Bought 5 series BMW - Looks to have been clocked! Help...
Discussion
Hi,
Forgive me as this is my first thread on here, however I am a member of other forums.
I am looking for advice..
I have just bought a E61 very recently from a dealer, and on looking closely through the history it is looking very likely to have been clocked. I was suspicious before purchase as the car appears to have changed hand in June 13 and has since only done a few hundred miles tops. The dealer fed me a very good story as I was really close to leaving it, however I had a proper car check done, checked all old MOT's online and the service book all add up. After previous very bad dealings with a second hand car (even with a pre-purchase inspection) I decided to go ahead then have the car inspected by a BMW specialist and return the car if its a shed.
The specialist could not find any evidence of clocking and said the car looks about right for its mileage. However several faults have been found including some present at the last MOT which I would say would now make the car fail (brakes). I've already shelled out around £300 to have a few things sorted and the car is due to have other things sorted (some at the dealers expense) but I'm now not so sure.
The main issue that gave me cause for concern after buying was the service indicators showed -10000 miles for the oil service, when according to the service book it was done just 3000 miles (1 year) ago by another BMW specialist. I called this specialist just in case they didn't have the equipment or it was broke, but they assured me they would have definitely reset the service lights.
On checking the documents tonight I have found a receipt (obviously gone unnoticed) inside a booklet for the car showing the mileage last Sept as 2000 miles more than I bought it with. Now in order for the service light to be -10000 miles means it has done at least 29000 miles since they were last reset, but the last MOT doesn't show this. And judging by the receipt I would say the last owner was doing about 1k a month. So it all just doesn't add up and I don't know what to do.
The milages are:
June 12: 80550 - MOT
June 12: 80627 - service stamp (oil, brake fluid)
Jan 13: 85326 - service stamp (oil, air filter, fuel filter)
June 13: 87946 - MOT
Sept 13: 90182 - repair starter motor
Jan 14: 88200 - me buying
I could return the car but the dealer bought my car and so what kind of mess would I end up tangled in. I don't want this ruining my life for years like a previous car did. I do however have legal protection with my house insurance so I suppose I could use that if necessary. The specialist I've had the car at said it seems pretty decent apart from the few issues I know about.
Should I shop the trader, or hammer him to fix every problem with the car plus cash to cover my expenses? Or just return the car and somehow try to get cash out of him for the car he took from me? Argh, my missus is laughing at me cause I always seem to have drama's with cars. Any advice or help would be appreciated.
Cheers,
Bob
Forgive me as this is my first thread on here, however I am a member of other forums.
I am looking for advice..
I have just bought a E61 very recently from a dealer, and on looking closely through the history it is looking very likely to have been clocked. I was suspicious before purchase as the car appears to have changed hand in June 13 and has since only done a few hundred miles tops. The dealer fed me a very good story as I was really close to leaving it, however I had a proper car check done, checked all old MOT's online and the service book all add up. After previous very bad dealings with a second hand car (even with a pre-purchase inspection) I decided to go ahead then have the car inspected by a BMW specialist and return the car if its a shed.
The specialist could not find any evidence of clocking and said the car looks about right for its mileage. However several faults have been found including some present at the last MOT which I would say would now make the car fail (brakes). I've already shelled out around £300 to have a few things sorted and the car is due to have other things sorted (some at the dealers expense) but I'm now not so sure.
The main issue that gave me cause for concern after buying was the service indicators showed -10000 miles for the oil service, when according to the service book it was done just 3000 miles (1 year) ago by another BMW specialist. I called this specialist just in case they didn't have the equipment or it was broke, but they assured me they would have definitely reset the service lights.
On checking the documents tonight I have found a receipt (obviously gone unnoticed) inside a booklet for the car showing the mileage last Sept as 2000 miles more than I bought it with. Now in order for the service light to be -10000 miles means it has done at least 29000 miles since they were last reset, but the last MOT doesn't show this. And judging by the receipt I would say the last owner was doing about 1k a month. So it all just doesn't add up and I don't know what to do.
