Trade Sales Only
Discussion
Just spotted this on the end of an ad. on another website.
Can any of the legal eagles tell me what if any standing this would have legally?
I would have thought that any trader selling to the public would be bound by SOGA no matter what the ad. said?
It's a long long time since we did some very very basic law as part of our business course but I seem to recall phrases like of merchantable quality, and fit for purpose?
Can any of the legal eagles tell me what if any standing this would have legally?
I would have thought that any trader selling to the public would be bound by SOGA no matter what the ad. said?
It's a long long time since we did some very very basic law as part of our business course but I seem to recall phrases like of merchantable quality, and fit for purpose?
The Sale of Goods Act applies to every sale of goods by a business. It is a common misconception that the Act does not apply when the purchaser buys in the course of a business. Some of the Act's provisions, however, only apply to consumer purchases.
If the ad means that the car will only be sold to traders, fine. If it is an attempt to exclude the statutory implied terms that apply to non business purchasers, it will fail
If the ad means that the car will only be sold to traders, fine. If it is an attempt to exclude the statutory implied terms that apply to non business purchasers, it will fail
People that go looking to buy trade sales at much lower prices than general retail forecourt prices and then find a fault and quote sale of goods act are total scumbags.
Its clearly laid out, if you want warranty go and see a big dealer and pay big money.
If you want to save some money buy trade sale and get a separate aftermarket warranty.
Its clearly laid out, if you want warranty go and see a big dealer and pay big money.
If you want to save some money buy trade sale and get a separate aftermarket warranty.
This has come up a lot recently.
A dealer can't dodge soga.
But, Soga does not mean what a lot of people think it means.
It's not a free 6 month warranty - it's just a law to stop sellers lying.
Also, with used cars there's even more grey area in terms of proving faults and wear and tear at purchase time, or arguing whether it's reasonable for a car of a certain age to develop a certain fault.
If a dealer says stuff about trade sales or sold as seen it's not a legally binding term.
But, it is an indication of the expected quality of the product and the potential for failure.
It is similar (in concept) to a shop selling seconds.
There will be some possible recourse if the car is not as described.
Or if there was an obvious fault that was not mentioned.
But, one would then question why you bought the car with spotting the obvious fault or checking the description.
A dealer can't dodge soga.
But, Soga does not mean what a lot of people think it means.
It's not a free 6 month warranty - it's just a law to stop sellers lying.
Also, with used cars there's even more grey area in terms of proving faults and wear and tear at purchase time, or arguing whether it's reasonable for a car of a certain age to develop a certain fault.
If a dealer says stuff about trade sales or sold as seen it's not a legally binding term.
But, it is an indication of the expected quality of the product and the potential for failure.
It is similar (in concept) to a shop selling seconds.
There will be some possible recourse if the car is not as described.
Or if there was an obvious fault that was not mentioned.
But, one would then question why you bought the car with spotting the obvious fault or checking the description.
Snowboy said:
...
it's just a law to stop sellers lying.
...
That is an inaccurate description of the Act. It codifies the law on sale of goods. It imposes obligations on business sellers as to the quality of goods sold regardless of what is said about them. it's just a law to stop sellers lying.
...
It is perhaps worth setting out the relevant parts of section 14 in full:-
Parliament said:
(2) Where the seller sells goods in the course of a business, there is an implied term that the goods supplied under the contract are of satisfactory quality.
(2A)For the purposes of this Act, goods are of satisfactory quality if they meet the standard that a reasonable person would regard as satisfactory, taking account of any description of the goods, the price (if relevant) and all the other relevant circumstances.
(2B)For the purposes of this Act, the quality of goods includes their state and condition and the following
(among others) are in appropriate cases aspects of the quality of goods—
(a)fitness for all the purposes for which goods of the kind in question are commonly supplied,
(b)appearance and finish,
(c)freedom from minor defects,
(d)safety, and
(e)durability.
(2C)The term implied by subsection (2) above does not extend to any matter making the quality of goods unsatisfactory—
(a)which is specifically drawn to the buyer’s attention before the contract is made,
(b)where the buyer examines the goods before the contract is made, which that examination ought to reveal, or
(c)in the case of a contract for sale by sample, which would have been apparent on a reasonable examination of the sample.
