Fire safety in retirement homes.
Discussion
Hiya fellow PHers, and Happy New Year.
I would appreciate a bit of advice from suitable experts on the above subject, if you would be so kind.
My current home is in a block of leasehold retirement flats (33 flats in the block) and this is a building constructed in 1989, and it is maintained and run by the freeholder/landlord/management company.
It has now been announced that a programme of work is to be carried out relating to fire safety, and that estimates for the work have been obtained from two contractors. The two estimates are in the range from about £38,000 to £42,000, but there is general disquiet amongst the leaseholders/residents about this level of expenditure, in relation to what might be sensibly required in order to maintain a suitable level of fire safety.
The management did produce a specification, though not a very precise one, but it appears that it has been partially left to the contractors to suggest what should be done, and to provide estimates based on their recommendations. This seems to me an odd way of going about it.
My feeling is that the managers should have produced a clear specification of what is to be done, based on the advice of an in-house expert, or an independent specialist, and it should not be left to the contractor to decide what to do. I would then expect to see two or three fixed price quotations for the carrying out of work specified by an independent specialist acting for the managers.
The other aspect of this concerns the question of what it is necessary to do in order to meet regulatory requirements. Given that the building is now about 25 years old, we are presumably obliged to continue to maintain, and periodically up-date, fire safety measures to meet current regulations, but not to meet the full standards that would be applicable to a new building being designed and constructed now. I would imagine that it is not feasible (well not at a bearable cost) for an existing building such as ours to be brought fully into line with the current new-build standards.
My conclusion, for the moment, is that what we should do is verify that our existing fire safety features are, at the very least, not inferior to those we had in 1989, and that they should be up-dated and improved as appropriate in relation to good practice for existing buildings of this type.
Of course we want a proper level of safety here, but at the moment I'm afraid we might be looking to spend a good deal of money not particularly wisely and effectively.
Your comments and advice will be much appreciated. Thanks, all.
I would appreciate a bit of advice from suitable experts on the above subject, if you would be so kind.
My current home is in a block of leasehold retirement flats (33 flats in the block) and this is a building constructed in 1989, and it is maintained and run by the freeholder/landlord/management company.
It has now been announced that a programme of work is to be carried out relating to fire safety, and that estimates for the work have been obtained from two contractors. The two estimates are in the range from about £38,000 to £42,000, but there is general disquiet amongst the leaseholders/residents about this level of expenditure, in relation to what might be sensibly required in order to maintain a suitable level of fire safety.
The management did produce a specification, though not a very precise one, but it appears that it has been partially left to the contractors to suggest what should be done, and to provide estimates based on their recommendations. This seems to me an odd way of going about it.
My feeling is that the managers should have produced a clear specification of what is to be done, based on the advice of an in-house expert, or an independent specialist, and it should not be left to the contractor to decide what to do. I would then expect to see two or three fixed price quotations for the carrying out of work specified by an independent specialist acting for the managers.
The other aspect of this concerns the question of what it is necessary to do in order to meet regulatory requirements. Given that the building is now about 25 years old, we are presumably obliged to continue to maintain, and periodically up-date, fire safety measures to meet current regulations, but not to meet the full standards that would be applicable to a new building being designed and constructed now. I would imagine that it is not feasible (well not at a bearable cost) for an existing building such as ours to be brought fully into line with the current new-build standards.
My conclusion, for the moment, is that what we should do is verify that our existing fire safety features are, at the very least, not inferior to those we had in 1989, and that they should be up-dated and improved as appropriate in relation to good practice for existing buildings of this type.
Of course we want a proper level of safety here, but at the moment I'm afraid we might be looking to spend a good deal of money not particularly wisely and effectively.
Your comments and advice will be much appreciated. Thanks, all.
I do not believe there is a mandatory requirement to improve the fire safety for an existing building unless there have been alterations or extensions to the structure..
If there are maintenance issues with the existing system then I would expect to have to repair and improve the present one , but...........
You could call the local authority building inspector and ask their advice , maybe they would even pop along and have a look.
Some authorities will do this for free, some will require a small fee.
If there are maintenance issues with the existing system then I would expect to have to repair and improve the present one , but...........
You could call the local authority building inspector and ask their advice , maybe they would even pop along and have a look.
Some authorities will do this for free, some will require a small fee.
Your local Fire Safety Officer/Fire Brigade and the local Council's Environmental Health Officer will be able to both visit and advise.
