English LAs' £600m profits from parking 'fines'
English LAs' £600m profits from parking 'fines'
Author
Discussion

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
The Independent and other media said:
Councils across England have been accused of implementing “an unacceptable mass ticketing culture” after the release of figures showing that car parking charges have generated £600m of surplus profit in the past year.

In towns and cities across the country, car parking costs have risen despite overall spending on local roads falling. But it is the combined profit – calculated by adding income from parking charges and penalty notices and then deducting running costs – which has proved most lucrative, according to a new study.

In 2012-13 councils generated a combined profit of £594m, a 5 per cent increase on the figure from the previous year. Budgets submitted by local authorities suggest the surplus for the financial year ending next April could be as high as £632m, while just 52 of the 353 parking authorities in England reported any sort of deficit.

According to the figures, calculated by the RAC Foundation through annual returns submitted by councils to the Department for Communities and Local Government, the London borough of Westminster generated the highest car parking surplus in Britain, of £39.7m. It was followed by Kensington & Chelsea in west London (£30.44 m) and Camden in north London (£23m). Outside the capital Brighton (£16.25m), Nottingham (£11.79m) and Manchester (£8.78m) generated the most profit in the top 10 regions.

The figures give ammunition to MPs who are calling for councils to publish annual parking-charge reports which show where the revenue is coming from and where it is being spent. Louise Ellman, the chairman of the House of Commons Transport Committee, previously said the use of parking charges and fines to raise revenue was “neither acceptable nor legal”.

According to the figures, calculated by the RAC Foundation through annual returns submitted by councils to the Department for Communities and Local Government, the London borough of Westminster generated the highest car parking surplus in Britain, of £39.7m. It was followed by Kensington & Chelsea in west London (£30.44 m) and Camden in north London (£23m). Outside the capital Brighton (£16.25m), Nottingham (£11.79m) and Manchester (£8.78m) generated the most profit in the top 10 regions.

The figures give ammunition to MPs who are calling for councils to publish annual parking-charge reports which show where the revenue is coming from and where it is being spent. Louise Ellman, the chairman of the House of Commons Transport Committee, previously said the use of parking charges and fines to raise revenue was “neither acceptable nor legal”.

The committee report also recommends that drivers should be given “five minutes’ grace” after their pay and display tickets expire before being issued infringement notices.

Paul Watters, the head of roads policy for the AA, said: “CCTV has fuelled an unfair culture of mass-ticketing instead of a deterrent. It has gone too far – and some streets are really raking it in. In terms of higher car parking charges, not only are they not cost-effective but it can have a damaging effect on visitors to a region and tourism.”

Stephen Glaister, the director of the RAC Foundation, said: “ Once again English councils have made record amounts from parking. Yet overall spending on local roads has fallen by 9 per cent over the past three years, with road safety expenditure down by as much as 20 percent.

“There’s no disputing the figures we have looked at. They are the numbers the councils themselves submit to central government. What’s more, council budgets show that the surplus for the current year is set to be higher.”

But Peter Box, the chairman of the Local Government Association’s economy and transport board, said: “Councils do not make a profit from parking. All income from charges and fines is spent on running parking services and any surplus goes on essential transport projects such as bringing our dilapidated road network up to scratch and providing subsidised bus travel for children or elderly residents.”
That last is so risible that the families of some PHers could find their Christmases ruined by the loss of their loved one who choked to death on reading it.

Streaky

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
I think that this is another example of the obsession of all Governments since 1979 with having a low headline rate of income tax. Local authority funding always gets squeezed by Central Government. The parking charges are a form of taxation. I don't mind taxes, but would prefer that Governments were up front about them, but they can't be because doing so would be electoral suicide.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
My understanding though is that to run the parking system expressly to generate a surplus for other spending would be unlawful. In that sense, it is the Authorties' acting ultra vires that would have us think of parking revenue as an alternate income tax.

I'd prefer central government to be more authoritarian on the matter, but that would cast the spotlight back on them, so I doubt it'll happen any time soon.

PAULJ5555

3,554 posts

207 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
I tend to park with a bit of respect for other road users and land owners. I park everyday on public highways I've not had a ticket in about 15 years.

If people were not so selfish the LA's would not ticket so many people.

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
There is an easy way for the Government to act if they want to. Just change the rules so the income from Fixed Penalties goes to the Treasury and Councils are given grants to run the schemes.

