Received a five figure sum in error - what would you do?
Received a five figure sum in error - what would you do?
Author
Discussion

pse12345

Original Poster:

153 posts

203 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
A former client mistakenly paid over 10k into my account yesterday. I will repay this today, but I'm curious how others would react? Also, purely out of curiosity, what's the legal position on this?

JimmyConwayNW

3,663 posts

156 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Send it my way.

Only joking, only one option for me return to client and let them know about their mistake.

berlintaxi

8,535 posts

204 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Chances are it would show up in an audit on his accounts, so do the right thing and return it, why would anybody consider doing anything else?

Council Baby

19,746 posts

221 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
A few years back we were paid £36k for a contract that had been cancelled by one of the multi-billion £ international clients. We got in touch with them by phone and letter/email several times and they did nothing. After about 9 months of 'efforts' to repay them one of their accountants said it was such a small sum and that they were understaffed so they'd just write it off if we stopped chasing them. I suspect they were covering someone's cock up.

The advice from accountants at our end was to attempt to repay for a year and after that just keep it, apparently that's perfectly legal. Someone else on here will know far better than me if that's correct though.

jgy6000

212 posts

201 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Don't repay it until you have spoken to them, could be a scam if the funds don't actually clear.

SVTRick

3,633 posts

226 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
January Sales
New HD flat screen
Track day
Bet Fred
Few weeks in the sun

Butter Face

35,165 posts

191 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
jgy6000 said:
Don't repay it until you have spoken to them, could be a scam if the funds don't actually clear.
Yeah this. I would be speaking to someone there with a bit of authority before returing anything.

Justin Cyder

12,624 posts

180 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
berlintaxi said:
Chances are it would show up in an audit on his accounts, so do the right thing and return it, why would anybody consider doing anything else?
Because not everyone is as honest as the day is long & therein lies the interesting part of the discussion.

Annually we see suppliers simply forgetting to invoice work to us to the tune of a few grand. As far as I am concerned their slack administration equals free money to us & we never inform anyone if they've omitted to send an invoice. It's not our job to improve their work processes.

Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Agreed, but forgetting to send an invoice is not the same as mistakenly paying someone.

Wings

5,981 posts

246 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Several years ago a registered charity paid rental monies into my bank account, this was after their client had vacated the rental premises. The charity had forgotten to cancel their DD for the rent with their bank. The over payments went on for several months, and was fortunately enough monies to cover my repair costs for the damage carried out to the rental premises, by the charity's client.

The charity's bank sent several letters threatening me with legal action to recover the monies, stating that the mistake for the over payments was the banks, no legal action ever followed.

TheBear

1,940 posts

277 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
It would be a theft under s5 where you have received another's property by mistake and have an obligation to restore it and you decide to keep it.

TheBear

1,940 posts

277 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Mr GrimNasty said:
That relates to credits received by way of Theft, Blackmail, Fraud or Stolen Goods. Not applicable here.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
The money would, however, be recoverable by the paying party under the civil law of restitution.

Dribbler247

Original Poster:

153 posts

203 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
jgy6000 said:
Don't repay it until you have spoken to them, could be a scam if the funds don't actually clear.
This was my first thought. All happily repaid now, obviously repaying the money was my only course of action. I must admit that it sent the man maths into overdrive when it appeared though!

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
PH'er in coke 'n' hookaz FAIL!

RG63AMG

157 posts

155 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
THIS without a doubt!!!

jgy6000 said:
Don't repay it until you have spoken to them, could be a scam if the funds don't actually clear.

topless360

2,763 posts

249 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Send it back and let them know, it's not your money.

I had a similar case where a client overpaid, I let them know and they thanked me and adjusted accordingly for the next payment. What goes around comes around in my eyes.

davamer23

1,158 posts

185 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
As said, proceed with caution. No good deed goes unpunished and all that.

davamer23

1,158 posts

185 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Soz, missed the bit that you'd already sorted it.

Must read all posts before commenting.