Parking tickets / defaced sign / nearby signage
Discussion
Had to park in a local town for work (Basildon Essex). Was directed by homeowner to parking by some garages nearby as property is on a green with no road. Garages to LHS about 25 of them- parking bay at end on the right - road is a dead end. Pulled into parking bay and sign adjacent (3 ft away)denoted a restriction as a residents only area but the times of enforcement totally obscure. Went to job asked homeowner about sign - they were unsure of times as only just moved in - went back to van (about 10 min elapsed) and I've got a ticket. Asked enforcement agency to cancel as sign
Obscured - they've refused stating signage in place was clear and have included a pic of a sign - NOT the sign I was parked adjacent to but one nearby ! ( about 20 yards away - didn't see it on day of offence as it's adjacent to a block of garages) I would argue that the sign adjacent to the bay I parked in was the one relevant to me as it was clearly the restriction on that bay - I think the councils view is that I should have looked for other signs and taken those as a guide. Should I contest or just cough up? Got pics but can't upload at the moment
Thanks for any replies
Ron
Obscured - they've refused stating signage in place was clear and have included a pic of a sign - NOT the sign I was parked adjacent to but one nearby ! ( about 20 yards away - didn't see it on day of offence as it's adjacent to a block of garages) I would argue that the sign adjacent to the bay I parked in was the one relevant to me as it was clearly the restriction on that bay - I think the councils view is that I should have looked for other signs and taken those as a guide. Should I contest or just cough up? Got pics but can't upload at the moment
Thanks for any replies
Ron My initial thought was to consider giving this a run on an appeal.
BUT the sign clearly says residents Parking with some sort of time limit which should have rung alarm bells and a need to check the area carefully for other signs which apparently are there.
Damage limitation and pay at the reduced rate?
dvd
BUT the sign clearly says residents Parking with some sort of time limit which should have rung alarm bells and a need to check the area carefully for other signs which apparently are there.
Damage limitation and pay at the reduced rate?
dvd
NH1 said:
Each seperate parking bay needs its own sign from what I know. These signs need to be legible, how are you to know that one sign relates to a different space or bay, go to PATAS if needed and you should win, you did get a picture of the obscured sign didn't you?
PATAS only applies to London Boroughs. Basildon is in Essex way beyond the GLA boundary. You mean the TPT (Traffic Penalty Tribunal based in Wilmslow). The ground for appeal in this case will be that the contravention did not occur (due to inadequate signage) - http://www.trafficpenaltytribunal.gov.uk/site/scri...We need to turn out attention to what the OP means when he says 'obscured'. The normal definition of obscured is that something is getting in the way of seeing the sign: see the Hanging Baskets example here - http://www.trafficpenaltytribunal.gov.uk/site/scri... Is it the case here that something made the sign not visible, or does he actually mean that it is illegible for some reason (defaced or faded/missing information)?
Local Authorities using a picture of a different (visible/compliant) sign is a an old and shabby trick designed to mislead which adjudicators have seen before. If the OP has a contemporaneous picture of the iffy one adjacent to the bay he parked in that will help.
If 'his' sign was obscured then imo he has an excellent chance of winning. If it was merely defective then he may succeed on non-compliance but otoh the adjudicator might consider it reasonable that he should look for another one that isn't. Especially if, in order to exit a cul-de-sac, he had to walk past it.
The next step in the appeal process is to wait until the NtO arrives and check it for any procedural impropriety. You might be surprised how many local authorities get this wrong. Box clever with the formal appeal at this stage. If/when that is rejected (which I reckon is highly likely given their sneaky approach to date) then the OP needs to ensure that he delivers the best possible punch at the TPT. It will be done on written evidence as, due to the distance involved, I very much doubt either party will request a hearing in front of the adjudicator.
NH1 said:
Each seperate parking bay needs its own sign from what I know. These signs need to be legible, how are you to know that one sign relates to a different space or bay, go to PATAS if needed and you should win, you did get a picture of the obscured sign didn't you?
I took on my LA on this basis and won at the adjudication (they declined both internal appeals of course). Since then the LA has altered all the signage in that area to make reference to a parking zone eg zone 2, the implication being that each bay is linked to another within that zone (1 hr free parking, no return to that zone within 2 hrs)!TX.
NH1 said:
Have the names changed for the adjudication process. I know there were 2, one was for london and the other for the rest of the Country. One was PATAS and the other was called something else but not the traffic penalty tribunal. Their office was in manchester and I won a case there.
You have a good memory. The TPT is a re-branding of NPAS (National Parking Adjudication Service). It became operational on 31st March 2008.I suspect they deliberately avoided commencement on April Fool's Day! The renaming came about to reflect the fact that NPAS's remit had been extended to include bus lane contraventions as well as several other factors. See this report - www.manchester.gov.uk/download/.../id/.../item_5_a...
NPAS was indeed centred in Manchester because the City Council was the lead body. Although TPT is based in Wilmslow, MCC remained the lead body for PATROLAJC (the snazzily titled Parking And Traffic Regulations Outside London Adjudication Joint Committee) until April this year when Cheshire East took over. That makes sense as Wilmslow is within their patch.
An interesting submission by PATROLAJC in March to the HoC Select Committee on Transport Local Authority Parking Enforcement review. http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201314/...
About time too as there are still far too many LA's who see DPE as a cash cow, outsource their parking control function, and don't give a flying
about ensuring that legal requirements and due process are observed. They have a duty to act proportionately and exercise unfettered discretion yet often do neither.Basildon Residents parking permits run from 10am - 2pm, they denote their parking areas by letters A - Z with the exception of X, they do not issue a permit for X as these are generally marked bays on corners where they dont have double yellow lines.
Visitors have a scrathcard permit handed to them by a resident to park in the above bays, without this or a permit a ticket will be issued, all there wardens drive unmarked vans.
Its basically an old system left behind by the CNT/BDC and Basildon Council still dont know how to police it properly.
Visitors have a scrathcard permit handed to them by a resident to park in the above bays, without this or a permit a ticket will be issued, all there wardens drive unmarked vans.
Its basically an old system left behind by the CNT/BDC and Basildon Council still dont know how to police it properly.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