The milages are:
June 12: 80550 - MOT
June 12: 80627 - service stamp (oil, brake fluid)
Jan 13: 85326 - service stamp (oil, air filter, fuel filter)
June 13: 87946 - MOT
Sept 13: 90182 - repair starter motor
Jan 14: 88200 - me buying
I could return the car but the dealer bought my car and so what kind of mess would I end up tangled in. I don't want this ruining my life for years like a previous car did. I do however have legal protection with my house insurance so I suppose I could use that if necessary. The specialist I've had the car at said it seems pretty decent apart from the few issues I know about.
Should I shop the trader, or hammer him to fix every problem with the car plus cash to cover my expenses? Or just return the car and somehow try to get cash out of him for the car he took from me? Argh, my missus is laughing at me cause I always seem to have drama's with cars. Any advice or help would be appreciated.
Cheers,
Bob
Why not challenge the dealer and tell him that you are not displeased with the car, but that as it appears to have been 'clocked' it was over-priced and has a few issues. Tell him that you don't want to be unfair but that you feel you might need to speak with Trading Standards and the MAA about it.
The dealer may well offer you a cash refund between the price paid and the price which might have been asked if the true mileage had been shown so long as you agree not to pursue the issue.
Would that be acceptable to you?.
The dealer may well offer you a cash refund between the price paid and the price which might have been asked if the true mileage had been shown so long as you agree not to pursue the issue.
Would that be acceptable to you?.
Cheers for the replies.
I do really need the car to be honest. I have a young baby and a dog and I've been waiting a long time to get a car sorted out. Don't really want to be messing about for months longer.
I doubt a new cluster. The BM specialist said the mileage is stored in 3 locations and unless they all match then you get a indication on the dash.. so whoever has done it has had the right gear.
I do plan to challenge the guy, just wanted a bit of advice first. The car does have quite a few niggles (mostly common problems) but now I wonder if it needs an oil change too. I had accepted an offer off him to repair two problems, but now I think id want everything fixed. I mean the problems add up to about £1500 all in. Some more serious than others. However the car is drivable and does drive quite nice.
I also wonder if it was clocked before the last MOT as-well so makes me start worrying about service intervals & turbo's etc.
I do really need the car to be honest. I have a young baby and a dog and I've been waiting a long time to get a car sorted out. Don't really want to be messing about for months longer.
I doubt a new cluster. The BM specialist said the mileage is stored in 3 locations and unless they all match then you get a indication on the dash.. so whoever has done it has had the right gear.
I do plan to challenge the guy, just wanted a bit of advice first. The car does have quite a few niggles (mostly common problems) but now I wonder if it needs an oil change too. I had accepted an offer off him to repair two problems, but now I think id want everything fixed. I mean the problems add up to about £1500 all in. Some more serious than others. However the car is drivable and does drive quite nice.
I also wonder if it was clocked before the last MOT as-well so makes me start worrying about service intervals & turbo's etc.
Roo said:
No one will clock a car only 2000 miles.
Its not 2000 miles, its 2000 miles plus what ever miles it did in a year, now that might be only 2000 but as you say why bother, more likely it did 12-13000 that would put it over the physiological 100k barrier, so a light haircut would make it much easier to shift on, an easy to get away with as all the history would look ok Oh and I have had it read by a specialist with all the proper BMW equipment who said they couldn't see anything.
I have tried contacting the previous owner but so far no joy.
The swirl flaps appear to have been done recently judging by the documentation, however there is no receipt for this. They do need to be coded out though I believe so somebody's had a computer on it.
I have tried contacting the previous owner but so far no joy.
The swirl flaps appear to have been done recently judging by the documentation, however there is no receipt for this. They do need to be coded out though I believe so somebody's had a computer on it.
