Unattended barking dog
Discussion
The flat next door to me has been rented by some Chinese students, who it turns out are absolute
s. Almost from the start, there's been problems with them dumping rubbish, making ridiculous amounts of noise (in every way - talking/shouting, music, banging things and drilling walls, all usually in the small hours of the morning), showing zero consideration generally for others.
These a
holes have now gone one better by going home to China over the Christmas and New Year holiday, leaving a little white dog of theirs confined to the flat. I know this from their friend who I challenged in the corridor a few days ago, and who appears to attend once a day presumably to put out food and water. However the dog barks and yelps for long periods of a time in the evening when unattended, including into the small hours of the morning. The dog doesn't appear to get any exercise or taken for walks (and I don't just mean now while they're away - I mean I've never seen it get taken out). There's an unpleasant smell in the corridor outside our flats, the lights appear to be left on permanently in the flat so it never gets dark, and some windows are open which drove the dog berserk overnight recently with the gales and rain we had. I think the dog's living conditions leave a lot to be desired and although it is clearly getting fed & watered, it sounds clearly distressed with the non-stop barking and howling and yelping.
I've contacted the Managing Agents for the flats, who have contacted the owner (who isn't local), who has contacted his letting agents and given them clear instruction to remove the dog and serve notice on the tenants for breach of lease. However the letting agents, who I had suspicions about anyway, are proving to be worse than useless and have yet to actually intervene. From the comments in the emails that have been going around between all parties, I get the impression that they don't even really consider it their responsibility and expect the Management Company for the flats to get the council/authorities to resolve the problem.
So far they've not entered the flat saying they do not have the authority to do so, presumably because they need the tenant's consent. However the tenant isn't here, and isn't going to be here for another week. I've made multiple reports to the RSPCA in light of the animal's obvious distress, I've reported it to the council's overnight noise team, yet I'm still stuck with a dog barking next door and keeping me awake until 3 or 4am in the morning.
Legal threats have been made against the owner who, for his part, has apologised and issued his letting agents with very clear instructions which would resolve the problem. Realistically, what options do I have or what can I expect to be done by the letting agent?
I'm back at work on Monday after the Christmas break and can't take another night of this, let alone having to be up in time for work.
s. Almost from the start, there's been problems with them dumping rubbish, making ridiculous amounts of noise (in every way - talking/shouting, music, banging things and drilling walls, all usually in the small hours of the morning), showing zero consideration generally for others.These a
holes have now gone one better by going home to China over the Christmas and New Year holiday, leaving a little white dog of theirs confined to the flat. I know this from their friend who I challenged in the corridor a few days ago, and who appears to attend once a day presumably to put out food and water. However the dog barks and yelps for long periods of a time in the evening when unattended, including into the small hours of the morning. The dog doesn't appear to get any exercise or taken for walks (and I don't just mean now while they're away - I mean I've never seen it get taken out). There's an unpleasant smell in the corridor outside our flats, the lights appear to be left on permanently in the flat so it never gets dark, and some windows are open which drove the dog berserk overnight recently with the gales and rain we had. I think the dog's living conditions leave a lot to be desired and although it is clearly getting fed & watered, it sounds clearly distressed with the non-stop barking and howling and yelping.I've contacted the Managing Agents for the flats, who have contacted the owner (who isn't local), who has contacted his letting agents and given them clear instruction to remove the dog and serve notice on the tenants for breach of lease. However the letting agents, who I had suspicions about anyway, are proving to be worse than useless and have yet to actually intervene. From the comments in the emails that have been going around between all parties, I get the impression that they don't even really consider it their responsibility and expect the Management Company for the flats to get the council/authorities to resolve the problem.
So far they've not entered the flat saying they do not have the authority to do so, presumably because they need the tenant's consent. However the tenant isn't here, and isn't going to be here for another week. I've made multiple reports to the RSPCA in light of the animal's obvious distress, I've reported it to the council's overnight noise team, yet I'm still stuck with a dog barking next door and keeping me awake until 3 or 4am in the morning.
Legal threats have been made against the owner who, for his part, has apologised and issued his letting agents with very clear instructions which would resolve the problem. Realistically, what options do I have or what can I expect to be done by the letting agent?
