Don't just leave it to your insurer.
Don't just leave it to your insurer.
Author
Discussion

Andy ap

Original Poster:

1,147 posts

203 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I need some advice regards to defending myself against what i have every reason to believe is a fraudulent whiplash claim against me.

Without going into too much detail i had a glancing contact with another vehicle where my front wing clipped his bumper and caused negligible damage to both cars purely superficial dent in my wing and scrape on his bumper from a <5mph touch. I have stupidly admitted fault which i'm now regretting and seriously tempted to change my mind (fat lot of good that would do).

To the point anyway, i have to leave it to my insurer (fully comp with LP) as far as i know to defend my corner but as i've admitted fault they will more than likely bend over so to speak despite my explicitly telling them the above.

I have got contact details for the ABI, the FCA the insurance fraud bureau and the ombudsman but i'm not going to take anything up against my insurer unless they leave me no choice. What i'm asking is it possible for me to contest it in writing such as writing a letter to the TP's solicitor with my side of the story and some independent references with respect the superficial damage to both cars etc etc.

I'm well aware posting this on a public forum could be my undoing should the TP see this but at least his dishonesty is out there.

Watch you backs people for the vultures are following the cowardly lying backstabbers.

Vealie

104 posts

157 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I've experienced this as well.

Unless you instruct them otherwise the insurer will take the line of least resistance and simply process a claim on your policy. It doesn't matter if you have legal fees they just do the simplest easiest thing.

Don't know why we pay them so much for the admin of our policies when they do next to nothing.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Has it not occurred to you that the party with the most to lose on any individual case is the insurance company? Don't you think they would fight it if they had a decent chance of winning? Unless you have compelling evidence that the other party isn't injured then what do you expect them to do? He will have a statement from a doctor saying he has whiplash and listing out all the issues this has caused.

It's frustrating but it needs the government to step in to change it and until then this is the system we're stuck with.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Pictures of dents don't prove anything though do they? If you want your insurance company to fight this in court they're going to need a bit more than that.

pacoryan

671 posts

262 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Like the majority of claim situations it is a commercial decision and has nothing to do with principles. Cheaper to settle than to fight.

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Andy ap said:
Watch you backs people for the vultures are following the cowardly lying backstabbers.
people should also watch out for other drivers hitting them wink

and as per the other thread why was it stupid for you to have admitted fault?

Grey Ghost

4,614 posts

251 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
This whole thing about whiplash claims really boils my p*ss mad

I was hit in a "non fault accident" in the summer by one of the local mouth breathing blonde bimbos we have imported from Hitler's favourite northern European destination. It was clearly her fault and 40+ decents shots of the accident proved I was not to blame.

The good news is that my car was perfectly repaired by my chosen repairer and a rather nice hire car provided whilst this took place.

The bad news was that when she brought round her insurance details later in the day she was moaning about a sore neck and that she might have suffered whiplash. She insisted she was going to A&E to get checked out after leaving my house. Now, whilst the impact was only between 5-10 mph there is a chance she could have suffered a neck injury so I let her blah, blah away until she had finished.

The next day I called my insurers to confirm a non fault accident had been recorded and they confirmed they had received a note from her insurers accepting liability and that they were now closing the case as I was happy with the outcome. I enquired about her mention of whiplash and was told her insurers may pay her for it !!!! how the flying f**k can they pay her for whiplash when the accident was clearly her fault

Anyway, roll on 3 months and I start getting phone calls from a legal firm asking if I suffered any injury in the accident. I told them politely the first 2 or 3 times I was fine but on the next occassion I was rather miffed with the continued interruption and asked what they were trying to achieve. The response astounded me.....despite me telling a registered legal firm I was not injured I was entitled to some money because I had been a victim of a non fault accident and could have suffered discomfort, effectively asking me to lie as I had clearly stated at least twice I was fine

And we wonder why our premiums do nothing but rise whilst insurers moan about increasing payouts for accident injuries.

