Selling a Car you know has been "clocked" - legalities?
Discussion
A friend bought a car from a dealer and subsequently found that is had been clocked (160,000 to 60,000)
They are currently going through the courts to seek recompense.
They have had an initial court hearing and the Judge agreed that the dealer did have a case to answer.
There was some doubt as the "Dealer" claimed he sold the car not as part of his business but privately as a favour to a friend, even though my friend saw it on his business premises and on his forecourt.
They are now in the next stage of the legal process.
Whilst all this goes on, six months now, they're stuck with a car which they can't/don't want to drive.
Their assumption is that they will win the case, they will give the dealer back the car and he will refund their purchase price, the costs they incurred which they shouldn't have had the car been a genuine 60,000 car and their legal fees.
If that happens all well and good!
But, my thinking is nothing is ever so black and white, if it were why would the dealer continue to defend themselves?
So, if my friend is left with the car they will want/need to sell it.
If sold as a 60,000 car it's worth £5000(ish) if a 160,000 mile car only scrap value (or is that scrap cost these days?)
So, where would my friend legally stand with not saying they think the car has done 160k but that the speedo says the car has done 60k?
They are currently going through the courts to seek recompense.
They have had an initial court hearing and the Judge agreed that the dealer did have a case to answer.
There was some doubt as the "Dealer" claimed he sold the car not as part of his business but privately as a favour to a friend, even though my friend saw it on his business premises and on his forecourt.
They are now in the next stage of the legal process.
Whilst all this goes on, six months now, they're stuck with a car which they can't/don't want to drive.
Their assumption is that they will win the case, they will give the dealer back the car and he will refund their purchase price, the costs they incurred which they shouldn't have had the car been a genuine 60,000 car and their legal fees.
If that happens all well and good!
But, my thinking is nothing is ever so black and white, if it were why would the dealer continue to defend themselves?
So, if my friend is left with the car they will want/need to sell it.
If sold as a 60,000 car it's worth £5000(ish) if a 160,000 mile car only scrap value (or is that scrap cost these days?)
So, where would my friend legally stand with not saying they think the car has done 160k but that the speedo says the car has done 60k?
Lots of mechanical issues with it which would be expected from car of this (160k) mileage but not of a car with 60,000 mileage so did a history search on MOTs etc etc and mileages increasing steadily to the 160,000 and then next year when the car was sold with 12 months MOT it only had 60,000 which tallied with the speedo. (mileages are rounded in this topic)
Part of their claim is that they paid to have some of the issues repaired (by the dealer who sold them the car) within a few months of ownership as they were naïve until someone who is mechanically knowledgeable found out and said "Whoa WTF are you doing?"
Part of their claim is that they paid to have some of the issues repaired (by the dealer who sold them the car) within a few months of ownership as they were naïve until someone who is mechanically knowledgeable found out and said "Whoa WTF are you doing?"
Edited by Marcellus on Wednesday 8th January 10:22
I totally agree they should seek compensation for the vast difference in mileage and as such difference in value. But I wonder why they are no longer using the car and why they deem it unfit to drive or won't drive it. There was obviously nothing visually wrong with it wear and tear wise before they bought it, so what has changed?
As for it being scrap value now that's rubbish, I say get some financial re-imbursement and use the car till it dies.
As for it being scrap value now that's rubbish, I say get some financial re-imbursement and use the car till it dies.
If you friend sells the car, he should avoid saying "speedo reading 60K" or similar without some qualification of the statement. Otherwise, it could be construed as a representation that 60K means 60K. Strictly speaking, a private seller has no obligation to make full disclosure, but he should be very careful about making any express or implied representations about mileage or condition. Far better to be honest and say that the speedo reading is off.
Also, does 100,000 extra miles on the car really convert it from a 5000 quid car to a scrapper? At that mileage, condition is what counts. You may be right, but the car might not be completely worthless.
Also, does 100,000 extra miles on the car really convert it from a 5000 quid car to a scrapper? At that mileage, condition is what counts. You may be right, but the car might not be completely worthless.