I'm back at work on Monday after the Christmas break and can't take another night of this, let alone having to be up in time for work.
Antony Moxey said:
Read the OP again, he's said he's contacted the RSPCA 'multiple times'.
Yes, I reported the issue on their 24 hour line, the local case handler called me back on Christmas Day and I gave further details, then I spoke to their national line again a couple of days ago to pass on my increasing concerns about the distress levels of the dog. The RSPCA have the details of the letting agent, so it's not even like they need the police to force entry (although after the indifference & ineptitude shown by the letting agent, I'd very much like for the police to smash the front door open!).I can only suspect that because the dog is actually getting fed and watered that it's not a high priority for them, despite the cruelty of leaving a dog largely unattended, the distress it's in, and the severe noise nuisance it is causing.
At the end of the day the buck ends with the LL, with either the lack of action, or actions of the letting agent, still leaving the LL legally accountable.
Not a quick solution, and anti social issues with neighbours, particularly with occupants of rental premises never are, I would advise first speaking directly with both the LL of the OP's rental property, and to the LL of the flat with the noisy tenant/s. A letting agent has a legal requirement under Section 1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, when requested in writing by a tenant for details of the LL's name and address, to supply within 21 days that same information, with failure to comply to that legislation, criminal sanctions can apply. Whilst the OP should make such a request to the letting agent, a quicker route to that information might be via an online search, application via the Land Registry web site. Might also be worth the same type of search for the offending tenant's flat, is it possible same LL for both properties?
The OP's next approach might be via the local Council's Environmental Office, for they have awesome powers, starting with an abatement noise notice being served on both the tenant/s and the LL, with possible legal sanctions following.
Whilst the Management Agents have rightly identified the breach of their tenancy lease by the offending tenant/s, there is also a breach of the lease by the LL, and so the Management Agents need to be holding the LL more legally accountable. The Management Agents, the LL and the Environmental Officer can all apply to the courts for entry to the flat, and remove the offending dog, noise.
Not a quick solution, and anti social issues with neighbours, particularly with occupants of rental premises never are, I would advise first speaking directly with both the LL of the OP's rental property, and to the LL of the flat with the noisy tenant/s. A letting agent has a legal requirement under Section 1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, when requested in writing by a tenant for details of the LL's name and address, to supply within 21 days that same information, with failure to comply to that legislation, criminal sanctions can apply. Whilst the OP should make such a request to the letting agent, a quicker route to that information might be via an online search, application via the Land Registry web site. Might also be worth the same type of search for the offending tenant's flat, is it possible same LL for both properties?
The OP's next approach might be via the local Council's Environmental Office, for they have awesome powers, starting with an abatement noise notice being served on both the tenant/s and the LL, with possible legal sanctions following.
Whilst the Management Agents have rightly identified the breach of their tenancy lease by the offending tenant/s, there is also a breach of the lease by the LL, and so the Management Agents need to be holding the LL more legally accountable. The Management Agents, the LL and the Environmental Officer can all apply to the courts for entry to the flat, and remove the offending dog, noise.
I have to admit to being a bit irrational when it comes to animals in distress.
If it was me, i'd stove the door in, and take the dog to safety. Make as much s
t for the residents as possible. Do you know their names? Out of the country, cause some bother with them at university with the UK border agency.
My argument - if I ended up in bother with the police - was that you made reasonable attempts to alert the authorities about the plight of the animal and that they did nothing.
The other alternative, when the friend goes round to get the dog, go in with them - whether they want you to or not. Get the dog, take it away. Maybe take some photos of the state the dog and the flat is in. Tell him to go to the law, and you'll make sure the friend is implicated in an animal cruelty case.
Give him a slap for good measure and make him clean the dog s
t up.
As I say, I can get irrational where animal cruelty is concerned. It runs in the family. Apparently back in the 1950s my maternal grandfather - I never knew him - saw a totter beating a horse in the street. The totter felt the wrong end of his own whip that day. His stock tipped into the road and dobbin led away to a place of safety. Not sure if my grandad had a goatee etc. Sounds like he might have had :-)
There will be people along to give you better, lawful advice. Take that, rather than mine. As someone said above. Piss boiling.
