Who Polices Licences? 45 points & still driving!
Discussion
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-25626147
A driver in Merseyside has 45 points on his licence and is still driving.
Who is responsible for ensuring that drivers who accrue more than 12 points are banned?
Twice I have had my licence revoked by DVLA because of a admin cock up on their part, and yet many drivers seem to be "getting away with it".
I am sure if I ran my business in the same manner as the DVLA run theirs, my customers would go elsewhere!!
While the court should be able to use discretion, this appears to be going too far!
A driver in Merseyside has 45 points on his licence and is still driving.
Who is responsible for ensuring that drivers who accrue more than 12 points are banned?
Twice I have had my licence revoked by DVLA because of a admin cock up on their part, and yet many drivers seem to be "getting away with it".
I am sure if I ran my business in the same manner as the DVLA run theirs, my customers would go elsewhere!!
BBC News said:
Liverpool man with 45 points among 7,300 avoiding bans
All points were accrued from 2011 to December 2013, the IAM said.
Almost 7,300 motorists with 12 points or more on their licences have not been banned from driving, the Institute of Advanced Motorists (IAM) has claimed.
Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA) latest figures show a man from Liverpool is driving with 45 penalty points on his licence, the IAM said.
Drivers are fined and face a temporary ban if they accumulate 12 points on their licence over a three-year period.
In exceptional cases, magistrates can use their discretion to avoid bans.
The motorist from Liverpool had committed speeding offences and failed to declare the name of the driver of the vehicle, the IAM said.
'Exceptional hardship'
A man from Warrington has the second highest number of points at 36 for driving without insurance.
Other drivers who avoided bans include:
A woman from Lincoln who has 34 points for failing to declare the driver of the vehicle and speeding
A woman from Hull who has 31 points for failing to declare the driver of the vehicle and speeding
Five men from Westcliff-on-Sea, Colchester, Brighouse, Doncaster and Dagenham have 30 points for offences including speeding and failing to declare the driver of the vehicle
All points were accrued from 2011 to December 2013.
A total of 7,293 motorists had 12 points or more on their licences, the IAM said.
Simon Best, its chief executive, said: "DVLA must rapidly overhaul their systems and working relationships with the courts to ensure that the whole principle of 12 points and you are off the road is not undermined.
"Any suggestion that some drivers may be able to speed with impunity and then talk themselves out of a ban puts our whole approach to enforcement into question."
The HM Courts and Tribunals Service said the "vast majority" of drivers were disqualified if penalty points reach or exceed 12.
A spokeswoman said: "Magistrates can use their discretion to not enforce a driving ban if doing so would cause exceptional hardship, such as losing a job or the ability to care for a dependent. A fine will still be enforced."
A DVLA spokesman said: "DVLA's role is to record the information provided by the courts.
"The courts are able to use their discretion to decide whether or not to disqualify a driver."
It seems to me that the courts are in some cases making a mockery of the law.All points were accrued from 2011 to December 2013, the IAM said.
Almost 7,300 motorists with 12 points or more on their licences have not been banned from driving, the Institute of Advanced Motorists (IAM) has claimed.
Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA) latest figures show a man from Liverpool is driving with 45 penalty points on his licence, the IAM said.
Drivers are fined and face a temporary ban if they accumulate 12 points on their licence over a three-year period.
In exceptional cases, magistrates can use their discretion to avoid bans.
The motorist from Liverpool had committed speeding offences and failed to declare the name of the driver of the vehicle, the IAM said.
'Exceptional hardship'
A man from Warrington has the second highest number of points at 36 for driving without insurance.
Other drivers who avoided bans include:
A woman from Lincoln who has 34 points for failing to declare the driver of the vehicle and speeding
A woman from Hull who has 31 points for failing to declare the driver of the vehicle and speeding
Five men from Westcliff-on-Sea, Colchester, Brighouse, Doncaster and Dagenham have 30 points for offences including speeding and failing to declare the driver of the vehicle
All points were accrued from 2011 to December 2013.
A total of 7,293 motorists had 12 points or more on their licences, the IAM said.
Simon Best, its chief executive, said: "DVLA must rapidly overhaul their systems and working relationships with the courts to ensure that the whole principle of 12 points and you are off the road is not undermined.
"Any suggestion that some drivers may be able to speed with impunity and then talk themselves out of a ban puts our whole approach to enforcement into question."
The HM Courts and Tribunals Service said the "vast majority" of drivers were disqualified if penalty points reach or exceed 12.
A spokeswoman said: "Magistrates can use their discretion to not enforce a driving ban if doing so would cause exceptional hardship, such as losing a job or the ability to care for a dependent. A fine will still be enforced."
A DVLA spokesman said: "DVLA's role is to record the information provided by the courts.
"The courts are able to use their discretion to decide whether or not to disqualify a driver."
While the court should be able to use discretion, this appears to be going too far!
Edited by Mill Wheel on Tuesday 7th January 08:01
Edited by Mill Wheel on Tuesday 7th January 08:02
You can get more than 12 points on your license and still keep it. 12 points seems to be the point at which you go to court and have to convince them not to take it off you. I worked for a guy who had 15 points but he was the MD of a company and managed to talk his way out of a ban in court. he said that he needed to drive for work and if he couldn't, he'd have to lay people off, etc. 45 points is taking the pee a bit though!!
I was lucky when I was young. I had 3 points then got done 3 times on the same day by the same hidden scamera van. This took the tally up to 12 so I had to go to court where I managed to keep my license. I was lucky as one of the speeding offences was just over the threshold and I was told they could have issued more than 3 for that. You live and learn.
