Restricted sick allowance.
Author
Discussion

toerag

Original Poster:

758 posts

163 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
So long story short, my employer has decided to restrict the amount of sick days taken.

As i understand this is how it works..

your *allowed* (ie. acceptable) to have three occurrences of sick in a working year. One sick is anything over
2 hours away from work (there are 2 hours leeway for dentist appointments etc.), so if you arrive at work 2 hours
& 1 mins late, that's counted as one sick.

or..

4% or the working year (8 days ish) is acceptable.

..after that begins disiplinary action starting with a verble warning through the usual steps (written warning, unpaid sick)
to eventually I guess loosing your job.

I'm not affected by this but there are some worried faces at work, my question is, is this even legal?

To dictate you should remain at a fixed level of health?







Edited by toerag on Tuesday 10th December 20:43

SmoothCriminal

5,985 posts

230 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Restrict sick days?

You do know paid sick days are a benefit and not an entitlement?

Yes this is legal don't know where you work but this is pretty common

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
The people who won't like it are the people that it's been implemented for. They have two choices.

I've been contracting for the past 13 years to get away from all corporate bullshiit. In those 13 years, i've had less than 10 sick days btw, but I also don't have any yearly appraisals to do, as I've yet to see any company do a half decent job of them.

gus607

1,001 posts

167 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
You're lucky to get that. Where I work we don't get any sickness benefit from the company at all. Even accidents at work get nothing.

Vaud

60,055 posts

186 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
gus607 said:
You're lucky to get that. Where I work we don't get any sickness benefit from the company at all. Even accidents at work get nothing.
You might like to check your rights on that.

Danielson73

703 posts

294 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Thats a bit harsh going down the disciplinary route if staff exceed the paid sick days limit. Should just be unpaid leave after that.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
No sensible employer is going to discipline a valued member of staff if they are genuinely sick. The rules are there to enable companies to deal with the ones taking the mick.

Look at it from another angle, if you're not sick all year you can have a 'sick' week before Christmas.

northandy

3,540 posts

252 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
In 23 years of work, I've never had a full week of sickness, accumulated it's probably under 10 days. To just point out I get paid sick pay for up to 6 months,

My point is that 8 days per year before 1st stage disciplinary is pretty lenient.

KM666

1,757 posts

214 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
We have this where I am and we're not paid for sick days. You can have 3 'sick' days in a period of 12 months running before disciplinary action. On your 2nd sick day you get 'guidence and councilling' with your return to work interview. Seems pretty normal in retail.

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
Many people… Not saying where or who…

They treat sick days as days they should use to top up their holidays, or days to take off after over indulgence on a monday after a heavy weekend.

Seen too many colleagues do this and know many in a certain sector that do this and it should be a sackable offence to be honest.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
toerag said:
So long story short, my employer has decided to restrict the amount of sick days taken.

As i understand this is how it works..

your *allowed* (ie. acceptable) to have three occurrences of sick in a working year. One sick is anything over
2 hours away from work (there are 2 hours leeway for dentist appointments etc.), so if you arrive at work 2 hours
& 1 mins late, that's counted as one sick.

or..

4% or the working year (8 days ish) is acceptable.

..after that begins disiplinary action starting with a verble warning through the usual steps (written warning, unpaid sick)
to eventually I guess loosing your job.

I'm not affected by this but there are some worried faces at work, my question is, is this even legal?

To dictate you should remain at a fixed level of health?
What limit, if any, is there on the three occurrences? A limit of 8 days out of a total working year (260 days excluding holidays assuming full time 5 days a week) is very harsh. What happens if a GP issues a Fit Note that says you are not fit for work over a longer period than 8 days?

Also an employee has a right to take sickness as part of their statutory paid holiday entitlement - https://www.gov.uk/taking-sick-leave
If the employer is not taking this into account they are breaking the law and could be in big trouble if the employee brought a tribunal claim for unfair dismissal.

SmoothCriminal

5,985 posts

230 months

Tuesday 10th December 2013
quotequote all
This is how it works.

You have 3 or more periods of absence (eg 1 day 1 day 2 days) you get a disiplinary meeting, you have more than 8 days in one year you get a disciplinary meeting.

This is where they will discuss the reasons why you've been absent if you have a sick note for over 8 days for a genuine reason they won't give you a warning just guidance just like any long term
Sickness.

If there is a trend like you take every Sunday off after payday then you will probably end up with a warning.


aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
The other side of the coin.

I used to work for a local authority, and regularly attended car shows which meant a long weekend away from home (travelling there on the Saturday and back on the Monday then back to work on the Tuesday having taken the Monday off as annual leave, for example). Any requests for occasional days off work as annual leave at the start or end of the week (as in the example above and which I did several times a year) usually led to an informal chat with our manager with the option of a referral to occupational health to discuss any possible addiction problems which required management so as to avoid the need to take time off work on this basis...

