Insurance help needed- rather complicated
Insurance help needed- rather complicated
Author
Discussion

JQ

Original Poster:

6,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
I work in commercial property and have been asked for help by a friend and it's outside my area of expertise and it has the potential to ruin him, so don't want to give poor advice. Obviously, my first advice was to get legal help, which he's already doing.

Anyway, Friend has a large wooden building on his land that he let a couple of friends occupy on a long term basis - a plumber and a mechanic. No leases in place, or anything in writing - the mechanic pays nothing and the plumber looks after the land as a form of payment.

The building burns to the ground following a fire in the mechanic's unit. Friend has no insurance, Mechanic has no insurance, but plumber does. Plumbers insurance have paid out £70,000 to date to the plumber for contents and are looking to pay a further £40,000 for the building. They are now chasing Friend for this money as Landlord, their argument being that the Landlord was negligent for permitting a mechanic to operate out of a wooden building. The mechanic has no money or assets, if it's of any relevance.

2 questions -
1) - Is Friend liable for insurance monies
2) - If they are liable, can Friend go after Plumber for the building insurance monies, as he has no intention of rebuilding and will pocket the cash. There was no lease in place, hence rebuild clause and Friend has no intention of rebuilding either.

Any help for the resident insurance experts would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Why would the insurer be looking to pay the plumber in respect of a building that wasn't his?

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
Why would the insurer be looking to pay the plumber in respect of a building that wasn't his?
The tenant often pays the building premium so they may have arranged cover

V8forweekends

2,506 posts

155 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
These are legal questions, not insurance ones. The question of liability can only be decided by a court - or realistically by two expensive lawyers deciding to settle because the arguing has already cost a fortune. It's a complex area, even for lawyers.

And that's a good Q about why the Plumber's getting the rebuilding cost paid when there's no lease.

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Is the only reason the Insurers are pursuing your friend that they rented the building to a mechanic?

If that's the only reason then they would need to prove this was negligent eg it was reasonably foreseable that a mechanic would / could burn down the building. This will not be easy for them to prove

NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
dacouch said:
REALIST123 said:
Why would the insurer be looking to pay the plumber in respect of a building that wasn't his?
The tenant often pays the building premium so they may have arranged cover
It would seem incredibly generous of the insurance company to pay out if there's no tenancy agreement requiring buildings insurance in place.

And even if they did, surely they'd pay the owner of the building, not the tenant? So chasing him to pay it back makes no sense.

Edited by NPI on Wednesday 8th January 21:28

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
This shows the pitfalls of letting property without taking the appropriate advice.

Not sure why the OP refers to residential advice, after all the properties where used for commercial properties and therefore will be subject to commercial law. The fact there is no lease is possibly irrelevant.

Sounds as if with the sums of money involved the best option is professional advice.

AyBee

11,365 posts

233 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Is it one building they were sharing or units within the building? If the plumber has been paid out for the building, then it sounds like he was insuring his property in the building and also the building itself. If he was doing this, surely he should have let them know that a mechanic was also using the building as part of the insurance policy?

JQ

Original Poster:

6,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
dacouch said:
Is the only reason the Insurers are pursuing your friend that they rented the building to a mechanic?

If that's the only reason then they would need to prove this was negligent eg it was reasonably foreseable that a mechanic would / could burn down the building. This will not be easy for them to prove
Yes, they are saying that because it was a wooden building it was negligent to permit someone working on cars to occupy the premises.

Whilst it may be difficult to prove, the insurance company have expensive lawyers and deep pockets, friend most certainly does not.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm not entirely certain that there's a contract in place with the mechanic. From my primary school law learnings* There needs to be offer, acceptance and consideration(payment of some sort) for there to be a contract. Now, I can see offer and acceptance as the mechanic is using the space, but is there any payment of any kind? Even a bit of mechanic-ing done on the cheap?

Also, there seems to be a bit of a confusion as to what the insured interest is on the property. The only way the insurers would be looking to pay out for the building is if you had an arrangement whereby the plumber was liable for the building. I imagine that a letter stating something like "The plumber has no insurable interest in the structure of the building." would be enough to stop them in their tracks, as you can't get a payout on something where you didn't incur a loss.

  • I didn't do law at primary school.

JQ

Original Poster:

6,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
AyBee said:
Is it one building they were sharing or units within the building? If the plumber has been paid out for the building, then it sounds like he was insuring his property in the building and also the building itself. If he was doing this, surely he should have let them know that a mechanic was also using the building as part of the insurance policy?
A single building with a dividing wall. Does the owner of a single unit in a terrace of 20 units have to inform their insurance company of the uses the other 19 units are put to?

