Legalities of incorrect tyre size
Legalities of incorrect tyre size
Author
Discussion

Rubber-Ducky

Original Poster:

284 posts

236 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Good afternoon fellow PHers.

My sister in law has just bought a second hand car (from a trader). She's going to get new rear tyres fitted as they're pretty worn, however closer examination has revealed that the front tyres (which have plenty of tread) are the incorrect size. They're 205/50R16 when they should be 225/50R16.

Is this legal? Should this have been picked up at the recent MOT? What should she do?

Thanks in advance!

Jakg

4,070 posts

199 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
It's not illegal, nor is it a matter for MOT (as long as they are the same size on each side and of the same construction)

Roo

11,504 posts

238 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
If they're legal, tread wise, they'll pass the MOT.

Only difference is speedo will be out by 3%

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
It might fail an MOT if the different size tyres put the speedo under, or possibly too far over?

But in general, so long as the tyres fit the wheels and the wheel arches it's not a legal problem.


ouch

132 posts

191 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
technically it's a change to the OE specification, so the insurance may not be valid (if they choose to be picky about it). Then you'd be driving without insurance, which is a legal issue.

Thing is you'd only really find out when the whole system is tested, like when involved in an accident.

ferdyg

193 posts

202 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
its the width that is different, not aspect

Its also quite a wide tyre, what car is it?

225/50/16

205/50/16

kiethton

14,670 posts

211 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
It's a non-issue.

Many people (myself included) fit 265 tyres (instead of 255) to their cars as there is far more choice in rubber, it costs less and gives some additional kerb protection.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
It might fail an MOT if the different size tyres put the speedo under, or possibly too far over?
Nope, speedo calibration isn't testable.

ferdyg said:
its the width that is different, not aspect

Its also quite a wide tyre, what car is it?

225/50/16

205/50/16
Except the profile is a %age of the tread width, so the 225/50 will be 10mm taller than 205/50.

Rubber-Ducky

Original Poster:

284 posts

236 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies.

The car is a BMW Z3 2.2

I think the speedo reading is taken from the gearbox output, so won't be affected.

I didn't think it would be an MOT issue, but just wanted to check.

The front tyres are Nexen ditch finders anyway, so I'll try and just persuade her to change all four and be done with it.

Interesting point re: insurance validity...

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
Snowboy said:
It might fail an MOT if the different size tyres put the speedo under, or possibly too far over?
Nope, speedo calibration isn't testable.
Really?
I'm tempted to call you out on that one as it seems totally counter intuitive for then not to test the speedo.
But that's just based on assumption rather then knowledge.

I might have to go and ask google.


Edit - yep, as of Jan 1 2012 a car needs a working, illuminated, glass covered speedo.


Edited by Snowboy on Friday 20th December 14:39

Roo

11,504 posts

238 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
How would they test its calibration?

Impasse

15,099 posts

272 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Edit - yep, as of Jan 1 2012 a car needs a working, illuminated, glass covered speedo.


Edited by Snowboy on Friday 20th December 14:39
I'm not sure "working" is the same as "calibrated". In other words, does it register a nominal flicker during the brake test on the rollers?

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Exactly. MOT testers have no facilities to measure accuracy of speedos, nor does an accuracy test appear in the testing manual.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Cool.
I learned something new.

On the bright side, it does mean I won't need to worry about the speedo when I put 31's on my Jeep. smile

Spangles

1,441 posts

216 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
TooMany2cvs said:
Snowboy said:
It might fail an MOT if the different size tyres put the speedo under, or possibly too far over?
Nope, speedo calibration isn't testable.
Really?
I'm tempted to call you out on that one as it seems totally counter intuitive for then not to test the speedo.
But that's just based on assumption rather then knowledge.

I might have to go and ask google.


Edit - yep, as of Jan 1 2012 a car needs a working, illuminated, glass covered speedo.


Edited by Snowboy on Friday 20th December 14:39
Not quite. It neeeds a speedo that isn't 'clearly inoperative'. In VOSA speak that's a long way from 'working'.

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Cool.
I learned something new.

On the bright side, it does mean I won't need to worry about the speedo when I put 31's on my Jeep. smile
You won't have to worry about it at MOT time. MOT passes do not protect you against subsequent prosecution for lack of roadworthiness.

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Rubber-Ducky said:
I think the speedo reading is taken from the gearbox output, so won't be affected.
What do you think the gearbox is connected to ?

Might it be measuring the times the wheels go round ?

Just a thought.

Edited by Exige77 on Friday 20th December 15:17

onomatopoeia

3,526 posts

248 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
ouch said:
technically it's a change to the OE specification, so the insurance may not be valid (if they choose to be picky about it). Then you'd be driving without insurance, which is a legal issue.
I'm not a legal person, nor do I claim to have any qualifications relating to reading legislation, but I'm pretty sure that no matter what size of tyre is fitted, if she has an insurance certificate she will be insured for the purposes of a "driving without insurance" (or whatever the precise wording is) charge. In the event of an at fault claim the insurers may seek to recover their costs after meeting the claim of a third party, but that's not the same as uninsured.

Someone will now come along and say that in the event of a claim the insurers would attempt to have the policy voided ab inito due to slightly wider tyres.

Rubber-Ducky

Original Poster:

284 posts

236 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Exige77 said:
Rubber-Ducky said:
I think the speedo reading is taken from the gearbox output, so won't be affected.
What do you think the gearbox is connected to ?
The clutch at the front, and the driveshaft at the rear.

Exige77 said:
Might it be measuring the times the wheels go round ?
Not the front ones.

Exige77 said:
Just a thought.
Thanks.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
onomatopoeia said:
ouch said:
technically it's a change to the OE specification, so the insurance may not be valid (if they choose to be picky about it). Then you'd be driving without insurance, which is a legal issue.
I'm not a legal person, nor do I claim to have any qualifications relating to reading legislation, but I'm pretty sure that no matter what size of tyre is fitted, if she has an insurance certificate she will be insured for the purposes of a "driving without insurance" (or whatever the precise wording is) charge. In the event of an at fault claim the insurers may seek to recover their costs after meeting the claim of a third party, but that's not the same as uninsured.

Someone will now come along and say that in the event of a claim the insurers would attempt to have the policy voided ab inito due to slightly wider tyres.
Correct.
See Section 148 RTA 1988. Cannot renage on Insurance 3rd party because of the condition of the vehicle

dvd