Driving, Diabetes, & DVLA, advice sought please
Driving, Diabetes, & DVLA, advice sought please
Author
Discussion

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Chaps.

I've had my diabetic checkup today, and I'm slightly surprised at what I'm being told, by my specialist GP.

I'm wondering if she's been on some sort of course or something, but I cannot find anything on what she is telling me by googling DVLA etc.

She is telling me that if I don't start checking my blood sugars before I drive, everytime, and log it, as well as checking them every two hours whilst driving, DVLA will revoke my licence.

Anyone any knowledge of this please ?

g3org3y

22,523 posts

222 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
Chaps.

I've had my diabetic checkup today, and I'm slightly surprised at what I'm being told, by my specialist GP.

I'm wondering if she's been on some sort of course or something, but I cannot find anything on what she is telling me by googling DVLA etc.

She is telling me that if I don't start checking my blood sugars before I drive, everytime, and log it, as well as checking them every two hours whilst driving, DVLA will revoke my licence.

Anyone any knowledge of this please ?
Insulin or tablet controlled?

gruffalo

8,183 posts

257 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
Chaps.

I've had my diabetic checkup today, and I'm slightly surprised at what I'm being told, by my specialist GP.

I'm wondering if she's been on some sort of course or something, but I cannot find anything on what she is telling me by googling DVLA etc.

She is telling me that if I don't start checking my blood sugars before I drive, everytime, and log it, as well as checking them every two hours whilst driving, DVLA will revoke my licence.

Anyone any knowledge of this please ?
I have been told only if you have a documented history of hypo's, last time I was at the doctors they told me that I was doing every thing fine that all was well under control see you in a year, I probably check my levels once a week.

Insulin controlled, I don't drive when hungry and avoid high carb intake when driving and keep wine gums in the car.

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
Insulin or tablet controlled?
Sorry, insulin, blood sugar levels aren't as much of an issue to the others.

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
gruffalo said:
I have been told only if you have a documented history of hypo's, last time I was at the doctors they told me that I was doing every thing fine that all was well under control see you in a year, I probably check my levels once a week.

Insulin controlled, I don't drive when hungry and avoid high carb intake when driving and keep wine gums in the car.
Insulin controlled and once a week level checks ??????

How the fook do you do that ?

I test at least four times a day, as I have to vary the fast acting insulin to what I'm about to eat or have just eaten.

I'm now being told, as I said, that I also have to test before I drive, everytime, and every two hours whilst driving, there are other almost as unbelievable stuff she said too, but I'll leave that until later.

I cannot find anything that says I must do as she'd like, and obviously I don't want to, which is why I'm checking.

I have no control issues, and never have had, ever.

She actually said that DVLA will revoke my licence if I don't do these checks.

g3org3y

22,523 posts

222 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
g3org3y said:
Insulin or tablet controlled?
Sorry, insulin, blood sugar levels aren't as much of an issue to the others.
Iirc, for group 2 drivers (HGVs) etc you need to have had:
- no severe hypos for 12 months
- full hypo awareness
- Sugar control twice daily
- submission of 3 months of glucose results prior to driving

With regards to group 1 I was under the impression when on insulin it was only an issue if one has suffered a severe hypo in the last year. I think it is true that you need monitoring while driving (every two hours or so).

Tablet/diet controlled diabetes do not need to inform the DVLA.

Check out the 'at a glance' guidelines here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/at-a-gl...

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
Iirc, for group 2 drivers (HGVs) etc you need to have had:
- no severe hypos for 12 months
- full hypo awareness
- Sugar control twice daily
- submission of 3 months of glucose results prior to driving

With regards to group 1 I was under the impression when on insulin it was only an issue if one has suffered a severe hypo in the last year. I think it is true that you need monitoring while driving (every two hours or so).

Tablet/diet controlled diabetes do not need to inform the DVLA.

Check out the 'at a glance' guidelines here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/at-a-gl...
Thanks.

I guess this is the bit she's worried about :

  • ***
Must regularly monitor their condition by checking their blood glucose levels at least twice daily and at times
relevant to driving. A glucose meter with a memory function to measure and record blood glucose levels
must be used

  • ***
It doesn't quite say what she's telling me though.

Strange to see the stuff for what you call group two now, it is changing for the better, my hgv was just removed, end of etc.

gruffalo

8,183 posts

257 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
gruffalo said:
I have been told only if you have a documented history of hypo's, last time I was at the doctors they told me that I was doing every thing fine that all was well under control see you in a year, I probably check my levels once a week.

Insulin controlled, I don't drive when hungry and avoid high carb intake when driving and keep wine gums in the car.
Insulin controlled and once a week level checks ??????

How the fook do you do that ?

I test at least four times a day, as I have to vary the fast acting insulin to what I'm about to eat or have just eaten.

I'm now being told, as I said, that I also have to test before I drive, everytime, and every two hours whilst driving, there are other almost as unbelievable stuff she said too, but I'll leave that until later.

I cannot find anything that says I must do as she'd like, and obviously I don't want to, which is why I'm checking.

I have no control issues, and never have had, ever.

