In full satisfaction of a claim
In full satisfaction of a claim
Author
Discussion

Wings

Original Poster:

5,983 posts

246 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Where one is in dispute with a person/company, and raises a compensation claim, to then receive a cheque for an amount lower than that being claimed, what action should the claimant take (with the cheque) in order to pursue the full settlement of their claim.


Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Either reject it or bank it but write promptly to the debtor stating that it is accepted on account of the full sum owed and not in full satisfaction. There is an authority for this that I can't quite find at the moment, but I also seem to recall either in the authority or a commentary on the authority that promptly was a matter of days, not weeks or months.

I have also represented clients at hearings where the court has accepted that a payment sent in full and final settlement which was accepted by a creditor as being on account was just that and was not taken as agreement to f&f settlement at a lower figure.

Wings

Original Poster:

5,983 posts

246 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Thank you for your reply.

My claim concerns an agent acting for me, who banked, cashed a cheque in his own personal bank account, that cheque coming from a third party and made payable to myself. This took me over 18 months to discover, and through having the assistance of an accountant.

The cheque I have now received is for the original sum/value of the wrongly banked cheque.

Using google I have located the following link, and was intending writing to the agent saying that I would only bank the cheque on the understanding that the cheque was not in full settlement, satisfaction of my intended claim.

http://www.addleshawgoddard.com/view.asp?content_i...




Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
If I follow you correctly you're saying the sum you've been sent was the original sum that you should have been paid, but you're pursuing extra by way of interest or some other costs you're wanting to apply because of the late payment?

Wings

Original Poster:

5,983 posts

246 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Although the amount of the cheque received, was the same amount of the original cheque that was wrongly cashed, banked in the agent's bank account. The cheque amount received is only a small part of a much larger claim I am preparing.

I should add that the agent's cheque came without any documentation, so not stipulating that the cheque was to be considered a full and final settlement of my claim against him,the agent.

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Wings said:
Although the amount of the cheque received, was the same amount of the original cheque that was wrongly cashed, banked in the agent's bank account. The cheque amount received is only a small part of a much larger claim I am preparing.

I should add that the agent's cheque came without any documentation, so not stipulating that the cheque was to be considered a full and final settlement of my claim against him,the agent.
Thanks for that. Given that there's no offer of the cheque being in full and final settlement for the whole of the debt then just give credit for that cheque against the total you're seeking. For the avoidance of doubt you could provide a receipt stipulating what part of the whole debt you're accepting the cheque as payment for, but on the facts as you've stated them I can't see acceptance of this cheque prejudicing the balance of the claim, particularly as it comes without anything proposing it is a f&f settlement.

Jasandjules

72,700 posts

260 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I would suggest you write to the other side. Include an invoice which states the amount originally owed, the cheque value being deducted, the amount outstanding - include interest at 8% if you wish.

Then include a short cover letter that says you have received the cheque to the sum of X with thanks and please find enclosed an invoice for the outstanding amount.