Phil Dicky said:
I totally agree they should seek compensation for the vast difference in mileage and as such difference in value. But I wonder why they are no longer using the car and why they deem it unfit to drive or won't drive it. There was obviously nothing visually wrong with it wear and tear wise before they bought it, so what has changed?
As for it being scrap value now that's rubbish, I say get some financial re-imbursement and use the car till it dies.
I think anyone who knew what they were looking at would have told them to run for the hills and not touch it with a barge pole but to them it was the "perfect car" even the registration plate was great (think in the mind set of a 17year old girl buying 1st car)As for it being scrap value now that's rubbish, I say get some financial re-imbursement and use the car till it dies.
Breadvan72 said:
If you friend sells the car, he should avoid saying "speedo reading 60K" or similar without some qualification of the statement. Otherwise, it could be construed as a representation that 60K means 60K. Strictly speaking, a private seller has no obligation to make full disclosure, but he should be very careful about making any express or implied representations about mileage or condition. Far better to be honest and say that the speedo reading is off.
Cheers BV, your opinions are always appreciated and respected!anonymous said:
[redacted]
I agree...these are the sort of cases that look cut and dry but seldom end that way.If he does manage to get judgement and it isnt paid, get high court bailiffs in, dont mess about with county court bailiffs as they are generally ineffective.
What exactly is been claimed for?
If you state that the mileage is 60k when you know that it is actually 160k (as you do) then that would be a fraudulent misrepresentation (FMR).
There are four facets to FMR:
1. The defendant makes a false representation to the claimant. (eg this car has 60k on the clock)
2. The defendant knows that the representation is false, alternatively, he is reckless as to whether it is true or false. (you know from your experience with the dealer that is has 160k)
3. The defendant intends that the claimant should act in reliance on it. (ie they buy the car thinking that it is lower mileage)
4. The claimant does act in reliance on the representation and, in consequence, suffers loss. (they buy the car based on your claim that it is 60k car but realise that they have bought something of much lower value after.
Considering the above, and the fact that a car dealer should (did?) discover prior to selling the vehicle that it was clocked, it sounds on the information provided that you would have a decent claim against the dealer for FMR yourself.
If you were successful in such a claim you would be entitled to rescission of the contract (ie put money back to you, car back to him PLUS damages).
Be aware that what I have put above is simply an overview to the law in this regard, and only deals with one type of misrep - FMR. There are other types which may be more applicable to your circumstances. If you have not yet engaged legal counsel I would call up a local firm and give them the basics over the phone. Most law firms will give you an initial meeting for free to determine whether or not they want to take the case...
The alternative of course is to cut your losses, sell the car with full disclosure about its history, take what you can get and put it down to an expensive lesson. Frankly, though, it sounds to me like you've been legged over by a dodgy dealer who needs to be taken to task. It may be worth taking non-legal routes to encourage him to come to a settlement - tell him you're thinking about writing to the local paper/some "dodgy dealer" TV show with your story etc. The threat of reputational damage and a reasonable offer to settle (eg we give the car back and you repay the money, or £4k back and we keep the car or something like that)is often more potent than the legal route.
Sorry it turned into a bit of an essay but hope that helps!
There are four facets to FMR:
1. The defendant makes a false representation to the claimant. (eg this car has 60k on the clock)
2. The defendant knows that the representation is false, alternatively, he is reckless as to whether it is true or false. (you know from your experience with the dealer that is has 160k)
3. The defendant intends that the claimant should act in reliance on it. (ie they buy the car thinking that it is lower mileage)
4. The claimant does act in reliance on the representation and, in consequence, suffers loss. (they buy the car based on your claim that it is 60k car but realise that they have bought something of much lower value after.
Considering the above, and the fact that a car dealer should (did?) discover prior to selling the vehicle that it was clocked, it sounds on the information provided that you would have a decent claim against the dealer for FMR yourself.
If you were successful in such a claim you would be entitled to rescission of the contract (ie put money back to you, car back to him PLUS damages).
