Part time trader, selling wife's car, SOGA apply?
Part time trader, selling wife's car, SOGA apply?
Author
Discussion

Spangles

Original Poster:

1,441 posts

216 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Hello,

My day job is nothing to do with cars, evenings and weekends though I fix them and sell 1 or 2 a year. The car side is all legit and above board, tax paid, road risks and liability insurance, website, separate ebay business account for selling cars and other car related stuff. The few cars I have sold I've been quite prepared to cover for any problems under the SOGA although thankfully I've never had to.

I want to sell the wife's car although it is registered in my name. However it's a 7yr old Renault diesel approaching 100k miles and whilst I don't know of any problems with it I wouldn't be at all surprised if it exploded into a million pieces tomorrow.

Given my situation is the SOGA always going to apply to any car I sell, even our own private ones? Or should I avoid the problem and put it straight into auction?



Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
RK does not mean ownership. As it's her car why not get your wife to sell it herself? Problem solved.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
SOGA applies to every sale of every car in England and Wales. This point is widely misunderstood.

The implied term as to quality does not apply to a sale made other than in the course of a business.

As your business is selling cars, you should ask your wife to sell her own car. If you sell it on her behalf, be sure not to claim expenses against your business or put the money through your books. You may still appear to the outside world to be trying a dodgy fake private sale, and so may get hassle anyway.

The effect of the implied term as to quality is moderated by the age of the car and known defects identified pre sale. An old and well used car is not expected to be as good as a new or nearly new one.

This car is, I infer, worth Jack. Auction it.




Edited by anonymous-user on Friday 3rd January 21:37

Spangles

Original Poster:

1,441 posts

216 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies.

I think on balance the auction is probably safer. Whilst it seems legal opinion is on my side BV makes the very good point that Mr Buyer could still make my life awkward.


SpeckledJim

34,611 posts

284 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
If you've had the car for a reasonable amount of time, and you're genuinely selling it privately, surely that's reasonable?

If I run a furniture showroom, that doesn't preclude me from flogging my pouffe (!) on gumtree...

av185

20,464 posts

158 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
If you've had the car for a reasonable amount of time, and you're genuinely selling it privately, surely that's reasonable?

If I run a furniture showroom, that doesn't preclude me from flogging my pouffe (!) on gumtree...
But the OP is a trader and even though the car is his wifes, it is registered to him and any car he sells will be in the course of his trade and be subject to SOGA conditions......yes

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
No, he can still make a sale on behalf of his wife outside the business, but he may get grief as no one will believe him. RK is not always owner, as any fule kno.

SpeckledJim

34,611 posts

284 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
av185 said:
SpeckledJim said:
If you've had the car for a reasonable amount of time, and you're genuinely selling it privately, surely that's reasonable?

If I run a furniture showroom, that doesn't preclude me from flogging my pouffe (!) on gumtree...
But the OP is a trader and even though the car is his wifes, it is registered to him and any car he sells will be in the course of his trade and be subject to SOGA conditions......yes
His commercial obligations only extend to his trading activities. Those undertaken specifically for profit.

This car wasn't bought, and isn't being sold, with a view to profit. And that's incidental to whether any profit is actually made.

It is a personal, private possession, and as such lies outside the course of his trade.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Spot on.

tbc

3,017 posts

206 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Selling 2 cars a year is hardly considered trading.

And I certainly wouldn't be registering for tax unless i was doing 10 cars plus a year

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
There is no magic number. You can be in business from the first sale. If you set out to make a profit, and aim to carry on the activity on a recurring basis, you are in business. Here's an extract from an opinion wot I wrote not long ago (it was not about SOGA):-

There is no single definition of "business". In IRC v Marine Steam Turbine [1920] KB 193, the Court took the view that the word “business” was used in the sense of “an active occupation or profession continuously carried on”. See also Customs and Excise Commissioners v Lord Fisher [1981] STC 236 and Sassi v HMRC [2009] UKFTT 280 (TC).

In Scarth v Amin [2008] EWHC 2886] QB , the Court said of “business” at 36-37:-

"We note that the word “business” can have a broad meaning. The Oxford English Dictionary gives the following meanings:

“III 11.a … a person's official duty …; function occupation… 12.a A person's official or professional duties as a whole; stated occupation, profession, or trade…”

37 There are the following definitions given in other legal contexts:

i) “Business” is a wider term than “trade”, and not synonymous with it, and means almost anything which is an occupation as distinguished from a pleasure. However the term must be construed according to its context: 47 Halsbury's Laws: 4th Ed [2001 Edition] para 6. See Rolls v Miller [1884] 27 Ch D 71 (“The word [“business”] means almost anything which is an occupation as distinguished from a pleasure - anything which is an occupation or duty which requires attention is a business” per Lindley, LJ).

ii) In the Sale of Goods Act 1979 “business” is defined as including the activities of any government department or local or public authority: section 61 (1). A similar definition appears in section 14 of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 .

iii) Under the Landlord & Tenant Act 1954 section 23 (2) “business” includes a trade, profession or employment, and includes any activity carried on by a body of persons whether corporate or incorporate. Whether an activity which is carried on by an individual tenant is a trade profession or employment so as to attract the statutory protection is a question of degree to be decided in the light of all the circumstances existing: Halsbury's Laws 4th Ed [Reissue] Vol 27 (1) para 565."


In other words, as lawyers are annoyingly wont to say: "it depends".

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
A mate of mine was contacted by the DVLA after buying and selling 6 cars in 9 months, asking him if he was a trader. He wrote back explaining that he was not, and he had lost money, due to serious poor "luck", and too much optimism.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Making a profit is not the test. Did your friend buy and sell with a view to profit?

I bought two cars last year and sold three different ones, but that doesn't make me a trader.

Spangles

Original Poster:

1,441 posts

216 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Our name is very rare, 2 seconds googling will link my motor trade activities. Not that I want to hide it anyway, I just wouldn't be trying to sell this particular model of car through the business, it's a bit flakey. I only bought it 'cos it was flipping cheap and so far it's been faultless, it can't last though.

Anyhoo WBAC are offering twice what I paid for it 2 years ago so hopefully they won't knock me down too far.

tbc

3,017 posts

206 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Say you have a large collection of cars for your pleasure and happen to sell a few of them for profit.

Does the man with the bowler hat and braces really need to know

TVR1

5,489 posts

256 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
tbc said:
Say you have a large collection of cars for your pleasure and happen to sell a few of them for profit.

Does the man with the bowler hat and braces really need to know
None of his business. Liquidating personal assets is quite legitimate.

In addition, don't forget that cars and many other items, including watches, are considered 'chattels' as far as HMRC are concerned. i.e they always depreciate. As they always depreciate, no CGT is due. why do you think those with excess cash choose to purchase such items?

Edited by TVR1 on Saturday 4th January 18:46