Worth contacting the council?
Discussion
Just had an interesting journey home, I left my house through single track lanes no problems on the way there, came back through same lane an hour later, rounded a blind bend up a small hill, and came face to face with a very large rock on the road, choice of roll car down the bank on the left or hit rock. So I hit the rock and thought "this might hurt" well what I wasn't expecting was a very loud bang, a flash of fire, I can't hear anything but ringing and somewhat dazed, silly as it sounds I thought I had shoved the engine through into the cabin (fire loud bang and something odd just appearing in the car) and I could no longer here the engine running.
I now have a car that looks like this inside

And now my alternator light is flashing, so something is bent or dislodged.
Gone from a car I was going to put up for sale to near worthless now as I can't sell it needing a new alternator, potentially bent lower arm(s) and a ruined interior.
I now have a car that looks like this inside

And now my alternator light is flashing, so something is bent or dislodged.
Gone from a car I was going to put up for sale to near worthless now as I can't sell it needing a new alternator, potentially bent lower arm(s) and a ruined interior.
You came round a blind corner too quick to stop. To find a rock that had not been there an hour ago. Just what are you expecting the council to do, patrol the roads at 20 minute intervals to clear them of any obstacles?. Consider yourself lucky, could have been far worse, maybe cyclist, pedestrian, horse or who knows.
Well should contact the Council or indeed Police to get the rock removed, but no point contacting Council in hope they will pay the bill because they can't have known the rock was there, so no responsibility to remove it unless you can prove they knew it was liable to fall on road and did nothing about it.
Shelsleyf2 said:
You came round a blind corner too quick to stop. To find a rock that had not been there an hour ago. Just what are you expecting the council to do, patrol the roads at 20 minute intervals to clear them of any obstacles?. Consider yourself lucky, could have been far worse, maybe cyclist, pedestrian, horse or who knows.
Que? Are you suggesting that I should drive at 5mph instead of the 20mph I was doing through? I would have liked to you know get up the actual hill.Chrisgr31 said:
Well should contact the Council or indeed Police to get the rock removed, but no point contacting Council in hope they will pay the bill because they can't have known the rock was there, so no responsibility to remove it unless you can prove they knew it was liable to fall on road and did nothing about it.
I've removed the rock to stop anyone else hitting it. My issue is this, they are not maintaining any roads around here at all, potholes at least a billion feet deep, there was 4 accidents recently because they haven't gritted the roads at all.There just seems to be no duty of care on any roads here, let alone the back lanes, there is one that is close to slipping away.
Annoying to say the least.
http://abbiss.co.nz/index.php?option=com_content&a...
In the OP's defence someone I know warned a 'professional driver' a few weeks ago that they'd not get through a narrow lane due to bits of fallen masonry in the road. The driver ignored the advice and then was seen reversing back out of the lane they'd been told that they'd not get along 5-10 minutes later.
Like the OP I've moved bits from the road and moved discarded, left cones to try to warn others.
You could just contact the council without asking PHers for their opinion.
In the OP's defence someone I know warned a 'professional driver' a few weeks ago that they'd not get through a narrow lane due to bits of fallen masonry in the road. The driver ignored the advice and then was seen reversing back out of the lane they'd been told that they'd not get along 5-10 minutes later.
Like the OP I've moved bits from the road and moved discarded, left cones to try to warn others.
You could just contact the council without asking PHers for their opinion.
Edited by carinaman on Monday 6th January 23:18
pits said:
Que? Are you suggesting that I should drive at 5mph instead of the 20mph I was doing through? I would have liked to you know get up the actual hill.
Sorry for your loss.However, if 20mph is a speed from which you can't stop in the distance you can see then, yes, 20mph is too fast
You hit something you couldn't stop in time to avoid: QED.Blue Oval84 said:
I'm sorry but anyone here who says that they can absolutely always stop in the distance they can see to be clear and would never be caught out by finding a rock dumped in their path on a blind bend is probably a liar.
(Or they drive really, really, really slowly)
I wouldn't lie about it. There's a very good chance many of us could have hit the same rock. But I wouldn't come onto PH complaining about how unfair it was or wondering if the council could "do anything about it".(Or they drive really, really, really slowly)
Bear in mind, however, that I learned to drive (ah-hem, spiritedly) in the Lake District on narrow lanes; I've just been back there for the festive period, and enjoyed the roads thoroughly. I encountered lots of pockets of flood water, fallen branches, stopped cars, and all manner of other hazards, whilst miraculously (...) making far better progress than others. I didn't hit any of them, however; had I done so, I'd have blamed myself, not the council...
Blue Oval84 said:
I'm sorry but anyone here who says that they can absolutely always stop in the distance they can see to be clear and would never be caught out by finding a rock dumped in their path on a blind bend is probably a liar.
(Or they drive really, really, really slowly)
They might reasonably claim that they should be able to stop in the distance they can say to be clear, even if they are human and make mistakes:(Or they drive really, really, really slowly)
Highway code rule : 126
"Stopping Distances. Drive at a speed that will allow you to stop well within the distance you can see to be clear."
I'm sure I've made mistakes in the past too, but I don't say this isn't the rule I should be following.
OneJag
OneJag said:
They might reasonably claim that they should be able to stop in the distance they can say to be clear, even if they are human and make mistakes:
Highway code rule : 126
"Stopping Distances. Drive at a speed that will allow you to stop well within the distance you can see to be clear."
I'm sure I've made mistakes in the past too, but I don't say this isn't the rule I should be following.
OneJag
We should all follow that rule I agree, but I'll be the first to admit I don't always drive at that sort of speed when going round a blind bend, so I certainly wouldn't castigate anyone on here who made the same mistake.Highway code rule : 126
