Are the police ever wrong?
Author
Discussion

ArmaghMan

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

211 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Simple question, particularly for serving officers, but obviously open to all.

Has any police force ever come out publicly and apologised for a major mistake before it officially had to?

I'm thinking of Hillsborough, the six, the four, the newspaper vendor Ian Tomlinson, Stephen Lawrence, and a multitude of others.
Seems to me that the reaction is to always close ranks ?

silverback mike

11,293 posts

284 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
I have just retired from the police and yes I have been wrong on times and quite happy to say so! Mind you I wasn't ACPO rank .......

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
I don't see the usual suspects on here jumping to take the opportunity to say the police are ever wrong, ever!!!

Edited by pcvdriver on Saturday 4th January 16:43

Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
The police are never wrong. Ever. Better? ;-)

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Mk3Spitfire said:
The police are never wrong. Ever. Better? ;-)
Tongue firmly in cheek then....or have you just been fraped by Snowy, Singlecoil or Derek?





Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
pcvdriver said:
Tongue firmly in cheek then....or have you just been fraped by Snowy, Singlecoil or Derek?
Ha! It's ok, changed my password now. In their defence, it's refreshing to see supporters/sympathisers rather than constant abuse and criticisms.

Bigends

6,196 posts

159 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
pcvdriver said:
pcvdriver said:
I don't see the usual suspects on here jumping to take the opportunity to say the po9lice are ever wrong, ever!!!
Tongue firmly in cheek then....or have you just been fraped by Snowy, Singlecoil or Derek?
I always persoannly apologised if I made cockups and still do. As an organisation the Police tend to be a bit slow - whether for legal reasons or not I dont know

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
The media professionals have developed a simple manta for evading trouble. Never admit anything, never, ever apologise, never accept responsibility for anything, never accept responsibility for any wrongdoing whatsoever. The Police are just one of the organisations that have adopted that mantra. Politics is perhaps the foremost adoptee. Is it naive to expect a society wedded to the culture of wealth and celebrity as the ultimate accolade to produce anything else? Sadly our leaders are not interested in the truth or fairness. Just in being at the top. I am not defending this. I am just recognising what it is. The modern approach to telling the truth. Not under any circumstances.

Edited by Steffan on Saturday 4th January 16:48

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Of course they get things wrong.

They are unlikely as an organisation to just immediately come out & say they are in relation to a specific case (but that's no different to other organisations) due to any potential litigation etc.

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
The truth will always (well mostly always) eventually come out, making litigation even more expensive if it comes out years later.

Worse still is the damage it does to public perception to individuals/organisations concerned.

What is spectacularly missing in today's society is the willingness of said individuals to act with honour in the first place, without the necessity of prompting by external forces to do the right thing - even if it means the loss of a career, and pension/other benefits.

Edited by pcvdriver on Saturday 4th January 17:05

ED209

6,027 posts

275 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
e very human being makes a mistake, it would be unnatural if they didn't. If i mess something up I am happy to admit it. There is noting at all wrong with making a mistake if you are trying to do the right thing.

Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
ED209 said:
There is noting at all wrong with making a mistake if you are trying to do the right thing.
And as long as you learn from it. It's the covering up of mistakes that gets you in the shed.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
pcvdriver said:
The truth will always (well mostly always) eventually come out, making litigation even more expensive if it comes out years later.
As an organisation they are unlikely to know the full truth until a relatively lengthy time after the event. They are not likely to want to confess to wrong doing until they know the full facts & the extent of wrong doing.


pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
As an organisation they are unlikely to know the full truth until a relatively lengthy time after the event. They are not likely to want to confess to wrong doing until they know the full facts & the extent of wrong doing.
An individual will know more or less straight away if they have erred, for want of a more suitable phrase. It is then down to the conscience of said individual to be honest enough to have the integrity to do the right thing immediately, Cover-ups are only possible with collusion of people with no backbone, who will say/do anything to remain undiscovered.

An individual should always protect the good name of their organisation by publically announcing the error of their ways at the earliest opportunity instead of remaining silent, in the hope that things will just blow over and never be noticed.

Edited by pcvdriver on Saturday 4th January 18:08

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
ArmaghMan said:
Simple question, particularly for serving officers, but obviously open to all.

Has any police force ever come out publicly and apologised for a major mistake before it officially had to?

I'm thinking of Hillsborough, the six, the four, the newspaper vendor Ian Tomlinson, Stephen Lawrence, and a multitude of others.
Seems to me that the reaction is to always close ranks ?
Have you ever apologised for being at fault, to any extent, for a managerial at a road traffic accident? The advice used to be not to do so. The reason is obvious.

If the police have done something wrong then by apologising early on can make any payout higher and also limits the defence. With the suggestion on here that the service should husband its funds, then that must have full support.

You say have to, and by that I assume you mean after any court case has been settled. That's the first opportunity the police have, in practice, to apologise without increasing costs.

