Towbar fitted to car not legally allowed to tow: MOT fail?
Towbar fitted to car not legally allowed to tow: MOT fail?
Author
Discussion

Deisel Weisel

Original Poster:

3,209 posts

215 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I’m referring to a Ford Puma 1.7 (2001). Puma’s appear to be missing the vital ‘train weight’ from their VIN plates, which means they can’t legally tow, apparently. But if I were to fit a tow-bar, will this be an MOT fail?

Dave 500

7,889 posts

273 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Not sure about the MOT but your insurance company won't be happy if you have a crash towing a trailer.

If its for a bike rack or something I wouldn't have thought it would really matter.

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Deisel Weisel said:
I’m referring to a Ford Puma 1.7 (2001). Puma’s appear to be missing the vital ‘train weight’ from their VIN plates, which means they can’t legally tow, apparently. But if I were to fit a tow-bar, will this be an MOT fail?
Can you actually manage to cover the rear number plate of a Puma with a tow bar ? biggrin

Deisel Weisel

Original Poster:

3,209 posts

215 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Dave 500 said:
Not sure about the MOT but your insurance company won't be happy if you have a crash towing a trailer.

If its for a bike rack or something I wouldn't have thought it would really matter.
Good point on the insurance. Yeah, they're not going to know, that it's not for a bike rack, but just the fitting of the tow bar might still be illegal.

covboy said:
Can you actually manage to cover the rear number plate of a Puma with a tow bar ? biggrin
Nope tongue out


http://www.rejects.co.uk/html/towbar.html


TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Deisel Weisel said:
I’m referring to a Ford Puma 1.7 (2001). Puma’s appear to be missing the vital ‘train weight’ from their VIN plates, which means they can’t legally tow, apparently. But if I were to fit a tow-bar, will this be an MOT fail?
It's not part of the MOT. At the moment. The test only cares if it's secure and if any 13-pin electrics work.

But it'd definitely be a C&U offence - any towbar fitted to any car first reg after 1998 has to meet the 94/20/EC regs, which state it has to be type approved for that car and use the manufacturer's approved fitting points. Whether you care about that is another issue... Biggest problem would be insurance in the event of a claim. If somebody rear-ends you, the assessor could claim that use of a non-approved bar has contributed to the damage. If you're towing and stuff it or the trailer goes walkies, they could claim that you shouldn't have been towing in the first place.

Deisel Weisel

Original Poster:

3,209 posts

215 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I think they're saying here that it's legal:

Type Approval and European Law 94/20EC
Most passenger cars registered after 1st August 1998 (S registration) must be fitted with a Type Approved towbar. These cars have an “e” mark on the VIN plate together with the maximum car and trailer mass. If the trailer mass is not specified then the car is not permitted to tow a trailer, however it may still be fitted with a support bracket to fit a cycle or motorbike carrier.


Deisel Weisel

Original Poster:

3,209 posts

215 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
It's not part of the MOT. At the moment.

But it'd definitely be a C&U offence - any towbar fitted to any car first reg after 1998 has to meet the 94/20/EC regs, which state it has to be type approved for that car and use the manufacturer's approved fitting points. Whether you care about that is another issue... Biggest problem would be insurance in the event of a claim. If somebody rear-ends you, the assessor could claim that use of a non-approved bar has contributed to the damage. If you're towing and stuff it or the trailer goes walkies, they could claim that you shouldn't have been towing in the first place.
All valid points. Thanks.

Cooperman

4,428 posts

281 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
You might want to fit a tow bar to tow trailers on private land. For example, I often move glider trailers around onto and off of the airfield. I might not ever tow one on the public road.

tehguy

178 posts

162 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
If the Puma is not type approved to tow then it is illegal to fit a tow bar and drive it on the road. On private land, for example your own farm, you can do whatever you want with what the hell you want. But if you were to somehow fit a towbar to a Puma (god knows how that other guy did it if there are no mounting points) and tow a trailer on the road you'd be breaking some C&U regs. The chances of you being caught unless you drove through a VOSA checkpoint are approximately nil, though, as most police know absolutely nothing about trailers or towing.

jbsportstech

5,069 posts

210 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Wasn't st170 the same as ford said not to tow but I have seen a few one with a big caravan on.

Funk

27,820 posts

240 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Focus ST isn't permitted to tow either.

jbsportstech

5,069 posts

210 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Fst 225 isn't the exhaust pretty much makes it's impossible.

The st170 was not approved by ford but a focus tow bar will fit and I have seen a few with tow bars.

Are they not allowed or not?

tehguy

178 posts

162 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
If it is not approved by the manufacturer then it is not legal.

joe_90

4,206 posts

262 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Funk said:
Focus ST isn't permitted to tow either.
Nor was the RS6 in Evo..

Edited by joe_90 on Monday 16th December 10:42

andye30m3

3,501 posts

285 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
My old M3 evo wasn't supposed to tow as in was a '98 car but a '97 car was fine

Must confess it did occasionally get used for towing, don't think I'd risk it now must be getting older and more sensible



I never had any issues at mot time although I would guess there's a legitimate case for using a tow bar for a bike rack rather than towing

Edited by andye30m3 on Monday 16th December 12:13

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Cooperman said:
You might want to fit a tow bar to tow trailers on private land. For example, I often move glider trailers around onto and off of the airfield. I might not ever tow one on the public road.
The problem is, if the cars structure has not been designed with towing in mind, you could be causing stress damage to the suspension components, chassis or floor pan that could be a contributing factor in an incident later on.

There is a reason why certain cars are not type approved for towing and it's usually for structural safety reasons and not just for the hell of it!

lawrencec

199 posts

223 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
ive seen a number of Mercedes coupes towing

one was last night with a small trailer on the back doing 70mph in the fast lane :/

and the the other had his roof down towing his motorboat like a boss smile

my e36 has a non approved tow bar on it where it mounts through the spare wheel well and bumper brackets. the approved type uses the chassis legs to mount too but I would never use it to tow up to its limit the car is too light

Edited by lawrencec on Wednesday 18th December 09:37

jbsportstech

5,069 posts

210 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
I think its the same with st170 as the tow bar for a 98-2004 focus fits the same as its would to 2.0 zetec but they didnt said it for type approval i think as its lower that standard car.

Seen a couple with trailers and one with 2/3 berth caravan although it wasn't pretty.

tehguy

178 posts

162 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
andye30m3 said:
My old M3 evo wasn't supposed to tow as in was a '98 car but a '97 car was fine

Must confess it did occasionally get used for towing, don't think I'd risk it now must be getting older and more sensible



I never had any issues at mot time although I would guess there's a legitimate case for using a tow bar for a bike rack rather than towing

Edited by andye30m3 on Monday 16th December 12:13
Wow. How far over the cars towing limit was that?

jbsportstech

5,069 posts

210 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
tehguy said:
Wow. How far over the cars towing limit was that?
car is not approved to tow so has no towing limit!