Countdown

49,597 posts

227 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
PAULJ5555 said:
I tend to park with a bit of respect for other road users and land owners. I park everyday on public highways I've not had a ticket in about 15 years.

If people were not so selfish the LA's would not ticket so many people.
Selfish being the right word. There seem to be more and more people who have to park right outside the takeaway/bookies even if it's next to a set of traffic lights. Who cares if it causes massive tailbacks at rush hour?



General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
PAULJ5555 said:
I tend to park with a bit of respect for other road users and land owners. I park everyday on public highways I've not had a ticket in about 15 years.

If people were not so selfish the LA's would not ticket so many people.
Which misses the point entirely. LA's should not be incentivised to fine through financial reward as this leads to over-zelous enforcement and a lack of compassion when there is genuine mitigation. Keep the roads clear by all means, hand out fines where necessary but don't use the income from those fines to subsidise general spending.

mudster

792 posts

275 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
PAULJ5555 said:
I tend to park with a bit of respect for other road users and land owners. I park everyday on public highways I've not had a ticket in about 15 years.

If people were not so selfish the LA's would not ticket so many people.
It's a good point. Parking 'taxes' are very much optional and I choose not to contribute.

There will be certain unique cases, but it would appear many of the electorate are happy with the status quo if they are contributing to LA's coffers.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
mudster said:
It's a good point. Parking 'taxes' are very much optional and I choose not to contribute.

There will be certain unique cases, but it would appear many of the electorate are happy with the status quo if they are contributing to LA's coffers.
You don't pay to park in council car parks then?

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
Are we to really believe that Westminster Council spent £40m on essential transport projects such as bringing their dilapidated road network up to scratch and providing subsidised bus travel for children or elderly residents?
I doubt they will open the books for scrutiny without being ordered to and even then after a bit of creativity.

mudster

792 posts

275 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
mudster said:
It's a good point. Parking 'taxes' are very much optional and I choose not to contribute.

There will be certain unique cases, but it would appear many of the electorate are happy with the status quo if they are contributing to LA's coffers.
You don't pay to park in council car parks then?
I genuinely can't remember the last time I did pay to park in a LA car park, but if I'm honest, I was really referring to the penalty charges. I would suspect any revenue increase will have come from this source rather than hugely increasing the cost of parking.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
streaky said:
The Independent and other media said:
But Peter Box, the chairman of the Local Government Association’s economy and transport board, said: “Councils do not make a profit from parking. All income from charges and fines is spent on running parking services and any surplus goes on essential transport projects such as bringing our dilapidated road network up to scratch and providing subsidised bus travel for children or elderly residents.”
That last is so risible that the families of some PHers could find their Christmases ruined by the loss of their loved one who choked to death on reading it.
Mr Box really needs to get his Act together. RTRA 1984 Section 122 is designed primarily to manage traffic. Nowhere does it give LAs revenue raising or taxing powers. LB Barnet got soundly spanked in the High Court for trying it on - http://cases.iclr.co.uk/Subscr/search.aspx?path=WL...

Most local authorities outsource their parking enforcement to private companies (e.g. Vinci Park in LB Bromley and LB Kingston-upon-Thames). These parasitic organisations have a bottom line incentive to issue as many tickets as possible which then translates to extra cash for the LA. A win-win for both of them but not the end user.

Edited by Red Devil on Monday 23 December 13:57

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
An I was said to be over reacting when I vowed not to go to a particular borough ever again after getting a ticket. There is a town centre not too far away from where I live that has footballers/barristers/doctors etc living less than a mile away yet its on its arse with the countries highest percentage of shut shops, there can be only one reason for this and its not a lack of money locally. Hardly any car parks and you are pounced on if you even look like parking unlawfully. Its somewhere else I dont bother going.

singlecoil

35,894 posts

277 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
PAULJ5555 said:
I tend to park with a bit of respect for other road users and land owners. I park everyday on public highways I've not had a ticket in about 15 years.

