Help very much required please - 'mouthbreather' content.
Discussion
On Friday 8th November, my car was in a pub car park as my band was playing there that night.
At half-time, I came out to my car to plug my phone in to charge it up.
As I opened the drivers door to the car, another vehicle reversed from a space opposite, coming at an angle towards the near-side rear quarter-panel of my car. The pub car park is quite dark, but I could clearly see the other vehicle's rear window was completely misted up inside, affording no rearward visibility whatsoever.
The vehicle crashed into mine, causing damage to the bumper and quarter-panel that I have since had quoted to repair at around £550.
Your man gets out of the car ( a T-reg Astra ) and looks at the damage. It was hard to get intelligible conversation from the gentleman, but I did manage to get a name and address plus phone number. He insisted that the damage would 'polish out' to which I insisted it clearly would not. In the end, he just told me to call him when I had decided what to do, and drove away.
I called, texted and left several messages and received no reply. I sent a letter, and again received no reply.
So I phoned my insurance company. I reported the incident, and they gave me his insurance company's details too. I called his insurance company, and they told me they would speak to him and report back. A week has gone by, so I called his insurance company again today.
The mouthbreather has told them that I was also reversing at the same time, and that the blame was therefore equal (as said, my car was parked and switched off, with the handbrake on). He has also told them that he wouldn't be claiming for any damage to his car.
They therefore told me that they dispute liability and would not deal with me further, and that I must get in touch with my insurance company so that they can liaise with each other.
I have just got off the phone to my insurance company. I am fully comprehensive - and yes, they will pursue the claim - providing I pay my excess of £500 first
otherwise, I can jog on.
That's not going to happen anytime soon - I am a medical student and totally skint.
So I have a damaged car through no fault of my own, that I cannot afford to repair - and no help from anyone, despite being insured fully comprehensive, and the car being parked. With a mouthbreather no doubt laughing at how clever he is.
I am actually really upset about this. When did the world become this way? Especially with insurance companies not willing to do their basic duty until money comes their greedy way?
The question is - VBRJ notwithstanding - where do I go with this? Is it pointless trying to go to his insurance company again as an individual? I would imagine I would just get laughed at.
Private court claim? But I imagine that costs money.
Police? Probably not I guess.
I would love some help and advice please. My car's old and a bit saggy, but it's all I can afford at the moment and I love it
Thanks.
At half-time, I came out to my car to plug my phone in to charge it up.
As I opened the drivers door to the car, another vehicle reversed from a space opposite, coming at an angle towards the near-side rear quarter-panel of my car. The pub car park is quite dark, but I could clearly see the other vehicle's rear window was completely misted up inside, affording no rearward visibility whatsoever.
The vehicle crashed into mine, causing damage to the bumper and quarter-panel that I have since had quoted to repair at around £550.
Your man gets out of the car ( a T-reg Astra ) and looks at the damage. It was hard to get intelligible conversation from the gentleman, but I did manage to get a name and address plus phone number. He insisted that the damage would 'polish out' to which I insisted it clearly would not. In the end, he just told me to call him when I had decided what to do, and drove away.
I called, texted and left several messages and received no reply. I sent a letter, and again received no reply.
So I phoned my insurance company. I reported the incident, and they gave me his insurance company's details too. I called his insurance company, and they told me they would speak to him and report back. A week has gone by, so I called his insurance company again today.
The mouthbreather has told them that I was also reversing at the same time, and that the blame was therefore equal (as said, my car was parked and switched off, with the handbrake on). He has also told them that he wouldn't be claiming for any damage to his car.
They therefore told me that they dispute liability and would not deal with me further, and that I must get in touch with my insurance company so that they can liaise with each other.
I have just got off the phone to my insurance company. I am fully comprehensive - and yes, they will pursue the claim - providing I pay my excess of £500 first
otherwise, I can jog on.That's not going to happen anytime soon - I am a medical student and totally skint.
So I have a damaged car through no fault of my own, that I cannot afford to repair - and no help from anyone, despite being insured fully comprehensive, and the car being parked. With a mouthbreather no doubt laughing at how clever he is.
I am actually really upset about this. When did the world become this way? Especially with insurance companies not willing to do their basic duty until money comes their greedy way?
The question is - VBRJ notwithstanding - where do I go with this? Is it pointless trying to go to his insurance company again as an individual? I would imagine I would just get laughed at.
Private court claim? But I imagine that costs money.
Police? Probably not I guess.
I would love some help and advice please. My car's old and a bit saggy, but it's all I can afford at the moment and I love it

Thanks.