If it was me, i'd stove the door in, and take the dog to safety. Make as much s
t for the residents as possible. Do you know their names? Out of the country, cause some bother with them at university with the UK border agency.My argument - if I ended up in bother with the police - was that you made reasonable attempts to alert the authorities about the plight of the animal and that they did nothing.
The other alternative, when the friend goes round to get the dog, go in with them - whether they want you to or not. Get the dog, take it away. Maybe take some photos of the state the dog and the flat is in. Tell him to go to the law, and you'll make sure the friend is implicated in an animal cruelty case.
Give him a slap for good measure and make him clean the dog s
t up.As I say, I can get irrational where animal cruelty is concerned. It runs in the family. Apparently back in the 1950s my maternal grandfather - I never knew him - saw a totter beating a horse in the street. The totter felt the wrong end of his own whip that day. His stock tipped into the road and dobbin led away to a place of safety. Not sure if my grandad had a goatee etc. Sounds like he might have had :-)
There will be people along to give you better, lawful advice. Take that, rather than mine. As someone said above. Piss boiling.
stroberaver said:
Antony Moxey said:
Read the OP again, he's said he's contacted the RSPCA 'multiple times'.
Yes, I reported the issue on their 24 hour line, the local case handler called me back on Christmas Day and I gave further details, then I spoke to their national line again a couple of days ago to pass on my increasing concerns about the distress levels of the dog. The RSPCA have the details of the letting agent, so it's not even like they need the police to force entry (although after the indifference & ineptitude shown by the letting agent, I'd very much like for the police to smash the front door open!).I can only suspect that because the dog is actually getting fed and watered that it's not a high priority for them, despite the cruelty of leaving a dog largely unattended, the distress it's in, and the severe noise nuisance it is causing.
They have been inundated collecting unwanted pets over the festive period!
Absolutely shocking.
wildcat45 said:
I have to admit to being a bit irrational when it comes to animals in distress.
If it was me, i'd stove the door in, and take the dog to safety. Make as much s
t for the residents as possible. Do you know their names? Out of the country, cause some bother with them at university with the UK border agency.
My argument - if I ended up in bother with the police - was that you made reasonable attempts to alert the authorities about the plight of the animal and that they did nothing.
The other alternative, when the friend goes round to get the dog, go in with them - whether they want you to or not. Get the dog, take it away. Maybe take some photos of the state the dog and the flat is in. Tell him to go to the law, and you'll make sure the friend is implicated in an animal cruelty case.
Give him a slap for good measure and make him clean the dog s
t up.
So theft, burglary, criminal damage and an assault to round it off... why not just burn the flat down with the dog and friend in it?If it was me, i'd stove the door in, and take the dog to safety. Make as much s
t for the residents as possible. Do you know their names? Out of the country, cause some bother with them at university with the UK border agency.My argument - if I ended up in bother with the police - was that you made reasonable attempts to alert the authorities about the plight of the animal and that they did nothing.
The other alternative, when the friend goes round to get the dog, go in with them - whether they want you to or not. Get the dog, take it away. Maybe take some photos of the state the dog and the flat is in. Tell him to go to the law, and you'll make sure the friend is implicated in an animal cruelty case.
Give him a slap for good measure and make him clean the dog s
t up.Wings said:
At the end of the day the buck ends with the LL, with either the lack of action, or actions of the letting agent, still leaving the LL legally accountable.
Not a quick solution, and anti social issues with neighbours, particularly with occupants of rental premises never are, I would advise first speaking directly with both the LL of the OP's rental property, and to the LL of the flat with the noisy tenant/s. A letting agent has a legal requirement under Section 1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, when requested in writing by a tenant for details of the LL's name and address, to supply within 21 days that same information, with failure to comply to that legislation, criminal sanctions can apply. Whilst the OP should make such a request to the letting agent, a quicker route to that information might be via an online search, application via the Land Registry web site. Might also be worth the same type of search for the offending tenant's flat, is it possible same LL for both properties?
The OP's next approach might be via the local Council's Environmental Office, for they have awesome powers, starting with an abatement noise notice being served on both the tenant/s and the LL, with possible legal sanctions following.