(2A)For the purposes of this Act, goods are of satisfactory quality if they meet the standard that a reasonable person would regard as satisfactory, taking account of any description of the goods, the price (if relevant) and all the other relevant circumstances.
(2B)For the purposes of this Act, the quality of goods includes their state and condition and the following
(among others) are in appropriate cases aspects of the quality of goods—
(a)fitness for all the purposes for which goods of the kind in question are commonly supplied,
(b)appearance and finish,
(c)freedom from minor defects,
(d)safety, and
(e)durability.
(2C)The term implied by subsection (2) above does not extend to any matter making the quality of goods unsatisfactory—
(a)which is specifically drawn to the buyer’s attention before the contract is made,
(b)where the buyer examines the goods before the contract is made, which that examination ought to reveal, or
(c)in the case of a contract for sale by sample, which would have been apparent on a reasonable examination of the sample.
People who buy from 'trade sales only' places are usually buying the absolute cheapest POS they can and then moan when they have a problem.
People that sell cars as 'trade sales' to the public usually have very thick skin and DGAF if the aforementioned person comes back moaning about the car and will tell them to FRO safe in the knowledge that a very very very small % of them will ever go any further than saying 'The Citizens Advice Bureau says.....' or 'SOGA says....' and will normally give the customer a swift 'f
k off' then move onto the next chump.
And so it is written is how it shall be.
People that sell cars as 'trade sales' to the public usually have very thick skin and DGAF if the aforementioned person comes back moaning about the car and will tell them to FRO safe in the knowledge that a very very very small % of them will ever go any further than saying 'The Citizens Advice Bureau says.....' or 'SOGA says....' and will normally give the customer a swift 'f
k off' then move onto the next chump.And so it is written is how it shall be.
JimmyConwayNW said:
People that go looking to buy trade sales at much lower prices than general retail forecourt prices and then find a fault and quote sale of goods act are total scumbags.
Its clearly laid out, if you want warranty go and see a big dealer and pay big money.
If you want to save some money buy trade sale and get a separate aftermarket warranty.
If traders want to make trades sales then they should sell to the TRADE. It's really very simple, and it's what 'trade sale' means.Its clearly laid out, if you want warranty go and see a big dealer and pay big money.
If you want to save some money buy trade sale and get a separate aftermarket warranty.
The reason why some traders try to sell to the public and advertise it as a trade sale is because they want to sell it for more than they would get if they sold it to the trade. The 'trade sale (but not really)' technique is also used to tempt members of the public into buying at what they believe to be a lower price than they would get in a normal retail sale.
Thanks to all, Breadvan in particular who laid it out chapter and verse in his own as always helpful style.
For those of us not in the know many many thanks.
I saw a particular car which I will try and link to, and thought it too much of a bargain, and now thanks to the good people of PH I now know that as usual if it looks too good to be true, chances are it is
http://www.usedcarsni.com/2008-BMW-M3-4-dr-saloon-...
For those of us not in the know many many thanks.
I saw a particular car which I will try and link to, and thought it too much of a bargain, and now thanks to the good people of PH I now know that as usual if it looks too good to be true, chances are it is
http://www.usedcarsni.com/2008-BMW-M3-4-dr-saloon-...
Butter Face said:
People ... saying 'The Citizens Advice Bureau says.....' ...
Thing is, the blandly generic advice on their website (and other similar ones) paints a pretty optimistic picture, which gives the great unwashed some very odd ideas as to what they're entitled to if a car (or anything else) goes wrong during (in vague terms) some length of time after purchase
.ArmaghMan said:
Thanks to all, Breadvan in particular who laid it out chapter and verse in his own as always helpful style.
For those of us not in the know many many thanks.
I saw a particular car which I will try and link to, and thought it too much of a bargain, and now thanks to the good people of PH I now know that as usual if it looks too good to be true, chances are it is
http://www.usedcarsni.com/2008-BMW-M3-4-dr-saloon-...
Have you actually contacted the seller to enquire about the car and if it's being sold to the general public, or are you just making an assumption about how the seller is running their business?For those of us not in the know many many thanks.
