Damaged sofa due to rental property
Damaged sofa due to rental property
Author
Discussion

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
I'm renting a new build 2 bedroom house, it was completed in June this year and we moved in on the 1stw eek of July, we love the house and any minor problems we've had have been sorted straight away, such as doors not closing properly and a window dropped slightly.

Fast forward to yesterday when we were tidying up, I moved our leather corner sofa away from the wall to find the rear of the sofa covered in mould and a damp patch on the wall. The sofa is less than a year old and cost just under £2000, I'm really not happy with the damage caused to the sofa, the back has got bad mould and the leather has started to sag and look out of shape.

Despite our attempts to get hold of our landlord we have been unable to contact them, we've just had to do what we've done with the other minor niggles and get in contact with the building company who are coming to look at the wall on Monday. The letting agent have basically told us it's nothing to do with them as the landlord is managing the property, but they wouldn't let us have any contact details of the landlord.

My main concern is our sofa, am I able to claim of the landlords insurance for a replacement or will I have to claim of my own contents insurance??

Sorry if I'm in the wrong section

craigjm

21,738 posts

231 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
It depends on what has caused the damp. If it is a structural problem then yes they would usually be liable. If its caused by the way you are living in the property then no.

Wings

5,982 posts

246 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Firstly, if the tenant requests the landlord’s name and address in writing from the agent, section 1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 requires that the agent must supply the tenant with that information within 21 days of receipt. Criminal sanctions apply for failure to comply to that legislation.

As to the mould damage, any claim depends on why the wall is damp, is it rising damp, penetrating damp or simply condensation. The latter is caused through lack of air circulating, furniture too near wall, lack of ventilation through windows, doors, extractor fans etc.

If rising or penetrating damp then landlord's insurance for sure, if condensation then again might be LL's, but could be your contents insurance.

If you wanted to go down dispute route, then the local council's environmental office/r will always carry out damp inspection on private rental property.

Edited by Wings on Thursday 19th December 22:20


Edited by Wings on Thursday 19th December 22:41

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Is there definitely damp coming through the wall, or is it condensation between the wall and sofa?

Andyjc86

1,149 posts

180 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
We had this in our first flat (new build, first tenants). We had a damp inspector out and he concluded (he was independent to us and the landlord), that the issue was our fault for not leaving the windows open all the time and having stuff too close to the walls. A memory foam mattress straight in the tip frown

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Doesn't new plaster need six months to fully dry out? That'd cause damp wouldn't it?

The Surveyor

7,624 posts

268 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
The damp is most likely to be due to the original construction drying out. Not uncommon on new build properties and you'll often find it at the back of kitchen cupboards as well as behind furniture placed next to walls, places where the air isn't circulating and removing the moisture.

Regardless, unless the landlord ( or his agent ) advised you not to put furniture against the wall for the first few months, it's down to him to sort it out.

To balance though, if it's the back of the sofa, which isn't seen, is it reasonable to seek a replacement?

darreni

4,552 posts

301 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
It'll be condensation between the sofa & the wall.

I assume the wall is an exterior one?
Cold wall meeting warm air from you sitting on the sofa= Condensation.

We had this on our wall/ sofa. Easy enough job to clean up.
I made a couple of oak spacers that sit on the floor behind the sofa & butt up against the skirting boards, giving a couple of inches gap for air to circulate & have never had a problem since.

Stubby Pete

2,488 posts

277 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
If you have your own insurance, claim off them. They will then exercise their subrogation rights against the landlord if appropriate.
Check your policy first though, it's quite likely that the damage described will not be covered.

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Damn it, I wrote out a long reply earlier on my mobile and it hasn't posted, Grrrr

Anyway, thank you all for taking the time to reply............the sofa hasn't been pushed up against the wall, we left a slight gap(1in max) due to not wanting to mark the wall as it's a rental property. I'm unsure what sort of damp has come through the wall, it could well be condensation, but we do have the windows open for a while every day, I like fresh air flowing through the house for a while.

