French parking ticket on french hire car...
Discussion
Hired a Mercedes on a recent trip to val d'isere in France, the vehicle was parked in allocated parking spaces for the residents of the chalet however my vehicle and many other 'locals' and 'owners' was towed, apparently a new rule was introduced last year stating that the vehicles had to be parked horizontally not vertically, no new signs stating this. I had 2 fines to pay 1) 35euro for a parking ticket 2) 121euro fine for tow.
I paid the tow fine which released the car but the parking ticket of 35 euros had to be bizarrely paid by getting a stamp from the 'Tabac' and returning the ticket to the Police station which was fine in principle but the 2 tabacs within a 50 mile radious did not have the stamp required, so on the way to the airport I tried another 3 tabacs which also had 'run out'.
I then asked the car hire company if they could sort it if I paid them a bit extra but they said they were unable to help and said I was unable to this online.
So my question is if I dont pay this, are the police likely to chase it through the hire car company, I dont want a big bill in 6 months from a debt agency?
I paid the tow fine which released the car but the parking ticket of 35 euros had to be bizarrely paid by getting a stamp from the 'Tabac' and returning the ticket to the Police station which was fine in principle but the 2 tabacs within a 50 mile radious did not have the stamp required, so on the way to the airport I tried another 3 tabacs which also had 'run out'.
I then asked the car hire company if they could sort it if I paid them a bit extra but they said they were unable to help and said I was unable to this online.
So my question is if I dont pay this, are the police likely to chase it through the hire car company, I dont want a big bill in 6 months from a debt agency?
aaronc said:
Hired a Mercedes on a recent trip to val d'isere in France, the vehicle was parked in allocated parking spaces for the residents of the chalet however my vehicle and many other 'locals' and 'owners' was towed, apparently a new rule was introduced last year stating that the vehicles had to be parked horizontally not vertically, no new signs stating this. I had 2 fines to pay 1) 35euro for a parking ticket 2) 121euro fine for tow.
Isn't parking a car horizontally the standard method used around the World? 
I'm not even sure how you'd park a car in a parking space vertically, but if you actually manage it, surely there a massive risk of it falling over?
aaronc said:
I paid the tow fine which released the car but the parking ticket of 35 euros had to be bizarrely paid by getting a stamp from the 'Tabac' and returning the ticket to the Police station which was fine in principle but the 2 tabacs within a 50 mile radious did not have the stamp required, so on the way to the airport I tried another 3 tabacs which also had 'run out'.
I then asked the car hire company if they could sort it if I paid them a bit extra but they said they were unable to help and said I was unable to this online.
So my question is if I dont pay this, are the police likely to chase it through the hire car company, I dont want a big bill in 6 months from a debt agency?
I suspect the hire car company will have to pay the fine and then they will take the amount of the fine from your credit card (which will have been in the small print of your rental contract).I then asked the car hire company if they could sort it if I paid them a bit extra but they said they were unable to help and said I was unable to this online.
So my question is if I dont pay this, are the police likely to chase it through the hire car company, I dont want a big bill in 6 months from a debt agency?
Pablo68 said:
So to summarise:
We've changed the rules
We haven't told you we changed the rules
We're fining you for breaking the new rules
We're making a bizarre and impossible process for you to pay the fine.
Yup sounds like the Froggies.
Exactly, no signage or anything, even the owners of the chalet and some locals had no idea it had changed, I kicked up a fuss but very difficult to argue when your just a tourist and more than willing to pay the fine just to get it done but they just wouldnt take the money!!!We've changed the rules
We haven't told you we changed the rules
We're fining you for breaking the new rules
We're making a bizarre and impossible process for you to pay the fine.
Yup sounds like the Froggies.
Possibly the most awkward and bizarre country when it comes to motoring offences.
caziques said:
Don;t even think about trying to pay.
Report any attempt by the hire car company to take money from your credit card account as unauthorized use. And yes f
k the French.
And then the hire car company will come back with the contract that the OP signed (the rental agreement), in which the small print will state something along the lines of:Report any attempt by the hire car company to take money from your credit card account as unauthorized use. And yes f
k the French."The person hiring the vehicle hereby authorises the hire company to take any additional payments as necessary to cover any fines/costs that may be incurred during the use of the vehicle."
Like it or not, when you sign the hire agreement you also authorise them to take additional payments.
