ACPO to lose PCC funding?
Author
Discussion

Mill Wheel

Original Poster:

6,149 posts

227 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2538282/Pa...

The Daily Mail has long held a dislike of ACPO, in common with many others, so read into this what you will, but the sacking of a senior manager for theft seems to indicate a lack of good practice somewhere!

Daily Mail said:
The row came as Acpo’s civilian chief executive was sacked last week after being accused of stealing from the body’s Westminster offices.

Tom Flaherty, 54, was thrown out for gross misconduct at a disciplinary hearing on Tuesday.

He had been suspended on full pay since he was arrested last April accused of stealing Sir Hugh’s desk diary amid a spate of petty thefts.

The case was a major embarrassment for Acpo as it faced accusations of a cover-up and the organisation, dubbed a ‘boys club for senior officers’ by its critics, now faces abolition after an independent review of its work.

Police and Crime Commissioners are expected to announce they will no longer fund it in its present form within weeks.
Meanwhile, the President of ACPO, Sir Hugh Orde, is urging that police officers should be paid more, in order to dissuade them from being dishonest.

Daily Mail said:
Hard-up officers are more likely to take bribes if they are underpaid, one of Britain’s most senior police chiefs has claimed.

The financial pressure felt by ‘certain ranks’ could fuel a wave of corruption, warned Sir Hugh Orde.

The president of the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo) also appeared to compare Britain to some third world countries where illegal payments to law enforcers are engrained in society.

But his comments provoked a row last night when furious MPs said it was ‘appalling’ to suggest officers could commit a crime to make ends meet.

Politicians said chief officers must keep a ‘sense of balance’ amid current reforms to police pay and pensions and claimed rank-and-file officers would be shocked at their integrity being questioned.

Sir Hugh singled out the starting salary of £19,000 for junior PCs as too low during an interview about morale as leaders battle to slash costs.

‘There are certain ranks in the service who are vulnerable in terms of their income and expenditure, which means we should be worried,’ he said.

‘One thing around learning from corruption and integrity is that if you underpay police officers – for example, there are some forces around the world where officers are hardly paid at all – the consequence is corruption.

‘I am not saying that is the case here at all, but it is something we should be mindful of. Some officers are under some financial pressure and they don’t dump those worries when they come to work.’
Hmm, so being honest is dependent on your pay level?
It doesn't seem to have worked with MPs and Bankers, so why does he think it would with corrupt police officers?
It would seem to me that if a person is corrupt, then no amount of pay will dissuade them.
Is that a view shared?

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
I have wondered what position ACPO has within law enforcement? If I remember rightly it is a private limited company, yet is responsible for creating guidelines from which some forces operate (such as those relating to speed enforcement) as well as a lobby group for whatever interests suit it at the time.

I would prefer a group with greater transparency and accountability to undertake that role.


Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
I would prefer a group with greater transparency and accountability to undertake that role.
AIUI the whole point of ACPO 'Ltd' is that it can avoid transparency & accountability.

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
It would seem to me that if a person is corrupt, then no amount of pay will dissuade them.
It's the same as any other job or profession. If people have the opportunity they'll be tempted.

People in other jobs that commit crimes while at their place of work may seek to hide the evidence or implicate others. Why would we expect corrupt police officers to behave any differently?

Bent people exist in all walks of life. The police are no different from any other organisation in that respect.

Did this chap steal the desk diary or was it a stitch up?

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
Hmm, so being honest is dependent on your pay level?
It doesn't seem to have worked with MPs and Bankers, so why does he think it would with corrupt police officers?
It would seem to me that if a person is corrupt, then no amount of pay will dissuade them.
Is that a view shared?
There is ample research to show that if you show contempt for staff, levels of theft and damage increases. It has little to do with pay levels so much as the way the employee sees their contributions valued. However:

Going back to the 70s, when there was a high level of corruption in the Met and City forces, and in many country forces as well, pay was dreadful. Even a police officer in London, with the highest pay around the country, could claim supplementary benefit if he had three kids.

The going rate for 'turning a blind eye', e.g. not investigating leads properly, was £35 a week, about doubling a PC's wage.

I had my own house when I joined the service and within 9 months I had gone through my savings and my bank manager actually called me in before I went into the red. (Ah! Old style bank managers.) He offered good, sound advice. Even so I was going to leave the job and it was only being given private work by my superintendent that got me through. It was against regulations, but then needs must I thought.

If you were at risk from losing your home, would you be more inclined to break regulations? If you broke regulations and then were offered a considerable sum just to not do your job, would you feel tempted if, like me, you could not afford to heat your house despite working all but three days a month?