Be aware that what I have put above is simply an overview to the law in this regard, and only deals with one type of misrep - FMR. There are other types which may be more applicable to your circumstances. If you have not yet engaged legal counsel I would call up a local firm and give them the basics over the phone. Most law firms will give you an initial meeting for free to determine whether or not they want to take the case...
The alternative of course is to cut your losses, sell the car with full disclosure about its history, take what you can get and put it down to an expensive lesson. Frankly, though, it sounds to me like you've been legged over by a dodgy dealer who needs to be taken to task. It may be worth taking non-legal routes to encourage him to come to a settlement - tell him you're thinking about writing to the local paper/some "dodgy dealer" TV show with your story etc. The threat of reputational damage and a reasonable offer to settle (eg we give the car back and you repay the money, or £4k back and we keep the car or something like that)is often more potent than the legal route.
Sorry it turned into a bit of an essay but hope that helps!
Marcellus said:
If sold as a 60,000 car it's worth £5000(ish) if a 160,000 mile car only scrap value (or is that scrap cost these days?)
nonsense its not scrap value just because its got 160k.Ok its worth a lot less than 60k, but its certainly not scrap value just cause its got some miles on it.
OutOfSync said:
If you state that the mileage is 60k when you know that it is actually 160k (as you do) then that would be a fraudulent misrepresentation (FMR).
There are four facets to FMR:
1. The defendant makes a false representation to the claimant. (eg this car has 60k on the clock)
2. The defendant knows that the representation is false, alternatively, he is reckless as to whether it is true or false. (you know from your experience with the dealer that is has 160k)
3. The defendant intends that the claimant should act in reliance on it. (ie they buy the car thinking that it is lower mileage)
4. The claimant does act in reliance on the representation and, in consequence, suffers loss. (they buy the car based on your claim that it is 60k car but realise that they have bought something of much lower value after.
Considering the above, and the fact that a car dealer should (did?) discover prior to selling the vehicle that it was clocked, it sounds on the information provided that you would have a decent claim against the dealer for FMR yourself.
If you were successful in such a claim you would be entitled to rescission of the contract (ie put money back to you, car back to him PLUS damages).
Be aware that what I have put above is simply an overview to the law in this regard, and only deals with one type of misrep - FMR. There are other types which may be more applicable to your circumstances. If you have not yet engaged legal counsel I would call up a local firm and give them the basics over the phone. Most law firms will give you an initial meeting for free to determine whether or not they want to take the case...
The alternative of course is to cut your losses, sell the car with full disclosure about its history, take what you can get and put it down to an expensive lesson. Frankly, though, it sounds to me like you've been legged over by a dodgy dealer who needs to be taken to task. It may be worth taking non-legal routes to encourage him to come to a settlement - tell him you're thinking about writing to the local paper/some "dodgy dealer" TV show with your story etc. The threat of reputational damage and a reasonable offer to settle (eg we give the car back and you repay the money, or £4k back and we keep the car or something like that)is often more potent than the legal route.
Sorry it turned into a bit of an essay but hope that helps!
It reads like an essay by a law student, and if I were your your tutor I would give the essay a Beta Minus because of the error on rescission. That is not possible when the car was used for some time after the sale. You have also missed out the need for the reliance to be reasonable reliance, so Beta Minus. Also, you are assuming that the dealer knew the true mileage. He quite possibly did , but assume nothing. Oops, it's now Beta Minus Minus Minus query Gamma. Fair effort, but a fail overall. Sorry! Revision class starts next week. There are four facets to FMR:
1. The defendant makes a false representation to the claimant. (eg this car has 60k on the clock)
2. The defendant knows that the representation is false, alternatively, he is reckless as to whether it is true or false. (you know from your experience with the dealer that is has 160k)
3. The defendant intends that the claimant should act in reliance on it. (ie they buy the car thinking that it is lower mileage)
4. The claimant does act in reliance on the representation and, in consequence, suffers loss. (they buy the car based on your claim that it is 60k car but realise that they have bought something of much lower value after.
