Tree branch has damaged car
Discussion
Late last week a branch fell off a tree onto my son's car (which was just back from the repairers after some tw*t reversed into it). The tree is located on the pavement (rather than a private garden) and is therefore probably the council's responsibility.
Anyone have a view on recovering the repair cost from the council so as to protect his valuable NCD?


Anyone have a view on recovering the repair cost from the council so as to protect his valuable NCD?
Fwark me, not this again! Chrimbo Compo Culcha Craziness!
OP, have you figured out how you are going to prove that the wind blowing a tree branch onto your car is the fault of the Council? Also, do you know where Councils get the money to pay insurance premia and such like? Clue: it doesn't grow on trees.
OP, have you figured out how you are going to prove that the wind blowing a tree branch onto your car is the fault of the Council? Also, do you know where Councils get the money to pay insurance premia and such like? Clue: it doesn't grow on trees.
Breadvan72 said:
Fwark me, not this again! Chrimbo Compo Culcha Craziness!
OP, have you figured out how you are going to prove that the wind blowing a tree branch onto your car is the fault of the Council? Also, do you know where Councils get the money to pay insurance premia and such like? Clue: it doesn't grow on trees.
OP, have you figured out how you are going to prove that the wind blowing a tree branch onto your car is the fault of the Council? Also, do you know where Councils get the money to pay insurance premia and such like? Clue: it doesn't grow on trees.

runnerbean 14 said:
I'd guess the counccil have insurance for this sort of thing. If it had been a tree in a private garden they would certainly have been insured under their household policy.
As I understand it, it comes under the 's
t happens' category uness the tree owner can be shown to be negligent in any way. As has been said elsewhere, this kind of unforseen incident is one of the reasons why we insure our valuable possessions.Your boys fancy Germany motor doesn't seem to tolerate wood paint interfaces as well as a little '60's Austin
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78b67l_yxUc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78b67l_yxUc
Magic919 said:
If the Council have been negligent, you'd have a case.
Around here the council don't actively manage their trees, if yours are the same they are definitely negligent.We have some large oaks at the end of our garden, when we first moved in the council came around every year and chopped off bits that weren't safe. Over the years they have bothered less and less.
My neighbour wrote to them a few of years ago pointing out that if something should happen they are negligent, they did send someone out to check them and subsequently got someone in to do a lot of pruning, nothing since.
FFs! So just because someone appears to be able to afford something means they should?
The OP asked a decent question, probably knowing the outcome but come on! This place is getting worse.
What's wrong with a civil response without an attack on the OP's (in this case his sons) wealth?? We all do our best to keep costs down regardless of income.
s
t does indeed happen though and this is one of those times.
Good luck!
The OP asked a decent question, probably knowing the outcome but come on! This place is getting worse.
What's wrong with a civil response without an attack on the OP's (in this case his sons) wealth?? We all do our best to keep costs down regardless of income.
s
t does indeed happen though and this is one of those times. Good luck!
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