On top of that the most likely way a bent copper will be put away nowadays is by another copper. Now if your colleague is struggling to pay his mortgage, heat his home, or other pressing need, then if you see he's doing something slightly wrong, and you know by your actions he will lose his job, his home, his partner and probably access to his kids, and you also know that your hard work is not valued, then it is tempting to turn away and carry on doing your own thing.

That said, my opinion is that people organising the corrupt practices went bent mainly for the thrill of it all. Those lower down were corrupted by their need for money.

On top of that, and equally important, was that higher pay attracted higher quality officers, and these were more reluctant to risk a good job for a few quid. Pay virtually doubled as we went into the 80s and, it would appear, the costs of bribing officers became prohibitive. Further, it was more rewarding working with higher quality officers. This encourages more quality people to apply.

A friend of mine has a son who wants to be a police officer. My mate, retired, said that he wanted to put him off but didn't want to force his ideas onto his kids. But one wonders what he would have said to, for instance, a graduate who asked whether it was a good idea to join. Or rather, one doesn't.

If history teaches us anything it is that we learn nothing from it. The current destruction of the conditions of service of officers has had a major effect on morale, more than the drop in wages, even with the severity of that. Many officers are now marking time until jobs come available in the private sector with more pay, much better conditions and a better press. The opportunities for corruption in the service are as available as they have always been. I can see corruption increasing tremendously, albeit from its current low level. Go onto the continent and see how corrupt some of the forces are there. They are better paid in the main that England/Wales officers.

In another thread, someone complained about the standard of police enquiries in the 70s. Given that the pay level was equivalent to bus drivers, it is remarkable that it was was good. Once the 80s got into its stride, with higher pay and higher quality staff, performance levels went up dramatically.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
carinaman said:
Did this chap steal the desk diary or was it a stitch up?
He got 12 months.

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks Rovinghawk. I didn't read the piece, but colleagues accusing people of stealing a desk dairy sounded a bit like office politics mudslinging to me.

If it's about pay wouldn't the greatest number of convicted and jailed police officers be unpaid Special Constables?

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
carinaman said:
Thanks Rovinghawk.
It's humour- stealing a diary, getting 12 months?

Whoosh?

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
If low pay is the reason that people are corrupt then we would be in the midst of a crime spree. The wages, working conditions and prospective pensions of most of the population has deteriorated over the last 5 years or so.
It would appear that the most corrupt in society are those who are those at the higher end of pay scales and fines to banks etc for misselling of their products is an example, as is politicians expenses. If a Police Constable on £25000 a year can be dishonest then even doubling the salary will not change them, they will just want more.

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Daily Mail said:
Why did police chiefs keep quiet about arrest of their chief executive? Civilian employee was accused of stealing a desk diary from Whitehall office?
He was allowed to leave ACPO and return to 'normal' police duties?

The article doesn't say whether the desk diary was recovered. It was a case of sabotage and/or office politics? The desk diary was a single point of failure. If there was an electronic diary there would have been a back up.

I don't put that much store in police disciplinary procedures. He may not have done it. I think that not facing criminal charges may be just as much an indication of a stitch up as allowing him to get away with it and slink off back to his police job.

Of more concern is ACPO seeking to drop 'Ltd.' from their name?


Edited by carinaman on Monday 13th January 12:17

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
ACPO was once a credible organisation.

Now it's a political organisation (and a Ltd. Co. as well)... scratchchin

Mill Wheel

Original Poster:

6,149 posts

227 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
aw51 121565 said:
ACPO was once a credible organisation.

Now it's a political organisation (and a Ltd. Co. as well)... scratchchin
And it's advice is held up in court and observed by magistrates.

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
http://www.acpo.police.uk/documents/CCCabinet%20mi...

See 5.3, 5.5 and 8.2

I wonder if 5.2 references the investigation into Fed 3 Sutton Coldfield meeting with MITCHELL?

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
and again the ACPO is a limited company canard is brought up.

Most large charities are also limited companies ... Interestingly they often have to have a subsidiary company to undertake some trading as their Ltd by guarantee company is held to the charity registration by the articles of association ( e.g. St John Ambulance is a Charity and a company limited by Guarantee , but it also has a couple of wholly owned subsidiaries to undertake trading activities outside those permitted for the main company / charity )

unforunately UK company law doesn't treat ' registered charity' as a form or company - so they are generally companies limited by guarantee or companies with minimal share capital ...

the CIC legal calssification was brought about to try to address this but it seems that being both a Charity and CIC causes more difficulties and many Charities are unwilling to relinquish their charity registration due to the kind of pointless mudslinging that comes from anything to do cahrities and their corporate legal persona...

