what does the highway code think about this?
what does the highway code think about this?
Author
Discussion

isee

Original Poster:

3,713 posts

214 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Nothing happened and this is just a theoretical question, but I realised I don't know the rules on this one and need help.

Let's say you are at a T-junction and turning left.
You check left first just to see that nobody is turning right off the main road and cuts a corner, as it often happens just as you pull up in line with the give way marker.
You then turn your head right to see if you can in fact pull out and turn left, you see a car, reasonably distant, but close enough for you to expedite your manoeuvre. So start moving while still looking right but turning your head to face the direction of your motion.

You have started your turn and are keeping well within the divider line so that the traffic going from your left to right (i.e. straight and in opposite direction of the direction you are about to take on the main road), but the driver of the oncoming car has encroached onto the lane you are about to occupy, whether it's lack of concentration or because there were cars parked on his side of the road.

Your car's right front corner clips that of the car's going opposite, who is at fault?

P.s. once again I have no axe to grind, and nothing happened, but I can see it from both driver's perspective and would like to know the official rule book stance on this. Thanks

speedking31

3,964 posts

167 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Look right, look left, look right again. Unless you have a very slow neck you will see anything you are likely to hit. You should then be looking in the direction of travel. If the car approaching from your right is so close as to require monitoring you are cutting it too fine. IMO etc.

Imagine pulling out into the path of an overtaking vehicle. Who do you think will be held mostly liable?

isee

Original Poster:

3,713 posts

214 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
speedking31 said:
Look right, look left, look right again. Unless you have a very slow neck you will see anything you are likely to hit. You should then be looking in the direction of travel. If the car approaching from your right is so close as to require monitoring you are cutting it too fine. IMO etc.

Imagine pulling out into the path of an overtaking vehicle. Who do you think will be held mostly liable?
Yes but provided the oncoming car is not an HGV you'd still pull out wouldn't you? I mean your paths do not cross (provided you both drive as you should.
Or are you saying I as the driver of the car at the T-junction, should be waiting until both directions are clear when turning left?

R0G

5,037 posts

186 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
If it was found that the other driver moved into your lane without good reason then that driver is going to be at fault if they did that when you started to pull out and keep within the confines of your lane

The authorities will go on what would a reason driver expect to happen

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
You're joining the major road at the junction on a give-way to vehicles already on the major road so you're in the wrong if you pull out on the oncoming car.

No matter which side of the road they're on, they have right of way and you have to wait for them to complete their manoeuvre by giving way.


Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Not quite enough detail about the collision.

You have to give way - that means from both directions.
The oncoming car should be in his lane - but there are loads of valid reasons for him to cross the center line - but he shouldn't do that in to oncoming traffic.

So, the question is.
Did you pull out into him
Or
Were you on the road and he pulled into your lane.

From what you said, I'm guessing it's the former.




isee

Original Poster:

3,713 posts

214 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Not quite enough detail about the collision.

You have to give way - that means from both directions.
The oncoming car should be in his lane - but there are loads of valid reasons for him to cross the center line - but he shouldn't do that in to oncoming traffic.

So, the question is.
Did you pull out into him
Or
Were you on the road and he pulled into your lane.

From what you said, I'm guessing it's the former.
That makes sense, as to your question and seeing as it's a theoretical question let's say the collision take place just as the vehicle pulling out is at the apex of their turn where their car would be closes to the centre line?

isee

Original Poster:

3,713 posts

214 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
So what I am picking up from the replies here is that it would be oncoming driver's fault if they had no valid reason to cross the centre line and the joining driver's fault if the oncoming car had the reason to cross the centre line?

Randomthoughts

917 posts

164 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Not necessarily. I still think the merging traffic will have the lion's share of the responsibility but some negligence will be attributed to the person coming the other way, should they have pre-empted your manoeuvre or if they were just driving like a tool.

XJ Flyer

5,526 posts

161 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
In most cases accident report forms contain the question was any vehicle travelling on the wrong side of the road when the accident happened.Which would probably apply in the case of pulling out on someone who was overtaking at a junction.Wether that would be an aqequate defence in the case of pulling out on traffic that's on the wrong side of the road owing to parked vehicles is another question.In that case the blame should probably be applied jointly to the person who parked the vehicle/s dangerously and the driver who pulled out without giving way to the traffic approaching from the left.Having said that it would also probably be a case of joint blame in the case of pulling out on traffic approaching from the left in any case.

Edited by XJ Flyer on Monday 16th December 13:56

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
isee said:
That makes sense, as to your question and seeing as it's a theoretical question let's say the collision take place just as the vehicle pulling out is at the apex of their turn where their car would be closes to the centre line?
It depends on the speeds of the cars, how long the oncoming car had been over the line, how quickly 'you' pulled out of the junction.

The reason the car crosses the line is important too.
Was it a reason you could have seen before pulling out or was it their random poor driving.

Prizam

2,447 posts

172 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
In this instance its not about "Lanes... its about who is on the road and who is not.

"You" were joining road road and collided with some one already on the road... weather they were in the correct lane or not is irrelevant.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Significance (TSGD 2002) of Give Way line (presumed one where the leg joins the T Bar ie main road)your in the wrong if you cross the GWL and cause a vehicle on the main road to deviate or reduce speed.
Any bearing?

dvd

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
Significance (TSGD 2002) of Give Way line (presumed one where the leg joins the T Bar ie main road)your in the wrong if you cross the GWL and cause a vehicle on the main road to deviate or reduce speed.
Any bearing?

dvd
Maybe.

It all depends on the how and why of the car that crossed the mid line.

We've all turned left out of junctions while cars were driving past on the opposite lane.
It's a perfectly legal and normal thing.

The question would be whether you could have anticipated the other car crossing the centre line, and whether the car was already over the line when you pulled out.

The OP's question is disgned to be right at the tipping point if fault.


speedking31

3,964 posts

167 months

Monday 16th December 2013
quotequote all
isee said:
Or are you saying I as the driver of the car at the T-junction, should be waiting until both directions are clear when turning left?
No. You asked:

isee said:
but the driver of the oncoming car has encroached onto the lane you are about to occupy
Implying you have not occupied that space and drive into it without looking.

I suggest; you look right and assess that you can complete your manoeuvre before the arrival of the vehicle from the right. You look where you are going. If all is clear you proceed onto the main road.

For example if a car is parked directly opposite your exit and someone is approaching from the left at a speed where they will have to move onto the 'wrong' side of the main road to pass the parked vehicle, I would be waiting for them to pass rather than claiming my priority (once on the main road). Sometimes if there is a stream of traffic from the left then edging out to make your intentions clear can help, but without completely blocking their path.