"Stopping Distances. Drive at a speed that will allow you to stop well within the distance you can see to be clear."
I'm sure I've made mistakes in the past too, but I don't say this isn't the rule I should be following.
OneJag
The Tunstall Hope Road in Sunderland is a good example of such a road (40mph limit, previously NSL, lots of tight corners) I've followed many people who are slow, but I don't think any of them have ever been slow enough that they could have stopped in time if they'd encountered a rock in the road on one of the corners.
That's why I find it hard to believe that anyone who throws these stones isn't in fact sat within a greenhouse.
Blue Oval84 said:
That's why I find it hard to believe that anyone who throws these stones isn't in fact sat within a greenhouse.
I'm in the greenhouse; you're welcome to share my box of rocks, as is the OP. I believe you may have missed the point of all of this, however: it isn't whether the OP should have been able to stop; it is whether the OP ought to have suggested that somebody else might be to blame.Blue Oval84 said:
We should all follow that rule I agree, but I'll be the first to admit I don't always drive at that sort of speed when going round a blind bend, so I certainly wouldn't castigate anyone on here who made the same mistake.
The Tunstall Hope Road in Sunderland is a good example of such a road (40mph limit, previously NSL, lots of tight corners) I've followed many people who are slow, but I don't think any of them have ever been slow enough that they could have stopped in time if they'd encountered a rock in the road on one of the corners.
That's why I find it hard to believe that anyone who throws these stones isn't in fact sat within a greenhouse.
The point about it being a mistake is still that you shouldn't do it, not that everyone is guilty and therefore there is no blame (comparatively)!The Tunstall Hope Road in Sunderland is a good example of such a road (40mph limit, previously NSL, lots of tight corners) I've followed many people who are slow, but I don't think any of them have ever been slow enough that they could have stopped in time if they'd encountered a rock in the road on one of the corners.
That's why I find it hard to believe that anyone who throws these stones isn't in fact sat within a greenhouse.
OneJag
Blue Oval84 said:
We should all follow that rule I agree, but I'll be the first to admit I don't always drive at that sort of speed when going round a blind bend, so I certainly wouldn't castigate anyone on here who made the same mistake.
The Tunstall Hope Road in Sunderland is a good example of such a road (40mph limit, previously NSL, lots of tight corners) I've followed many people who are slow, but I don't think any of them have ever been slow enough that they could have stopped in time if they'd encountered a rock in the road on one of the corners.
That's why I find it hard to believe that anyone who throws these stones isn't in fact sat within a greenhouse.
What if the "rock" was an oncoming car? This is far from an uncommon occurrence in my experience of single track roads. Strangely I have yet to hit an oncoming car, or a horse, or a tree, all of which I have found unexpectedly around blind corners on single track roads. Harsh braking is required on occasion, but if it's that tight and blind then sub-20 seems to be warranted.The Tunstall Hope Road in Sunderland is a good example of such a road (40mph limit, previously NSL, lots of tight corners) I've followed many people who are slow, but I don't think any of them have ever been slow enough that they could have stopped in time if they'd encountered a rock in the road on one of the corners.
That's why I find it hard to believe that anyone who throws these stones isn't in fact sat within a greenhouse.
No wonder there are so many accidents on rural single carriageways if people just bomb it round corners hoping the way is clear, especially given the recent weather makes obstructions much more likely.
pits said:
Shelsleyf2 said:
You came round a blind corner too quick to stop. To find a rock that had not been there an hour ago. Just what are you expecting the council to do, patrol the roads at 20 minute intervals to clear them of any obstacles?. Consider yourself lucky, could have been far worse, maybe cyclist, pedestrian, horse or who knows.
Que? Are you suggesting that I should drive at 5mph instead of the 20mph I was doing through? I would have liked to you know get up the actual hill.Chrisgr31 said:
Well should contact the Council or indeed Police to get the rock removed, but no point contacting Council in hope they will pay the bill because they can't have known the rock was there, so no responsibility to remove it unless you can prove they knew it was liable to fall on road and did nothing about it.
I've removed the rock to stop anyone else hitting it. My issue is this, they are not maintaining any roads around here at all, potholes at least a billion feet deep, there was 4 accidents recently because they haven't gritted the roads at all.There just seems to be no duty of care on any roads here, let alone the back lanes, there is one that is close to slipping away.
Annoying to say the least.
Streaky
Flibble said:
What if the "rock" was an oncoming car? This is far from an uncommon occurrence in my experience of single track roads. Strangely I have yet to hit an oncoming car, or a horse, or a tree, all of which I have found unexpectedly around blind corners on single track roads. Harsh braking is required on occasion, but if it's that tight and blind then sub-20 seems to be warranted.
On a single track road then clearly it is far, far more likely that you will find a car heading straight for you so I'd suggest driving more for the conditions. I wasn't discussing single track roads though.And, I've just re-read the OP and realised that he is actually discussing single-track which makes your points much more relevant than I first thought. I'll just shut up now.

If you went round a corner to find an object in the road and despite braking to the best of your ability you still hit said object with enough speed to deploy front, side and curtain airbags in your car then you were certainly driving too fast. The fact that other roads in the area have potholes does not alter this fact.
ked.
pits said:
Are you suggesting that I should drive at 5mph instead of the 20mph I was doing through? I would have liked to you know get up the actual hill.
At 5mph you are still moving so you would have eventually got up the hill the only difference being that you car would not be f
ked.Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


