Do bikers ever get prosecuted for "undertaking" traffic.
Discussion
On a dual carriageway this morning in stationery traffic. A biker came down between the two lanes beeping his horn at every car to clear the way for him to ride down (he was shaking his head as he passed each car that had to move).
It made me wonder if bikers are ever prosecuted for effectively undertaking to make progress, in this case he was forcing a third lane to be created for his personal use. Any experience on here?
It made me wonder if bikers are ever prosecuted for effectively undertaking to make progress, in this case he was forcing a third lane to be created for his personal use. Any experience on here?
Not this s
t again.
Filtering is entirely legal. It's actually mentioned in Rule 88 of the Highway Code here:
https://www.gov.uk/rules-motorcyclists-83-to-88
plus plenty of case law if you google a little.
The riding you describe would be unlikely to see the guy nicked (for what offence? Bad manners?), and it's a moot point at what speed filtering becomes illegal when the traffic does start to move. In any case, riding aggressively in the way you describe is a bit daft and likely to end in tears for one party in particular, so I wouldn't worry about it too much.
FWIW I filter most days. Carefully and conservatively would probably describe the way I do it, and there are others who are quicker, for whom I make room gladly. I've never filtered in the way you describe, nor in several years of commuting have I seen any other rider filter that way. If I had, I would say, but in my experience it's not common. People move over if they want to, and don't if they don't. There's not a lot I can do about it. The only time I use my horn when filtering is if a driver hasn't seen me and tries to change lane or drift into me as I pass, since I'd rather not get knocked off.
t again.Filtering is entirely legal. It's actually mentioned in Rule 88 of the Highway Code here:
https://www.gov.uk/rules-motorcyclists-83-to-88
plus plenty of case law if you google a little.
The riding you describe would be unlikely to see the guy nicked (for what offence? Bad manners?), and it's a moot point at what speed filtering becomes illegal when the traffic does start to move. In any case, riding aggressively in the way you describe is a bit daft and likely to end in tears for one party in particular, so I wouldn't worry about it too much.
FWIW I filter most days. Carefully and conservatively would probably describe the way I do it, and there are others who are quicker, for whom I make room gladly. I've never filtered in the way you describe, nor in several years of commuting have I seen any other rider filter that way. If I had, I would say, but in my experience it's not common. People move over if they want to, and don't if they don't. There's not a lot I can do about it. The only time I use my horn when filtering is if a driver hasn't seen me and tries to change lane or drift into me as I pass, since I'd rather not get knocked off.
Edited by N Dentressangle on Wednesday 8th January 22:37
GuitarPlayer63 said:
On a dual carriageway this morning in stationery traffic. A biker came down between the two lanes beeping his horn at every car to clear the way for him to ride down (he was shaking his head as he passed each car that had to move).
Did the horn and shaking head while filtering actually happen? I've never seen anything like that in the history of the entire universe. FFS. It's not filtering. How many times do people have to post this same old guff.
Filtering is when there is traffic to your left travelling (but stationary) in the same direction and the traffic to your right is traveling in the opposite direction.
What the OP has described is lane splitting. This is a grey area for insurance (civil law) matters. However, plod (criminal law) will not be interested unless traffic starts moving in which case the speed of the traffic will dictate what (if any) action they take.
To add, there is nothing that wrong with lane splitting IMO and I used to do it when I commuted by bike many moons ago. However, beeping your horn is the sign of a the sort of arse who also uses full beam and puts his hazards on and also thinks having a loud exhaust saves lives. Blah, blah.
Filtering is when there is traffic to your left travelling (but stationary) in the same direction and the traffic to your right is traveling in the opposite direction.
What the OP has described is lane splitting. This is a grey area for insurance (civil law) matters. However, plod (criminal law) will not be interested unless traffic starts moving in which case the speed of the traffic will dictate what (if any) action they take.
To add, there is nothing that wrong with lane splitting IMO and I used to do it when I commuted by bike many moons ago. However, beeping your horn is the sign of a the sort of arse who also uses full beam and puts his hazards on and also thinks having a loud exhaust saves lives. Blah, blah.
AdeTuono said:
Semantics. You, and everyone else, knows what it means. And it's not illegal.
It's not semantics and it is not proven to be legal either from a motoring (criminal burden of proof) perspective. Every chance a civil insurance matter would settle 50/50 if a crash was between the biker and the car to his right. Probably 100% in bikers favour if crash was with car to his left. Of course I know little about this having run one of the largest bike insurers for years and currently a very senior role with one of the largest insurers in the UK.
LoonR1 said:
AdeTuono said:
Semantics. You, and everyone else, knows what it means. And it's not illegal.
It's not semantics and it is not proven to be legal either from a motoring (criminal burden of proof) perspective. Every chance a civil insurance matter would settle 50/50 if a crash was between the biker and the car to his right. Probably 100% in bikers favour if crash was with car to his left. Of course I know little about this having run one of the largest bike insurers for years and currently a very senior role with one of the largest insurers in the UK.

creampuff said:
Did the horn and shaking head while filtering actually happen? I've never seen anything like that in the history of the entire universe.
I see use of horn, shaking of head and salt shaker signals almost daily. Spend an hour sat in traffic on the a40 out of london around 6pm and you will see it too. That in itself tends to amuse me, along with the guy over-revving the engine on his bike to 'alert' you of his presence. I tend to keep to the left of the lane I am in, but what does frustrate me is when I am to the left of the middle lane (3 lane carriageway), I have created space for bikes to safely pass on the right of me, but then I get harassed by someone coming down to the left of me. Can't win!!Edited to add, I see more occurences of the nod of the head/raised hand to say thank you than the aggressive approach.
Edited by rpgk on Thursday 9th January 08:08
Six Fiend said:
Funny that, my TrafPol examiners all called it filtering and I've never been marked down for it on test.
Nice snip. You'll see that I stated that plod aren't all that interested too. Good luck when it comes down to a civil matter.
Better still show me where it's legal and referred to anywhere? Equally review the pictures etching in the Highway Code where they describe filtering and compare and contrast. I know the HC isn't definitive but there is no precedent set anywhere that shows what you're describing as filtering.
I guess there's legal 'filtering' then plain English 'filtering' depending on your perspective.
It happens.
On the fast lane* of the M25 bikes used to filter down the right hand side near the crash barrier and down the right.
In general I'd say 50% of bikers are safe and polite.
30% are safe but a bit rude.
And 20% are total t
ts.
Oh, and that 20% goes up a lot in the summer.
From a road use perspective I see it the same as some t
t sitting off a rear bumper flashing to try and get past.
- * you know what I mean. If you really want to try and start a fight about it don't waste everyone's time.
It happens.
On the fast lane* of the M25 bikes used to filter down the right hand side near the crash barrier and down the right.
In general I'd say 50% of bikers are safe and polite.
30% are safe but a bit rude.
And 20% are total t
ts.Oh, and that 20% goes up a lot in the summer.
From a road use perspective I see it the same as some t
t sitting off a rear bumper flashing to try and get past.- * you know what I mean. If you really want to try and start a fight about it don't waste everyone's time.
Whether its legal or not will depend on the circumstances of each occasion. If the biker is beeping his horn and gesticulating to force others to move for him, it sounds like s3 Inconsiderate, though the chances of being pulled for it are somewhere between 'no' and 'Bob' on the hope scale.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