From the following link there is a telephone help line, where one can speak to trained solicitors for advice.
http://www.lease-advice.org/
Section 21 of the Landlord & Tenant Act deals with repairs etc., which states that where the total cost of a single lot of building works exceed £250 per flat******. In the case of a block of 6 flats the total cost would have to exceed £1500, then 3 contractors quotes for the works have to be put forward and approved by the majority of the leaseholders.
• ****Late last year 2012, there was Judgement in Phillips v Francis 2012 EWHC 3650 (Ch), that sent shock waves to all management companies, since the judgement in part said that £250 was for EACH leaseholder, AND for the TOTAL of each accounting year, and not for EACH building repair/works. This Judgement is now under appeal, and shortly due to be heard.
From the following link there is a telephone help line, where one can speak to trained solicitors for advice.
http://www.lease-advice.org/
Section 21 of the Landlord & Tenant Act deals with repairs etc., which states that where the total cost of a single lot of building works exceed £250 per flat******. In the case of a block of 6 flats the total cost would have to exceed £1500, then 3 contractors quotes for the works have to be put forward and approved by the majority of the leaseholders.
• ****Late last year 2012, there was Judgement in Phillips v Francis 2012 EWHC 3650 (Ch), that sent shock waves to all management companies, since the judgement in part said that £250 was for EACH leaseholder, AND for the TOTAL of each accounting year, and not for EACH building repair/works. This Judgement is now under appeal, and shortly due to be heard.
As suggested above, unless the structure of the building has been substantially modified, there is no legal reason to adhere to current building regs. We have recently upgraded all the communal lighting on one site and had to use current regs. I'm not aware of any fire related safety improvements which are mandatory but care homes might be covered under additional legislation, we manage domestic flats.
The building control officer at the local council will be very helpful, they are keen to help and like people asking questions
The building control officer at the local council will be very helpful, they are keen to help and like people asking questions

I did maintenance in high class retirement houses/flats for a couple of years.
As stated, it's all down to the fire risk assessment as to how far you go.
The standard fire exit signs, smoke detectors, break glass etc all apply but as to what else is to happen is all down to the risk assessment.
The places I looked after were remote monitored, so if the system went into alarm, the fire brigade were alerted the same instant.
This is something that is becoming more common, although I don't think that there is a specific regulation that states it must be monitored remotely (it's been a fair few years since I was involved in fire stuff)
As stated, it's all down to the fire risk assessment as to how far you go.
The standard fire exit signs, smoke detectors, break glass etc all apply but as to what else is to happen is all down to the risk assessment.
The places I looked after were remote monitored, so if the system went into alarm, the fire brigade were alerted the same instant.
This is something that is becoming more common, although I don't think that there is a specific regulation that states it must be monitored remotely (it's been a fair few years since I was involved in fire stuff)
I was advised recently that management companies should have fire risk assessments done on all common area's, if the management company has carried one out as is their duty of care I would suspect they are also have some responsibility for implementing the suggestions.
It's difficult to know whats reasonable without seeing the report and knowing what the proposed works are.
It's difficult to know whats reasonable without seeing the report and knowing what the proposed works are.
Just as some background guidance, have a look on the government website, this section covers the impacts of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order :- http://www.local.gov.uk/web/guest/publications/-/j...
As far as the specification is concerned, it's not unusual for a tender to be let for specialist work on the basis of a performance specification, leaving the specialist contractors to include the design work as part of the tender. Your landlords could appoint their own design team (with their own PI Insurance etc), but those cost would of course be passed on to the tenants as part of the project fees provided they are reasonable. Remember, it's a 33 flat development and elderly residents are quite a high risk sector so on the face of it, it sounds like a higher spec system isn't unreasonable and at just over £1,000 per flat, for a fully addressable system with redcare automatic alarm the cost isn't horrific either.
If the spec calls for 33 battery powered smoke detectors screwed to the ceiling, the cost is a little less reasonable
Good look with this one.
As far as the specification is concerned, it's not unusual for a tender to be let for specialist work on the basis of a performance specification, leaving the specialist contractors to include the design work as part of the tender. Your landlords could appoint their own design team (with their own PI Insurance etc), but those cost would of course be passed on to the tenants as part of the project fees provided they are reasonable. Remember, it's a 33 flat development and elderly residents are quite a high risk sector so on the face of it, it sounds like a higher spec system isn't unreasonable and at just over £1,000 per flat, for a fully addressable system with redcare automatic alarm the cost isn't horrific either.
If the spec calls for 33 battery powered smoke detectors screwed to the ceiling, the cost is a little less reasonable

Good look with this one.
Edited by The Surveyor on Thursday 2nd January 21:13
It's a difficult one to answer without more information. What do the works involve?
