HELP with Parking Eye
Discussion
Good Morning All,
Could someone please help me with a predicament.
An ex-employee who was visiting a customer has incurred the following:

This is dated to November 2012.
It also has a time entered & departed along with a photo of the car entering & leaving (approximately 40mins).
The parking charge was £100 reduced to £60 if paid within 14 days of issue.
We then received another of the same notice asking us to pay but giving an extra 2 days to pay.
(This is all dated Nov/Dec 2012).
Employer ignored these.
Early in Dec 2013, we received a form from the court asking us to file a defence (the company is registered vehicle keeper).
As stated in the ex-employee's contract, they have to pay all speeding/parking fines.
So the form is sent to the ex-eomplyee informing him & asking him to sort it out, he then phones the court, saying he's not the registered keeper & he won't be paying, the court says it's up the registered keeper to pay (the company).
Xmas eve in Dec 2013 we received a 'notice of proposed allocation to the small claims track'
Stating that the defendent (Parking Eye) has filed a defence & that it is suitable for small claims & we have until the 2nd Jan 14 to respond, (we were closed for business Xmas eve until yesterday).
We have today received a letter from Parking Eye with 'notice to proceed'.
As well as now court papers stamped by the court, they've said they do not wish to enter into any mediation.
But want us to pa the fine + costs (£160 circa).
What is the best thing to do now?
My employer has asked me to do some research, help more than appreciated!
To start with can we get it moved closer to us?
Could someone please help me with a predicament.
An ex-employee who was visiting a customer has incurred the following:
This is dated to November 2012.
It also has a time entered & departed along with a photo of the car entering & leaving (approximately 40mins).
The parking charge was £100 reduced to £60 if paid within 14 days of issue.
We then received another of the same notice asking us to pay but giving an extra 2 days to pay.
(This is all dated Nov/Dec 2012).
Employer ignored these.
Early in Dec 2013, we received a form from the court asking us to file a defence (the company is registered vehicle keeper).
As stated in the ex-employee's contract, they have to pay all speeding/parking fines.
So the form is sent to the ex-eomplyee informing him & asking him to sort it out, he then phones the court, saying he's not the registered keeper & he won't be paying, the court says it's up the registered keeper to pay (the company).
Xmas eve in Dec 2013 we received a 'notice of proposed allocation to the small claims track'
Stating that the defendent (Parking Eye) has filed a defence & that it is suitable for small claims & we have until the 2nd Jan 14 to respond, (we were closed for business Xmas eve until yesterday).
We have today received a letter from Parking Eye with 'notice to proceed'.
As well as now court papers stamped by the court, they've said they do not wish to enter into any mediation.
But want us to pa the fine + costs (£160 circa).
What is the best thing to do now?
My employer has asked me to do some research, help more than appreciated!
To start with can we get it moved closer to us?
Edited by theguvernor on Friday 3rd January 11:50
kowalski655 said:
Why is Parking Eye the defendant? Are you suing them?. Who filed the defence? Who are the parties to the claim? PE and the employee or employer?
What happened to the original claim?
I suspect the OP's got his claimants and defendants in a tangle in his post and the ex-employee has filed a defence. What happened to the original claim?
It's a commercial decision, either pay up and go after the ex-employee pursuant to his contract or try to defend the claim on the usual grounds then go after the employee if PE win.
If you do go after the ex-employee he may have a strong argument for only paying the original fine, after all the company failed to provide his details to PE and also failed to settle before the claim was issued and court costs incurred.
Thanks for the replies so far.
I had it as defendant as PE had sent a form saying defendants claim or response or something (we hadn't responded).
Employer has had a few from PE before, ignored them & they all went away, so just did with this one.
I've since spoken with the court & have told them about us being closed over Xmas, they've given us an additional 7 days to reply & are seinding us another letter, they also confirmed we are the defendants & can apply to get the hearing listed locally, which we will be doing, we're also open to paying the original £60 just to get it out the way so will be ticking the mediation box.
Apparently it's not listed yet as PE haven't paid the fee for it to be listed.
The ex-employee is claiming he can't remember it, i guess it's our word against his in that respect!
I had it as defendant as PE had sent a form saying defendants claim or response or something (we hadn't responded).
Employer has had a few from PE before, ignored them & they all went away, so just did with this one.
I've since spoken with the court & have told them about us being closed over Xmas, they've given us an additional 7 days to reply & are seinding us another letter, they also confirmed we are the defendants & can apply to get the hearing listed locally, which we will be doing, we're also open to paying the original £60 just to get it out the way so will be ticking the mediation box.
Apparently it's not listed yet as PE haven't paid the fee for it to be listed.
The ex-employee is claiming he can't remember it, i guess it's our word against his in that respect!
AJI said:
What evidence do they have that the car registered to you was parked?