The police generally cooperate and allow full access to files, such as serials, statements, etc. I have been criticised as something I had put on a serial when running a major incident, a contract murder, which was found to be spot on, as it gave the other side massive leverage in their case against the police. It was all rubbish but, because of one entry on a contemporaneous report/serial, the defence went for that.

You quote Stephen Lawrence: in what way were the police culpable?

You suggest Hilsboro: can I ask the same question?

The odd thing is that the police cannot say that they ran an incident well, either. A chief constable got sacked for doing so. Or rather, that was the excuse. What in was in fact was the the first CC to be relieved of his post for political reasons, by the worst Home Secretary this country has had at least since 1975.

The police have to follow the instructions of their lawyers.

I used to apologise in certain circumstances. I would say/write something like:

I am sorry that our performance was not what you expected . . .

Oddly enough that tended to end the criticism/complaint despite following it with an explanation as to why they were talking rubbish.

I spoke with a crew member of the second vehicle to turn up to the Lawrence scene. He was of the opinion that they made a number of mistakes, some, or at least one, which to him, and me, was inexcusable, yet this was not mentioned in the enquiry despite it being, to the PC, obvious. Further, one WPC was criticised by name in the report, despite not being required to give evidence, yet she did nothing, absolutely nothing, wrong. She was of the opinion that that was why she was not allowed to give her evidence.

The police accepted the criticism, apologised to the woman as it was outrageous, but, as she was told, there was no way the police could criticise the report. Even so, it effected her career.

Some poster suggested that the truth will out: that is farcical, and the exact opposite of what happens. The media does not even report what the enquiries say, and the enquiries are, in my experience, rubbish in many cases. Or rather the cases that I have information on.

The shooting of the naked man in Hastings: think you know what happened there? You don't. The police could put facts out but they don't, they accept what the judges say.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
silverback mike said:
I have just retired from the police and yes I have been wrong on times and quite happy to say so! Mind you I wasn't ACPO rank .......
Long time no see here. Enjoy your retirement.

Streaky

Matt 211988

223 posts

155 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
whats the score with police being wrong on minor incidents?

I was pulled over and the officer informed me that my vehicle was too low. I did not have enough room in the archs for my tyres to fit and it would easily bottom out if I hit a bump (my car had been like this for over a year and was never a problem, even on big impacts), he also said my tyres would be rubbing on the inside of my archs and eventually pop (which they weren't because i rolled the archs to make sure they didnt rub)

I just let him get on with his blabbing even though I knew he was wrong, I see it as if I tell him he is wrong, he will take offence to it and think I am being a cheeky tt and keep me there for longer and go over my car with a fine tooth comb

is this the best course of action or should I point out the error in his ways?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Of course the police get things wrong.
But, from a professional standpoint they will not officially announce any sort of apology until all the facts are in and any sort of trial or judgement is completed.

An individual cop may apologise off the cuff for something I guess.
If they stood on your foot or something trivial.

It's no different to any large professional group or body.
McDinalds never apologise for burning people.
Tesco never apologise for horse burgers.

They say, "it's an unfortunate incident, out thoughts are with the families"
In the background the lawyers are shouting "make no official statement of guilt".

We live in a compensation culture.
It's horrible; it turns even the decent people of the world into 'no comment' drones.

Then it depends what the apology is for.
Was it a genuine mistake, was it corruption or malice, were correct guidelines followed.

Some people just want to be given stones to throw at 'the man', they like seeing the police cast down into the pit.
Others have a genuine curiosity over what happened.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
pcvdriver said:
vonhosen said:
As an organisation they are unlikely to know the full truth until a relatively lengthy time after the event. They are not likely to want to confess to wrong doing until they know the full facts & the extent of wrong doing.
An individual will know more or less straight away if they have erred, for want of a more suitable phrase. It is then down to the conscience of said individual to be honest enough to have the integrity to do the right thing immediately, Cover-ups are only possible with collusion of people with no backbone, who will say/do anything to remain undiscovered.

An individual should always protect the good name of their organisation by publically announcing the error of their ways at the earliuest opportunity instead of remaining silent, in the hope that things will just blow over and never be noticed.
Yes an individual will tend to know whether they have erred more or less straight away.

Whether an individual will put the good name of an organisation before their own interests will depend on the individual. A large part of that will depend on factors such as how they are treated/ or feel valued by the organisation on a day to day basis & how they are likely to be treated after admitting to doing something wrong.

That doesn't alter the fact that a publicly funded body (which will have to fund litigation defence from these funds) will have to be mindful of how any public admissions will impact on potential payments from those funds & the knock on effects to future service availability. On a large scale this is all likely to lead to a culture of being relatively guarded until all the facts are known & potential consequences considered.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
A major incident will really need a bit of precision to show which parts of it were wrong and need apologising for. This will often come from an external source who will publish some form of report etc. I wouldn't expect any organisation that's potential major wrong-doing is subject to statutory / external bodies to apologise until that body has concluded its investigation.