I'm not wanting to be awkward in anyway with our landlord, I'd just like to be able to get hold of them to speak to them about the issue, we've already been to the site sales office and have got someone coming to see it on Monday, I don't feel it's upto us to arrange this sort of thing but are more than willing to as I respect that it's not my property and like to have it sorted before it got any worse if it was an issue. I'm looking toward maybe claiming for a new sofa due to it being a newish sofa and it wasn't cheap, also due to the fact we are looking to buy a house soon and depending on the layout of the house, the rear of our sofa could be on view and wouldn't look great with a mouldy saggy back. But if something can be done to our current sofa to return it to how it was, then that's fine.

We've been to a house over the road who have the same landlord as us and they are also looking to get hold of the landlords due to issues with their property, such as damp under the windows, but they are also unable to contact the landlord.


2 sMoKiN bArReLs

32,050 posts

266 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Worst "it's the first time we've cleaned behind our sofa in six months" thread ever hehe

You might struggle with insurance as mold tends to take a while to attack?

Edited by 2 sMoKiN bArReLs on Friday 20th December 20:43

Slagathore

6,225 posts

223 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
If the sofa wasn't touching the wall, then how has moisture from the damp wall tramsferred on to the sofa? It does sound like condensation. Usually black mould if it's a condensation problem.

Is there any staining/water marks on the wall itself?

Unless the walls drying out are introducing moisture to that area specifically and that's why it formed there?

Is it likely that a new build would have damp issues? I know some of them are poor quality, but usually that's just the finishes. I'd expect with a proper cavity wall and DPC, proper damp would be quite rare?

I've read a fair bit about people having condensation problems with new builds because they're so tightly sealed and only the trickle vents bring in fresh air, and they're usually not very good, or left shut.




Wings

5,982 posts

246 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Some external walls can have cold spots, so with the warmth of a room, the cold spots create moisture, condensation and then mould. One rental flat, with one cold wall, mould problem, I have recently had thermal board fixed to the wall, thereby removing the cold spots to that wall.

Another rental property, again with the same above problem, I have had to remove two fitted wardrobes, and supply the tenant with two freestanding wardrobes.

Leather shoes, coats, furniture seems to attract mould, and modern living, heating full blast, cooking, washing, out all day, windows and doors closed, so lack of ventilation, just fuels condensation.

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
2 sMoKiN bArReLs said:
Worst "it's the first time we've cleaned behind our sofa in six months" thread ever hehe

You might struggle with insurance as mold tends to take a while to attack?

Edited by 2 sMoKiN bArReLs on Friday 20th December 20:43
Haha if only, my mrs drives me up the wall, I'm constantly getting told to move your feet when the hovers out, dusting the v while I'm watching it etc etc lol

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Slagathore said:
If the sofa wasn't touching the wall, then how has moisture from the damp wall tramsferred on to the sofa? It does sound like condensation. Usually black mould if it's a condensation problem.

Is there any staining/water marks on the wall itself?

Unless the walls drying out are introducing moisture to that area specifically and that's why it formed there?

Is it likely that a new build would have damp issues? I know some of them are poor quality, but usually that's just the finishes. I'd expect with a proper cavity wall and DPC, proper damp would be quite rare?

I've read a fair bit about people having condensation problems with new builds because they're so tightly sealed and only the trickle vents bring in fresh air, and they're usually not very good, or left shut.
As you say, how did the moisture get onto the sofa, any time I moved the sofa I always made sure it was left back with a slight gap left between the wall and sofa, but I can't say the same for my mrs as I couldn't be sure she wouldn't have pushed it right the way back to the wall, she says she didn't and aren't going to argue with her about it. Yes, there is water/staining marks on the wall and also the mould on the sofa is a light grey colour.

The houses have been built by a very reputable building firm, Croudace, and it's big estate this one and is all finished to a high standard so I can't see it being shoddy workmanship, but I'll find out more when they come round on Monday.


As for your last point, we did have a chat with the builder last time they were round and he said the houses are sealed and insulated to the highest level. My dad seems to think the trickle vents may have been blocked by the gravel/shingle that's been put around the borders of the house.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
It's a new build drying out. Most new builds have a list of no-no's - putting things on or very close to walls for 6 months is one of them.

tbc

3,017 posts

206 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
If it's a fairly new build then painting the plaster before it has fully dried out could be the cause. Should also have hairline cracks due to expansion of the plaster.

Although wouldn't put it past the landlord to claim you been drying your washing inside