She actually said that DVLA will revoke my licence if I don't do these checks.
I used to test every few hours and now I know how I feel and medicate accordingly, slow acting jab once a day and one fast acting with each meal. I have an average of 6.3 as my level and have had for the last 5 years, it never changes, I control my diet quite strictly but still eat what I want just in moderation and allow for it in my injections.

There will be not many non diabetic peoplek who have as stable a blood sugar level as a well controlled insulin using diabetic, yet we have to put up with 3 year licences and DVLA making up stupid rules like not being allowed to drive a minibusrolleyes

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
gruffalo said:
I used to test every few hours and now I know how I feel and medicate accordingly, slow acting jab once a day and one fast acting with each meal. I have an average of 6.3 as my level and have had for the last 5 years, it never changes, I control my diet quite strictly but still eat what I want just in moderation and allow for it in my injections.

There will be not many non diabetic peoplek who have as stable a blood sugar level as a well controlled insulin using diabetic, yet we have to put up with 3 year licences and DVLA making up stupid rules like not being allowed to drive a minibusrolleyes
I'm as stable as you, although my average is slightly higher, high 7's this time.

Like you I know exactly how I feel, but I still test at every meal, as well as first thing.

I have the same driving restrictions as you of course, they took my HGV in the mid 90's, and my minibus and 7.5 tons in 2000.

I take it you have no knowledge of these new "rules" ?

PlayersNo6

1,102 posts

187 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
gruffalo said:
I have been told only if you have a documented history of hypo's, last time I was at the doctors they told me that I was doing every thing fine that all was well under control see you in a year, I probably check my levels once a week.

Insulin controlled, I don't drive when hungry and avoid high carb intake when driving and keep wine gums in the car.
+1 AFAIK. This is also obvious from the license renewal form where they ask questions about incidence of hypos and your awareness of it. Not aware of any new rules...

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
The change in the rules is new to me. I was diagnosed about eight years ago and notified DVLA as being on diet and tablets ,as required. Reply was that I'd complied with regulations. Today ,I wouldn't have to notify them ,but the Insurance companies are still behind the times and like the "DVLA AWARE, NO RESTRICTIONS" reply . I wouldn't be bothered by any medical reports, as my surgery say my control ( if to me a tad high at 7.0) is good. So I'd now question if DVLA don't want to know, just why the insurance companies do .

TankRizzo

8,031 posts

224 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Had my checkup two weeks ago, nurse said nothing like this. I test a few times a week but no more than that. I also renewed my licence six weeks ago and nothing was said then; the licence comes back so quickly that to be honest I suspect the DVLA don't bother checking sometimes.

Type 1 for 23 years.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
This has come up before. It does not apply to your average, diabetic car-driver. However, it appears that several diabetic clinics are giving this advice to everyone. A friend who is a pharmacist with a large chain of chemists told me a year ago that there had been a marked upturn in enquiries about recording monitors from diabetic customers who had been told they must get one or stop driving.

Disturbingly incorrect advice in the main, but it appears that's the guidance they were given. Even the posters in the surgeries had this wrong message.

Streaky

scubiedoo

177 posts

242 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Its yet more legislation bringing us into line with the EU, started earlier this year

Medical Practioners At a Glance Guide to Medical standards
Page 35 shows that for driving Group 1 car/motorcycle
DIABETES MELLITUS
INSULIN-TREATED
• Must have awareness of hypoglycaemia.
• Must not have had more than one episode of hypoglycaemia requiring the assistance of another person in the preceding twelve months.
• There must be appropriate blood glucose monitoring. This has been defined by the Secretary of State’s Honorary Medical Advisory Panel on Driving and Diabetes as no more than 2 hours before the start of the first journey and every 2 hours while driving. More frequent testing may be required if for any reason there is a greater risk of hypoglycaemia for example after physical activity or altered meal routine.
• Must not be regarded as a likely source of danger to the public while driving.
• The visual standards for acuity and visual field must be met
Impaired awareness of hypoglycaemia has been defined by the Secretary of State's Honorary Medical Advisory Panel on Driving and Diabetes as, 'an inability to detect the onset of hypoglycaemia because of a total absence of warning symptoms'.

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
streaky said:
This has come up before. It does not apply to your average, diabetic car-driver. However, it appears that several diabetic clinics are giving this advice to everyone. A friend who is a pharmacist with a large chain of chemists told me a year ago that there had been a marked upturn in enquiries about recording monitors from diabetic customers who had been told they must get one or stop driving.

Disturbingly incorrect advice in the main, but it appears that's the guidance they were given. Even the posters in the surgeries had this wrong message.

Streaky
Cheers Streaky.

I, along with everyone else on insulin are actually issued with these meters, these days it is only the non insulin types that have to buy them.

They used to get them issued too if their team wanted, but not now with the cutbacks.

What is odd for me is that fairly recently it was in the news that we were being told/encouraged to cut back on our test strip use, as they are so expensive, although my nurse told me to carry on as before, and now I have a specialist GP basically asking me to test an extra 3, 4, or 5 times a day !

I'd have no fingertips left.

The rest of todays "advice" was just as astonishing to be honest, along with more threats regarding DVLA and revokation of my licence for failing to comply.

