Local Speedwatch Disbands
Author
Discussion

Cooperman

Original Poster:

4,428 posts

281 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
The local Speedwatch 'vigilantes' in St. Ives, Cambs., are to disband this week because the local council will not support them.
They issued so many 'letters' via Cambs. Police that the Police told them that they would only send a limited number of warning letters. St. Ives Council refused to support them and said that speed enforcement is a police matter and not something to spend the rates money on. A bit of common sense there for a change.
There has been a lot of whinging in the press form these vigilantes, but most replies are that 'spy-watch' activities have no place in our society.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
The early stages of every oppressive regime in history have involved the public reporting other members of the public to authorities.
It's not a road I'm keen to travel.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
You won't be so smug about the falling social structures come Local Speedwatch: Beyond Thunderdome.

Cooperman

Original Poster:

4,428 posts

281 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
A friend who went through one of their 'speed checks' stopped, got out and without saying anything started to take photos of them.
They got most irate and told him he was not allowed to do that and that if he didn't stop they would call the Old Bill. He said that if they could check his speed in a public place he could take their photos in the same public place. He suggested they look on Facebook later to see 'Vigilantes in Action'.

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
1. Wouldn't that indicate an area with a high level speeding and therefore possibly overdue for a bit police presence and enforcement?

2. If there is that much speeding wouldn't there also be a proportionate amount of accidents, injuries and fatalities?

3. Therefore it would make sense to have the 'Speed Watch' people there but after they've had some First Aid training and they've been issued with First Aid kits etc. and 'Police Accident' signs etc.

Or have I misunderstood Correlation isn't Causation again?

Cambs. Police should speak to Chief Constable Nick Gargan at Avon and Somerset?


4. If the problem is postage costs perhaps the Speed Watch people could be given police IT logins and Email addresses and they could Email those that they have recorded as exceeding a speed limit along with an image of a kitten?

Or a puppy?

5. I bet Royal Mail as they're only partially privatised preach this precautionary principle road safety nonsense that swills around the public sector and comes from Europe. Perhaps they'd be prepared to offer free postage to 'Speed Watch' groups?

jurbie

2,444 posts

232 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
carinaman said:
1. Wouldn't that indicate an area with a high level speeding and therefore possibly overdue for a bit police presence and enforcement?

2. If there is that much speeding wouldn't there also be a proportionate amount of accidents, injuries and fatalities?

3. Therefore it would make sense to have the 'Speed Watch' people there but after they've had some First Aid training and they've been issued with First Aid kits etc. and 'Police Accident' signs etc.
I thought most of these things were set up to give the interfering busybodies something to do and in the process prove to them that actually everybody doesn't treat that bit of road as a racetrack? I even saw one yesterday, a bored looking plod wishing he was somewhere else and a frustrated looking retired chap getting annoyed that no one was actually speeding.

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
BBC News Website said:
The chief constable of Avon and Somerset Police has said he will buy any speed cameras from local councils unwilling to operate them for £1.
One way of making enforcement by camera more affordable and reducing their operating costs would be to get the volunteers emptying them and maintaining them.

Getting unpaid volunteers running the Speed Cameras would make more money and mean more money to reinvest in more cameras to make more money.

K£rch$ng!

Plus it would mean that the police could get on with policing communities and catching criminals instead of speeding drivers.

Guybrush

4,364 posts

237 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
Cooperman said:
A friend who went through one of their 'speed checks' stopped, got out and without saying anything started to take photos of them.
They got most irate and told him he was not allowed to do that and that if he didn't stop they would call the Old Bill. He said that if they could check his speed in a public place he could take their photos in the same public place. He suggested they look on Facebook later to see 'Vigilantes in Action'.
Well done your friend. A virtual drink to them. thumbup

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
jurbie said:
I thought most of these things were set up to give the interfering busybodies something to do and in the process prove to them that actually everybody doesn't treat that bit of road as a racetrack? I even saw one yesterday, a bored looking plod wishing he was somewhere else and a frustrated looking retired chap getting annoyed that no one was actually speeding.
I know of one near me in Kent that was set up as the non-locals didn't slow down from 60 to 30 to pass through the village. So a load of the old busybodies set up near the entrance to the village. They then discovered that it was the LOCALS who were ignoring the limits and mostly the non locals did (I would assume as they didn't know the road)

It backfired somewhat when they realised they were lettering most of the village and becoming quite unpopular in the process, haven't seen them since

BGarside

1,568 posts

168 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
If the police did their job and policed the roads people would not feel it necessary to do it themselves.

