Nightmare with boiler
Discussion
I've been having an absolute nightmare with a boiler at a flat I own and rent out and was wondering where I stand legally with regards to the plumber.
- I first had and issue and called him in on christmas eve to look at it, he diagnosed the problem and ordered parts.
- Came back shortly after christmas with a electrical board that didn't fix it, tenant had been texting me all day christmas eve and boxing day.
- Couple of days later came back with a fan that also didn't fix, by this point he'd told my tenant not to contact him i suspect she's been texting him every 20minutes so he's got pissed off.
- couple of days later come back with the wrong gas valve.
- Yesterday finally fits a no gas valve and text us to say it al sorted, great new. about 5 hours later I get a text from the tenant saying its not fixed and that from day 1 he's been telling her it needs a new one.
- Last night I asked him to pop back out today as he only lives only 200yards down the road.
- Now doesn't answer the phone and hasn't been out today
So at the moment I've got a really pissed off tenant who thinks that she should have a new boiler despite be having replaced what feels like most of the components, presumably an ever increasing bill and still no hot water or heating. On top of this I'm getting the feeling she's going to with hold the rent payment although might be wrong (due tomorrow), I was intending to do a refund of some sort but where to I stand if she withholds rent?
How long should I wait before getting someone else out? and where to I stand when he presents a bill?
I know these things aren't easy to diagnose and don't want to be unreasonable but am really getting the impression he's given up. I'm also pretty annoyed he's put the idea of a new boiler in my tenants mind and now she's ringing me a couple of times a day saying this is what she wants.
- I first had and issue and called him in on christmas eve to look at it, he diagnosed the problem and ordered parts.
- Came back shortly after christmas with a electrical board that didn't fix it, tenant had been texting me all day christmas eve and boxing day.
- Couple of days later came back with a fan that also didn't fix, by this point he'd told my tenant not to contact him i suspect she's been texting him every 20minutes so he's got pissed off.
- couple of days later come back with the wrong gas valve.
- Yesterday finally fits a no gas valve and text us to say it al sorted, great new. about 5 hours later I get a text from the tenant saying its not fixed and that from day 1 he's been telling her it needs a new one.
- Last night I asked him to pop back out today as he only lives only 200yards down the road.
- Now doesn't answer the phone and hasn't been out today
So at the moment I've got a really pissed off tenant who thinks that she should have a new boiler despite be having replaced what feels like most of the components, presumably an ever increasing bill and still no hot water or heating. On top of this I'm getting the feeling she's going to with hold the rent payment although might be wrong (due tomorrow), I was intending to do a refund of some sort but where to I stand if she withholds rent?
How long should I wait before getting someone else out? and where to I stand when he presents a bill?
I know these things aren't easy to diagnose and don't want to be unreasonable but am really getting the impression he's given up. I'm also pretty annoyed he's put the idea of a new boiler in my tenants mind and now she's ringing me a couple of times a day saying this is what she wants.
IANAL
you need to get your tenant sorted out with HW and CH ASAP
worry about the rest later
I would
1 speak directly to the engineer you have used previously
2 depending on his version of events get him to guarantee a fix within a short time frame
or 3 get another person to fix the boiler ASAP
4 finally I would forego a half months rent at the very least to placate the tennant
edited to add on reading the OP again - you have been very slow to sort this out since Christmas Eve IMO and should be giving your tenant a month rent free at the least and have this sorted ASAP
TWO WEEKS WITHOUT HEAT AND WATER IS NOT ACCEPTABLE
you need to get your tenant sorted out with HW and CH ASAP
worry about the rest later
I would
1 speak directly to the engineer you have used previously
2 depending on his version of events get him to guarantee a fix within a short time frame
or 3 get another person to fix the boiler ASAP
4 finally I would forego a half months rent at the very least to placate the tennant
edited to add on reading the OP again - you have been very slow to sort this out since Christmas Eve IMO and should be giving your tenant a month rent free at the least and have this sorted ASAP
TWO WEEKS WITHOUT HEAT AND WATER IS NOT ACCEPTABLE
Edited by dingg on Friday 10th January 11:21
You have two issues:
As for the plumber, tell him that he hasn't fixed it and you're getting someone else in. He shouldn't charge you for the wasted visits and hasn't responded to your calls and you have no faith in him.