If people were not so selfish the LA's would not ticket so many people.
Which misses the point entirely. LA's should not be incentivised to fine through financial reward as this leads to over-zealous enforcement and a lack of compassion when there is genuine mitigation fines to subsidise general spending.
I would be interested to know more about these concepts, neither of which appear to make much sense on the face of it.

singlecoil

35,894 posts

277 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
Mandown46 said:
singlecoil said:
I would be interested to know more about these concepts, neither of which appear to make much sense on the face of it.
My local council made my street, and all the surrounding ones permit parking, supposedly to solve an issue of people parking on residential streets.
Probably, these people parked there, then walked into the city, to avoid the large parking charges in the car parks.
I never had a single problem parking my car, at worst, I parked 20 metres from my front door.

A guy behind me gets a ticket on his bike constantly, his parking permit has been stolen no end of time, he appeals every ticket, though he has had to pay about 1 in 3, not to mention the hassle that entails applying for a new pass every time.

In addition, you are only allowed a maximum of 2 visitors passes, so, if you have a party, only 2 of the people you invite are allowed to drive there, the rest have to make other arrangements, or they will get fined as well.

There was never a parking problem there in the first place :/
Interesting stuff, thanks for sharing, but not quite sure how it answers my query.

Terminator X

21,039 posts

235 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
I protest every ticket and take it to the adjudicator person; for the sake of £30 I like them to work for their money. If we all did that they system would implode in a paperwork mountain idea

TX.

GPSHead

657 posts

272 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
Mandown46 said:
singlecoil said:
I would be interested to know more about these concepts, neither of which appear to make much sense on the face of it.
My local council made my street, and all the surrounding ones permit parking, supposedly to solve an issue of people parking on residential streets.
Probably, these people parked there, then walked into the city, to avoid the large parking charges in the car parks.
I never had a single problem parking my car, at worst, I parked 20 metres from my front door.

A guy behind me gets a ticket on his bike constantly, his parking permit has been stolen no end of time, he appeals every ticket, though he has had to pay about 1 in 3, not to mention the hassle that entails applying for a new pass every time.

In addition, you are only allowed a maximum of 2 visitors passes, so, if you have a party, only 2 of the people you invite are allowed to drive there, the rest have to make other arrangements, or they will get fined as well.

There was never a parking problem there in the first place :/
Interesting stuff, thanks for sharing, but not quite sure how it answers my query.
I'm with you. Being a fellow control freak, I think it's great that councils use parking enforcement as an unofficial source of revenue by putting in unreasonable and unnecessary restrictions and then rigorously enforcing them. And then there's the bonus of being able to "cleverly" wind up those who object to that abuse of process by playing dumb and pretending not to see the point. Genius, that is.

There is (for one) the minor problem that our town centres are being irrevocably ruined by this approach of deliverately making legal parking next-to-impossible where it was once easy. But if we don't care about the side effects of speed cameras (killing people...no big deal) then we're hardly likely to concern ourselves with mere running down of amenities, are we? Controlling and stealing from motorists at every opportunity is more important than, well, anything, apparently.

Not sure what motorists and motorcyclists did to deserve such smug, unmitigated spite in the first place. Enjoying their freedom a bit too much, maybe? I just can't see why someone would be so vindictive as to think it's somehow amusing when ordinary people start being persecuted and ticketed for simply parking outside their houses, not bothering anyone else, as they have done with zero problems for years. Why the desperation to interfere? What is so horrifying about the scenario of, I don't know, just allowing people to go about their business unmolested?

Morningside

24,147 posts

260 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
And I thought all this crap was going to end once the Tories got in.



What?


Oh?

frown

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
From the article"But Peter Box, the chairman of the Local Government Association’s economy and transport board, said: “Councils do not make a profit from parking. All income from charges and fines is spent on running parking services and any surplus goes on essential transport projects such as bringing our dilapidated road network up to scratch and providing subsidised bus travel for children or elderly residents"

Didn't Eric Pickles say something like "any resemblance between the truth and this is purely accidental"( or words to that effect)

singlecoil

35,894 posts

277 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
GPSHead said:
I'm with you. Being a fellow control freak, ...
blah blah blah
I'm going to go out on the thin spindly limb of a cheap, dried up xmastree and guess that that's sarcasm?

But it doesn't really work because being a control freak is all about wanting to be in control of something, and I really haven't the slightest interest in being in control of parking in cities.

Nor am I a "I want to park WTF I like, WTF I like" kind of guy.

But I do recognise that if there were no parking restrictions, I still wouldn't be able to park where I liked because there would be someone else there already, and a queue of cars waiting to take his place whenever he chose to come back and drive off.