Some queries about a speeding offence
Some queries about a speeding offence
Author
Discussion

Aquarius909

Original Poster:

99 posts

196 months

Tuesday 17th December 2013
quotequote all
Unfortunately I recently received a letter saying I was photographed doing 35 in a 30 and I was wondering if I could request a little advice from the community on some issues around this offence:

1) I remember where I was on the morning of the offence and I was in the general area where they claim to have snapped me but I have no recollection of being on the specific road they say they clocked me on. In fact I'm 90+% certain I wasn't there (but I was about a half mile away, to be fair). Have I any right to see evidence or do I have to go to court to see that?

2) Presumably if they've got the name of the road I was on wrong the charge is invalid, right?

3) Is there any downside to gong to court? Presumably I will lose my option of a Speed Awareness course which they have suggested in the letter should be offered to me if I'm eligible.

4) Regarding eligibility for a Speed Awareness course, the rules say you can't have one if you've been on one in the last 3 years. I attended one in Feb 2011 so 3 years will shortly expire. I can't recall from the last time how long it was between the then offence and the Speed Awareness course but can I opt to do a course for this offence in late February or daly March (thereby satisfying the 3 years rule) or am I just clutching at straws here?

Thankfully in 20+ years of driving the incidents mentioned above are the only times I've had any issues so I'm afraid this leaves me not very well informed about how the system works. I would be grateful for any thoughts or comments.

agtlaw

7,442 posts

237 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
Don't make any contact with the ticket office (by phone or otherwise) until at least 15 days have passed since the alleged offence. Don't post details online.

You have a potential defence. More details needed (but see above).

Not entitled to evidence at this stage.

Interesting point about timing of SAC. Check force policy?

Courts impose income based fines. Also, costs and a victim surcharge.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
In general, an admin mistake is not a defence.
The address will just be corrected and the offence will remain.

But, there are exceptions to this depending on the exact wording of 'stuff' and whether it was a fixed camera, a patrolling cop or wotnot.
If it was a speed trap I think it can depend on whether the trap was in the right place but the papetwork is wrong or whether it was set up in the wrong place.

It all seems a bit random.

If that's the only defence you take to court though, then it may not end well.

elanfan

5,527 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
There's been a lot made on here about the offence remains even if they get the location wrong - and technically they are right.

However there have been other threads where I and others have said it is worth a challenge and the result has been 'no further action'. So it has to be worth a go.

Presumably you have a 172 to respond to? If so don't fill it in but write 'see attached' across it and write a polite short letter stating you have no knowledge of you or anyone else having access to the car being at that location at that time. See what happens - you might strike lucky they may send you a photo.

ferrariF50lover

1,834 posts

257 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
Purely for clarification:

1/2 a mile at 30mph, obviously, takes 1 minute to drive. You say you were half a mile from the location of the alleged offence at the time on the notice. How do you know this with such accuracy?

Simon.

Juliet1981

25 posts

156 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
elanfan said:
Presumably you have a 172 to respond to? If so don't fill it in but write 'see attached' across it and write a polite short letter stating you have no knowledge of you or anyone else having access to the car being at that location at that time. See what happens - you might strike lucky they may send you a photo.
Just a word of caution about this bit of advice, if he says adamantly none was driving the car in that location at that time & they do happen to have a photo if his car in that location, they won't just send the photo & say go on have another go at naming the driver. What they will do is summons him to court for failing to name the driver, which is 6 points & a fine.

Aquarius909

Original Poster:

99 posts

196 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
ferrariF50lover said:
Purely for clarification:

1/2 a mile at 30mph, obviously, takes 1 minute to drive. You say you were half a mile from the location of the alleged offence at the time on the notice. How do you know this with such accuracy?

Simon.
I know where I was that morning because I had a somewhat unusual meeting to attend in a location I don't frequent. The motorway was unexpectedly closed due to an accident so I came off to find and alternative route and ended up abandoning my trip, as all local roads were congested with people dong the same as me, and just returned to the office. That's why it sticks in my mind. I recall the route I took back to the office and while I passed maybe 1/2 a mile away from the road where they say they snapped me, I don't believe I actually travelled it.

Aquarius909

Original Poster:

99 posts

196 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
Juliet1981 said:
elanfan said:
Presumably you have a 172 to respond to? If so don't fill it in but write 'see attached' across it and write a polite short letter stating you have no knowledge of you or anyone else having access to the car being at that location at that time. See what happens - you might strike lucky they may send you a photo.
Just a word of caution about this bit of advice, if he says adamantly none was driving the car in that location at that time & they do happen to have a photo if his car in that location, they won't just send the photo & say go on have another go at naming the driver. What they will do is summons him to court for failing to name the driver, which is 6 points & a fine.
I agree with Julliet1981. This is a high risk strategy and the form S172 I have now does say if I don't tell them who was driving the car at the time of the offence I will get 6 points and a fine. I am going to return the form in the coming days. I can't see the upside to not doing this though I might include a letter stating my case (for the record)

But can I ask again about the speeding course. 35 in a 30 is clearly eligible and all else being equal I would expect they would send me on one. However, there is this somewhat vague '3 year rule' in place and I have attended a course before in Feb 2011. How long does it take to go from offence to speeding course normally? The rule says you can't attend a course within 3 years of your last one so how likely are they to just put the course at the end of Feb 2014 so it's then more than 3 years later; or do they mean I can't offend again within 3 years of a course - bit technical but you can see why I'm asking.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
Aquarius909 said:
However, there is this somewhat vague '3 year rule' in place and I have attended a course before in Feb 2011. How long does it take to go from offence to speeding course normally?
If the course provider is part of the National program, the important dates will those of the offences, not the courses.

