Hypothetical specs puzzle
Author
Discussion

HertsBiker

Original Poster:

6,443 posts

302 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
OK, drive half way into specs array, stop, swap driver. Blast off at speed. Exceed average speed. Who gets named, who gets ticket? Am really trying to mess up the system here, not worried about anything. Just harmless fun, seeing as the scum keep saying speed kills when it doesn't. We all know planes and trains are safe, it's the sudden deceleration caused by morons that kills.

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I imagine they would drop the speeding charge and do you both for careless driving.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
With what evidence? Excess speed does not automatically equate with careless.

Red 4

10,744 posts

218 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
The only thing you'll mess up is your licence.

Expect points and a fine for misuse of the hard shoulder too.

Moronic post.

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
With what evidence? Excess speed does not automatically equate with careless.
Their defense appears to be that they stopped (presumably on the hard shoulder) to swap drivers before 'blasting' off.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Red 4 said:
Moronic post.
yes

dxg

10,842 posts

291 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
There's plenty of specs around here that aren't on motorways.

Nottingham and Mansfield both have them. The Mansfield, as I recall, is enforcing a 30mph limit. So plenty of opportunity to legally swap drivers...

BonzoG

1,554 posts

245 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Add a 40-mile stretch of the A77, and the road from Belfast to Bangor, to that list.

Interesting question - 1.5 points/£50 each? laugh

Red 4

10,744 posts

218 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Simple answer - NIP and s.172 to registered keeper.

Good luck explaining yourself to the court.


robinessex

12,044 posts

212 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Do a Jeremy Clarkson. Stop halfway thro' the speed zone. Wait 10 minutes. Complete the remaing section at 200mph!

HertsBiker

Original Poster:

6,443 posts

302 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
roofer said:
Red 4 said:
Moronic post.
yes
I reckon you two are pretty moronic for not adding anything of value to a discussion. Haven't you seen any roads that are now ruined by specs? Mile after mile of mind numbing boredom only livened up by stopping after a camera to build up a bit of spare? Not motorway at all. Now crawl under your bridge and do nothing as you obviously aren't interested in motoring.

Ki3r

8,921 posts

190 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
I reckon you two are pretty moronic for not adding anything of value to a discussion. Haven't you seen any roads that are now ruined by specs? Mile after mile of mind numbing boredom only livened up by stopping after a camera to build up a bit of spare? Not motorway at all. Now crawl under your bridge and do nothing as you obviously aren't interested in motoring.
Time of the month?

AmitG

3,572 posts

191 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I think it's an interesting question.

Suppose that you are in the middle of an average-speed monitored stretch, and you swap drivers for a legitimate reason. Say, the first driver falls ill and you have to stop the car and take over. Or, the stretch of road being monitored includes a service stop (not uncommon on motorways) and you switch over then.

You drive really fast through the remaining section and the overall average speed limit for that section is exceeded.

NIP is sent to the registered keeper (which could be, but is not necessarily, one of you). They want to know who was driving.

You answer that over that stretch of road, you both were. This is the honest truth.

Who gets the fine and/or points?

With a fixed-point speed camera this doesn't arise, since they are only interested in who was driving that specific car at the time that the camera was passed, and clearly only one person could have done that.

Hugo a Gogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
I reckon you two are pretty moronic for not adding anything of value to a discussion. Haven't you seen any roads that are now ruined by specs? Mile after mile of mind numbing boredom only livened up by stopping after a camera to build up a bit of spare? Not motorway at all. Now crawl under your bridge and do nothing as you obviously aren't interested in motoring.
try 5 arrow-straight flat brand new lanes each way with 100kph limit and average speed cameras, three or four lanes empty at any given time (outside of the busy periods), add in getting a fine for being 3 or 4 kph over

that's the A2 out of Amsterdam

singlecoil

35,898 posts

277 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
OK, drive half way into specs array, stop, swap driver. Blast off at speed. Exceed average speed. Who gets named, who gets ticket? Am really trying to mess up the system here, not worried about anything. Just harmless fun, seeing as the scum keep saying speed kills when it doesn't. We all know planes and trains are safe, it's the sudden deceleration caused by morons that kills.
'Speed kills' is a catch phrase, of course speed itself doesn't kill, but excessive speed in certain circumstances does kill, and that's what the phrase means. But that's too many words for a satisfactory catch phrase, hence the short (but strictly speaking inaccurate) phrase is used instead.

If you could come up with another catch phrase to counter it, then that would be something worth posting about.

BTW, there are many causes of sudden deceleration, morons are just one of them. There are also accidents, mechanical failures, unforeseen events etc.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
i would be quite surprised if you could pass one of the cameras change drivers, and still get up to enough speed by the next one to exceed the average speed
what is the maximum distance they can be apart ?

how about what would happen if your car was cloned, and someone drove the cloned car on at a slip road a little way up ahead of you?

AmitG

3,572 posts

191 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
doogz said:
AmitG said:
I think it's an interesting question.

Suppose that you are in the middle of an average-speed monitored stretch, and you swap drivers for a legitimate reason. Say, the first driver falls ill and you have to stop the car and take over. Or, the stretch of road being monitored includes a service stop (not uncommon on motorways) and you switch over then.

You drive really fast through the remaining section and the overall average speed limit for that section is exceeded.

NIP is sent to the registered keeper (which could be, but is not necessarily, one of you). They want to know who was driving.

You answer that over that stretch of road, you both were. This is the honest truth.

Who gets the fine and/or points?

With a fixed-point speed camera this doesn't arise, since they are only interested in who was driving that specific car at the time that the camera was passed, and clearly only one person could have done that.
If you're being deceitful, fair enough. If you're being honest, it'd be the guy that drove really fast through the remaining section, would it not?
I understand your point. I'm interested in the "honest/deceitful" angle. I'm not a lawyer so if I've missed the point completely I apologise boxedin

Let's consider the fixed camera case. I've never received a NIP paperbag but my understanding is that a letter goes to the registered keeper asking them to identify who was driving this specific car at this specific time at this specific location. There is only one possible individual. That individual, once identified, can either admit guilt and get penalised, or take it to court where judgement will be made.

Now consider the average-speed camera case. At the outset, the only question that can reasonably be asked is who was driving at the time of the offence. The NIP cannot ask anyone to admit guilt before that person is identified. They cannot ask if anyone wants to own up to anything.

In this case, "where and when" is a distance and duration, rather than a specific place and time. So, given this question, the only honest and truthful answer is that 2 people fall into this category. Whether one or both of those two thinks they may or may not have been speeding is irrelevant to the question being asked.

What happens then? My guess is that both end up being prosecuted.

What specifically does a NIP for alleged violation of an average speed check, ask for?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
In the real world - the two drivers have an argument and one of them agrees to be sacrificed on the alter of speed cameras.

In the rich celeb world, it goes to court, huge amounts of money is paid to lawyers in an attempt to dodge a few points.
Eventually someone either gets prosecuted or the whole lot is abandoned and they all go for golf.

jkh112

23,948 posts

189 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
'Speed kills' is a catch phrase, of course speed itself doesn't kill, but excessive speed in certain circumstances does kill, and that's what the phrase means.

If you could come up with another catch phrase to counter it, then that would be something worth posting about.
Speed Matters wink

Hugo a Gogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
In the real world - the two drivers have an argument and one of them agrees to be sacrificed on the alter of speed cameras.
for example someone saying his wife should accept the points?