Out of sight out of mind car!
Out of sight out of mind car!
Author
Discussion

aikmanmosquito

Original Poster:

56 posts

193 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
I'll try and be quick! A guy left me his car to undertake a restoration nearly nine years ago. At the start he left me some money to get it started, but only enough to make a start, then as he works abroad I didn't hear from him for a while.
About a year passed in which I'd get an occasional email, then he would appear back home and come and see his car, but although I'd spent by this time a fair amount of money on it, he still only handed me occasional small amounts.
About 5 years ago I decided to close my business for one reason or another, so emailed him to say that I'd a certain amount of time left before I had to give up my unit and that he should come and take his car and square me up for what work I'd done.
He then explained that he couldn't be back in the UK within the timescale, so we agreed that I'd take the car to my house and it would sit there until he came to collect.
Well since then, he has still only contacted me by emails, he has no family up here, but has in England, so when he comes back from working abroad he usually goes there. I have carried no more work on the car as I've basically not been paid. I have asked and asked for him to take the car away, but all I get is excuses.
Now I feel that it is convenient for him to leave the car with me, as he has no permanent address in the UK as he sold his flat up here, and his car is sat untaxed, and un mot'd in my drive. I'm reluctant to just dump it as he owes me a lot of money.
Where do I stand within the law as I've had this car sat on my property for a heck of a long time, and enough is now enough!


SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
You make out an invoice for storage. By now this will have become a rather substantial invoice.

Then you notify the owner that if the invoice is not paid in (say) fourteen days, you will take possession of the car, have it auctioned and settle your bill.

If the car's auction price does not settle the bill, then you will explain that you will then take legal action to recover the remainder of the invoice from him.

In any event, the likelihood is that you will end up with the car, maybe you want to finish the restoration yourself and keep it?

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
You make out an invoice for storage. By now this will have become a rather substantial invoice.

Then you notify the owner that if the invoice is not paid in (say) fourteen days, you will take possession of the car, have it auctioned and settle your bill.

If the car's auction price does not settle the bill, then you will explain that you will then take legal action to recover the remainder of the invoice from him.

In any event, the likelihood is that you will end up with the car, maybe you want to finish the restoration yourself and keep it?
As this post suggests you have a lien (right of recompense) over the car. Both for work done and storage which will be considerable. Secure the vehicle with appropriate alarms etc and follow the advice above. If the owner disputes this take him to SC court for all your costs including storage security and work done. You will win and very probably either get paid and return the vehicle or end up owning the vehicle, You will have possession and can apply for a new V5 in your name. Good luck. This actually happens pretty regularly with unclaimed and abandoned cars.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
You make out an invoice for storage. By now this will have become a rather substantial invoice.

Then you notify the owner that if the invoice is not paid in (say) fourteen days, you will take possession of the car, have it auctioned and settle your bill.

If the car's auction price does not settle the bill, then you will explain that you will then take legal action to recover the remainder of the invoice from him.

In any event, the likelihood is that you will end up with the car, maybe you want to finish the restoration yourself and keep it?
I don't think you can just conjour up a bill like that. If the subject of storage costs bias never been discussed then you can't just turn round and say "oh by the way, I've been racking up charges of £100/week for storage but never told you." Totally unenforceable.

You could tell him that you're going to start charging him in "14 days from today" at whatever rate, and that if he doesn't agree then he's to move the car. But you can't charge retrospectively.

redstu

2,287 posts

270 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
You have more patience than a saint!
Is it an interesting car?

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
See section 12 of the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977. The bailee is you. The bailor is the owner.

Subject to giving notice to the owner, you can sell the car. If the sale price covers your charges, you account to the owner for the surplus. You are entitled by common law to charge a reasonable amount for storage.

The Act said:
Uncollected goods

12 Bailee’s power of sale.

(1)This section applies to goods in the possession or under the control of a bailee where—

(a)the bailor is in breach of an obligation to take delivery of the goods or, if the terms of the bailment so provide, to give directions as to their delivery, or

(b)the bailee could impose such an obligation by giving notice to the bailor, but is unable to trace or communicate with the bailor, or

(c)the bailee can reasonably expect to be relieved of any duty to safeguard the goods on giving notice to the bailor, but is unable to trace or communicate with the bailor.

(2)In the cases of Part I of Schedule 1 to this Act a bailee may, for the purposes of subsection (1), impose an obligation on the bailor to take delivery of the goods, or as the case may be to give directions as to their delivery, and in those cases the said Part I sets out the method of notification.

(3)If the bailee—

(a)has in accordance with Part II of Schedule 1 to this Act given notice to the bailor of his intention to sell the goods under this subsection, or

(b)has failed to trace or communicate with the bailor with a view to giving him such a notice, after having taken reasonable steps for the purpose,and is reasonably satisfied that the bailor owns the goods, he shall be entitled, as against the bailor, to sell the goods.

(4)Where subsection (3) applies but the bailor did not in fact own the goods, a sale under this section, or under section 13, shall not give a good title as against the owner, or as against a person claiming under the owner.