Contractor's design is common, particularly on smaller projects but it is still important the performance criteria are set out clearly. With only £4,000 difference in cost, I'm guessing they have both proposed similar solutions.
What is required legally to comply is a grey area. Busa mav is correct in saying there is no mandatory requirement, however, the building manager has to provide a facility that is safe. Unfortunately most legislation will not tell you how this is achieved and it is down to the building manager to seek suitable advice and implement any recommendations. If they had a fire risk assessment and chose to dismiss the recommendations, they would be on a very sticky wicket if there was an incident.
Contractor's design is common, particularly on smaller projects but it is still important the performance criteria are set out clearly. With only £4,000 difference in cost, I'm guessing they have both proposed similar solutions.
What is required legally to comply is a grey area. Busa mav is correct in saying there is no mandatory requirement, however, the building manager has to provide a facility that is safe. Unfortunately most legislation will not tell you how this is achieved and it is down to the building manager to seek suitable advice and implement any recommendations. If they had a fire risk assessment and chose to dismiss the recommendations, they would be on a very sticky wicket if there was an incident.
As stated the FRA should be carried out by a competent person , they will decide what is required , since 2005 the owner of the property have been required to do this.
They may have not had it done before or have a diffrent person carryout the FRA
I seen alot of this where a company doing the FRA has just taken it over and recommend additional equipment be installed even though the previous company did not
With regard to the fire alarm they would recommend a certain level of protection be fitted say L3 (exit routes and adjoining rooms)and would install a system to this specification
They may have not had it done before or have a diffrent person carryout the FRA
I seen alot of this where a company doing the FRA has just taken it over and recommend additional equipment be installed even though the previous company did not
With regard to the fire alarm they would recommend a certain level of protection be fitted say L3 (exit routes and adjoining rooms)and would install a system to this specification
Many thanks for the additional comments and information. We appear to have quite a good system already, with fire doors, clearly marked escape routes, smoke detectors, fire alarm system with repeaters in each flat etc. It's not as if we're having to start from scratch, or needing to make major improvements to a seriously deficient system.
Anyhow, things have moved on a bit since I put up the original post last Thursday. We are now going to have a meeting with the management to discuss the entire project, so I don't think it is appropriate for us as residents to start bringing in our own outside specialists at this time. This is really a matter for the management, but naturally we want to see that we are going to end up with a good system at a sensible cost.
Thanks again,
Dave.
Anyhow, things have moved on a bit since I put up the original post last Thursday. We are now going to have a meeting with the management to discuss the entire project, so I don't think it is appropriate for us as residents to start bringing in our own outside specialists at this time. This is really a matter for the management, but naturally we want to see that we are going to end up with a good system at a sensible cost.
Thanks again,
Dave.
It sounds like they are keeping you informed which is good, and hopefully they're able to come up with sensible proposal.
One word of caution on the existing system, if modifications are needed it may not be possible to a 25 year old system, meaning a new system is the only practical option.
Let us know how it goes, cheers
Paul
One word of caution on the existing system, if modifications are needed it may not be possible to a 25 year old system, meaning a new system is the only practical option.
Let us know how it goes, cheers
Paul
In regards to the fire alarm aspect itself, if its sheltered housing or a nursing home, BS5839 2013 recommends that it should be a L1 catogry, meaning automatic fire detection in every area, including each contained flat, the corridors, any voids, roof spaces etc. the cabling must be enhanced in places like this, as should the mains etc, so a full new fire alarm is much easier than adding onto existing. This should be a monitored system too, so the fire bridage / nominated person are alerted immedialty
each fire door should be at least 1 hour rated in the cases of the infirm.
this is a recommendation but its down to your risk assessment, which you have to have by law, to decide what fire safety you need, in many cases its just extinguishers.
each fire door should be at least 1 hour rated in the cases of the infirm.
this is a recommendation but its down to your risk assessment, which you have to have by law, to decide what fire safety you need, in many cases its just extinguishers.
Edited by okie592 on Monday 6th January 21:55
OK, thanks for the additional replies.
I don't have any particular expertise in this subject area, so all I can do is look at the manner in which this project is being handled, and seek to have a suitably qualified person advise us. I would then hope that we might have a better understanding of what up-dating is needed to meet current regulatory requirements for a building of this type and age, and give us a decent system based on common sense and good practice in the interests of us having a good level of protection.
I don't have any particular expertise in this subject area, so all I can do is look at the manner in which this project is being handled, and seek to have a suitably qualified person advise us. I would then hope that we might have a better understanding of what up-dating is needed to meet current regulatory requirements for a building of this type and age, and give us a decent system based on common sense and good practice in the interests of us having a good level of protection.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