I saw a particular car which I will try and link to, and thought it too much of a bargain, and now thanks to the good people of PH I now know that as usual if it looks too good to be true, chances are it is
http://www.usedcarsni.com/2008-BMW-M3-4-dr-saloon-...
It could be that if you were to enquire about this vehicle, the seller will tell you straight away that he cannot sell it to you as it's a trade sale only, as stated in the advert.
aw51 121565 said:
Butter Face said:
People ... saying 'The Citizens Advice Bureau says.....' ...
Thing is, the blandly generic advice on their website (and other similar ones) paints a pretty optimistic picture, which gives the great unwashed some very odd ideas as to what they're entitled to if a car (or anything else) goes wrong during (in vague terms) some length of time after purchase
.The SOGA implies terms into consumer contracts that are likely to be negotiated if there was equality of bargaining power. The law assumes consumers are at a disadvantage and effectively removes the right of the more savvy consumer to negotiate with the seller. The law is more concerned with the economic need for consumer confidence in general than freedom of individuals to contract.
BV's quote is spot on.
I had very much simplified it, but I don't consider my comment wrong.
That whole quote gives a dealer the option to say;
It's a used car, I don't know the history. Make sure you check it yourself before you buy it.
The price reflects this lack of certainty in reliability.
But, the exact same car sold for a greater amount with a more confident sales pitch might have a stronger 'cover' under soga due to the claims made by the dealer.
(Great runner, very reliable etc)
Soga is there to stop people getting ripped off.
But if a dealer sells as car as cheap car that might be a bit ropey, then the customer can't complain under soga if it turns out to he a bit ropey.
I had very much simplified it, but I don't consider my comment wrong.
That whole quote gives a dealer the option to say;
It's a used car, I don't know the history. Make sure you check it yourself before you buy it.
The price reflects this lack of certainty in reliability.
But, the exact same car sold for a greater amount with a more confident sales pitch might have a stronger 'cover' under soga due to the claims made by the dealer.
(Great runner, very reliable etc)
Soga is there to stop people getting ripped off.
But if a dealer sells as car as cheap car that might be a bit ropey, then the customer can't complain under soga if it turns out to he a bit ropey.
I think it's a shame that I can't choose the terms of a contract when I buy a car. I would like the flexibility to buy on a trade basis if I choose too, and make sure that the reduction in price offsets the perception of risk. I just don't like regulations protecting me when I don't need the protection - all it does is make 'trade sale' cars more expensive to buy.
You are free to contract, as no one is forcing you to make a claim under any statute or rule that protects the private buyer, but the rules are there for those who want and in many cases need them.
Consumer protection works on utilitarian principles. Most people wouldn't or couldn't negotiate for themselves, and inequality of bargaining power is the norm when buying from a large commercial organisation
Consumer protection works on utilitarian principles. Most people wouldn't or couldn't negotiate for themselves, and inequality of bargaining power is the norm when buying from a large commercial organisation
Breadvan72 said:
You are free to contract, as no one is forcing you to make a claim under any statute or rule that protects the private buyer, but the rules are there for those who want and in many cases need them.
Consumer protection works on utilitarian principles. Most people wouldn't or couldn't negotiate for themselves, and inequality of bargaining power is the norm when buying from a large commercial organisation
In which case why can't a dealer say that it is a trade sale, and a private buyer contracts on that basis? Surely if this is clear, the buyer has accepted that the terms of the contract mean that they have no warranty or guarantee? All the replies above imply that a dealer can't do this, which I think is a bit sad.Consumer protection works on utilitarian principles. Most people wouldn't or couldn't negotiate for themselves, and inequality of bargaining power is the norm when buying from a large commercial organisation
JimmyConwayNW said:
People that go looking to buy trade sales at much lower prices than general retail forecourt prices and then find a fault and quote sale of goods act are total scumbags.
Its clearly laid out, if you want warranty go and see a big dealer and pay big money.
If you want to save some money buy trade sale and get a separate aftermarket warranty.
SOGA is not a warranty.Its clearly laid out, if you want warranty go and see a big dealer and pay big money.
If you want to save some money buy trade sale and get a separate aftermarket warranty.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