JQ

Original Poster:

6,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
JQ said:
resident insurance experts
Chrisgr31 said:
Not sure why the OP refers to residential advice
Glad your not reviewing my leases wink

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Baffled. Why would the plumber have insured a building that he doesn't own?

It's a while since I looked after the Commercial side of things, but unless the plumber is specifically responsible for reinstatement of the building then he has no loss and therefore can not claim for this incident. I think someone has already posted that and that to me is the end of it.

JQ

Original Poster:

6,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Baffled. Why would the plumber have insured a building that he doesn't own?

It's a while since I looked after the Commercial side of things, but unless the plumber is specifically responsible for reinstatement of the building then he has no loss and therefore can not claim for this incident. I think someone has already posted that and that to me is the end of it.
Standard practice in commercial leases is for tenants to be responsible for for buildings insurance. A good landlord would however, be take responsibility for organising the insurance and reclaiming the costs from the tenant.

As there was no lease the plumber is not responsible for re-instatement and also has no intention of reinstating. Does this mean they can't claim on the buildings cover? The plumber's view is that he paid the premium so is pursuing the claim and the insurance co certainly haven't dismissed it and are discussing values. As yet the insurance co have not paid out on that element yet. But they have definitely paid out on the £70,000 contents and they are pursuing friend for those monies.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
JQ said:
A single building with a dividing wall. Does the owner of a single unit in a terrace of 20 units have to inform their insurance company of the uses the other 19 units are put to?
He hasn't got an insurer in this case so I can't think of any reason why he would have to inform anyone.

I suppose it is possible that the plumber tenant insured "his" bit of the building, noting the landlord and that this insurer are looking to the landlord to reinstate the (presumably attached) unit occupied by the mechanic.

I can't see anyway they can force him to contribute.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
JQ said:
But they have definitely paid out on the £70,000 contents and they are pursuing friend for those monies.
In that case I am at a loss. I really can't see how they can do that unless he was a party to the contract OR he was in some way responsible for the fire.

Unless he was playing with matches just before the fire I really can't see how he can dragged into it.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
JQ said:
Standard practice in commercial leases is for tenants to be responsible for for buildings insurance. A good landlord would however, be take responsibility for organising the insurance and reclaiming the costs from the tenant.

As there was no lease the plumber is not responsible for re-instatement and also has no intention of reinstating. Does this mean they can't claim on the buildings cover? The plumber's view is that he paid the premium so is pursuing the claim and the insurance co certainly haven't dismissed it and are discussing values. As yet the insurance co have not paid out on that element yet. But they have definitely paid out on the £70,000 contents and they are pursuing friend for those monies.
So effectively you're saying the plumber has insured a building that he doesn't own and is going to pocket the cash and walk away. It doesn't work like that. He can't walk away, nor will an insurer pay out for it. His insurer may want to recover the contents payout as pork911 rightly says but the plumber has no contract forcing him to insure the building and even if he did he has to reinstate not pocket it.

He is in breach of at least one basic principle of insurance by trying to do this.

JQ

Original Poster:

6,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
JQ said:
Standard practice in commercial leases is for tenants to be responsible for for buildings insurance. A good landlord would however, be take responsibility for organising the insurance and reclaiming the costs from the tenant.

As there was no lease the plumber is not responsible for re-instatement and also has no intention of reinstating. Does this mean they can't claim on the buildings cover? The plumber's view is that he paid the premium so is pursuing the claim and the insurance co certainly haven't dismissed it and are discussing values. As yet the insurance co have not paid out on that element yet. But they have definitely paid out on the £70,000 contents and they are pursuing friend for those monies.
So effectively you're saying the plumber has insured a building that he doesn't own and is going to pocket the cash and walk away. It doesn't work like that. He can't walk away, nor will an insurer pay out for it. His insurer may want to recover the contents payout as pork911 rightly says but the plumber has no contract forcing him to insure the building and even if he did he has to reinstate not pocket it.

He is in breach of at least one basic principle of insurance by trying to do this.
Cheers.

Any views on how likely it is that the insurance co could successfully pursue the claim for the £70,000 already paid out for the contents, as that's the pressing matter at the moment, the buildings claim is a side issue at present?

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Your mate needs a decent property litigation specialist. I can suggest one.

Has he got any OTHER insurance policies that include some form of legal expenses cover that would enable him to defend this?

If not, this could cost him a few £k.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
JQ said:
Cheers.

Any views on how likely it is that the insurance co could successfully pursue the claim for the £70,000 already paid out for the contents, as that's the pressing matter at the moment, the buildings claim is a side issue at present?
They'd need to prove that the landlord was negligent to have any chance. Can they do this? No idea as the details matter hugely here. What business did the mechanic do? Welding or any form of flammable / inflammable materials? Is having petrol on the premises a risk if contained inside a car? Is the petrol in canisters? Is it in a plastic container? And so on.