VERDICT?
Author
Discussion

cindychops

Original Poster:

409 posts

189 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
About a year ago i started a topic regarding a biker that was involved in a fatal accident and my wife was a witness,the post was locked as the case was ongoing but now the verdict is in and i think there has been a major miscarriage of justice?would it be o.k for me to discuss it on this forum?

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Yes, of course it would be. Do you have a link to the original thread and any press reports?

cindychops

Original Poster:

409 posts

189 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
I will post a link from a few days ago so people can be impartial then i will comment why i think that something is not right.
http://www.grimsbytelegraph.co.uk/Motorist-denies-...

Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
cindychops said:
About a year ago i started a topic regarding a biker that was involved in a fatal accident and my wife was a witness,the post was locked as the case was ongoing but now the verdict is in and i think there has been a major miscarriage of justice?would it be o.k for me to discuss it on this forum?
What's the verdict? The article doesn't say.

Bill

58,935 posts

286 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
It's not clear whether he was filtering from behind her or in front. If in front then that seems fine, if behind then harsh. But it is only a conviction for careless rather than dangerous driving and the biker died so there's not much to argue with on the face of it, even if he was speeding.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
I know the location well (parents in law live in Waltham). To be honest, on the barest of detail provided by the paper, it seems a just result.

There are no winners in such circumstances.

Hackney

7,443 posts

239 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
The link goes to an article saying the woman has asked that the case go to court rather than magistrates. A story linked to that says she was found guilty.

So I can't find much to question in the verdict based on the information I've seen so far.
Seems like she turned across two lanes of stationary traffic colliding with a "filtering" biker who was potentially breaking the speed limit.

Although I don't think that breaking the speed limit should be a factor.... she should still see him and not make the turn.

cindychops

Original Poster:

409 posts

189 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Before todays verdict was announced i will now mention what my wife knew,she was stationary behind the corsa ans saw the motorbike level with a volvo (both stationary)as they were waiting to see what the corsa was going to do,my wife still insisted that the bike was not moving and i believe her but thats our view.
The bike then pulled forward and at the same time the corsa cut straight across in front of him but there was not any screeching of tyres or a loud impact and the biker laid his bike down as he knew this was his only option,as can be seen from the picture the bike was mere feet away from the corsa.
When the police came round to question my wife he said that on the cctv the bike was travelling SLOWER than the school kids on pedal bikes!after a visit to the police station to have her statement taped we both thought the corsa driver would have admitted fault as from what my wife told me it was obvious that the corsa cut across in front of the bike.
The bike was was not hindered and in plain sight and the wether was clear,the road was dry and the sunlight was not a factor in the reason as to why the corsa driver did not see said bike.
Fast forward one year-my wife had to attend court to give her statement of events to the judge & jury,she reitterated what was in her original statement and after that the judge asked if she knew what the spped limit was? my wife replied "yes,its 30mph" the judge then said "would you be surprised to know that the bike was travelling at 45mph" this really shocked her and was very very upset as there was no way that was the case!.
Obviousley there is a massive difference between crawling forward at 5mph or so but 45mph is just unbeliveable.
If that was case how come the bike landed only mere feet from the impact?
I know it was an accident but as the driver had not had her licence a year and admitted she was late and to plead NOT guilty just seems so wrong.
The comments in the next link even seem to blame the biker but how can the crash investigators have got the speed differential wrong imho.
http://www.grimsbytelegraph.co.uk/Driver-guilty-ca...

Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
This does sound a bit strange. How did the crash investigators work out 45mph?

cindychops

Original Poster:

409 posts

189 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Kawasicki said:
This does sound a bit strange. How did the crash investigators work out 45mph?
I thought 45mph was 1000 mtrs per second but the damage to the bike does not seem consitant,i don't want to see the driver go to prison but what about the injured parties immediate family????150 hrs community service is just shocking,HOW COULD MY WIFE HAVE GOT IT SO WRONG?when i told her the verdict earlier she was very upset and our thoughts will always be with the bikers family.

ikarl

4,082 posts

230 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Would be interesting to hear how they worked out 45mph

Wonder how the deceased's family are taking the verdict, must be horrible to hear such conflicting views

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
cindychops said:
Kawasicki said:
This does sound a bit strange. How did the crash investigators work out 45mph?
I thought 45mph was 1000 mtrs per second but the damage to the bike does not seem consitant,i don't want to see the driver go to prison but what about the injured parties immediate family????150 hrs community service is just shocking,HOW COULD MY WIFE HAVE GOT IT SO WRONG?when i told her the verdict earlier she was very upset and our thoughts will always be with the bikers family.
You know a 1000 mtrs is a kilometer right.

cindychops

Original Poster:

409 posts

189 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
ikarl said:
Would be interesting to hear how they worked out 45mph

Wonder how the deceased's family are taking the verdict, must be horrible to hear such conflicting views
My wife has had so much grief from people saying things like "what you say will put the driver in prison" and stuff like "why did you get involved,just say you saw nothing" my wife did it because it was the right thing to do and we did it for the family of the biker.

cindychops

Original Poster:

409 posts

189 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
NH1 said:
cindychops said:
Kawasicki said:
This does sound a bit strange. How did the crash investigators work out 45mph?
I thought 45mph was 1000 mtrs per second but the damage to the bike does not seem consitant,i don't want to see the driver go to prison but what about the injured parties immediate family????150 hrs community service is just shocking,HOW COULD MY WIFE HAVE GOT IT SO WRONG?when i told her the verdict earlier she was very upset and our thoughts will always be with the bikers family.
You know a 1000 mtrs is a kilometer right.
sorry,yes just realised.

Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
cindychops said:
ikarl said:
Would be interesting to hear how they worked out 45mph

Wonder how the deceased's family are taking the verdict, must be horrible to hear such conflicting views
My wife has had so much grief from people saying things like "what you say will put the driver in prison" and stuff like "why did you get involved,just say you saw nothing" my wife did it because it was the right thing to do and we did it for the family of the biker.
Are "people" your friends? If so, I would suggest that you get new ones.

It would seem that you are happy with the verdict, but think that the sentence is lenient due to things which you perceive to be incorrect in some testimonies? Might I suggest that you aren't armed with as much information as the judge was?

ikarl

4,082 posts

230 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
cindychops said:
ikarl said:
Would be interesting to hear how they worked out 45mph

Wonder how the deceased's family are taking the verdict, must be horrible to hear such conflicting views
My wife has had so much grief from people saying things like "what you say will put the driver in prison" and stuff like "why did you get involved,just say you saw nothing" my wife did it because it was the right thing to do and we did it for the family of the biker.
It must be a nightmare for the family to have heard your wife say what speed she thought the bike was doing and then be told 45mph, that doesn't look like a 45 mph collision to me!

Can I ask, how did the biker die? Did the car go over him?

(Btw, your wife done the right thing! People that have said that have obviously never been in that position..maybe if they had they wouldn't be so insensitive)

IanA2

2,897 posts

193 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
ikarl said:
Would be interesting to hear how they worked out 45mph

Wonder how the deceased's family are taking the verdict, must be horrible to hear such conflicting views
It says in the newspaper report that the incident was caught on cctv and the the investigators used the cctv evidence to calculate the speed.

cindychops

Original Poster:

409 posts

189 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Disco You said:
cindychops said:
ikarl said:
Would be interesting to hear how they worked out 45mph

Wonder how the deceased's family are taking the verdict, must be horrible to hear such conflicting views
My wife has had so much grief from people saying things like "what you say will put the driver in prison" and stuff like "why did you get involved,just say you saw nothing" my wife did it because it was the right thing to do and we did it for the family of the biker.
Are "people" your friends? If so, I would suggest that you get new ones.

It would seem that you are happy with the verdict, but think that the sentence is lenient due to things which you perceive to be incorrect in some testimonies? Might I suggest that you aren't armed with as much information as the judge was?
Whenever there seems to be an accident involving a motorbike and a car everyones reaction is usually that the bike would have been riding too fast but in this case i honestly believe he was not?to travel from sationary/crawling to 45 mph (silently) seems a bit odd,as i stated earlier would the bike be in the resting position after a few feet away from the corsa????

Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
cindychops said:
Disco You said:
cindychops said:
ikarl said:
Would be interesting to hear how they worked out 45mph

Wonder how the deceased's family are taking the verdict, must be horrible to hear such conflicting views
My wife has had so much grief from people saying things like "what you say will put the driver in prison" and stuff like "why did you get involved,just say you saw nothing" my wife did it because it was the right thing to do and we did it for the family of the biker.
Are "people" your friends? If so, I would suggest that you get new ones.

It would seem that you are happy with the verdict, but think that the sentence is lenient due to things which you perceive to be incorrect in some testimonies? Might I suggest that you aren't armed with as much information as the judge was?
Whenever there seems to be an accident involving a motorbike and a car everyones reaction is usually that the bike would have been riding too fast but in this case i honestly believe he was not?to travel from sationary/crawling to 45 mph (silently) seems a bit odd,as i stated earlier would the bike be in the resting position after a few feet away from the corsa????
Have you seen the CCTV footage then? That would seem to be a fairly good way of calculating the speed of the bike.

cindychops

Original Poster:

409 posts

189 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Disco You said:
cindychops said:
Disco You said:
cindychops said:
ikarl said:
Would be interesting to hear how they worked out 45mph

Wonder how the deceased's family are taking the verdict, must be horrible to hear such conflicting views
My wife has had so much grief from people saying things like "what you say will put the driver in prison" and stuff like "why did you get involved,just say you saw nothing" my wife did it because it was the right thing to do and we did it for the family of the biker.
Are "people" your friends? If so, I would suggest that you get new ones.

It would seem that you are happy with the verdict, but think that the sentence is lenient due to things which you perceive to be incorrect in some testimonies? Might I suggest that you aren't armed with as much information as the judge was?
Whenever there seems to be an accident involving a motorbike and a car everyones reaction is usually that the bike would have been riding too fast but in this case i honestly believe he was not?to travel from sationary/crawling to 45 mph (silently) seems a bit odd,as i stated earlier would the bike be in the resting position after a few feet away from the corsa????
Have you seen the CCTV footage then? That would seem to be a fairly good way of calculating the speed of the bike.
My wife has not seen the cctv footage but when the traffic police visited us he said that kids bikes were travelling slower than the deceased!why so much difference?i do not agree with the verdict as 150 hrs community service for taking someones life is just disrespectable to the biker.the police also mentioned that the corsa driver head did not move to the left she only looked in the direction she was going which was into the school because she was running late.
a sad sad buisness as i know even the harshest sentence would not bring him back but just seems unjust imho.