F
k the French all you like but the Law is on their side!4rephill said:
And then the hire car company will come back with the contract that the OP signed (the rental agreement), in which the small print will state something along the lines of:
"The person hiring the vehicle hereby authorises the hire company to take any additional payments as necessary to cover any fines/costs that may be incurred during the use of the vehicle."
Like it or not, when you sign the hire agreement you also authorise them to take additional payments.
F
k the French all you like but the Law is on their side!
As stated before several times on here if your card is replaced for what ever reason the old one is invalid as the details of the new one will be different."The person hiring the vehicle hereby authorises the hire company to take any additional payments as necessary to cover any fines/costs that may be incurred during the use of the vehicle."
Like it or not, when you sign the hire agreement you also authorise them to take additional payments.
F
k the French all you like but the Law is on their side!Does not matter what you have signed or agreed too the charge cannot be put on your old card.
The hire company will have to fight you to get the money, they cannot charge your bank or card account if the card detail they hold is invalid.
If you disagree with the hire company about any charge and dispute they have to either come to some agreement with you or do one, they cannot debit any money.
Some absolutely vile racism being spouted on this thread - PH at its worst.
It's a bit hard to work out what the Parking infringement was (horizontal parking, as pointed out above is generally the only way to do it) but the new rules on parking are all clearly stated on the website of the Mayor's office, and the only sign you would be likely to see would be one referring to "stationnement genant" which is presumably what you did. I would say that the owners of the chalet have a fairly heavy responsibility for informing you of this and I suspect your "allocated" parking space didn't actually belong to the chalet at all, which is why you were able to be towed.
If you feel hard done by, complain to the mayor's office, since it will be his "police municipal" who will have issued the ticket, but I don't see why you should try to pass the fine on to the hire company, since they have done nothing wrong.
As to the method of paying, a quick google revealed that there are 3 tabacs in Val d'isere itself, another 2 in nearby Bourg St.Maurice and a further 92 in the rest of Savoie, so your comment that there were only 2 payment points within 50 miles is nonsense I'm afraid.
Clearly, if some of the bilious posters above choose never to visit France again because 1 Brit has been given a £30 parking fine, then the French will not give a flying f**k. And nor should they.
It's a bit hard to work out what the Parking infringement was (horizontal parking, as pointed out above is generally the only way to do it) but the new rules on parking are all clearly stated on the website of the Mayor's office, and the only sign you would be likely to see would be one referring to "stationnement genant" which is presumably what you did. I would say that the owners of the chalet have a fairly heavy responsibility for informing you of this and I suspect your "allocated" parking space didn't actually belong to the chalet at all, which is why you were able to be towed.
If you feel hard done by, complain to the mayor's office, since it will be his "police municipal" who will have issued the ticket, but I don't see why you should try to pass the fine on to the hire company, since they have done nothing wrong.
As to the method of paying, a quick google revealed that there are 3 tabacs in Val d'isere itself, another 2 in nearby Bourg St.Maurice and a further 92 in the rest of Savoie, so your comment that there were only 2 payment points within 50 miles is nonsense I'm afraid.
Clearly, if some of the bilious posters above choose never to visit France again because 1 Brit has been given a £30 parking fine, then the French will not give a flying f**k. And nor should they.
SVTRick said:
France is a real nice place to visit
Just spoilt by of load of cheese eating surrender monkeys.
And I have not forgotten who sold Exocet's to the Argies to blow up our troops.
If you get upset over who sells what to whom in the arms trade, then you'll really hate the British.Just spoilt by of load of cheese eating surrender monkeys.
And I have not forgotten who sold Exocet's to the Argies to blow up our troops.
Anyhow, call a Savoyard a Frenchman and you will be, how can I put this, in pain, as BV72 reminded me on another thread.
[quote=Bluebarge]Some absolutely vile racism being spouted on this thread - PH at its worst.
It's a bit hard to work out what the Parking infringement was (horizontal parking, as pointed out above is generally the only way to do it) but the new rules on parking are all clearly stated on the website of the Mayor's office, and the only sign you would be likely to see would be one referring to "stationnement genant" which is presumably what you did. I would say that the owners of the chalet have a fairly heavy responsibility for informing you of this and I suspect your "allocated" parking space didn't actually belong to the chalet at all, which is why you were able to be towed.
