Ebay again, negative feedback left while item is in the post
Discussion
Hi all
Long story, and I suspect the answer is that I'm stuffed and eBay won't give a toss but here we go
My wife uses my ebay account to sell a few items, nothing serious, clothes and shoes and the like. She sold a pair of shoes 99p plus postage. Item ended on 19th November at 2031, payment sent shortly after. Item was posted on Thursday 21st November, as per the listing which said "within two working days of cleared payment" but not before she'd already sent an email querying what was happening and where they were!!!
Thought nothing of it until I get a message through ebay on 29th November and the following exchange takes place:
Then another message yesterday:
The money I couldn't give a toss about, even if they get delivered after I refund her I won't be bothered, what I want is to get the negative feedback removed, I've sent her a request to do it and have had no response, she's not responded to my latest message and frankly, she sounds like the kind of dimwit that would just leave it up there just to be a pain
Has anybody had any success with calling Ebay? I've trawled their humorously titled "Help" pages but they seem far more keen to help buyers than sellers as usual
Alternatively, anybody have any fresh ways to exact revenge? She lives miles away so any frozen sausages would have thawed out by the time I got to her lawn...
Long story, and I suspect the answer is that I'm stuffed and eBay won't give a toss but here we go
My wife uses my ebay account to sell a few items, nothing serious, clothes and shoes and the like. She sold a pair of shoes 99p plus postage. Item ended on 19th November at 2031, payment sent shortly after. Item was posted on Thursday 21st November, as per the listing which said "within two working days of cleared payment" but not before she'd already sent an email querying what was happening and where they were!!!
Ebay said:
From: Her to Me
Sent: 21-Nov-13 12:59
Dear [my ebay id],
hey just wondering when will these be here or dispatched
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 21-Nov-13 13:02
Dear [her ebay id],
Hi [her name]
I'm handling this for my wife, she's come down with something nasty this week and I've been away in London until late last night
I've packaged the shoes and am going to town shortly, they'll be dispatched today
[me]
- [my ebay id]
Item was posted less than an hour later via Small Parcels 2nd Class, Recorded delivery (as with all our items) and proof of postage was retainedSent: 21-Nov-13 12:59
Dear [my ebay id],
hey just wondering when will these be here or dispatched
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 21-Nov-13 13:02
Dear [her ebay id],
Hi [her name]
I'm handling this for my wife, she's come down with something nasty this week and I've been away in London until late last night
I've packaged the shoes and am going to town shortly, they'll be dispatched today
[me]
- [my ebay id]
Thought nothing of it until I get a message through ebay on 29th November and the following exchange takes place:
Ebay said:
From: Her to Me
Sent: 29-Nov-13 12:07
Dear [my ebay id],
hello not recieved these yet?
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 29-Nov-13 12:21
Dear [her ebay id],
Hi [her name]
I have the proof of postage here, they were sent on 21st November via 2nd Class Recorded post
Tracking barcode is [tracking number] and RM currently say it's in their network, detailed tracking isn't available for recorded post, only proof of delivery
I'll keep an eye on it, RM say they can't investigate or open a claim until 15 days from the due delivery date which is another week or two, I will contact them as soon as I can and get it sorted
Sorry it's got delayed, usually RM are very good but sometimes they drop the ball!!
Regards
[me] & [my wife]
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 29-Nov-13 12:22
Dear [my ebay id],
its ok np x just was wondering really thanks x
- [her ebay id]
By this time I'm bracing for a RM lost item claim and a paypal refund, so get ready to submit the claim at the end of the fifteen daysSent: 29-Nov-13 12:07
Dear [my ebay id],
hello not recieved these yet?
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 29-Nov-13 12:21
Dear [her ebay id],
Hi [her name]
I have the proof of postage here, they were sent on 21st November via 2nd Class Recorded post
Tracking barcode is [tracking number] and RM currently say it's in their network, detailed tracking isn't available for recorded post, only proof of delivery
I'll keep an eye on it, RM say they can't investigate or open a claim until 15 days from the due delivery date which is another week or two, I will contact them as soon as I can and get it sorted
Sorry it's got delayed, usually RM are very good but sometimes they drop the ball!!
Regards
[me] & [my wife]
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 29-Nov-13 12:22
Dear [my ebay id],
its ok np x just was wondering really thanks x
- [her ebay id]
Then another message yesterday:
Ebay said:
From: Her to Me
Sent: 04-Dec-13 22:27
Dear [my ebay id],
hey iv still not got these?