I hope once the FCA and other such bodies get bored fining banks for their poor conduct over the past few years (decades ?) they turn their focus to the legal world because in my opinion it is starting to get a significant amount of negative press from a minority (I hope) of the profession purely on the issue of whiplash and other associated claims.

Surely it would not be difficult to challenge a few of these claims and have them thrown out, a few examples made for what it in effect fraud and some headlines grabbed to put a stop to this practise.

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Grey Ghost said:
This whole thing about whiplash claims really boils my p*ss mad

I was hit in a "non fault accident" in the summer by one of the local mouth breathing blonde bimbos we have imported from Hitler's favourite northern European destination. It was clearly her fault and 40+ decents shots of the accident proved I was not to blame.

The good news is that my car was perfectly repaired by my chosen repairer and a rather nice hire car provided whilst this took place.

The bad news was that when she brought round her insurance details later in the day she was moaning about a sore neck and that she might have suffered whiplash. She insisted she was going to A&E to get checked out after leaving my house. Now, whilst the impact was only between 5-10 mph there is a chance she could have suffered a neck injury so I let her blah, blah away until she had finished.

The next day I called my insurers to confirm a non fault accident had been recorded and they confirmed they had received a note from her insurers accepting liability and that they were now closing the case as I was happy with the outcome. I enquired about her mention of whiplash and was told her insurers may pay her for it !!!! how the flying f**k can they pay her for whiplash when the accident was clearly her fault

Anyway, roll on 3 months and I start getting phone calls from a legal firm asking if I suffered any injury in the accident. I told them politely the first 2 or 3 times I was fine but on the next occassion I was rather miffed with the continued interruption and asked what they were trying to achieve. The response astounded me.....despite me telling a registered legal firm I was not injured I was entitled to some money because I had been a victim of a non fault accident and could have suffered discomfort, effectively asking me to lie as I had clearly stated at least twice I was fine

And we wonder why our premiums do nothing but rise whilst insurers moan about increasing payouts for accident injuries.

I hope once the FCA and other such bodies get bored fining banks for their poor conduct over the past few years (decades ?) they turn their focus to the legal world because in my opinion it is starting to get a significant amount of negative press from a minority (I hope) of the profession purely on the issue of whiplash and other associated claims.

Surely it would not be difficult to challenge a few of these claims and have them thrown out, a few examples made for what it in effect fraud and some headlines grabbed to put a stop to this practise.
how do you think those claims companies got your details?

Grey Ghost

4,614 posts

251 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
pork911 said:
how do you think those claims companies got your details?
I fully understand how my details we passed on and that is another area of issue, but off topic here. My point was that insurance companies appear to be happy to pay out for claims without investigating them to any real extent and as such policy prices go up and we all suffer.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Seriously, how many markets are more competitive than car insurance? Do you really believe insurance companies just pay out willy nilly when there's a reasonable prospect of fighting the claim?

shovelheadrob

1,564 posts

202 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I had a few years of claims companies calling & texting me almost daily after a non fault accident, my car was hit while parked, I was over one hundred miles away at work at the time! Most of them got told to fk off, but I asked a couple how I could be entitled to compensation, I was told if it was under a certain threshold (6k or thereabouts IIRC) the insurance co would just pay it rather than risk more in a court case. Vultures I tell you fkin' vultures.

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
Seriously, how many markets are more competitive than car insurance? Do you really believe insurance companies just pay out willy nilly when there's a reasonable prospect of fighting the claim?
I do.

I foolishly over took a car that was braking and almost stationary and moving to the left, to have her turn into a staff car park entrance on the right.

No indicators from "piccasso bh" or Mrs PB as I call her.

Now I destroyed the suspension and every panel apart from the drivers side wings, and doors and boot.

I also destroyed her drivers side wing and removed the headlamp from behind.

No witnesses.