Your Tenant has every right to feel unhappy and I think that, even though you have done everything that you can to resolve it, it hasn't been. You might consider some form of gesture of goodwill whilst you seek another plumber.
As for the plumber, tell him that he hasn't fixed it and you're getting someone else in. He shouldn't charge you for the wasted visits and hasn't responded to your calls and you have no faith in him.
Your Tenant has every right to feel unhappy and I think that, even though you have done everything that you can to resolve it, it hasn't been. You might consider some form of gesture of goodwill whilst you seek another plumber.
I completely agree regarding the tenant, she has every right to be pissed off and I full intend to make a refund.
Issue started as he was the only plumber who'd come out on christmas eve, It's difficult as being a gas appliance I can't really do anything with it and he's constantly telling me this next new part he get will fix it.
I've text him last night and left him a message today to give me a call to discuss, I'd like to tell him to bugger off and use someone else to fix it or fit a new boiler but don't want to be unreasonable with him either.
Issue started as he was the only plumber who'd come out on christmas eve, It's difficult as being a gas appliance I can't really do anything with it and he's constantly telling me this next new part he get will fix it.
I've text him last night and left him a message today to give me a call to discuss, I'd like to tell him to bugger off and use someone else to fix it or fit a new boiler but don't want to be unreasonable with him either.
singlecoil said:
dingg said:
TWO WEEKS WITHOUT HEAT AND WATER IS NOT ACCEPTABLE

First I heard of him suggesting changing the whole lot was this morning from my tenant.
Is it therefore reasonable for me to tell him to bugger off? and if I do what costs should I be liable for?
I'm not on commission. I've got British Gas landlord coverage.
So, when my tenants call me at 8pm there is someone there the following afternoon. Their parts coverage is such that they can get pretty much all parts the following morning.
Boiler coverage is about £20 a month - this is call-outs, parts and labour. But I've got the full works including electrics drains, plumbing and heating as well as the statutory gas checks for £40ish a month.
If your boiler isn't currently working, I think you have to pay £99 for the first fix (whatever it is) as long as you sign up for a year.
Give them a call. After the first call out you can even authorise them to speak to the tenant direct, so the tenant calls BG at 3am to tell them they have a leak and not you. All on an 0800 number.
So, when my tenants call me at 8pm there is someone there the following afternoon. Their parts coverage is such that they can get pretty much all parts the following morning.
Boiler coverage is about £20 a month - this is call-outs, parts and labour. But I've got the full works including electrics drains, plumbing and heating as well as the statutory gas checks for £40ish a month.
If your boiler isn't currently working, I think you have to pay £99 for the first fix (whatever it is) as long as you sign up for a year.
Give them a call. After the first call out you can even authorise them to speak to the tenant direct, so the tenant calls BG at 3am to tell them they have a leak and not you. All on an 0800 number.
JustinP1 said:
I'm not on commission. I've got British Gas landlord coverage.
So, when my tenants call me at 8pm there is someone there the following afternoon. Their parts coverage is such that they can get pretty much all parts the following morning.
Boiler coverage is about £20 a month - this is call-outs, parts and labour. But I've got the full works including electrics drains, plumbing and heating as well as the statutory gas checks for £40ish a month.
If your boiler isn't currently working, I think you have to pay £99 for the first fix (whatever it is) as long as you sign up for a year.
Give them a call. After the first call out you can even authorise them to speak to the tenant direct, so the tenant calls BG at 3am to tell them they have a leak and not you. All on an 0800 number.
fSo, when my tenants call me at 8pm there is someone there the following afternoon. Their parts coverage is such that they can get pretty much all parts the following morning.
Boiler coverage is about £20 a month - this is call-outs, parts and labour. But I've got the full works including electrics drains, plumbing and heating as well as the statutory gas checks for £40ish a month.