"The world" that you seem to think is against you has ways been this way. Your insurers need to have suffered a loss to exercise their subrogation rights and pursue the claim for you. Without this they have no loss and are therefore legally unable to act.
The excess is applicable as it is an uninsured loss and recoverable once liability is found in your favour. Your insurer does not profit from this. It is a legal and required process.
Don't let that get in the way of you blaming them for it. Also intrigued why they gave you his insurers details. This is a serious breach of protocol.
The excess is applicable as it is an uninsured loss and recoverable once liability is found in your favour. Your insurer does not profit from this. It is a legal and required process.
Don't let that get in the way of you blaming them for it. Also intrigued why they gave you his insurers details. This is a serious breach of protocol.
Edited by LoonR1 on Monday 2nd December 21:32
LoonR1 said:
"The world" that you seem to think is against you has ways been this way. Your insurers need to have suffered a loss to except use their subrogation rights and pursue the claim for you. Without this they have no loss and are therefore legally unable to act.
The excess is applicable as it is an uninsured loss and recoverable once liability is found in your favour. Your insurer does not profit from this. It is a legal and required process.
Don't let that get in the way of you blaming them for it. Also intrigued why they gave you his insurers details. This is a serious breach of protocol.
Well, however it's viewed, morally it's a crock of sThe excess is applicable as it is an uninsured loss and recoverable once liability is found in your favour. Your insurer does not profit from this. It is a legal and required process.
Don't let that get in the way of you blaming them for it. Also intrigued why they gave you his insurers details. This is a serious breach of protocol.
t, is it not?No idea why they gave me his details, but they happily supplied me with his insurance company and policy number...
LoonR1 said:
Excuse for what? Knowing my stuff and having something of value to contribute even if it isn't what some posters want to read?
I guess hard work and an ability to learn.
Possibly the fact you come across as an aI guess hard work and an ability to learn.
hole? Your replies do seem a bit condescending?. I feel for the op, last week my old Jag was bumped up the rear by a lady shunted from behind, not much damage but as the car is worth very little it would be written off. Also as I would have to pay my excess to claim I can appreciate where the op is coming from, maybe £600 is buttons to your good self but I can't afford more than a weeks wages this close to Xmas, as the op can't.Just my 2p's worth
Humper said:
Possibly the fact you come across as an a
hole? Your replies do seem a bit condescending?. I feel for the op, last week my old Jag was bumped up the rear by a lady shunted from behind, not much damage but as the car is worth very little it would be written off. Also as I would have to pay my excess to claim I can appreciate where the op is coming from, maybe £600 is buttons to your good self but I can't afford more than a weeks wages this close to Xmas, as the op can't.
Just my 2p's worth
Like I've said before, neither the knowledge nor the temperament for the credentials claimed.....
hole? Your replies do seem a bit condescending?. I feel for the op, last week my old Jag was bumped up the rear by a lady shunted from behind, not much damage but as the car is worth very little it would be written off. Also as I would have to pay my excess to claim I can appreciate where the op is coming from, maybe £600 is buttons to your good self but I can't afford more than a weeks wages this close to Xmas, as the op can't.Just my 2p's worth
Humper said:
maybe £600 is buttons to your good self but I can't afford more than a weeks wages this close to Xmas, as the op can't.
Just my 2p's worth
At no point have I said or even suggested that. Just my 2p's worth
Thanks for the insult. I may be blunt but that's in my nature. It doesn't alter the free advice being given.
Can we not argue and bicker on my thread please. Thanks 
I am grateful for the advice given, as bad and as annoying as it is.
My anger is because insurance is a necessary legal requirement, and as such, we have to suffer it. So I have no choice in whether to enter into it or not. My choice as a consumer is removed.
Hence, when I come to use the service I am paying for, to be told to jog on is disappointing at best.
Anyway, we've established that the insurance companies between them are not going to pay for the damage done to my parked car by an imbecile.
What would REALLY contribute to this thread is some ideas about where I go from here.
Ta.

I am grateful for the advice given, as bad and as annoying as it is.
My anger is because insurance is a necessary legal requirement, and as such, we have to suffer it. So I have no choice in whether to enter into it or not. My choice as a consumer is removed.
Hence, when I come to use the service I am paying for, to be told to jog on is disappointing at best.
Anyway, we've established that the insurance companies between them are not going to pay for the damage done to my parked car by an imbecile.
What would REALLY contribute to this thread is some ideas about where I go from here.
Ta.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