It is a contract for parking right, so they would need to prove the car was parked for the contract to become 'enforceable'?
It is a contract for parking right, so they would need to prove the car was parked for the contract to become 'enforceable'?
theguvernor said:
It also has a time entered & departed along with a photo of the car entering & leaving (approximately 40mins).
I would have thought a more solid basis for evidence would have been required for a court.
A camera capturing a car passing the entrance point to a car park area does not provide 'beyond reasonable doubt' evidence that the car used a parking bay.
But as I didn't get a law degree, is the level of 'beyond reasonable doubt' applicable to all court cases or just certain cases?
A camera capturing a car passing the entrance point to a car park area does not provide 'beyond reasonable doubt' evidence that the car used a parking bay.
But as I didn't get a law degree, is the level of 'beyond reasonable doubt' applicable to all court cases or just certain cases?
Civil cases are based on the idea that it's more likely than not (balance of probabilities).
The OPs firm should take a pragmatic decision. If the time it takes to defend the matter costs more than paying up, I'd just pay up, as you can't easily claim those costs back.
The way to have solved the problem would have been to name the driver when requested.
The OPs firm should take a pragmatic decision. If the time it takes to defend the matter costs more than paying up, I'd just pay up, as you can't easily claim those costs back.
The way to have solved the problem would have been to name the driver when requested.
Corpulent Tosser said:
Not that it helps but why did the employer not just give the name of the driver at the time, particularly if his contract stated he was responsible for such charges ?
AIUI at that time PE could not pursue the RK. Surely that is still the case. Unless the OP has his 2012 and 2013 mixed up?10 Pence Short said:
Civil cases are based on the idea that it's more likely than not (balance of probabilities).
The OPs firm should take a pragmatic decision. If the time it takes to defend the matter costs more than paying up, I'd just pay up, as you can't easily claim those costs back.
The way to have solved the problem would have been to name the driver when requested.
This.The OPs firm should take a pragmatic decision. If the time it takes to defend the matter costs more than paying up, I'd just pay up, as you can't easily claim those costs back.
The way to have solved the problem would have been to name the driver when requested.
£160? As much as I dislike these muppets I'd pay that to make it go away.
speedking31 said:
Corpulent Tosser said:
Not that it helps but why did the employer not just give the name of the driver at the time, particularly if his contract stated he was responsible for such charges ?
AIUI at that time PE could not pursue the RK. Surely that is still the case. Unless the OP has his 2012 and 2013 mixed up?Basically it's a company car, the registered keeper is the company, the sales rep had the car 24/7 until he was asked to leave the companies emplyoment, in their contract it states they have to pay all parking or speeding fines.
He was visiting a customer on the time, he was there approximately 40mins, the camera shows him entering the car park at one time & leaving 40mins later, reg clearly visible.
Approximately 4 months or so after the fine was received, sales rep was asked to leave companies employment, in Dec 13 we received the court papers, company director sent papers to ex-employee asking him to settle, ex-employeee phoned the court to ask what to do, they asked if he was the registered keeper, he said no, the company is, so it got referred back to us again.
Boss knows he may well have to pay the fine if it does go to court, but it doesn't hurt to try & get it reduced from £160 circa to £60.
However PE have said they don't want to mediate.
After speaking with ex-employee he claims to never even remember going there.
I suppose the next step is to get it transferred to our local court & see if PE follow it up, if they do, then we'll offer to pay the original £60 so it doesn't go to court.
He was visiting a customer on the time, he was there approximately 40mins, the camera shows him entering the car park at one time & leaving 40mins later, reg clearly visible.
Approximately 4 months or so after the fine was received, sales rep was asked to leave companies employment, in Dec 13 we received the court papers, company director sent papers to ex-employee asking him to settle, ex-employeee phoned the court to ask what to do, they asked if he was the registered keeper, he said no, the company is, so it got referred back to us again.
Boss knows he may well have to pay the fine if it does go to court, but it doesn't hurt to try & get it reduced from £160 circa to £60.
However PE have said they don't want to mediate.
After speaking with ex-employee he claims to never even remember going there.
I suppose the next step is to get it transferred to our local court & see if PE follow it up, if they do, then we'll offer to pay the original £60 so it doesn't go to court.
If you want the problem to go away quickly I suggest you offer them the £60 plus the court costs they have so far paid.
It seems to me this could all have easily been avoided if you paid the £60 in Dec 2012 and then obtained reimbursement from the employee. You appear to have failed to follow your own procedure.
It seems to me this could all have easily been avoided if you paid the £60 in Dec 2012 and then obtained reimbursement from the employee. You appear to have failed to follow your own procedure.
It is often suggested that you could write to the land owner to cancel the ticket. Explain the situation in kind terms and ask for the generosity of the land owner to see if he could get the ticket cancelled. After all, I think I'm correct in saying the land owner is the employer of the PPC.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