For instance, if you complete a course, you should not qualify for another course offer if you re-offend within 3 years of the date of the original offence.

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
Don't post details online.

most importantly be careful what info you post on here. A certain poster trawls for info to pass back .

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
It's obviously a cloned car and just some bizarre fluke that they were only 1/2 a mile from you. Go to court, challenge it, deny it's your car in the photo, claim it's a good clone as they've got the dents and distinguishing features like your car and the driver has had plastic surgery to look like you too.

Nailed on defence and you'll probably get £3m in compensation too.

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
It's obviously a cloned car and just some bizarre fluke that they were only 1/2 a mile from you. Go to court, challenge it, deny it's your car in the photo, claim it's a good clone as they've got the dents and distinguishing features like your car and the driver has had plastic surgery to look like you too.

Nailed on defence and you'll probably get £3m in compensation too.
A sensible post at last!


arfur daley

834 posts

197 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
[quote=Who me ?]

most importantly be careful what info you post on here. A certain poster trawls for info to pass back .

[/quote]
Basterds why don't they fork off?

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
arfur daley said:
Basterds why don't they fork off?
These boots are made for walking...

RyanOPlastry

910 posts

239 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
arfur daley said:
Basterds why don't they fork off?
These boots are made for walking...
Not Mining?

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
RyanOPlastry said:
SV8Predator said:
arfur daley said:
Basterds why don't they fork off?
These boots are made for walking...
Not Mining?
These hints are the Pits, man.

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
And be careful to use the correctly headed A4 paper when sending out correspondence in a previous job as well nuts .

Anyway, The Peter Principle apparently came in to play (once again) hehe , just ask him to cite the sources for some of his propaganda as posted on here then watch several of us pull it apart.

Go to Court contesting a speeding allegation and you'll possibly meet "the dream team" from RSS - which might include Mr C cloud9 if you're lucky... But it'll cost you, because they'll kick your backside with their knowledge ( rofl see above, I kicked his backside with the help of several others on here once).

nuts

ferrariF50lover

1,834 posts

257 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
It's obviously a cloned car and just some bizarre fluke that they were only 1/2 a mile from you. Go to court, challenge it, deny it's your car in the photo, claim it's a good clone as they've got the dents and distinguishing features like your car and the driver has had plastic surgery to look like you too.

Nailed on defence and you'll probably get £3m in compensation too.
To be absolutely honest, OP, I'm afraid this (the underlying message, not the sarcasm) is probably where just about everyone is going to sit having read your reply to my earlier question.

I did once have a car cloned (likely car, explanation as to how it could have happened) and I got off based on this. It helped that, at about the time of the offence, by pure chance, I was caught on Sky Sports attending a football match some 60 miles from the camera which flashed "my" car. I wrote to the Speed Camera Department and explained (but also filled out the s172 with "I don't know, please see attached"). I got a letter back a few weeks later from the CC of the relevant force telling me that A) there was a cloned car out there and B) that I could carry the letter and give it to any copper who stopped me (because both my private plate and the original cloned plate were on some sort of ANPR style stop/check list, which is fair enough) as evidence of who I was.

I had a significantly stronger story to tell than "it can't have been me, I was half a mile away". You might have a technical defence, and it's for sure any decent solicitor will be happy to run it (for a fee), but things like these are so often about what you are able to convince people to believe, rather than the actual facts as they truly exist. I'm very much afraid that, were I a Magistrate/DJ presented with your story, I'd be inclined to call you a big fat liar liar pants on fire.

Simon.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
Don't make any contact with the ticket office (by phone or otherwise) until at least 15 days have passed since the alleged offence. Don't post details online.

You have a potential defence. More details needed (but see above).

Not entitled to evidence at this stage.

Interesting point about timing of SAC. Check force policy?

Courts impose income based fines. Also, costs and a victim surcharge.
I once requested a photo and was provided with one. Is this at the discretion of the force? I was under the impression you had the right to request this.

tehguy

178 posts

162 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Aquarius909 said:
Unfortunately I recently received a letter saying I was photographed doing 35 in a 30 and I was wondering if I could request a little advice from the community on some issues around this offence:

1) I remember where I was on the morning of the offence and I was in the general area where they claim to have snapped me but I have no recollection of being on the specific road they say they clocked me on. In fact I'm 90+% certain I wasn't there (but I was about a half mile away, to be fair). Have I any right to see evidence or do I have to go to court to see that?

2) Presumably if they've got the name of the road I was on wrong the charge is invalid, right?

3) Is there any downside to gong to court? Presumably I will lose my option of a Speed Awareness course which they have suggested in the letter should be offered to me if I'm eligible.

4) Regarding eligibility for a Speed Awareness course, the rules say you can't have one if you've been on one in the last 3 years. I attended one in Feb 2011 so 3 years will shortly expire. I can't recall from the last time how long it was between the then offence and the Speed Awareness course but can I opt to do a course for this offence in late February or daly March (thereby satisfying the 3 years rule) or am I just clutching at straws here?

Thankfully in 20+ years of driving the incidents mentioned above are the only times I've had any issues so I'm afraid this leaves me not very well informed about how the system works. I would be grateful for any thoughts or comments.
1 - you don't seem to be denying that you were near where the NIP says you were at the time, so chances are you were there

2 - no, small administrative errors make no difference, they simply correct them. it doesn't change the fact that you were speeding

3 - if you are guilty and you don't intend to fight, then yes there are downsides and they are that the fine will be substantially higher. if you choose to go to court you will lose the offer of the course

4 - it's the date of the offence that matters I believe, so you don't seem to be eligible for the course.