If your boiler isn't currently working, I think you have to pay £99 for the first fix (whatever it is) as long as you sign up for a year.
Give them a call. After the first call out you can even authorise them to speak to the tenant direct, so the tenant calls BG at 3am to tell them they have a leak and not you. All on an 0800 number.
k me - for £500 a year I'd want blowjobs and all sorts to be honest.What the OP needs is (a) a decent plumber, and (b) some damage limitation with the tenant.
Bugger the original bloke - if he hasn't fixed it then tell him to get lost. If needs be, phone the manufacturer & see if they can recommend someone in your area. Chances are they'll have a proper bloke who knows that boiler inside out who can fix it immediately.
I used to have BG boiler care at home. They were great at taking the DD every month, but 2 weeks after my son was born, the boiler packed up. 2 weeks & 4 engineers from BG later, I still have no heating or hot water. I did have a letter from one engineer telling me that the flue was no longer meeting current regs, but I didn't have any heating or hot water. It's a SIME boiler, so out of frustration I called SIME. They gave me a number of their local bloke & he was brilliant. He came out that day & within 15 minutes, the radiators were warming nicely. It turned out to be some daft filter needed cleaning rather than what BG were suggesting - a discounted new boiler to replace the 2 year old one we had. Needless to say, the refund of any money we'd paid, a couple of hundred quid on top by way of apology and the SIME blokes bill paid helped a bit, but I wouldn't let BG unblock my sink, let alone touch a gas appliance.
I'm a LL and have a bloody good plumber at the end of the phone. Costs me a bottle of something nice at Christmas but they are worth their weight in gold.
JustinP1 said:
I'm not on commission. I've got British Gas landlord coverage.
So, when my tenants call me at 8pm there is someone there the following afternoon. Their parts coverage is such that they can get pretty much all parts the following morning.
Boiler coverage is about £20 a month - this is call-outs, parts and labour. But I've got the full works including electrics drains, plumbing and heating as well as the statutory gas checks for £40ish a month.
If your boiler isn't currently working, I think you have to pay £99 for the first fix (whatever it is) as long as you sign up for a year.
Give them a call. After the first call out you can even authorise them to speak to the tenant direct, so the tenant calls BG at 3am to tell them they have a leak and not you. All on an 0800 number.
I've had the opposite experience with BG to be honest. I had a breakdown and paid a one off fee to get it fixed with a view to going on their boiler coverage scheme.So, when my tenants call me at 8pm there is someone there the following afternoon. Their parts coverage is such that they can get pretty much all parts the following morning.
Boiler coverage is about £20 a month - this is call-outs, parts and labour. But I've got the full works including electrics drains, plumbing and heating as well as the statutory gas checks for £40ish a month.
If your boiler isn't currently working, I think you have to pay £99 for the first fix (whatever it is) as long as you sign up for a year.
Give them a call. After the first call out you can even authorise them to speak to the tenant direct, so the tenant calls BG at 3am to tell them they have a leak and not you. All on an 0800 number.
They came and did the one off fix which was fine for all of 10 minutes, until they left. Had to wait another two weeks for them to come and fix the problem they failed to resolve. Endless phone calls and weeks without hot water. Cant imagine their service for rental properties is much better.
northwest monkey said:
what BG were suggesting - a massively overpriced then discounted new boiler to replace the 2 year old one we had.
EFA.I wouldn't touch BG with a barge pole. They were bloody useless at providing the service I was paying for but very good at trying to rip me off.
marting said:
I've had the opposite experience with BG to be honest. I had a breakdown and paid a one off fee to get it fixed with a view to going on their boiler coverage scheme.
They came and did the one off fix which was fine for all of 10 minutes, until they left. Had to wait another two weeks for them to come and fix the problem they failed to resolve. Endless phone calls and weeks without hot water. Cant imagine their service for rental properties is much better.
My daughter is having the same with Scottish Power's version at the moment. They seem to use their own guys, rather than contract out, but why make appointments and then just simply fail to turn up?They came and did the one off fix which was fine for all of 10 minutes, until they left. Had to wait another two weeks for them to come and fix the problem they failed to resolve. Endless phone calls and weeks without hot water. Cant imagine their service for rental properties is much better.
