Question about being drunk in charge of a vehicle.
Discussion
Hi all.
I was looking for a bit of advice on an idea I had about New Year. A few of us are going to a local organised street party. With being unsure about the weather, and taxi availability, I had thought about parking an older vehicle that I have nearby with warm wet weather gear, a couple of umbrellas, and a change of footwear for the ladies in case we end up walking home (which has happened before!). The vehicle in question has an older type remote control alarm which has a separate remote to unlock/lock. I had planned on parking the vehicle up, leaving the ignition key at home which is 5 miles away, and just take the remote to unlock/lock the vehicle at the end of the night. Would this still constitute being in charge of the vehicle whilst under the influence if I have no way to start it?
I was looking for a bit of advice on an idea I had about New Year. A few of us are going to a local organised street party. With being unsure about the weather, and taxi availability, I had thought about parking an older vehicle that I have nearby with warm wet weather gear, a couple of umbrellas, and a change of footwear for the ladies in case we end up walking home (which has happened before!). The vehicle in question has an older type remote control alarm which has a separate remote to unlock/lock. I had planned on parking the vehicle up, leaving the ignition key at home which is 5 miles away, and just take the remote to unlock/lock the vehicle at the end of the night. Would this still constitute being in charge of the vehicle whilst under the influence if I have no way to start it?
I kind of see where the OP is coming from, and where the law is coming from, but something has gone very wrong in society where the OP is concerned about unlocking his car to get a coat out.
I'm not sure if this is a statement on OP's paranoia or the state (and trust) of modern policing.
I'm not sure if this is a statement on OP's paranoia or the state (and trust) of modern policing.
I did plan on driving the car to the venue and leaving it, and get a lift in later.
It might sound like paranoia, but with the way things are, I don't want to jeopardise my New Year for being locked up for something as silly. However that might not be as bad as the wrath of the ladies when they've got to walk home in the no doubt ridiculous heels they'll be wearing should I decide against parking my car at the venue! Haha.
It might sound like paranoia, but with the way things are, I don't want to jeopardise my New Year for being locked up for something as silly. However that might not be as bad as the wrath of the ladies when they've got to walk home in the no doubt ridiculous heels they'll be wearing should I decide against parking my car at the venue! Haha.
rash_decision said:
I did plan on driving the car to the venue and leaving it, and get a lift in later.
It might sound like paranoia, but with the way things are, I don't want to jeopardise my New Year for being locked up for something as silly. However that might not be as bad as the wrath of the ladies when they've got to walk home in the no doubt ridiculous heels they'll be wearing should I decide against parking my car at the venue! Haha.
The 'ladies' could always leave some sensible shoes in the car! It might sound like paranoia, but with the way things are, I don't want to jeopardise my New Year for being locked up for something as silly. However that might not be as bad as the wrath of the ladies when they've got to walk home in the no doubt ridiculous heels they'll be wearing should I decide against parking my car at the venue! Haha.

randomman said:
I hope to God they have something else more important to see to on new year's eve otherwise just about everyone banned or warned for repeated posts on here referring to 'jobsworth' police officers will be owed a formal, written apology from the mod team.

Some hope of that.
I doubt it would be a problem. In fact I wouldn't even bother with detaching the ignition key. Drunk in Charge, means in charge of the car. It doesn't apply to opening doors, or being a passenger or whatever. Consider the majority of people don't separate their car and house keys either - so the majority of party people on a Saturday night will have car keys with them; despite a general lack of intention to use them for anything. I keep mine apart - but only because I've got an irrational dislike of dangling keys from the ignition.
Anyway you have to be doing something that constitutes being in charge of the car - which opening doors does not.
Anyway you have to be doing something that constitutes being in charge of the car - which opening doors does not.
surveyor said:
I kind of see where the OP is coming from, and where the law is coming from, but something has gone very wrong in society where the OP is concerned about unlocking his car to get a coat out.
I'm not sure if this is a statement on OP's paranoia or the state (and trust) of modern policing.
This! and what a sad state of affairs we are in.I'm not sure if this is a statement on OP's paranoia or the state (and trust) of modern policing.
No slur on the OP BTW .....
It'll be fine.
The law is there to catch people being idiots.
People drunk asleep at the wheel of a parked car who clearly drove there, but aren't actually driving when found.
Or someone who would drive drunk, but is too hammered to get the key in the ignition.
The laws aren't there to stop sensible people grabbing a coat from the car before walking home.
That said - if your drunken 'Mr Hyde' self is a bit silly, you might want to leave the starter key at home in case he thinks it's a good idea to drive.
The law is there to catch people being idiots.
People drunk asleep at the wheel of a parked car who clearly drove there, but aren't actually driving when found.
Or someone who would drive drunk, but is too hammered to get the key in the ignition.
The laws aren't there to stop sensible people grabbing a coat from the car before walking home.
That said - if your drunken 'Mr Hyde' self is a bit silly, you might want to leave the starter key at home in case he thinks it's a good idea to drive.
Futuramic said:
I doubt it would be a problem. In fact I wouldn't even bother with detaching the ignition key. Drunk in Charge, means in charge of the car. It doesn't apply to opening doors, or being a passenger or whatever. Consider the majority of people don't separate their car and house keys either - so the majority of party people on a Saturday night will have car keys with them; despite a general lack of intention to use them for anything. I keep mine apart - but only because I've got an irrational dislike of dangling keys from the ignition.
Anyway you have to be doing something that constitutes being in charge of the car - which opening doors does not.
If only!Anyway you have to be doing something that constitutes being in charge of the car - which opening doors does not.
There have been cases of responsible people getting done for drunk in charge who have merely used their keys to slip into the back seat too sleep off their drunken excesses whilst uncaring pissheads who are 2 or 3 times over the limit are driving home regardless!
PoleDriver said:
If only!
There have been cases of responsible people getting done for drunk in charge who have merely used their keys to slip into the back seat too sleep off their drunken excesses whilst uncaring pissheads who are 2 or 3 times over the limit are driving home regardless!
Really?There have been cases of responsible people getting done for drunk in charge who have merely used their keys to slip into the back seat too sleep off their drunken excesses whilst uncaring pissheads who are 2 or 3 times over the limit are driving home regardless!
I've heard stories that start like that, but then we find Mr Drunk was 'just sitting in the driving seat for a moment'.
Or we find that the although Mr Drunk is in the backseat, the car seems to have been driven some distance during the night, or is parked in a hedge.
I don't know of any genuinely innocent cases of drunk in charge being nabbed by the police.
Let alone any that made it to court.
10 Pence Short said:
A friend of mine was banned after sleeping off his night out in the back of his van. He did so quite often, and there was a proper bulkhead between the front and cargo area.
As an aside, there isn't an automatic ban for drunk in charge offences. 10pp or discretionary ban (any length).Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



.