I was lucky when I was young. I had 3 points then got done 3 times on the same day by the same hidden scamera van. This took the tally up to 12 so I had to go to court where I managed to keep my license. I was lucky as one of the speeding offences was just over the threshold and I was told they could have issued more than 3 for that. You live and learn.
The chap from Warrington with 36 points accrued them in under 2 weeks, being caught without insurance 6 times apparently!
Assuming his car was seized each time, and he has recovered it from the Police/recovery depot, that is an expensive alternative to insuring it in the first place.
Assuming his car was seized each time, and he has recovered it from the Police/recovery depot, that is an expensive alternative to insuring it in the first place.
The courts can choose not to impose a ban if they think it would cause exceptional hardship, but they must ignore any circumstances which have already been used to avoid a totting ban in the last 3 years. So while in theory there's no limit to the number of times you can avoid a ban, in practice you'd have to have a lot of very unusual circumstances to do it more than once or twice and to rack up more than 15 or so points and keep your licence. And contrary to popular opinion, magistrates tend not to be completely stupid...
So I suspect that most of these cases are either (a) admin/IT cock-ups where the court hasn't been aware of the diver's history or (b) someone who commits a lot of offences in a short time period and has them all dealt with in a single court hearing, so only has to make a single hardship plea.
An example of (b) would be a case I read about on a solicitor's blog of an HGV driver who failed to notice a temporary speed limit on a road he obviously drove a lot, and by the time the first NIP arrived he'd already been caught 9 times by the same set of average speed cameras. Is that ban-worthy? The magistrates obviously thought not, and let him keep driving despite his 27 points. Another hypothetical example would be a person who gets home from several months abroad and finds that the person he left the car with has been driving like a knob, that there are 5 unopened NIPs on the doormat and that the deadline for replying to them has already passed... But of course, the full details of cases like that wouldn't make as good a headline as "driver with a squillion points keeps licence"
So I suspect that most of these cases are either (a) admin/IT cock-ups where the court hasn't been aware of the diver's history or (b) someone who commits a lot of offences in a short time period and has them all dealt with in a single court hearing, so only has to make a single hardship plea.
An example of (b) would be a case I read about on a solicitor's blog of an HGV driver who failed to notice a temporary speed limit on a road he obviously drove a lot, and by the time the first NIP arrived he'd already been caught 9 times by the same set of average speed cameras. Is that ban-worthy? The magistrates obviously thought not, and let him keep driving despite his 27 points. Another hypothetical example would be a person who gets home from several months abroad and finds that the person he left the car with has been driving like a knob, that there are 5 unopened NIPs on the doormat and that the deadline for replying to them has already passed... But of course, the full details of cases like that wouldn't make as good a headline as "driver with a squillion points keeps licence"
7,293 such motorists out of - what? - 30 million UK driving licence holders, a rate of around 0.024% from scribbling on the back of a fag packet, indicates that the 'system' is probably working reasonably well.
Linked item is typical BBC "OMG! never let the facts get in the way of a non-story" rubbish
.
Linked item is typical BBC "OMG! never let the facts get in the way of a non-story" rubbish
.The Magistrates Association estimated a couple of years ago that around 10% of drivers reaching 12 points successfully avoid a totting ban ( linky). They don't estimate what proportion of those who get further points and have to make a second hardship plea are successful, but I'm willing to bet that it's lower - probably much lower.
Aretnap said:
Another hypothetical example would be a person who gets home from several months abroad and finds that the person he left the car with has been driving like a knob, that there are 5 unopened NIPs on the doormat and that the deadline for replying to them has already passed... But of course, the full details of cases like that wouldn't make as good a headline as "driver with a squillion points keeps licence"
The holidaying RK wouldn't get any points if this were true and he convinced the court as such.357RS said:
Assuming the chap actually has insurance, who insures him and what is his premium? It must be stratospheric!
Unless he is on a group policy, where they don't ask about individuals?I used to have a Direct Line policy, for example, where anyone over 30 could drive the car, as it was cheaper than adding my parents

Mill Wheel said:
BBC News said:
The motorist from Liverpool had committed speeding offences and failed to declare the name of the driver of the vehicle, the IAM said.
All the people listed with 30 point+ seem to involve failure to declare, i think it's people in charge of fleet vehicles who didn't keep proper records who have ended up with the points applied to their license
mcflurry said:
357RS said:
Assuming the chap actually has insurance, who insures him and what is his premium? It must be stratospheric!
Unless he is on a group policy, where they don't ask about individuals?I used to have a Direct Line policy, for example, where anyone over 30 could drive the car, as it was cheaper than adding my parents

It seems these drivers actually plan their strategy to ensure they don't lose their licence... by not naming, or naming drivers whose family circumstances will see the driver allowed to continue driving and "get away with it", as the police don't have sufficient resources to follow it up.
Perhaps the police expect the courts to be less lenient... hence my question - WHO should police the issuing of points, and the administration of licence infringements?
mrmr96 said:
Aretnap said:
Another hypothetical example would be a person who gets home from several months abroad and finds that the person he left the car with has been driving like a knob, that there are 5 unopened NIPs on the doormat and that the deadline for replying to them has already passed... But of course, the full details of cases like that wouldn't make as good a headline as "driver with a squillion points keeps licence"
The holidaying RK wouldn't get any points if this were true and he convinced the court as such.Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