The snag is that if you don't know a good local guy you can easily end up with a duffer, like the OP has. As a LL, at least if you're using a large organisation you've covered your backside.
northwest monkey said:
JustinP1 said:
I'm not on commission. I've got British Gas landlord coverage.
So, when my tenants call me at 8pm there is someone there the following afternoon. Their parts coverage is such that they can get pretty much all parts the following morning.
Boiler coverage is about £20 a month - this is call-outs, parts and labour. But I've got the full works including electrics drains, plumbing and heating as well as the statutory gas checks for £40ish a month.
If your boiler isn't currently working, I think you have to pay £99 for the first fix (whatever it is) as long as you sign up for a year.
Give them a call. After the first call out you can even authorise them to speak to the tenant direct, so the tenant calls BG at 3am to tell them they have a leak and not you. All on an 0800 number.
fSo, when my tenants call me at 8pm there is someone there the following afternoon. Their parts coverage is such that they can get pretty much all parts the following morning.
Boiler coverage is about £20 a month - this is call-outs, parts and labour. But I've got the full works including electrics drains, plumbing and heating as well as the statutory gas checks for £40ish a month.
If your boiler isn't currently working, I think you have to pay £99 for the first fix (whatever it is) as long as you sign up for a year.
Give them a call. After the first call out you can even authorise them to speak to the tenant direct, so the tenant calls BG at 3am to tell them they have a leak and not you. All on an 0800 number.
k me - for £500 a year I'd want blowjobs and all sorts to be honest.The statutory Gas certificate checks - that was £90 privately.
Boiler serviced once a year - £80? Privately.
Call out to reset the boiler - £60 privately.
Second call out for a small boiler part - £100?
That was in the first month.
Then, there was the leaking stop tap that was fully replaced, £80 bill saved.
Two stuck radiator stats replaced - £60.
Slow running drains, subcontracted to Dynorod, a couple of hours work - £100.
Then, this month the tenants call me to let me know that water is pouring through the ceiling. Dynorod were out as an emergency. They found the leak by cutting through the ceiling. Replaced the pipe. This week they came back to make good, replacing a couple of m2 of ceiling and reskimming.
I've not paid out a penny on the house apart from the monthly amounts to British Gas. After the last incident, I think I am about £1000 up, as well as countless hours of my time. And most importantly in this situation, the tenants are happy that whatever happens at the house, a trusted contractor will be there in 24 hours.
JustinP1 said:
For my £500 a year I've got:
The statutory Gas certificate checks - that was £90 privately.
Boiler serviced once a year - £80? Privately.
Call out to reset the boiler - £60 privately.
Second call out for a small boiler part - £100?
That was in the first month.
Then, there was the leaking stop tap that was fully replaced, £80 bill saved.
Two stuck radiator stats replaced - £60.
Slow running drains, subcontracted to Dynorod, a couple of hours work - £100.
Then, this month the tenants call me to let me know that water is pouring through the ceiling. Dynorod were out as an emergency. They found the leak by cutting through the ceiling. Replaced the pipe. This week they came back to make good, replacing a couple of m2 of ceiling and reskimming.
I've not paid out a penny on the house apart from the monthly amounts to British Gas. After the last incident, I think I am about £1000 up, as well as countless hours of my time. And most importantly in this situation, the tenants are happy that whatever happens at the house, a trusted contractor will be there in 24 hours.
£20/month for that level of cover? Thought it was alot more than that i.e. dealing with a stop tap would fall outside the remit of the initial level iirc.The statutory Gas certificate checks - that was £90 privately.
Boiler serviced once a year - £80? Privately.
Call out to reset the boiler - £60 privately.
Second call out for a small boiler part - £100?
That was in the first month.
Then, there was the leaking stop tap that was fully replaced, £80 bill saved.
Two stuck radiator stats replaced - £60.
Slow running drains, subcontracted to Dynorod, a couple of hours work - £100.
