Need advice on failure to insure
Need advice on failure to insure
Author
Discussion

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
I've just received a penalty for failure to insure one of my motorcycle, but believe that I have not broken the law due to the circumstances:

In July, shipped the vehicle to Israel as I need to make use of it during multiple visits I have been making there over the last few months.

The bike is still in Israel and will most likely be returning it to the UK in early 2014, but I won't be leaving it there for more than one year since the date of shipment. As far as I'm aware, there was no requirement to declare the bike as an export due to the fact that the bike will be coming back within a year.

There is no insurance company in the UK that will insure the motorcycle for use outside the EU - or at least in Israel - and I therefore cancelled my insurance policy in the UK and took one out with an insurance company based in Israel. The vehicle is, however, still taxed in the UK.

I made the MID aware of this when they initially sent me a reminder, but they seem to have just ignored this.

Does the DVLA have any grounds to prosecute me? Clearly, I would not want to pay to insure myself for something that I'm not doing!

Thanks


TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
I think your problem is that you should have canceled the tax.

You can not have tax but no insurance.

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
I followed the advice from here:

https://www.gov.uk/taking-vehicles-out-of-uk/for-l...

"But a UK-registered vehicle exported temporarily remains subject to UK law. That means that you need to make sure it is taxed in the UK while it’s abroad."

There's no mention about keeping the bike insured though.

trickywoo

14,288 posts

261 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
I followed the advice from here:

https://www.gov.uk/taking-vehicles-out-of-uk/for-l...

"But a UK-registered vehicle exported temporarily remains subject to UK law. That means that you need to make sure it is taxed in the UK while it’s abroad."

There's no mention about keeping the bike insured though.
Sounds like a test case may be a possibility. Might be worth seeing if one of those no win no fee companies may be interested in some free publicity.

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Or hopefully some more PHs will offer more advice and I'll challenge it myself. There's no way I'm willing to pay to insure myself for something I'm not doing.

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
I followed the advice from here:

https://www.gov.uk/taking-vehicles-out-of-uk/for-l...

"But a UK-registered vehicle exported temporarily remains subject to UK law. That means that you need to make sure it is taxed in the UK while it’s abroad."

There's no mention about keeping the bike insured though.
There is, within the Continuous Insurance legislation itself though (and this bit of UK law is, admittedly and like so many from the past decade or so, not well thought out at all in that it completely misses those who it is aimed at and instead ensnares people such as yourself frown ).

smile

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
So it worth taking this to court, or is there a strict statutory obligation to 'continuously' insure your bike, regardless of circumstances like mine?

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
So it worth taking this to court, or is there a strict statutory obligation to 'continuously' insure your bike, regardless of circumstances like mine?
My understanding was that it had to be either:
1. SORN, or
2. Insured
However that applies to cars in the UK. No idea how it applies to cars which are not currently in the UK.

I assume, from what you said above, that you didn't do anything regards telling the DVLA that it was out of the country, and nor did you cancel the tax. So for sure their records would show the car as in the UK and not SORN or insured, hence proceedings initiated.

I think (as you already know) you need to find out what the actual law is on this. Keep us up to date as it sounds interesting.

richard sails

813 posts

290 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
TPS said:
I think your problem is that you should have canceled the tax.

You can not have tax but no insurance.
Yes you can, but you must declare SORN and keep the car off the road. There is no legal requirement to cancel your road tax when you declare SORN.

Ignore what it says on the DVLA website, their info is over simplified to the point of being wrong, you need to read the words on the statute for the full info.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
Does the DVLA have any grounds to prosecute me?
The SORN regulations apply only to vehicles that are kept in Great Britain.

Does the documentation sent to you by DVLA contain any references to the particular law you they think you have contravened ?

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
richard sails said:
Yes you can, but you must declare SORN and keep the car off the road. There is no legal requirement to cancel your road tax when you declare SORN.
I was always under the impression that SORN cancelled the current tax disc, it was up to you whether you cashed in the now decorative piece of paper.

richard sails

813 posts

290 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Engineer1 said:
richard sails said:
Yes you can, but you must declare SORN and keep the car off the road. There is no legal requirement to cancel your road tax when you declare SORN.
I was always under the impression that SORN cancelled the current tax disc, it was up to you whether you cashed in the now decorative piece of paper.
Thats how the DVLA imply it works when you do keep the car/bike off the road as they put a 'note' on the system. However in law there is no mechanism to invalidate the tax disc for a SORN declaration without you returning it. Once you re-insure the car you can take to the roads with the same tax disc, however its worth ringing them to tell them that the car is back on the road with the original tax disc as they sometimes do make the odd mistake!

I have done it several times.


Mill Wheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
So it worth taking this to court, or is there a strict statutory obligation to 'continuously' insure your bike, regardless of circumstances like mine?
Are you riding the bike while in Israel without insurance, or do you have a policy in Israel to cover you?

Just a thought...!

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
Are you riding the bike while in Israel without insurance, or do you have a policy in Israel to cover you?

Just a thought...!
Yes, I had to take out an Israeli insurance policy

Kapenta

1,842 posts

227 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
Are you riding the bike while in Israel without insurance, or do you have a policy in Israel to cover you?

Just a thought...!
OP said:
...There is no insurance company in the UK that will insure the motorcycle for use outside the EU - or at least in Israel - and I therefore cancelled my insurance policy in the UK and took one out with an insurance company based in Israel. The vehicle is, however, still taxed in the UK.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
I followed the advice from here:

https://www.gov.uk/taking-vehicles-out-of-uk/for-l...

"But a UK-registered vehicle exported temporarily remains subject to UK law. That means that you need to make sure it is taxed in the UK while it’s abroad."

There's no mention about keeping the bike insured though.
Well, apart from this bit...

Government website said:
"But a UK-registered vehicle exported temporarily remains subject to UK law.
UK law says any UK-reg motor vehicle must have a UK insurance policy or be SORNed. International reciprocity says that every temp import motor vehicle must be legal in it's home country, as well as meeting whatever local requirements there might be. They'll almost certainly include insurance that covers you in the country. If you have to buy a local policy to top up your home policy, so be it.

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
UK law says any UK-reg motor vehicle must have a UK insurance policy or be SORNed. International reciprocity says that every temp import motor vehicle must be legal in it's home country, as well as meeting whatever local requirements there might be. They'll almost certainly include insurance that covers you in the country. If you have to buy a local policy to top up your home policy, so be it.
True, but it then only defines 'subject to UK law' as meaning that it needs to be taxed. It doesn't make any mention of insurance. That's why I'm unsure.

Mill Wheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Kapenta said:
Mill Wheel said:
Are you riding the bike while in Israel without insurance, or do you have a policy in Israel to cover you?

Just a thought...!
OP said:
...There is no insurance company in the UK that will insure the motorcycle for use outside the EU - or at least in Israel - and I therefore cancelled my insurance policy in the UK and took one out with an insurance company based in Israel. The vehicle is, however, still taxed in the UK.
I was wondering if the policy was still in force while the OP is back in blighty or if it was on a short term basis only.
Copy the policy document and send it in - it then proves where the bike is and that it is insured, and why it wont appear on the MIB database.

Odie

4,187 posts

213 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
I therefore cancelled my insurance policy in the UK and took one out with an insurance company based in Israel. The vehicle is, however, still taxed in the UK.
So it is insured then. Just produce your insurance document and perhaps proof that the vehicle was shipped to Israel. Surely that all you need to do

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Also you can't be insured by two companies at once.

You can't SORN it as that is off the road and if it is off the road then not legal to use on a road