The parking space/s did belong to the chalet however the rules of the parking had apparently changed last year as they made the road 2 way (used to be one way only) and due to the that the cars now had to be parked horizontally to the road not sideways as they have been for the last 20 years. The problem was when we arrived there was already 3 vehicles (2 of which were owners of the chalet) which had been parked there for 4 weeks (snow had built up around the vehicles) and parked sideways, sign displayed as 'parking for chalet residents only). All 4 vehicles were towed and fined.
If you feel hard done by, complain to the mayor's office, since it will be his "police municipal" who will have issued the ticket, but I don't see why you should try to pass the fine on to the hire company, since they have done nothing wrong. I did visit the tourist office to complain but couldnt be bothered due to the amount of paperwork, easier to pay the fine and enjoy the weeks holiday
As to the method of paying, a quick google revealed that there are 3 tabacs in Val d'isere itself, another 2 in nearby Bourg St.Maurice and a further 92 in the rest of Savoie, so your comment that there were only 2 payment points within 50 miles is nonsense I'm afraid.
All the Tabacs in Valdsire and Tignes were out of stamps, also the one in Bourg was also out. I wasnt prepared to start travelling miles and miles on the hope of getting a stamp....I was more willing to pay but couldnt. My complaint is the lack of signage and notification to the residents which casued all of us to be towed. I have now sent the ticket with a mate who was off to France to be paid.
It's a bit hard to work out what the Parking infringement was (horizontal parking, as pointed out above is generally the only way to do it) but the new rules on parking are all clearly stated on the website of the Mayor's office, and the only sign you would be likely to see would be one referring to "stationnement genant" which is presumably what you did. I would say that the owners of the chalet have a fairly heavy responsibility for informing you of this and I suspect your "allocated" parking space didn't actually belong to the chalet at all, which is why you were able to be towed.
The parking space/s did belong to the chalet however the rules of the parking had apparently changed last year as they made the road 2 way (used to be one way only) and due to the that the cars now had to be parked horizontally to the road not sideways as they have been for the last 20 years. The problem was when we arrived there was already 3 vehicles (2 of which were owners of the chalet) which had been parked there for 4 weeks (snow had built up around the vehicles) and parked sideways, sign displayed as 'parking for chalet residents only). All 4 vehicles were towed and fined.
If you feel hard done by, complain to the mayor's office, since it will be his "police municipal" who will have issued the ticket, but I don't see why you should try to pass the fine on to the hire company, since they have done nothing wrong. I did visit the tourist office to complain but couldnt be bothered due to the amount of paperwork, easier to pay the fine and enjoy the weeks holiday
As to the method of paying, a quick google revealed that there are 3 tabacs in Val d'isere itself, another 2 in nearby Bourg St.Maurice and a further 92 in the rest of Savoie, so your comment that there were only 2 payment points within 50 miles is nonsense I'm afraid.
All the Tabacs in Valdsire and Tignes were out of stamps, also the one in Bourg was also out. I wasnt prepared to start travelling miles and miles on the hope of getting a stamp....I was more willing to pay but couldnt. My complaint is the lack of signage and notification to the residents which casued all of us to be towed. I have now sent the ticket with a mate who was off to France to be paid.
@ Bluebarge,
I just paid 900 euros for suffering a 1 tyre blow out on a French Auto route.
If i hadn't had Green Flag the result would have been in excess of 2500 euros `(hotels,hire car etc)
i am not going to bore the forum with the whole story but lets just say it cemented my opinion of the French i'm afraid.
I just paid 900 euros for suffering a 1 tyre blow out on a French Auto route.
If i hadn't had Green Flag the result would have been in excess of 2500 euros `(hotels,hire car etc)
i am not going to bore the forum with the whole story but lets just say it cemented my opinion of the French i'm afraid.
CGJJ said:
@ Bluebarge,
I just paid 900 euros for suffering a 1 tyre blow out on a French Auto route.
If i hadn't had Green Flag the result would have been in excess of 2500 euros `(hotels,hire car etc)
i am not going to bore the forum with the whole story but lets just say it cemented my opinion of the French i'm afraid.
So because you incurred some motoring costs in a foreign country, you hold a grudge against that country. Very mature.I just paid 900 euros for suffering a 1 tyre blow out on a French Auto route.
If i hadn't had Green Flag the result would have been in excess of 2500 euros `(hotels,hire car etc)
i am not going to bore the forum with the whole story but lets just say it cemented my opinion of the French i'm afraid.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