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
mph1977 said:
and again the ACPO is a limited company canard is brought up.

Most large charities are also limited companies ....
How is it a canard? A group of senior police form a group to formulate joint policy; why should it be a limited company?

Charities aren't taxpayer funded & don't have the power to influence law enforcement that ACPO does.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
rewc said:
If low pay is the reason that people are corrupt then we would be in the midst of a crime spree. The wages, working conditions and prospective pensions of most of the population has deteriorated over the last 5 years or so.
It would appear that the most corrupt in society are those who are those at the higher end of pay scales and fines to banks etc for misselling of their products is an example, as is politicians expenses. If a Police Constable on £25000 a year can be dishonest then even doubling the salary will not change them, they will just want more.
We are in the midst of corruption.

I was involved in the initial stages of an enquiry into a local government department. Everyone took a consideration.

Low pay is not 'the' reason. Indeed, it might not even by the main reason. But it is a reason, something that starts improper behaviour.

Say you were hard up and at risk of having to leave the police. You tell your chief superintendent and he says there is a regular sporting event that needs bouncers. You turn up, spend four hours serving drinks to east end villains, even recognising people you've nicked. You gleefully accept the tips, and at the end of each evening you get paid more than a week's wage. Oddly, and rather ironically, more than the bent coppers get each week. And this fee will be exceeded by the tips.

I know a number of police officers who did this. It is not corrupt as such, just against a code of conduct.

It is a simple step from that to doing other little just jobs.

It is easy for those with next week's food bill paid for to say it is wrong, but put yourself in the place of a PC working all but 3 days a month, with a baby and a toddler. Getting food parcels from one's parents when he should be providing for his own family. I bet some police officers were in that position and I bet they gave into the temptation to be a bouncer.

I don't know why other jobs and professions go bent but if you are getting into debt, as many police officers were in the 70s, and had the opportunity to show favours, then there is a great temptation. After all, who would you be hurting? Some garage will get the tow business, and a body has to be buried. So an undetakers slip you a fiver for calling them first. Things still tick over.

The reason that corruption flourishes is a weak discipline/investigative system. That's what gave rise to the high level corruption. No one bothered, in fact it was encouraged. Traffic wardens who invent offences are supported by their bosses.

When money increased in the service, so did the quality of the recruits. As we got more comfortable, the risk wasn't seen as worthwhile. Many of those required to leave during the Countryman enquiry into police corruption went on to powerful roles in banking, forming a firm within a firm there, according to some.

ACPO officers have nothing in the way of a discipline dept overlooking them. It was done by the government in the case of the Mets so when certain media moguls formed close liaisons with senior MPs and ACPO followed suit, who is to complain? And to whom?

After all, ACPO officers had a social life with their equals, and editors and the like fall into that category, don't they? What could go wrong?

I mean, apart from what went on.

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
Charities aren't taxpayer funded & don't have the power to influence law enforcement that ACPO does.
Who democratically elected ACPO? Has the Queen given them a Royal Warrant or something?

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
mph1977 said:
and again the ACPO is a limited company canard is brought up.

Most large charities are also limited companies ....
How is it a canard? A group of senior police form a group to formulate joint policy; why should it be a limited company?

Charities aren't taxpayer funded & don't have the power to influence law enforcement that ACPO does.
what other legal persona should ACPO have ?

a traditional partnership ? an LLP ? a CIC ? a none departmental government body ? QUANGO ?

there have been policing policy NDGBs and QUANGos operating in parallel ...

my point with Charities is that some people seem to presume that becasue a charity is a Ltd company as well it is somehow 'not a charity any more ' or 'doesn;t care about it;s charitable objectives ' ... usually when their wants as volunteers / commercial customers are not met ...

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
mph1977 said:
what other legal persona should ACPO have ? ...
None. When I get together with colleagues to discuss how to do things we don't need a legal persona.

It could just be a gathering of folks in the same profession.

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
mph1977 said:
what other legal persona should ACPO have ? ...
None. When I get together with colleagues to discuss how to do things we don't need a legal persona.

It could just be a gathering of folks in the same profession.
do you object to other professional assocaitions and professional representative organisations having a legal persona of their own and setting policy and guidance ( like the Medical Royal Colleges, the RCN and RCM, CPSM etc etc etc )?