Trademark question
Author
Discussion

tjl

Original Poster:

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Trying to help my 21 year old son who has got off his backside for a change and set up his own video production business. He's making good progress, website established a few months ago, starting to get some interesting work. Mostly corporate video, some sporting events etc a mixture of work where he is sub-contracting as a camera man but he's now out touting for new business himself as the returns are better. Fair play to him so far. Sole trader not a limited company as yet.

Out of the blue this morning he received a letter from someone who advises that they are the owner of "Word Trademarks" that appear in my son's website name. Son's website is www."registeredmark".co.uk. I've checked the online register and the words appear to have been trademarked in 2007. Both businesses appear to be working in the same field. The letter is essentially a cease and desist letter giving him 1 month to stop using the mark quoting section 10(1) Trade Marks Act 1994. The letter also states that the owner has built up a strong reputation in the marks over 16 years.

Any trademark knowledge out there ? He would struggle to afford any proper legal advice and I'm not sure where to turn. I would hate to have to tell him that he has to start over and re-brand everything he has tried to create, create new websites etc


Joeguard1990

1,217 posts

157 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
It doesn't sound good tbh... If the name is the same and someone else has the trademark and is going about getting him to change it lawfully then I can't see your Son keeping the name.

On the plus side, I would have thought that your Son would be able to keep the same website address. He has purchased the domain name so is rightefully his to host whatever he wants on.

Martin4x4

6,506 posts

163 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Is the other business in the UK? Because I find it difficult to believe they would register a world wide trademark but not the domain. Assuming they are a foreign company they are trying this because they don't have a leg to stand on unless they can afford to pursue an action in the UK.

Domain names (WebSite addresses) are not trademarks and a trademark doesn't give you automatic right to the domain name. See http://www.nominet.org.uk/disputes

A trademark needs to more that just a general word, it is brand, a style, a logo etc. Assuming your son is not passing off a similar design/styling; it need not infringe the trademark rights.
http://www.ipo.gov.uk/types/tm/t-about/t-whatis.ht...

What is the word? Is it general word, a made up word?

Sounds like an attempt at domain hijacking, perhaps because your son has done well getting good organic search placement.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_domain_hijack...

DO not OFFER to sell them the domain, it significantly weakness his position. If they are serious they will make an offer.



Edited by Martin4x4 on Tuesday 14th January 23:11

V8LM

5,566 posts

240 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Joeguard1990 said:
It doesn't sound good tbh... If the name is the same and someone else has the trademark and is going about getting him to change it lawfully then I can't see your Son keeping the name.

On the plus side, I would have thought that your Son would be able to keep the same website address. He has purchased the domain name so is rightefully his to host whatever he wants on.
I doubt he could use the website for a business in the same field as the one who has registered the trade mark. Best bet would be to get the other company to buy the domain name from him, and rebrand.

tjl

Original Poster:

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks all for taking the trouble to reply. The other party is a UK business - I don't think it's a limited company. To give some background on the domain name issue, without giving away the parties details, my son has a website called www."name of animal"productions.co.uk and the other party has www."name of animal".ws - ws extension seems to be high level domain for Western Samoa. The registered trademark is "name of animal" productions.

I'm not sure if this is a domain name issue or a trademark issue or both !!

Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Let me get this straight, he named his company the same as an existing company which does the same thing and has a trademark on the name?

How does he possibly hope to have a leg to stand on?

tjl

Original Poster:

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Disco You said:
Let me get this straight, he named his company the same as an existing company which does the same thing and has a trademark on the name?

How does he possibly hope to have a leg to stand on?
He probably doesn't but I thought I would try and see if there were helpful folks on PH who might have a view. Neither business appear to be companies - sole traders as best I can find out. He did purchase a .co.uk domain name that was available

Vaud

60,043 posts

186 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
One moment.

.ws is not widely used. I have never (to my knowledge) encountered a UK company using .ws

Have a read at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.ws ".ws has been marketed as a domain hack, with the .ws purportedly standing for "World Site" or "Web site", providing a "global" internet presence to registrants."

Without knowing the details, this is a possibility, and your son has been targeted by a company that operates, much like patent trolls, on a basis of claiming the ownership to a domain space with only a shell company behind it - if any - speculative trading, if you like. Send out enough letters, enough threats, you get a live one and settle for £500, etc.

As I say, possibility, only a possibility. For a small fee he/you could look at companies house (unless as you say they are not a ltd company) and see how active the company is and use that to judge how likely they are to take action.

My gut feel is it is a domain troll pushing speculative boiler plate letters - and you would see no further action, but I am neither a lawyer, nor qualified to advise - and don't have all the facts, etc. So my advice should be treated with extreme caution.

in fact, wait for a real lawyer or barrister, one will be along shortly.





SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
tjl said:
I've checked the online register and the words appear to have been trademarked in 2007. Both businesses appear to be working in the same field.
Why are you asking here, when effectively you've answered your own question?

And I find it bizarre that "Both businesses appear to be working in the same field". You're not telling us the whole story (as usual).