NPI said:
That looks very odd - why would anyone service the car after 6mths/5K miles?
Precisely. I did wonder before I bought it but there was no concrete evidence to the contrary. Perhaps a new owner. Has had a two owners recently for pretty short intervals. But like I say dealer spun a good story for the last owner.matjk said:
Roo said:
No one will clock a car only 2000 miles.
Its not 2000 miles, its 2000 miles plus what ever miles it did in a year, now that might be only 2000 but as you say why bother, more likely it did 12-13000 that would put it over the physiological 100k barrier, so a light haircut would make it much easier to shift on, an easy to get away with as all the history would look ok If it had done 13k in the year you would be a complete idiot to wind it back any mileage, let alone enough to be 2k less miles than it had covered.
Roo said:
If it had done 50k in the year you would wind it back just short of that.
If it had done 13k in the year you would be a complete idiot to wind it back any mileage, let alone enough to be 2k less miles than it had covered.
It could have been wound back every year before the service / MOT...If it had done 13k in the year you would be a complete idiot to wind it back any mileage, let alone enough to be 2k less miles than it had covered.
0a said:
Roo said:
If it had done 50k in the year you would wind it back just short of that.
If it had done 13k in the year you would be a complete idiot to wind it back any mileage, let alone enough to be 2k less miles than it had covered.
It could have been wound back every year before the service / MOT...If it had done 13k in the year you would be a complete idiot to wind it back any mileage, let alone enough to be 2k less miles than it had covered.
My reply was in response to if it had done 13k that year and been wound back to keep it under 100k. You wouldn't do that and cock it up by 2k. Well, unless you're an idiot.
0a said:
Roo said:
If it had done 50k in the year you would wind it back just short of that.
If it had done 13k in the year you would be a complete idiot to wind it back any mileage, let alone enough to be 2k less miles than it had covered.
It could have been wound back every year before the service / MOT...If it had done 13k in the year you would be a complete idiot to wind it back any mileage, let alone enough to be 2k less miles than it had covered.
0a said:
It could have been wound back every year before the service / MOT...
For even the limited service/MOT history above to make sense, it must have been clocked every 6mths.Or the car was hardly used, had two services in quick succession, and the mileage on the starter replacement invoice is wrong. Hmmm....

Having said that, if the car looks OK then does it really matter? The OP is soon going to blast past the 100K milestone anyway, and the turbo usually goes at 120K so it's likely to go in his ownership at some point or other.
NPI said:
For even the limited service/MOT history above to make sense, it must have been clocked every 6mths.
Or the car was hardly used, had two services in quick succession, and the mileage on the starter replacement invoice is wrong. Hmmm....
Having said that, if the car looks OK then does it really matter? The OP is soon going to blast past the 100K milestone anyway, and the turbo usually goes at 120K so it's likely to go in his ownership at some point or other.
I suppose its one of those, but don't like feeling cheated and the dealer could well have made a good few extra grand out of me. And its also the unknown... what has it actually done. How much has it missed its service intervals if at all. Being an Evo owner too these 19k service intervals seem ludicrous. I'm used to every 4k or so. Perhaps I should just push him to pay for a service plus fixing all the issues.Or the car was hardly used, had two services in quick succession, and the mileage on the starter replacement invoice is wrong. Hmmm....

Having said that, if the car looks OK then does it really matter? The OP is soon going to blast past the 100K milestone anyway, and the turbo usually goes at 120K so it's likely to go in his ownership at some point or other.
For peace of mind it could be worth an oil, air and fuel filter yourself so you actually know it has been done. Or haggle with dealer to do it.
Hopefully minor niggles aside it turns out to be a good car,
On the mileage front it could potentially even be the previous owner prior to trading the car, or as others have said before the MOT's.
Hopefully minor niggles aside it turns out to be a good car,
On the mileage front it could potentially even be the previous owner prior to trading the car, or as others have said before the MOT's.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


