Overdue invoice - late penalties Small Claims Q
Overdue invoice - late penalties Small Claims Q
Author
Discussion

ReaderScars

Original Poster:

6,087 posts

207 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I have had reason to send out reminders for non payment of invoices. Prior to sending out the first invoice I stated out 'late payment penalties' of £100 for four weeks late should the due date go ignored.

If the invoice remains unpaid I also stated further penalties of £25 per day past the four week deadline.

Would these late penalties be enforceable via Small Claims or are they likely to be seen as an unenforceable fine?

This isn't a supplier, client etc. There is no 'goodwill' between myself and the recipient of the invoices.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Absent agreement to them by the customer, your late payment charges are unenforceable. You can claim interest at a modest rate on an unpaid debt.

If you assert that you contracted on the basis that the payments stipulated would be payable, they will be unenforceable as penalties unless they represent genuine pre estimates of loss caused by late payment.

Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 11th December 14:12

ReaderScars

Original Poster:

6,087 posts

207 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I've edited this reply having read your edited response to my op.

Thanks. There are no losses incurred.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Just claim interest on the debt. Add this to your claim:

The claimant claims interest under Section 69 of the County Courts Act 1984 at the rate of 8% per annum from from (date of debt arising) until payment or at such rate and for such period as the court shall consider appropriate.

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
From your mention of invoices if these are commercial debts you can also plead interest under the Late Payment of Commercial Debts legislation (out and about and can't recall the full title) which is interest at 8% above base rate and also an additional £40 or £70 payment depending on the sum due.




Edited by Andy_GSA on Wednesday 11th December 14:31

Terminator X

21,048 posts

235 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
[thread high-jack]

My payment terms are +28 days and two clients are as of today 2 weeks and a day late on the due date (one of them a regular who pays late every month, aarrgghh!), out of interest how long can / should one wait before adding interest and chasing it?

[/thread high-jack]

TX.

tintopracer

139 posts

198 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Under the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998, you are entitled to claim interest from the date when the payment is due. For example, if you have agreed terms for payment of 28 days from date of invoice, then you can claim interest on the debt from the 29th day.

You need to be certain of:

1. you can prove that the payment terms are agreed between you and your customer;
2. you can prove the debt is due i.e. invoice sent and received. May be worth phoning your customer's accounts dept. to ask when payment will be made. If they don't dispute receipt of the invoice or the sum claimed this could be useful evidence later of these two issues;
3. if you google this Act, you'll find there are also guides as to how much interest is due and how to pursue it with the customer.

If you want to then pursue it through the Small Claims Court, the above will be issues the Judge will need to hear from you on, to prove the debt is owed if you're customer tries to avoid payment.

Wozy68

5,436 posts

201 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
As bottle washer, cabinet maker, accounts, sales and chief purchaser for my mighty international plc, I can't always keep a watchful eye on supplier terms or even due dates for payment. I'd never use them again, though if they ever charged me interest on a debt. (Unless it was exceptionally old) I wouldn't pay the interest. Someone tried once to add it, I ignored it and paid the original amount and heard no more.

Though suppliers have tightened their belts with credit control over the last 5 years (and quite rightly so). If they didn't allow for some flexibility in payment terms, twice as many firms would have gone due to cashflow restrictions than have.

To the OP, your terms are the most severe I have come across. Either you are in big business or not any of the trades I deal with. I wouldn't use you with terms like that. But then again, you know your business, I don't.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
My clients (solicitors, in house lawyers, and the Government) pay me when they can be arsed. It takes months, and sometimes years to get paid. The Government pays bupkiss but pays quickly, unless it's legal aid, which is bupkiss multiplied by feck all, and takes years to pay. There is no really effective way to chase the clients, as it's a buyers market. Until recently, we didn't even have any contractual right to our fees. Now we do, but I have never heard of any barrister suing for fees.

Terminator X

21,048 posts

235 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Wozy - whilst you're no doubt correct it's also bang out of order to keep people waiting for payment beyond the due date. I don't like chasing anyone for money but what can I do when they don't pay on time? Bear in mind they've already had the benefit of at least 28 days grace sometimes much more if the work was done for them at beginning of the month with invoice sent at the end.

TX.

Edit - btw my invoices have the due date written on them.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
My clients (solicitors, in house lawyers, and the Government) pay me when they can be arsed. It takes months, and sometimes years to get paid. The Government pays bupkiss but pays quickly, unless it's legal aid, which is bupkiss multiplied by feck all, and takes years to pay. There is no really effective way to chase the clients, as it's a buyers market. Until recently, we didn't even have any contractual right to our fees. Now we do, but I have never heard of any barrister suing for fees.
Quite. Interest free, unsecured lending, where the borrower sets the borrowing limit, and the repayment date is when the borrower says it is. With debt waivers offered when the borrower asks for them. The lesser known service offered by barristers.

Wozy68

5,436 posts

201 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
My clients (solicitors, in house lawyers, and the Government) pay me when they can be arsed. It takes months, and sometimes years to get paid. The Government pays bupkiss but pays quickly, unless it's legal aid, which is bupkiss multiplied by feck all, and takes years to pay. There is no really effective way to chase the clients, as it's a buyers market. Until recently, we didn't even have any contractual right to our fees. Now we do, but I have never heard of any barrister suing for fees.
I make bespoke fitted furniture. Try chasing a debt when it's bolted to their wall. No chance of removing it. Hands of the Gods then If they declare themself bankrupt, or at least that was once the case.

There is still a very large Cotswold stone house in Gloucestershire with beautiful oak panelling throughout the downstairs rooms with matching joinery oak doors that the client never paid me for. He lost the house, the Bank got it, but I never got the panelling.

Lesson learnt there.

surveyor

18,708 posts

215 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Still solicitors can take as long to pay out, as someone who does a lot of work for them.

My fee's tend to be small, and it never ceases to irk me when they pay late.

I did enjoy instructing debt collectors on one, who I did not particularly want to do any work for again, seeing as he was too busy to pay me. Sadly he did not pay the additional costs of instructing the debt collector, and I was told that courts frown on litigation to collect costs. The result is I a did a very good job, instrumental in settling the case, with a very fast turnaround and made £0 profit.

I think when it gets to 2 months you can apply a £45 charge for the costs incurred in collecting.

V8 Fettler

7,019 posts

163 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Wozy68 said:
I make bespoke fitted furniture. Try chasing a debt when it's bolted to their wall. No chance of removing it. Hands of the Gods then If they declare themself bankrupt, or at least that was once the case.

There is still a very large Cotswold stone house in Gloucestershire with beautiful oak panelling throughout the downstairs rooms with matching joinery oak doors that the client never paid me for. He lost the house, the Bank got it, but I never got the panelling.

Lesson learnt there.
You could structure your contract to achieve payment for works completed off site (i.e. manufacture). In my experience, many contractors have severe cash flow problems that are only masked by jacking up prices, have to press them to invoice promptly (engineering and construction). Bizarre.