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 05-Dec-13 04:49
Dear [her ebay id],
[her name]
As I said before, Royal Mail will not accept any claim for loss or delay until at least fifteen working days from the due date of delivery
If this case the item was posted on the 21st November, making the due delivery date the 25th November (three working days for RM 2nd Class Recorded items). Fifteen working days from then is the 12th December
I know it's frustrating but I can't do anything until then, please let me know if the item is delivered in the mean time and as soon as I can I'll submit a claim for the loss if it doesn't arrive
Thanks
[me]
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 05-Dec-13 17:03
Dear [my ebay id],
i need these for tomorrow
- [her ebay id]
Quite what she expected me to do I have no idea, so I leave it last night, come back to ebay today and see that she's left me negative feedback saying "never got these", so I send her a message:Sent: 04-Dec-13 22:27
Dear [my ebay id],
hey iv still not got these?
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 05-Dec-13 04:49
Dear [her ebay id],
[her name]
As I said before, Royal Mail will not accept any claim for loss or delay until at least fifteen working days from the due date of delivery
If this case the item was posted on the 21st November, making the due delivery date the 25th November (three working days for RM 2nd Class Recorded items). Fifteen working days from then is the 12th December
I know it's frustrating but I can't do anything until then, please let me know if the item is delivered in the mean time and as soon as I can I'll submit a claim for the loss if it doesn't arrive
Thanks
[me]
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 05-Dec-13 17:03
Dear [my ebay id],
i need these for tomorrow
- [her ebay id]
Ebay said:
From: Me to Her
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:27
Dear [her ebay id],
[her name]
Thank you for your negative feedback, very helpful
Precisely what should I have done to make Royal Mail deliver this item to you?
I will send you a request to revise your feedback, if you do not respond I will report your malicious activity to Ebay
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:34
Dear [my ebay id],
i want my shoes or money bk x
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:38
Dear [her ebay id],
So instead of opening a Buyer Protection case you leave negative feedback, very intelligent...
Open a case, revise your feedback and you will receive a refund...
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:44
Dear [my ebay id],
i want my shoes monday next week please or i will report you to ebay and get them to sort it out.. i have never had this problem before and i dont want it now. if you cant have them here monday i will order a refund and report you
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:49
Dear [her ebay id],
The shoes were posted on the 21st November as the tracking number shows, from the point of postage the seller is not responsible for Royal Mail if they fail to deliver
Feel free to open a buyer protection case as I already asked you to do...
Have you even spoken to your delivery office?
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:53
Dear [my ebay id],
yea been twice
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:57
Dear [her ebay id],
Then if you can think of anything I can do to force Royal Mail deliver the item please let me know, otherwise I can do nothing regarding delivery - the item was posted, via a tracked service, the proof of postage is on the Royal Mail website and the original receipt that I have here, from that point onwards I am not responsible for whether RM deliver the parcel or not!!!
Remove your negative feedback, open a case for a refund, and it will be issued...
- [my ebay id]
Now... The tracking number still shows the parcel as "posted and being progressed through our delivery network. Obviously if it doesn't get delivered then I'll be issuing a refundSent: 06-Dec-13 14:27
Dear [her ebay id],
[her name]
Thank you for your negative feedback, very helpful
Precisely what should I have done to make Royal Mail deliver this item to you?
I will send you a request to revise your feedback, if you do not respond I will report your malicious activity to Ebay
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:34
Dear [my ebay id],
i want my shoes or money bk x
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:38
Dear [her ebay id],
So instead of opening a Buyer Protection case you leave negative feedback, very intelligent...
Open a case, revise your feedback and you will receive a refund...
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:44
Dear [my ebay id],
i want my shoes monday next week please or i will report you to ebay and get them to sort it out.. i have never had this problem before and i dont want it now. if you cant have them here monday i will order a refund and report you
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:49
Dear [her ebay id],
The shoes were posted on the 21st November as the tracking number shows, from the point of postage the seller is not responsible for Royal Mail if they fail to deliver
Feel free to open a buyer protection case as I already asked you to do...
Have you even spoken to your delivery office?
- [my ebay id]
From: Her to Me
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:53
Dear [my ebay id],
yea been twice
- [her ebay id]
From: Me to Her
Sent: 06-Dec-13 14:57
Dear [her ebay id],
Then if you can think of anything I can do to force Royal Mail deliver the item please let me know, otherwise I can do nothing regarding delivery - the item was posted, via a tracked service, the proof of postage is on the Royal Mail website and the original receipt that I have here, from that point onwards I am not responsible for whether RM deliver the parcel or not!!!
Remove your negative feedback, open a case for a refund, and it will be issued...