Apparently if my blood sugars go low now, I have to exit the drivers seat, and remove the keys from the ignition, the time of my "low" will be recorded on my meter (which it actually will, providing I have the clock set correctly, I can't remember the last time I checked it), and if I were to have an accident within an hour of going low, insurance companies now have an agreement with mobile phone companies, they will use this to track my location and the time(s) I have driven.

I asked why I had to exit the drivers seat etc, and was told it was in case I became confused and decided to drive.

I did point out to her that I am diabetic not senile.

I think in all my years of being diabetic, and with all the miles I drive, that a low has only happened to me whilst driving two or three times, the last being shortly after a regime change, possibly six or seven years ago.

It really isn't an issue, although it is a nuisance, as you aren't supposed to drive for 40 minutes (I leave an hour to be sure), and that was a long time to be sat up a motorway embankment, but I did it.

It wasn't a good consultation to be honest, she even told me she didn't think there was any point in trying to "hone" my care plan,(not that I'd asked for any honing, they called me in, I didn't ask to be checked), if I won't give up smoking.

Does anyone think there is any point in asking DVLA about this, or will I just cause myself trouble ?

funkyrobot

18,789 posts

259 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
streaky said:
This has come up before. It does not apply to your average, diabetic car-driver. However, it appears that several diabetic clinics are giving this advice to everyone. A friend who is a pharmacist with a large chain of chemists told me a year ago that there had been a marked upturn in enquiries about recording monitors from diabetic customers who had been told they must get one or stop driving.

Disturbingly incorrect advice in the main, but it appears that's the guidance they were given. Even the posters in the surgeries had this wrong message.

Streaky
Cheers Streaky.

I, along with everyone else on insulin are actually issued with these meters, these days it is only the non insulin types that have to buy them.

They used to get them issued too if their team wanted, but not now with the cutbacks.

What is odd for me is that fairly recently it was in the news that we were being told/encouraged to cut back on our test strip use, as they are so expensive, although my nurse told me to carry on as before, and now I have a specialist GP basically asking me to test an extra 3, 4, or 5 times a day !

I'd have no fingertips left.

The rest of todays "advice" was just as astonishing to be honest, along with more threats regarding DVLA and revokation of my licence for failing to comply.

Apparently if my blood sugars go low now, I have to exit the drivers seat, and remove the keys from the ignition, the time of my "low" will be recorded on my meter (which it actually will, providing I have the clock set correctly, I can't remember the last time I checked it), and if I were to have an accident within an hour of going low, insurance companies now have an agreement with mobile phone companies, they will use this to track my location and the time(s) I have driven.

I asked why I had to exit the drivers seat etc, and was told it was in case I became confused and decided to drive.

I did point out to her that I am diabetic not senile.

I think in all my years of being diabetic, and with all the miles I drive, that a low has only happened to me whilst driving two or three times, the last being shortly after a regime change, possibly six or seven years ago.

It really isn't an issue, although it is a nuisance, as you aren't supposed to drive for 40 minutes (I leave an hour to be sure), and that was a long time to be sat up a motorway embankment, but I did it.

It wasn't a good consultation to be honest, she even told me she didn't think there was any point in trying to "hone" my care plan,(not that I'd asked for any honing, they called me in, I didn't ask to be checked), if I won't give up smoking.

Does anyone think there is any point in asking DVLA about this, or will I just cause myself trouble ?
As above, my fiancee (type 1 insulin controlled for about 11 years now) was informed a while ago about driving and hypos. She was told that if she had more than one severe hypo that required help from someone else whilst driving, they would consider reviewing her licence.

Seems to be a bit of confusion around where the person has the hypo. From the information given to my fiancee it related to driving a vehicle at the time. As we all know, hypos can happen at any time, so removal of licence would result in a lot of diabetics walking or getting the bus. smile

From what I can ascertain, help from another person involves medical professionals (i.e. an ambulance).

I'll look at some of the info posted above and pass this on to my fiancee.

Oh yes, she injects four to five times a day (slow release twice then fast release for each meal) and the only risk she presents to the public is her speed. She drives far too slow! smile

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
I've had my diabetic checkup today, and I'm slightly surprised at what I'm being told, by my specialist GP.
Why not book an appointment with your regular GP and ask them what they think?

Or with your usual diabetes consultant at your hospital?

This is the internet: reliable, personalised health advice is not its forte. wink

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I don't understand why you haven't asked the DVLA about it?

funkyrobot

18,789 posts

259 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
I don't understand why you haven't asked the DVLA about it?
Because he wants a proper answer. smile

DCS01

350 posts

213 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I've been a type 2 for some years now, with no problems. However at my last check up they told me I would have to go onto insulin, starting in Jan. Two injections a day. Not a problem in its self.
All this talk of testing and driving does worry me, along with the limited license. Can anyone shed any light on, do the DVLA suspend your license before giving it back to you. And this testing lark.
I am a proffesional driver (car delivery and collections) and am just coming to the end of a probationary period with a new employer, not good news if I have to tell them I cannot drive, as the DVLA has susrpended my license for a time, till the new insulin program has been sorted out.