(5)A bailee exercising his powers under subsection (3) shall be liable to account to the bailor for the proceeds of sale, less any costs of sale, and—

(a)the account shall be taken on the footing that the bailee should have adopted the best method of sale reasonably available in the circumstances, and

(b)where subsection (3)(a) applies, any sum payable in respect of the goods by the bailor to the bailee which accrued due before the bailee gave notice of intention to sell the goods shall be deductible from the proceeds of sale.

(6)A sale duly made under this section gives a good title to the purchaser as against the bailor.

(7)In this section, section 13, and Schedule 1 to this Act,

(a)“bailor” and “bailee” include their respective successors in title, and

(b)references to what is payable, paid or due to the bailee in respect of the goods include references to what would be payable by the bailor to the bailee as a condition of delivery of the goods at the relevant time.

(8)This section, and Schedule 1 to this Act, have effect subject to the terms of the bailment.

(9)This section shall not apply where the goods were bailed before the commencement of this Act.
Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 11th December 08:20

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
SV8Predator said:
You make out an invoice for storage. By now this will have become a rather substantial invoice.

Then you notify the owner that if the invoice is not paid in (say) fourteen days, you will take possession of the car, have it auctioned and settle your bill.

If the car's auction price does not settle the bill, then you will explain that you will then take legal action to recover the remainder of the invoice from him.

In any event, the likelihood is that you will end up with the car, maybe you want to finish the restoration yourself and keep it?
I don't think you can just conjour up a bill like that. If the subject of storage costs bias never been discussed then you can't just turn round and say "oh by the way, I've been racking up charges of £100/week for storage but never told you." Totally unenforceable.

You could tell him that you're going to start charging him in "14 days from today" at whatever rate, and that if he doesn't agree then he's to move the car. But you can't charge retrospectively.
I think you are wrong in law. Possession of the car lies with the OP. Which businessman do you know who would store a car for nothing? For years? There is a lien which the OP can use to obtain payment for storage. There is no requirement to agree charges before storage. The owner left his car with the OP for years. He did not ask whether he could do so. How would you avoid the lien and recover the car? There is a lien in place which legally must be discharged before recovery of the vehicle can be achieved. The storage charges must be commensurate and reasonable to be enforceable. The OP is owed money on the car. There is no such thing as free storage of vehicles. For years? Those charges must be reasonable but are clearly enforceable. If the original owner really wants his car back he will have to pay the OP. Otherwise the OP already has possession of the car and will receive ownership through the courts.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
The facts stated by the OP would support a claim to storage charges based on restitution or implied contract.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
If I left my car with a garage for repair after a crash I would not expect to pay storage charges on top of the cost of the work. However it is clear that whilst a couple of weeks is acceptable a few years is not. Is it clear where to draw the line? How do you determine when to start the clock and how much to charge per week? It's clear that they have been in communication with each other, so I think it's unreasonable to back date charges to a point in time which pre dates any discussion of storage charges.

I think the op is partly to blame for letting this get so out of hand. He should have threatened storage fees as soon as it was causing him a problem. Not 'leave it too late' and then try to back date the charges.

All IMO and ianal (that's probably clear, but I can still give a point of view!)

JimmyConwayNW

3,664 posts

156 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Sounds like he isn't coming back for it regardless so might aswell just sell it.

Randomthoughts

917 posts

164 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
JimmyConwayNW said:
Sounds like he isn't coming back for it regardless so might aswell just sell it.
For him to then come back and issue you a claim that you then struggle to defend.

Do it properly, don't bugger around with stupidity like just flogging it on a hunch that he doesn't care. As soon as he gets a whiff that it's now easy money to extract, he'll be all over you like a rash.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Randomthoughts said:
JimmyConwayNW said:
Sounds like he isn't coming back for it regardless so might aswell just sell it.
For him to then come back and issue you a claim that you then struggle to defend.

Do it properly, don't bugger around with stupidity like just flogging it on a hunch that he doesn't care. As soon as he gets a whiff that it's now easy money to extract, he'll be all over you like a rash.
I would certainly agree the OP should use the correct process of law to obtain ownership of the vehicle before attempting any form of sale. I personally do not think that the original owner would have much hope of regaining possession of his car unless he pays the OP in full for the work and lengthy storage. No business can be required to store substantial vehicles for nothing. A court case would make the position beyond doubt.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Steffan said:
A court case would make the position beyond doubt.
I will wager there has been at least one already! I'm sure if BV is asked nicely he can find one in his lexicon. smile

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Jerry Juhan Developments SA v Avon Tyres Ltd
Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
23 February 2000
Subject: Contracts
Keywords: Bailment; Conversion; Implied terms; Tortious liability

Summary: SA, who claimed to be the bailor of certain tyre moulds, appealed against a finding that the bailee of the moulds, AT, had been relieved of liability by reason of SA's failure to recover the moulds within a reasonable period of time. Whilst finding that SA had not been the bailor of the moulds, the court held that, in the absence of a clear notice from AT to the bailor that it regarded itself as discharged from liability in the event of a failure to collect the moulds by a specified date, AT remained under a duty not to convert, inflict wilful damage on, or act with gross negligence in relation to the moulds.

matchmaker

9,095 posts

231 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
OP, where do you stay? Your post suggests that it is not in England, so the law stated by my learned friend BV72 and others may not apply smile

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Section 12 of the 1977 Act does not extend to Scotland. Scots common law may differ from that of England in this area.