- [my ebay id]
The money I couldn't give a toss about, even if they get delivered after I refund her I won't be bothered, what I want is to get the negative feedback removed, I've sent her a request to do it and have had no response, she's not responded to my latest message and frankly, she sounds like the kind of dimwit that would just leave it up there just to be a pain
Has anybody had any success with calling Ebay? I've trawled their humorously titled "Help" pages but they seem far more keen to help buyers than sellers as usual
Alternatively, anybody have any fresh ways to exact revenge? She lives miles away so any frozen sausages would have thawed out by the time I got to her lawn...

stuartmmcfc said:
In all honesty, does 1 negative feedback really matter?
In terms of my health, family life and general wellbeing? No, probably not 
In terms of it now saying "98.2% positive feedback" next to my name instead of 100%? Yes, it's very frustrating that I now appear less trustworthy because one woman is too stupid to understand how the postal system works...
Thanks addsvrs, I've reported her earlier today and left an explanation of what's happened, as you got, no response but it's early days yet... Will try live chat and see if they're more helpful...
ZiggyNiva said:
Ebay will do nothing. I had this with a negative feedback left for apparent non delivery even though the buyer never contacted me or opened a case, just left feedback. I also had proof of their name signing for the parcel, but Ebay said there was nothing they could do.
That's kind of what I was expecting...Sorry to hear you got shafted...
PurpleMoonlight said:
The purchaser has be far more patient that I would have been.
Refund her money.
You're missing the point. Why should he when the buyer can't be bothered to use the correct protocol available via eBay? Until she does the negative feedback seems more than a tad malicious. That's what the OP is concerned about not the issue of a refund.Refund her money.
If you're working to a specific deadline then buying anything by post, irrespective of source, has a certain risk attached. Get over it.
ZiggyNiva said:
Ebay will do nothing. I had this with a negative feedback left for apparent non delivery even though the buyer never contacted me or opened a case, just left feedback. I also had proof of their name signing for the parcel, but Ebay said there was nothing they could do.
Too many scummy buyers know that eBay's attitude allows them to rip people off with impunity. It's one of the risks you have to weigh up and accept if you choose to sell stuff by using it. It's something you can factor in if your volume is sufficient. If you only have occasional higher value possessions you want to shift it's just not worth it.Red Devil said:
PurpleMoonlight said:
The purchaser has be far more patient that I would have been.
Refund her money.
You're missing the point. Why should he when the buyer can't be bothered to use the correct protocol available via eBay? Until she does the negative feedback seems more than a tad malicious. That's what the OP is concerned about not the issue of a refund.Refund her money.
Why should the purchaser be forced to open a dispute. Are sellers not able to refund without being forced to by Ebay all of a sudden???
PurpleMoonlight said:
The purchaser paid on 19/11 and had not received the item by 06/12. The feedback is fair and correct.
Utter Utter b
ksIn the listing it said posted within 2 working days, I assume it said so in the listing postage by RM 2nd class (recorded) The OP has answered all the buyers questions, told them that RM say it is 5 working days but that a claim for loss cant be entertained for 15 days.
Not valid to give the OP a neg for RM's screw up. (especially as he can prove he posted it when and where he said he had) The buyer is a muppet pure and simple.
PurpleMoonlight said:
Are sellers not able to refund without being forced to by Ebay all of a sudden???
And if I refund, and the item is delivered now, she gets the money and the shoes and I can claim nothing because Royal Mail will not consider any item delayed or lost until three weeks after sendingThat's not how it works
You would really would leave negative feedback after being promptly provided with proof of postage and a tracking number?? That's pretty t
ttish and unnecessary behaviour - I'd had ebay items lost and damaged in the post before, always left +ve feedback for the seller once it's sorted out...the_lone_wolf said:
And if I refund, and the item is delivered now, she gets the money and the shoes and I can claim nothing because Royal Mail will not consider any item delayed or lost until three weeks after sending
That's not how it works
It works how you want it to work.That's not how it works
How do you know she wouldn't have paid once they did arrive, which I doubt they ever will.
You are deeming her a crook because you think she would want to keep payment and goods, she is deeming you a crook because she thinks you are trying to keep her money and the goods.
If you are so worried about a negative feedback you should have gone about this differently ...
PurpleMoonlight said:
Are you incapable of volunteering?
I volunteered to refund as soon as RM declare the parcel as lost as soon as it appeared that there was an issue with the deliveryShould I have volunteered a refund the day after the estimated delivery date? Two days? Three?
How long should I have waited before issuing a refund that was never requested?
Unless you use fully online trackable delivery - i.e. Special Delivery not just Recorded - you're always going to lose on a dispute saying that the goods have not been delivered.
It's obviously not cost-effective to do that - and buyers won't pay for it on anything but the priciest items - so it's always a bit of a risk.
It's obviously not cost-effective to do that - and buyers won't pay for it on anything but the priciest items - so it's always a bit of a risk.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


