Murder without jurisdiction?
Murder without jurisdiction?
Author
Discussion

airbrakes

Original Poster:

10,714 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Hypothetical question here, generated by the events of a tv show in which the following is planned by a character.

If you intended to kill someone, lets say you traveled to "4 corners" in the US, where 4 states meet at one point. Say you stood in 1 state and fired a gun at the correct angle so the bullet travelled through the second state before hitting the victim in the third state. The victim then stumbled about a bit before wandering into the 4th state, collapsing and dying.
Given that each state has its own jurisdiction, would it be possible to try you for murder in any of the 4 states? The events happening in each state only form a legal process of murder if they happen all together, but split up as they are they are all legally innocent in each state. As far as state 1's jurisdiction goes, you fired a gun which is perfectly legal on its own. In state 3, someone was hit by a stray bullet from out of state and wounded, and in state 4 they entered whilst wounded and then died of pre-existing injuries - so it technically legally wouldn't be murder?

Any legal eagles care to comment on this? It is a genuinely interesting hypothesis that even has some of my Law student friends stumped.

ninja-lewis

5,507 posts

221 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
If either victim or perpetrator is Indian then it would be subject to FBI/Federal jurisdiction because "4 Corners" lies within an Indian reservation.

As that's probably not the answer you were expecting: depending on the State laws involved, probably any of States 1, 3 or 4 could claim jurisdiction for homicide.

Edit: Again, depending on State laws, even State 2 may be able to claim jurisdiction for crimes committed near its state boundaries.

Californian Penal Code said:
782. When a public offense is committed on the boundary of two or
more jurisdictional territories, or within 500 yards thereof, the
jurisdiction of such offense is in any competent court within either
jurisdictional territory.

790. (a) The jurisdiction of a criminal action for murder or
manslaughter is in the county where the fatal injury was inflicted or
in the county in which the injured party died or in the county in
which his or her body was found. However, if the defendant is
indicted in the county in which the fatal injury was inflicted, at
any time before his or her trial in another county, the sheriff of
the other county shall, if the defendant is in custody, deliver the
defendant upon demand to the sheriff of the county in which the fatal
injury was inflicted. When the fatal injury was inflicted and the
injured person died or his or her body was found within five hundred
yards of the boundary of two or more counties, jurisdiction is in
either county.
Edited by ninja-lewis on Sunday 8th December 17:33

Dibble

13,292 posts

271 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
It's the same as any other crime crossing state lines and federal jurisdiction takes precedence. So it would be ''United States vs Airbrakes' rather than 'Nevada vs Airbrakes'.

Red 4

10,744 posts

218 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
It would appear your "law student" friends aren't too bright.


ralphrj

4,135 posts

222 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Wikipedia but...

wikipedia said:
If the victim is a federal official, an ambassador, consul or other foreign official under the protection of the United States, or if the crime took place on federal property or involved crossing state lines, or in a manner that substantially affects interstate commerce or national security, then the federal government also has jurisdiction.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_(United_States...

It would be tried in a Federal Court rather than a State Court.


Dibble

13,292 posts

271 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Red 4 said:
It would appear your "law student" friends aren't too bright.
Or know how to Google.

Pints

18,451 posts

225 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Dibble said:
It's the same as any other crime crossing state lines and federal jurisdiction takes precedence. So it would be ''United States vs Airbrakes' rather than 'Nevada vs Airbrakes'.
I suspect he's already wanted in several states for crimes against fashion.

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Dibble said:
Red 4 said:
It would appear your "law student" friends aren't too bright.
Or know how to Google.
Or haven't watched a dozen films where the feds gain jurisdiction after something happens across state lines.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
More to the point, where would they bury the survivor?

Streaky

greygoose

9,675 posts

226 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
streaky said:
More to the point, where would they bury the survivor?

Streaky
Hopefully nowhere if he survived.

GreigM

6,740 posts

280 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
It probably wouldn't be a federal issue. Murder is generally a federal issue under very strict conditions (federal land, federal employee, in DC etc). The firing of the gun and the death of the victim are "distinct" (while related) events, but in themselves don't cross state lines.

Where the person died is the state where murder is committed,the fact the gun was fired out of state is immaterial, the murder "occurred" when the person died and that state has jurisdiction. Its like poisoning someone with a slow acting poison when they are about to board a plane - where they die determines where the crime took place, until that point it is "attempted".

The state where the bullet was fired could also try for a number of crimes, including attempted murder, firearms charges etc and if the state prosecutor was adventurous may try for a murder charge also (in addition to the "death" state - this wouldn't breach any double jeopardy laws) but this is more grey as to whether or not its a valid charge.

The other states where the bullet traveled are unlikely to have any case at all.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
streaky said:
More to the point, where would they bury the survivor?

Streaky
In the 'Rock and Pop' section of HMV under 'S'.

IanA2

2,897 posts

193 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
In the 'Rock and Pop' section of HMV under 'S'.
roflroflroflrofl

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
greygoose said:
streaky said:
More to the point, where would they bury the survivor?

Streaky
Hopefully nowhere if he survived.
Anyone seen the parrot?

Streaky

KFC

3,687 posts

161 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-25230699 how did this guy find himself arrested in UK for a death that occurred while he was living in Abu Dhabi?

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
KFC said:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-25230699 how did this guy find himself arrested in UK for a death that occurred while he was living in Abu Dhabi?
Serious Crime Act 2007, by virtue of Schedule 4 ?

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2007/27/schedu...

Supernova190188

936 posts

170 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
on a similar note then , but what would happen if somebody murdered someone else out in the middle of the pacific say where no country has jurisdiction?

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Supernova190188 said:
on a similar note then , but what would happen if somebody murdered someone else out in the middle of the pacific say where no country has jurisdiction?
The law of the nation where the ship was registered would apply.

But what if there's no ship? On one of Peary's polar expeditions, one of his team members was reputedly murdered by his Eskimo companions, on foot, on the polar ice cap, in international waters. They were never tried, partly because many years after the event when it came out nobody had any enthusiasm for searching through remote parts of Greenland to find them and bring them to the US for trial under a wholly alien system, but IIRC also because nobody was sure whether they could be tried under US law, or indeed any law. That was a hundred years ago though; things may have moved on since then.

Octoposse

2,425 posts

216 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Supernova190188 said:
on a similar note then , but what would happen if somebody murdered someone else out in the middle of the pacific say where no country has jurisdiction?
Assuming they got there by boat, then the country of registration of the vessel would have jurisdiction. If they swam there I'd go for the nationality of the beach . . . otherwise I'd just put them before the first court you could get to and let the lawyers hammer out most appropriate jurisdiction.

Octoposse

2,425 posts

216 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Aretnap said:
But what if there's no ship? On one of Peary's polar expeditions, one of his team members was reputedly murdered by his Eskimo companions, on foot, on the polar ice cap, in international waters. They were never tried, partly because many years after the event when it came out nobody had any enthusiasm for searching through remote parts of Greenland to find them and bring them to the US for trial under a wholly alien system, but IIRC also because nobody was sure whether they could be tried under US law, or indeed any law. That was a hundred years ago though; things may have moved on since then.
Reaper Drone nowdays! (But US law claims jurisdiction in these circumstances anyway).