One size fits all, eh? nuts There wasn't any counselling or treatment available for attending car shows 200 miles away from home with 2 nights' camping and a BBQ with a few drinks with friends, oddly enough hehe .

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
SmoothCriminal said:
This is how it works.

You have 3 or more periods of absence (eg 1 day 1 day 2 days) you get a disiplinary meeting, you have more than 8 days in one year you get a disciplinary meeting.
A return to work discussion/interview conducted straight off the bat as a disciplinary hearing after 4 days sickness as described may not go down well should an unfair dismissal claim be forthcoming. Employers have a duty of care and such action might be regarded as unduly punitive - http://www.acas.org.uk/media/pdf/7/t/B04_1.pdf

The interesting statistic in that link is the average per annum sickness absence is 8.4 days.

SmoothCriminal said:
This is where they will discuss the reasons why you've been absent if you have a sick note for over 8 days for a genuine reason they won't give you a warning just guidance just like any long term Sickness.
Agreed, but to treat such a discussion as a disciplinary issue would be pretty extreme.

SmoothCriminal said:
If there is a trend like you take every Sunday off after payday then you will probably end up with a warning.
If there is a pattern it requires further investigation and, depending on what it reveals, a warning might well be appropriate.

andyiley

13,663 posts

183 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
Also an employee has a right to take sickness as part of their statutory paid holiday entitlement - https://www.gov.uk/taking-sick-leave
If the employer is not taking this into account they are breaking the law and could be in big trouble if the employee brought a tribunal claim for unfair dismissal.
I think you may be mis-reading what your link says.

It says "Employees only need a fit note from a doctor after 7 days off work sick and have the right to use their statutory holiday entitlement during their sickness."

Which means if you are on the sick, you have the right to get paid for it by opting to call it holiday.

The way you worded your post implies that you can use sickness to boost up your annual leave entitlement.

Edited by andyiley on Wednesday 11th December 07:17

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
An employer has many legal reasons to terminate employment, one of which is capability. Someone who is off sick often is potentially incapable of doing the job.

Dismissal is a final option in all cases.

Although I wish I'd had a £1 for everyone who appealed their dismissal after frequent periods of sickness withe reason being "but I was genuinely sick the last time". Obviously begging the question "and what about all the other times?"

FiF

49,056 posts

282 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
To some extent I have seen various implementations of this attempt to deal with those who take the mick.

For example, the Mrs' place has a return to work interview after the first occasion, and it is part of the disciplinary process, which frankly gets up the noses of the staff. Yet they don't action it properly.

She has a colleague that I would have shown the gate long ago, e.g. asks to swap shift with someone else due to private business, if nobody swaps then she calls in sick. Manipulating cow because she knows that people will now always swap rather than be constantly left short handed and run ragged.

On the other side my own employer had a rule of x days paid sick allowed per year. If in your first year you had 3 days off in year 2 it was 2x - 3 and so on. Accumulated each year up to a maximum of 6 months on full pay another 6 on half.

Became really ill and was off for months. Their attitude was that regardless of the rules I'd accumulated enough for over a whole year at full pay so not to worry about pay or still having a job.

The point is that firms will have rules but it's what they do with those rules which determines if they are decent sorts. Exactly the same argument applies to the other side of the equation the employees.

One place got asked if I had taken my 7 days yet. 7 days? Yes you' re allowed 7 days off every 3 months or they ask questions. Nationalised industry. Got the hell out of there.

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
toerag said:
...I'm not affected by this but there are some worried faces at work, my question is, is this even legal?

To dictate you should remain at a fixed level of health?
An employer can fairly dismiss an employee for failure to comply with its sickness policy where absence is intermittent, genuine and for unrelated health reasons subject to a fair process including a fair review of reasons for absence, notice of the required improvement and warnings of the consequences of failure to adequately improve. (Subject to the absence not being related to a disability.


Also, if the policy is not contractual, the absence usually needs to cause problems for the organisation. The stricter the policy, the more difficult it may be to show the dismissal is reasonable.

Statutory holiday pay entitlement is irrelevant.



spitfire-ian

4,261 posts

259 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I'd never heard of sick allowance before a friend was saying he'd run out of holiday entitlement but that was ok as he'd still got 5 sick days left to take!

On the flip side, any bonus I get is reduced depending on how many days off sick I have.

jesta1865

3,453 posts

240 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
i contract and so if i don't work i don't get paid, last week i had to take a day off as i could hardly walk after a nasty tackle at football.

it's made me think again about playing at my age.

i also am diabetic and i haven't had 8 days off a year because of it since 2002 why it was diagnosed.

longest i ever had off was years ago when i broke my leg playing football, but i was paye then and the bank were very good about it.