Fraud by a client - would Plod be interested?
Fraud by a client - would Plod be interested?
Author
Discussion

Tom_C76

Original Poster:

1,923 posts

219 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
We run a small consulting business. We carried out work for a tradesman on a project. We billed tradesman. Tradesman surcharged his client(householder) for our fees. Tradesman then, in spite of many promises, cheques in post, planning to drop money round etc, has not passed said surcharged fees on to us.

I have an email from the householder confirming that they paid extra for our fees on top of what they had agreed for the tradesman's work. To me this is clearly receiving money under false pretences and therefore fraud. Is it worth trundling round to the police station with my file?

T

Mandat

4,657 posts

269 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
What are the false pretences that you think were given?

It sounds like a normal transaction where your subcontracted work has been recharged to the end client with a % markup. Sounds fairly routine to me.

The problem that you have is extracting money from your client, which is the tradesman, which seems like a simple credit control issue.


Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
What were the payment terms which you agreed with the tradesman?

Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Depending on the full circs, it could end up being a civil matter rather than a police one.

singlecoil

35,894 posts

277 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Agree with the others, nothing to do with the householder, it's your client, the tradesman, that owes you the money.

No, the police will not be interested, they will say it's a civil matter and they would be right.

Tom_C76

Original Poster:

1,923 posts

219 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Mandat said:
What are the false pretences that you think were given?

It sounds like a normal transaction where your subcontracted work has been recharged to the end client with a % markup. Sounds fairly routine to me.

The problem that you have is extracting money from your client, which is the tradesman, which seems like a simple credit control issue.
In my view the false pretence is that he charged his client separately and specifically for the cost of paying us, then pocketed the extra money.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
No he charged his customer for a service and provided it as agreed. He sub-contracted that service to you so as above, this is a civil issue. Ultimately if he doesn't pay you'll have to go to court and you will probably win. Still doesn't guarantee you'll get paid though unfortunately.


mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
Agree with the others, nothing to do with the householder, it's your client, the tradesman, that owes you the money.

No, the police will not be interested, they will say it's a civil matter and they would be right.
This.

Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
It can be both fraud and a civil matter.

The problem you will have is showing he had no intention of paying you - which will be near impossible in an isolated case.

djohnson

3,687 posts

254 months

Thursday 26th December 2013
quotequote all
As you set it out above it's a simple debt recovery issue and unless there's some aggravating factor which you're not mentioning police will neither interested not able to assist. That the ultimate customer is someone other than the trader is largely irrelevant since from what you write I suggest your issue is with the trader. That the you can evidence the payment from the ultimate customer to the trader is helpful in that it makes it difficult for the trader to dispute the quality of your work or similar. I'd proceed with usual debt recovery process and if unsure then a quick call to your accountant is needed. Hope this helps.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Thursday 26th December 2013
quotequote all
Would you be as concerned if he had paid you and his end client wouldn't pay him? Would you consider that fraud?

Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Thursday 26th December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Would you be as concerned if he had paid you and his end client wouldn't pay him? Would you consider that fraud?
Probably not but it wouldn't stop it being fraud.

Fraud is about making false representations and its perfectly possible the client could have acted fraudulently i nthe scenario you pose- but it would not be the concern of the Op but of the tardesman.

Like I have said, proving intent on an isolated case like this would be impossible unless you had some blatant evidence of the trader admitting procuring a service with no intention to pay the supplier.