Whilst the Management Agents have rightly identified the breach of their tenancy lease by the offending tenant/s, there is also a breach of the lease by the LL, and so the Management Agents need to be holding the LL more legally accountable. The Management Agents, the LL and the Environmental Officer can all apply to the courts for entry to the flat, and remove the offending dog, noise.
Thanks for the comments. I should point out though that I'm not renting myself - I own my flat but the one next door is let out. therefore I have no landlord or letting agent of my own to refer the issue to. I am however a Director of the Management Company for the flats, although this seems to count for nothing when it comes to actually removing the dog asap. As you say, everything takes so long with so many hoops to jump through, that the tenants will probably be back by the time anything happens - which is probably what the neighbouring flat's letting agents are hoping for. I've already had direct contact through email with the owner/landlord of the neighbouring flat, and aside from liability, practically speaking there's nothing he can do other than what he has done, which is direct the letting agent to remove the dog immediately and serve notice on the tenants.Not a quick solution, and anti social issues with neighbours, particularly with occupants of rental premises never are, I would advise first speaking directly with both the LL of the OP's rental property, and to the LL of the flat with the noisy tenant/s. A letting agent has a legal requirement under Section 1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, when requested in writing by a tenant for details of the LL's name and address, to supply within 21 days that same information, with failure to comply to that legislation, criminal sanctions can apply. Whilst the OP should make such a request to the letting agent, a quicker route to that information might be via an online search, application via the Land Registry web site. Might also be worth the same type of search for the offending tenant's flat, is it possible same LL for both properties?
The OP's next approach might be via the local Council's Environmental Office, for they have awesome powers, starting with an abatement noise notice being served on both the tenant/s and the LL, with possible legal sanctions following.
Whilst the Management Agents have rightly identified the breach of their tenancy lease by the offending tenant/s, there is also a breach of the lease by the LL, and so the Management Agents need to be holding the LL more legally accountable. The Management Agents, the LL and the Environmental Officer can all apply to the courts for entry to the flat, and remove the offending dog, noise.
As mentioned I have reported the issue to the city council's overnight noise team, who have attended previously (but unfortunately by the time they got here, the dog had gone quiet), and they've sent me forms to make a log of the noise disturbances and report back to them. So the issue is raised and logged with them, but it's not going to achieve anything in the short term.
If I can catch the friend coming again as he enters or leaves the flat, then I will have further words with him. He's also Chinese and last time I spoke with him about the noise he pointed out that he was just a friend stopping by to check on the place, which admittedly is true enough. However he's also complicit in leaving a distressed dog confined in a flat 24/7, which makes me wonder whether he would like to be locked up and kept awake until 3am most nights. Unfortunately I'm out this evening and so will probably not be able to speak to the friend.
Must admit I'm no animal lover - I've never had pets, probably never will, and wouldn't know where to start with looking after one - but it seems bloody awful to leave a dog confined to a flat like that. Everyone knows dogs need walking and exercising, surely? Even little ones!
I've also recently spoken to the local dog/cat charity who run a couple of shelters in the area, to see if they had any advice or suggestions, and they confirmed that the RSPCA was my only hope, but that if the animal is being fed & watered then they probably won't intervene, despite the cruelty of leaving it unattended and indoors all day.

Just spoken again with the RSPCA, enquiring about the lack of response/feedback over the problems I'd previously reported, and upon re-explaining the situation to them and mentioning that it does get fed & watered once a day, the RSPCA told me there isn't anything they could or would do unless it was going more than 24 hours without being attended.
Apparently being locked indoors with nowhere to exercise, nowhere for it's waste, and in obvious distress at all times of night & day, doesn't count enough for the RSPCA to act.
Apparently being locked indoors with nowhere to exercise, nowhere for it's waste, and in obvious distress at all times of night & day, doesn't count enough for the RSPCA to act.

KFC said:
So theft, burglary, criminal damage and an assault to round it off... why not just burn the flat down with the dog and friend in it?
That would be silly. Burning a flat would damage the OP's property. A word to the wise. If you are going to quote me, do not be selective please. The last paragraph in my post was pretty important. It's omission changes the context and spirit and real meaning of the post which was suggesting the OP doesn't actually commit crimes..
Thanks.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


