machines: put the original in one device and about two dozen came out the other end in minutes. The management would not support a prosecution as it wasn't worth their while. So we gave the bloke back all the gear and told trading standards, who were not interested.
technoluddite said:
Derek Smith said:
Possession of DVD ripping software is an offence I believe.
I'm not sure this is correct. I don't believe the Digital Economy Act addressed it, and can't think of any existing legislation that could be interpreted in such a way.Happy to be educated though!
As you say, I might be wrong. I didn't look it up and it is only hearsay. Does anyone know one way or the other?
As an aside, I was in 'half blues', which is uniform with a civilian coat over the top. As those selling certain items caught sight of us there was a degree of panic. Word went around and a couple of tables were just left as the sellers went for a constitutional with their money. The trading standards chap said that they would not be back. I asked him what would happen to their DVDs and CDs. He said "The others will help themselves and sell them next week."
Derek Smith said:
It's what I've been told, I think by trading standards, this during a walk through of a boot fair at Brighton railway station yard. It was specifically software that allowed to to crack the protection on DVDs. It might just be an offence to sell it?
It isn't illegal own software that backup up your data (owned or licensed) even if it 'cracks' blu ray copy protection, provided it is for your own personal use.Selling or redistributing the backed up data is, though from your example not serious, oddly.
There is a difference between civil breaches and criminal breaches.
At the moment (but possibly soon to be changed) it is 'against the law' to make copies of any copyrighted work (assumign no exemption applies) without the consent of the copyright holder. This is a civil breach - which gives the copyright owner the right to sue.
So if you just copy your own CDs, although there is technically a breach of the law - nothign is actually going to happen.
To commit a criminal offence you have to share or sell copyrighted material on a much larger scale - more than what we might call personal copying.
As for software to assist in copying, perhaps they were referring to this section
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/sectio...
At the moment (but possibly soon to be changed) it is 'against the law' to make copies of any copyrighted work (assumign no exemption applies) without the consent of the copyright holder. This is a civil breach - which gives the copyright owner the right to sue.
So if you just copy your own CDs, although there is technically a breach of the law - nothign is actually going to happen.
To commit a criminal offence you have to share or sell copyrighted material on a much larger scale - more than what we might call personal copying.
As for software to assist in copying, perhaps they were referring to this section
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/sectio...
Mojooo said:
There is a difference between civil breaches and criminal breaches.
At the moment (but possibly soon to be changed) it is 'against the law' to make copies of any copyrighted work (assumign no exemption applies) without the consent of the copyright holder. This is a civil breach - which gives the copyright owner the right to sue.
So if you just copy your own CDs, although there is technically a breach of the law - nothign is actually going to happen.
To commit a criminal offence you have to share or sell copyrighted material on a much larger scale - more than what we might call personal copying.
As for software to assist in copying, perhaps they were referring to this section
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/sectio...
That seems to fit the bill, so to speak. This was around 91/92 and the legislation was described as 'new'. At the moment (but possibly soon to be changed) it is 'against the law' to make copies of any copyrighted work (assumign no exemption applies) without the consent of the copyright holder. This is a civil breach - which gives the copyright owner the right to sue.
So if you just copy your own CDs, although there is technically a breach of the law - nothign is actually going to happen.
To commit a criminal offence you have to share or sell copyrighted material on a much larger scale - more than what we might call personal copying.
As for software to assist in copying, perhaps they were referring to this section
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/sectio...
We were after some lowish value jewellery being sold on a stall which was the proceeds of a burglary a couple of days before. One of my PCs (LBO on a rest day, no pay) had gone with the victim to the boot fare and the loser had identified the property. A dispute occurred and a supervisor was asked to attend. Trading standards were also informed and met me at the entrance. So my mind was elsewhere.
We couldn't get the bloke for handling although he did give us a name.
The TS chap felt that the legislation was too complex as no one could know it all unless it was their job. Much of it, he said, was contradictory.
But it was amusing to see the fleeing stallholders and the neighbouring ones eyeing up the remains.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


