Workmen trash plants when repairing neighbours broken fence
Discussion
Asking for a friend, yes really ! Their neighbours fence came down during the recent storms and the neighbours got someone in to replace it today. My friends OH came home at lunchtime to find that they had trampled all over a flower bed destroying the plants (mostly roses) that were growing there beforehand. To rub salt into the wound, the workmen were then verbally aggressive towards her which has only upset her more. Any suggestions as to what they can do next ? I've mentioned that garden plants are fairly resilient (the ones in our garden have survived my best attempts to trample them in the past
) but she seems to think her plants are now a lost cause 
) but she seems to think her plants are now a lost cause 
A word with the neighbours is obvious first call. Perhaps they could withold something from the bill to recompense the loss the plants. Either that or get name of the contractors, photographic evidence and small claims court. If they want to go nuclear then report it as criminal damage to the Police.
I think the important words are "got someone in to replace it(fence)". We had it a few years ago ,when one neighbour had a wooden post fail . She got someone in. Mr Cowboy. I pointed out one plant, we'd rescued from my late father's being my mother's favourite and of sentimental value. It got decimated, although it was clear of the work area. I made it pointedly obvious that he would not be allowed in my garden again,and if he did any work on the fence ,it would be from their side. Last bit of bad weather some panels came down ,and someone else got the job, along with her asking if the bloke could come in to dig out old posts. Different story- no mess , and as our two dogs don't see eye to eye, she kept hers in whilst the fence was down .
My friends arranged a time when it would be OK for the contractor to start (12 O'Clock) he turned up early, did it as fast as possible and was obviously trying to leave before they got home to find the mess he made. Was he committing trespass if he entered their property before an agreed time ?
gcollins said:
Not defending the workmen with the language, but recently having had a new fence replaced its hardly surprising that some of my plants and next doors were a little trampled shall we say.....
I know it seems "wimpish" but they are only a few plants, so I would enjoy the fixed fence and sort them out myself in the spring. Being newly planted the loss isn't going to be a mature full flowering rosebed.Neighbourly relations can turn quickly on the smallest thing, it generally find it easiest to avoid any possible antagonism.
Indeed, if it was me I would just chalk it up to experience and hope that karma evened things out at some point. I suspect my wife would take a slightly different approach with the contractor as she is always quite protective of her garden, however our 1 year old beagle/collie cross has ruined the garden anyway so it wouldn't be an issue for us 

Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