Considering the above, and the fact that a car dealer should (did?) discover prior to selling the vehicle that it was clocked, it sounds on the information provided that you would have a decent claim against the dealer for FMR yourself.
If you were successful in such a claim you would be entitled to rescission of the contract (ie put money back to you, car back to him PLUS damages).
Be aware that what I have put above is simply an overview to the law in this regard, and only deals with one type of misrep - FMR. There are other types which may be more applicable to your circumstances. If you have not yet engaged legal counsel I would call up a local firm and give them the basics over the phone. Most law firms will give you an initial meeting for free to determine whether or not they want to take the case...
The alternative of course is to cut your losses, sell the car with full disclosure about its history, take what you can get and put it down to an expensive lesson. Frankly, though, it sounds to me like you've been legged over by a dodgy dealer who needs to be taken to task. It may be worth taking non-legal routes to encourage him to come to a settlement - tell him you're thinking about writing to the local paper/some "dodgy dealer" TV show with your story etc. The threat of reputational damage and a reasonable offer to settle (eg we give the car back and you repay the money, or £4k back and we keep the car or something like that)is often more potent than the legal route.
Sorry it turned into a bit of an essay but hope that helps!
Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 8th January 17:43
Breadvan72 said:
It reads like an essay by a law student, and if I were your your tutor I would give the essay a Beta Minus because of the error on rescission. That is not possible when the car was used for some time after the sale. You have also missed out the need for the reliance to be reasonable reliance, so Beta Minus. Also, you are assuming that the dealer knew the true mileage. He quite possibly did , but assume nothing. Oops, it's now Beta Minus Minus Minus query Gamma. Fair effort, but a fail overall. Sorry! Revision class starts next week.
Haha! Good points well made, although my understanding was that the parties need not necessarily be put back into their exact pre-contractual positions. In other words if OP had only put a few hundred extra miles on it, rescission may still be possible (assuming that the other conditions were met)?As for reasonable reliance, I would have thought that relying on a car dealer who states the mileage to be [X] is reasonable, no?
Finally, I did not say that the dealer did know the true mileage but if he did then it would be an FMR claim. If not (as I said) a different sort of misrep claim may be more appropriate (eg negligent misrep?).
Probably still a beta response, but perhaps an upgrade on appeal is on the cards?
p.s. to amalgamate two conversations into one, I'm a solicitor round the corner on the Aldwych. I shall keep an ear out for the burble of a Jensen going past when I'm having an ale in the Edgar Wallace.
Breadvan72 said:
I was being a bit severe! I was always a bit of a tough b
d as a pupilmaster, but nowadays my pupils take silk (unlike me!) and we are all still friends (and they can buy me lunch for a change).
EW a very fine pub, let's have a pint.
Definitely keen for a pint in the EW, although it will have to be after the end of January as I'm trying out this "dry month" fad. So it's just dry martinis, dry sherry and maybe the odd bottle of jurancon (demi sec) for me ...
d as a pupilmaster, but nowadays my pupils take silk (unlike me!) and we are all still friends (and they can buy me lunch for a change).EW a very fine pub, let's have a pint.
Breadvan72 said:
If you friend sells the car, he should avoid saying "speedo reading 60K" or similar without some qualification of the statement. Otherwise, it could be construed as a representation that 60K means 60K. Strictly speaking, a private seller has no obligation to make full disclosure, but he should be very careful about making any express or implied representations about mileage or condition. Far better to be honest and say that the speedo reading is off.
Also, does 100,000 extra miles on the car really convert it from a 5000 quid car to a scrapper? At that mileage, condition is what counts. You may be right, but the car might not be completely worthless.
Huh? Also, does 100,000 extra miles on the car really convert it from a 5000 quid car to a scrapper? At that mileage, condition is what counts. You may be right, but the car might not be completely worthless.

Shouldn't that be:
"Far better to be honest and say that the odometer reading is off"?

Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