She claims whiplash, she says she was indicating. Neither are true. Insurance company have a bill of £1500 for my car, and £1000 for her repairs plus £3k to £5K? for a whiplash claim? Somewhere between £6K and £8K payout for my stupid error. I say my, I mean her error.

As soon as they start disagreeing the price they pay would shoot up. if they lost ? Lawyers costs ? £8K becomes £58K maybe. Based on probability, you'd need better than a 80% chance of winning to take that on surely ?

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Eh? You appear to disagree with me but then prove my point!

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
New POD said:
...I destroyed the suspension and every panel apart from the drivers side wings, and doors and boot.

I also destroyed her drivers side wing and removed the headlamp from behind.

...She claims whiplash, she says she was indicating. Neither are true.
are you claiming low velocity impact? wink

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Grey Ghost said:
pork911 said:
how do you think those claims companies got your details?
I fully understand how my details we passed on and that is another area of issue, but off topic here. My point was that insurance companies appear to be happy to pay out for claims without investigating them to any real extent and as such policy prices go up and we all suffer.
are you really saying her insurer accepted liability on her behalf and then paid her out for her injuries?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
Grey Ghost said:
Anyway, roll on 3 months and I start getting phone calls from a legal firm asking if I suffered any injury in the accident. I told them politely the first 2 or 3 times I was fine but on the next occassion I was rather miffed with the continued interruption and asked what they were trying to achieve. The response astounded me.....despite me telling a registered legal firm I was not injured I was entitled to some money because I had been a victim of a non fault accident and could have suffered discomfort, effectively asking me to lie as I had clearly stated at least twice I was fine
Tell them the call is being recorded and ask for their consent. Then they might think twice about making such a suggestion. If they still press ahead and pressure a potential client into making a false claim in order to obtain compensation their conduct might be of interest to the SRA. By asking the right questions you can get them to provide all the ammunition you need.



Edited by Red Devil on Monday 16th December 01:16

walm

10,644 posts

233 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
Grey Ghost said:
how the flying f**k can they pay her for whiplash when the accident was clearly her fault
Off topic and dumb question I should certainly know the answer to but please humour me...

If I drive into a tree and cripple myself, am I insured?
i.e. can I claim on my own insurance for loss of earnings etc...

Obviously if I cripple someone else I am covered - that's the third party bit...
But what about me??

I thought I would be covered, which makes Grey Ghosts complaint above unfounded but thinking about it I am not sure...

TwigtheWonderkid

49,302 posts

181 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
walm said:
Off topic and dumb question I should certainly know the answer to but please humour me...

If I drive into a tree and cripple myself, am I insured?
i.e. can I claim on my own insurance for loss of earnings etc...

Obviously if I cripple someone else I am covered - that's the third party bit...
But what about me??

I thought I would be covered, which makes Grey Ghosts complaint above unfounded but thinking about it I am not sure...
You have very limited cover, as outlined in your policy, which you should actually read, as it's quite important.

Normally £5K for death, £2500 for loss of limb ect. No loss of earning cover or any other consequential loss. It's car insurance. If you want life cover or personal accident, then buy one of those policies.

walm

10,644 posts

233 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
You have very limited cover, as outlined in your policy, which you should actually read, as it's quite important.

Normally £5K for death, £2500 for loss of limb ect. No loss of earning cover or any other consequential loss. It's car insurance. If you want life cover or personal accident, then buy one of those policies.
Thanks for that, will check but I am sure you are right.
It just seems weird that third parties are so much better covered.
Although I guess it stops the crash-for-cash lot just driving themselves into trees all the time...!

TwigtheWonderkid

49,302 posts

181 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
walm said:
Thanks for that, will check but I am sure you are right.
It just seems weird that third parties are so much better covered.
Although I guess it stops the crash-for-cash lot just driving themselves into trees all the time...!
Because that's what you're paying for!

You wouldn't buy a pet policy for your dog, and then think it's odd that the policy gave cover for your dog being injured, but not you!