Carphone warehouse dispute
Author
Discussion

Jim86

Original Poster:

21 posts

219 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
I sent my phone away to carphone warehouse to be repaired under warranty. They have just called me to say that they are unable to repair my phone and they do not have any of the same phone to offer as a replacement. They have offered me the choice of 4 phones as a replacement but I'm not happy with them and I have been told that a refund is not an option.

Am I legally entitled to a refund on this?

Regards

Jim

Edited by Jim86 on Saturday 21st December 12:13

scorcher

4,130 posts

265 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Jim86 said:
They have offered me 4 phones as a replacement
You'll look like a drug dealer, don't accept!

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Jim86 said:
I sent my phone away to carphone warehouse to be repaired under warranty. They have just called me to say that they are unable to repair my phone and they do not have any of the same phone to offer as a replacement. They have offered me the choice of 4 phones as a replacement but I'm not happy with them and I have been told that a refund is not an option.

Am I legally entitled to a refund on this?

Regards

Jim
How long have you had the phone?

Jim86

Original Poster:

21 posts

219 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Andy_GSA said:
How long have you had the phone?
18 months

barker22

1,037 posts

198 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
What exactly is wrong with the other 4 phones. Surely one of them is an upgrade from your 'old' phone.

Jim86

Original Poster:

21 posts

219 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
barker22 said:
What exactly is wrong with the other 4 phones. Surely one of them is an upgrade from your 'old' phone.
I don't consider them an upgrade

Butter Face

35,167 posts

191 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Jim86 said:
barker22 said:
What exactly is wrong with the other 4 phones. Surely one of them is an upgrade from your 'old' phone.
I don't consider them an upgrade
Whether you 'consider' them an upgrade or not is irrelevant.

They are probably all technically upgraded from your old phone. They're fulfilling their obligations, simple.

After 18 months you are lucky to get offered anything at all really.

Anonamoose

442 posts

166 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Jim86 said:
barker22 said:
What exactly is wrong with the other 4 phones. Surely one of them is an upgrade from your 'old' phone.
I don't consider them an upgrade
What phone broke and what replacements are they offering?

The fact you didn't put that in your OP says to me that most people would class them as an upgrade. Of course I might be wrong but it seems pretty significant to the issue for you to miss it out.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Jim86 said:
I don't consider them an upgrade
So what phone was it, and what are they offering you?

Jim86

Original Poster:

21 posts

219 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I buy sim free phones. Going off the ebay completed listings my phone is worth more than the refurb replacements

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Does this help?

If a repair is impossible or unfeasible, you must then be offered a replacement. Due to the emphasis on proportionality in this legislation, you must give the seller reasonable time to repair or replace before demanding your money back and you should be aware that any refund given may well take account of any use you have had of the goods since you took possession of them. If you do not want the seller to repair or replace, or they have told you they are unable to, you can then request they reduce the purchase price to an appropriate amount, although this does not affect your ability to take return the item if something else goes wrong.

http://whatconsumer.co.uk/returning-damaged-or-fau...


smileymikey

1,446 posts

257 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
18 months old and they are offering a brand spanking new phone to replace it?!? I don't get the problem tbh.... Im assuming your contract is 24 months. Why not Ebay the replacement phone as brand new in box then chip in a couple of quid for something at the top of the food chain?? With the prospect of another new phone in six months when your contract expires that you can get for free and punt out for three or four hundred quid....but maybe I'm missing "the principle of the matter"

smileymikey

1,446 posts

257 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Jim86 said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I buy sim free phones. Going off the ebay completed listings my phone is worth more than the refurb replacements
This has appeared since my post....I still think your chancing it a bit. 18 months is a lifetime when it comes to a phone

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
This thread needs phone details.

Jim86

Original Poster:

21 posts

219 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
Does this help?

If a repair is impossible or unfeasible, you must then be offered a replacement. Due to the emphasis on proportionality in this legislation, you must give the seller reasonable time to repair or replace before demanding your money back and you should be aware that any refund given may well take account of any use you have had of the goods since you took possession of them. If you do not want the seller to repair or replace, or they have told you they are unable to, you can then request they reduce the purchase price to an appropriate amount, although this does not affect your ability to take return the item if something else goes wrong.

http://whatconsumer.co.uk/returning-damaged-or-fau...
Thats great thanks!

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
It's to CW's credit that they repair out of warranty phones with no argument. They don't have the exact same phone in stock so what do you expect them to do? Buy one off ebay for you? They can only give you what they have and you seem reluctant to tell us which phones are being discussed for some reason.


Jim86

Original Poster:

21 posts

219 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
It's to CW's credit that they repair out of warranty phones with no argument. They don't have the exact same phone in stock so what do you expect them to do? Buy one off ebay for you? They can only give you what they have and you seem reluctant to tell us which phones are being discussed for some reason.
It isn't out of warranty

Crafty_

14,232 posts

231 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Jim86 said:
barker22 said:
What exactly is wrong with the other 4 phones. Surely one of them is an upgrade from your 'old' phone.
I don't consider them an upgrade
Why should you get an upgrade from a warranty ?

The warranty should replace (as closely as possible) like for like, never seen a warranty (for anything) that doesn't.

I think you are trying it on to be honest.

Jim86

Original Poster:

21 posts

219 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Crafty_ said:
Why should you get an upgrade from a warranty ?

The warranty should replace (as closely as possible) like for like, never seen a warranty (for anything) that doesn't.

I think you are trying it on to be honest.
I never said I wanted an upgrade, it was a comment in reply to a previous post

Crafty_

14,232 posts

231 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
So whats wrong with the 4 phones offered to you ?