Then, this month the tenants call me to let me know that water is pouring through the ceiling. Dynorod were out as an emergency. They found the leak by cutting through the ceiling. Replaced the pipe. This week they came back to make good, replacing a couple of m2 of ceiling and reskimming.
I've not paid out a penny on the house apart from the monthly amounts to British Gas. After the last incident, I think I am about £1000 up, as well as countless hours of my time. And most importantly in this situation, the tenants are happy that whatever happens at the house, a trusted contractor will be there in 24 hours.
Sounds like your plumber is useless. I would tell him not to bother invoicing for his time because you're not paying for useless work and get a new, competent plumber in. If he does issue and invoice and feels aggrieved at your non-payment, let him issue proceedings and you can then decide whether to fight or pay (or more likely settle for a lower amount than that invoiced).
How old is the boiler? It may be that a fix will merely be a short term fix and it will keep going wrong. I had that recently with a 6 year old Keston boiler (not my choice, was in the flat when I bought it and they're notoriously bad - 6 years was apparently a "good one"). In that case, best to bite the bullet and get a new one. The cheap man buys twice and all that.
1 month rent free seems reasonable to keep the cold and dirty tenant happy. Maybe snap a few of the icicles off his nose as a show of good faith.
It is worth noting that if your boiler is not against an outside wall, the flues now need to be visible on their way out of the house. That was a nice bonus kick in the teeth when my boiler went wrong as it means redecorating as well as getting a new boiler.
It must be a close run thing between lawyers and plumbers for the most hated profession.
How old is the boiler? It may be that a fix will merely be a short term fix and it will keep going wrong. I had that recently with a 6 year old Keston boiler (not my choice, was in the flat when I bought it and they're notoriously bad - 6 years was apparently a "good one"). In that case, best to bite the bullet and get a new one. The cheap man buys twice and all that.
1 month rent free seems reasonable to keep the cold and dirty tenant happy. Maybe snap a few of the icicles off his nose as a show of good faith.
It is worth noting that if your boiler is not against an outside wall, the flues now need to be visible on their way out of the house. That was a nice bonus kick in the teeth when my boiler went wrong as it means redecorating as well as getting a new boiler.
It must be a close run thing between lawyers and plumbers for the most hated profession.
JustinP1 said:
This week they came back to make good, replacing a couple of m2 of ceiling and reskimming.
That's crap service. Why the hell didn't they redecorate?;)On a serious note I'm with you. My tenants don't even call me with HW/CH issues, they call BG Homecare themselves. I pay £27pm for HW/CH cover, annual service and cert, and it's all tax deductible too.
OP. Get hold of plumber and talk. BG do a fix service and is either £99 or £179 and then put it on homecare.
OP, as a LL myself I have been there, always happens at Christmas time, in fact had a breakdown on a flat's boiler 5 days before Christmas. My usual gas safe engineer was unable to complete repair prior to Christmas, so had to use my back up engineer. Problem turned out to be circuit board and fan, with repair completed on Christmas Eve.
Was the plumber you used Gas Safe registered, since he sounds a plonker, similar to my experiences in the past with BG's engineers. Engineers that works for BG, are supplied with manuals for each make, model of boiler, starting from a list of working faults, working down the list until the boiler is fixed.
OP either contact local LLs in your area, or carry out a search on Gas Safe's web site for a local boiler engineer. http://www.staygassafe.co.uk/
As for your present situation, I would refuse to pay the engineer you have previously used, and offer a small consolation to your tenant for the inconvenience.
Was the plumber you used Gas Safe registered, since he sounds a plonker, similar to my experiences in the past with BG's engineers. Engineers that works for BG, are supplied with manuals for each make, model of boiler, starting from a list of working faults, working down the list until the boiler is fixed.
OP either contact local LLs in your area, or carry out a search on Gas Safe's web site for a local boiler engineer. http://www.staygassafe.co.uk/
As for your present situation, I would refuse to pay the engineer you have previously used, and offer a small consolation to your tenant for the inconvenience.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