Speeding seesm to have become a non-issue in Britain, with everyone complicit in it and negligible enforcement. Speeding is the norm.

That doesn't make it a good idea.

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
If more people are speeding than not then the road speed has been incorrectly set.

Vaud

60,053 posts

186 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
voyds9 said:
If more people are speeding than not then the road speed has been incorrectly set.
Not true. The public are not always right.

People speed past the school near us, it is a 30 zone. Many do 45, mainly I think because it used to be 40 and was dropped after a series of fatalities. Are the public right, or th authority for setting it based on context?

DougMcC

769 posts

194 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
BGarside said:
If the police did their job and policed the roads people would not feel it necessary to do it themselves.
The police do police the roads. What would be nice is if the police that specifically police the roads weren't being cut/ amalgamated/ whatever.

Vaud

60,053 posts

186 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
DougMcC said:
The police do police the roads. What would be nice is if the police that specifically police the roads weren't being cut/ amalgamated/ whatever.
I think cuts are a bit of a red herring. Speeding hasn't been a real priority even in the peak of police funding - it was pushed to automation since about 1995 (?). In fact most of camera growth whilst spending was rising... "camera numbers multiplied from 1,600 in 2000 to 4,737 in 2007, according to AA figures."

budfox

1,510 posts

160 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
If there's a lower form of life than a pensioner who has nothing better to do than sit on one of those £8.95 seats from Asda in a fluorescent and mentally jerk off every time he clocks someone doing 35MPH outside his house I've yet to see it.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
Guybrush said:
Well done your friend. A virtual drink to them. thumbup
His friend should make sure he doesn't do it to the same group twice or more, as it could easily constitute harassment.

turbobloke

117,589 posts

291 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Vaud said:
voyds9 said:
If more people are speeding than not then the road speed has been incorrectly set.
Not true. The public are not always right.

People speed past the school near us, it is a 30 zone. Many do 45, mainly I think because it used to be 40 and was dropped after a series of fatalities. Are the public right, or th authority for setting it based on context?
If the sentiment in your post is about saving lives rather than enforcement, what makes you think locals who ignored the number 40 on the end of a pole will suddenly act differently when the number changed to 30?

Near a school as anywhere else, drivers should drive at a safe speed for the conditions, which may well be below 30 mph. Claiming safety as a reason for speed limits getting lower and lower suggests that roads and cars are becoming more dangerous to everyone which is not the case.

A series of fatalities is tragic but more than likely is a statistical blip on which reduced limits and/or increased enforcement will have no effect for two reasons, firstly because the deaths have already happened and secondly because the role of excessive speed (not necessarily above the limit) as a causal factor in accidents is very minor - see Transport Research Laboratory Report 323. On top of that, exceeding the posted limit is a factor in less than 4% of accidents according to data from 11 police forces.

If accurate information on causes of RTAs is sought, try the webpages of Paul Smith's Safespeed site and the Association (now Alliance) of British Drivers, which draw from TRL and Police data.

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

292 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Vaud said:
People speed past the school near us, it is a 30 zone. Many do 45, mainly I think because it used to be 40 and was dropped after a series of fatalities.
Or possibly because 30 seems ridiculously low and they decide they may as well be hanged for a sheep. Which would explain why the limit was 40 in the first place.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Wouldn't surprise me if it was the same bunch of balding and blue rinse geriatrics I encountered. The old duffer who was in charge of the gun had been clearly buoyed up by the sound of my exhaust. I think he was expecting me to be hurtling towards them when I came into view round the bend. He looked somewhat flustered when he discovered that I was bang on the 30 limit in second. The old biddy by his side was scowling and waving her arms. She looked like she needed cheering up so I blew her a kiss. The look on her face was priceless.

I was sorely tempted to turn round and go back through the village just for scensoreds and giggles and really push her buttons but decided against it.

Cooperman

Original Poster:

4,428 posts

281 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
The best one I heard of was not from my area. A guy went through a 'vigilante' speed check, saw them start to write down his number, turned around, went back and asked if he had got 'Fastest Time of the Day'. On being told he hadn't, he said he needed to make his second run now and that he would be sure to try harder. Apparently their faces were a picture!