Vaud

60,043 posts

186 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
tjl said:
I've checked the online register and the words appear to have been trademarked in 2007. Both businesses appear to be working in the same field.
Define same "field". Which register was looked up?


Just a thought: do trademarks automatically entitle a trademark holder to the domain name?
The WIPO has a view: http://www.wipo.int/sme/en/faq/tm_faqs_q2.html

tjl

Original Poster:

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
Why are you asking here, when effectively you've answered your own question?

And I find it bizarre that "Both businesses appear to be working in the same field". You're not telling us the whole story (as usual).
I am telling the whole story and am trying to help a perhaps naïve 21 year old deal with an issue that he doesn't have the skills to deal with a neither do I. He's trying to develop a video / cameraman business rather than sitting at home scratching his a*se. He might not have been thorough in his homework before he started but I'm just trying to help him out as any good dad would

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
tjl said:
I'm just trying to help him out as any good dad would
And that's just as it should be.

tjl said:
I've checked the online register and the words appear to have been trademarked in 2007.
Now you know how to advise your son.



tjl

Original Poster:

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Vaud said:
Define same "field". Which register was looked up?


Just a thought: do trademarks automatically entitle a trademark holder to the domain name?
The WIPO has a view: http://www.wipo.int/sme/en/faq/tm_faqs_q2.html
Vaud - in his letter , the other party gave the reference number for the trademark registration which I checked on the IPO.gov.uk website to see if it was valid, which it appears to be. The fields covered were class 9 and class 41 which seem to cover video production,film etc

tjl

Original Poster:

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
Now you know how to advise your son.
I'm still not sure I do - he purchased the domain name. confused

Vaud

60,043 posts

186 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Check his professional insurance, etc, you may have legal cover for this. It's a minefield. But I would be surprised that company going to the trouble of UK trademarking didn't also register every domain name going.

Either way, trademark rights don't, as I understand it, confer automatic domain name rights, but I might be mistaken and happy to be corrected. Is the letter targeted at his company as a whole, or just the domain name presence?

tjl

Original Poster:

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Vaud said:
Check his professional insurance, etc, you may have legal cover for this. It's a minefield. But I would be surprised that company going to the trouble of UK trademarking didn't also register every domain name going.

Either way, trademark rights don't, as I understand it, confer automatic domain name rights, but I might be mistaken and happy to be corrected. Is the letter targeted at his company as a whole, or just the domain name presence?
Vaud - the letter says "I note that you are using the infringing mark on your website and in connection with the production and distribution of ...... video recordings". I doesn't make any reference to the domain name. As I mentioned earlier, this other party appears to also be a sole trader. He did have a limited company 10 years or so ago in a similar ltd company name but this has since been dissolved. I don't think he is a scammer despite the .ws domain name. His website has a UK mobile number and he seems to specialise in wedding videos and appears legit.

Vaud

60,043 posts

186 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
I think this is best left to the experts - one will be along shortly. I've asked all my useful (hopefully) questions. I don't want to give you legal advice as I'm not a lawyer and I'm at my limit.

That said, sole traders aren't known for their deep pockets, so my highly uneducated guess is that this is a quick boilerplate desist letter, but don't rely on that in anything else than an opinion. No good uk trader in my view would trademark AND then pick .ws instead of the available.co.uk domain.

tjl

Original Poster:

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Vaud said:
I think this is best left to the experts - one will be along shortly. I've asked all my useful (hopefully) questions. I don't want to give you legal advice as I'm not a lawyer and I'm at my limit.

That said, sole traders aren't known for their deep pockets, so my highly uneducated guess is that this is a quick boilerplate desist letter, but don't rely on that in anything else than an opinion. No good uk trader in my view would trademark AND then pick .ws instead of the available.co.uk domain.
Vaud - thanks. I appreciate your thoughts on this.

Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
If he is using a name that is a tardemark then the domain is only one aspect of the issue - the content of the site will be in breach as well.

If you register a tarde mark then you have exclusive sue of it - whilst that does not mean you can lay claim to every domain, if it is likely to cause confusing then he is prob stuffed - even if the domain doesnt if he is using the name on the actual site then he might be stuffed.

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1994/26/sectio...
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1994/26/sectio...

As someone else has said, if he has basically copied another company then he had made brought it on himself.

Martin4x4

6,506 posts

163 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
You can check Company Registrations at:

http://wck2.companieshouse.gov.uk//wcframe?name=ac...

I pretty sure I've identified both site, his is designed by Therapy and your sons by Cude.

To infringe the style has to be identical or very similar, but it is immediately obvious you son's domain name is different from the trademark word. The Trademark is the single word. You sons domain name adds productions. The style of both websites is very different, his is traditional your sons modern. The trademark doesn't seem to cover video production which is classes 38 & 41.

The case for claiming infringement seems weak.

I would respond by denying infringement on the grounds there is clearly no attempt to pass-off and request specific details on what he considers to be the infringement. Give him the same 1 month or you will consider the matter closed.


Edited by Martin4x4 on Wednesday 15th January 00:14


Edited by Martin4x4 on Wednesday 15th January 00:28