Letting agency went bust - what happens to the deposit?
Letting agency went bust - what happens to the deposit?
Author
Discussion

CraigyMc

Original Poster:

18,374 posts

267 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Mods - if this doesn't belong in SP&L please feel free to move it.

Chaps, I rarely ask for advice on here and I'm not much one for whining so hopefully someone can give a (non legally binding but) professional opinion.
I'll be taking formal legal advice on this as soon as I can practicably do so, but in the meantime perhaps you can help me sleep. I'm working the next couple of days and will be in the air a lot during office hours.

The issue:
I've been happily living in the same privately rented property since 2009, always with the same local lettings agency managing the property on behalf of our landlady. The management appears to consist of 6-monthly failures to perform an inventory, and yearly successes in arranging for a gas safety check.

The problem I have is that the letting agents have apparently ceased trading - simply put, since November last year there's a big pile of mail at their door, nobody answers the phone and the director has apparently disappeared, at least according to the news. Their interim accounts were due at the close of 2013, and weren't filed. The lettings agency has ceased to be.

In November, a couple of days after they "did a runner", I noted this news in the press and talked to the landlady - we agreed that the lettings agency had ceased to exist from a functional point of view.
I started paying my landlady the rent directly, my bank to her bank, bypassing the apparently defunct lettings agency.
There was no interruption to the rent payments - the first payment direct to her happened on the same day as it would have gone to the agents - indeed there have been any issue with rent payments since I took residence: I'm a model tenant.

The thing at issue is that the letting agency were holding the deposit which I paid on the day I moved in, which was in 2009 - so it would appear that the deposit has disappeared too.

My question is this - assuming nothing that would cause the deposit to be witheld, who is liable for the deposit once the agreement comes to an end? - the landlady, or the newly-disappeared agents?
I suppose my real question is: if the letting agents go bust, is the landlady responsible for returning the deposit to me, or am I shafted?

The apparently absent agency were members of the TDS (the tenancy deposit scheme) - and I have a letter from the TDS saying the deposit is still protected, but will no longer be protected from February 14th 2014 onward.

The landlady wants to appoint a new agency (a big chain) and the chain are directing me to raise a dispute with the TDS because "the landlady can't" and "because it's the only way you'll get your deposit". I am highly suspicious of recieving advice like this from people who
(a) aren't legally qualified to give me advice and
(b) are subect to a conflict of interest (being that they are probably going to be my landlady's new agents).

In addition to this, I don't think the TDS scheme exists to cover this situation.

From what I've read, the TDS seems to exist to arbitrate arguments over the amount of deposit witheld by a landlord from a tenant at the end of a tenancy, rather than to protect the tenant or landlord against the insolvency of a letting agent who hold the deposit.

I need legal advice to unpick this situation without losing the deposit or ending up accused of fraud against the TDS.
It's currently my understanding that the missing letting agents were simply agents of the landlady (operating on her behalf) and that she is responsible for returning my deposit to me at the end of the tenancy.

I can afford to lose the deposit, which is in the order of £1200. I'm not struggling financially at all - but this is causing a lot of stress which I don't cope with well. I find it very hard to concentrate or sleep when something like this is unresolved.

Any thoughts gratefully recieved.

Edited by CraigyMc on Wednesday 15th January 19:07

standardman

424 posts

199 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
http://www.ablepropertytrust.co.uk/wp-content/uplo...

Ultimately the landlord is liable to return the deposit. If they chose a crap agent, their issue.


anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Absent any agreement to the contrary, the deposit was held by the agent as agent for the landlord. The clue is in the word agent. The landlord will be liable to return the deposit minus reasonable deductions when the tenancy ends. The risk here falls on the landlord, not on you.

CraigyMc

Original Poster:

18,374 posts

267 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Thank you both for your input.

I am sitting here shaking. It's ridiculous: I spend similar amounts of money to this on Motorsport in any given summer month.

I think it's the conflict-with-people rather than the value of the money thats getting to me.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
That is always unpleasant, and is a good reason for avoiding legal disputes if at all possible, but try to relax here, as you are in the right.

CraigyMc

Original Poster:

18,374 posts

267 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
That is always unpleasant, and is a good reason for avoiding legal disputes if at all possible, but try to relax here, as you are in the right.
So: I think I know where I stand.

If you would indulge me with a "how bad can it get" type scenario, if it got as far as me moving out (at a mutually agreed time, say in 2+months), and the landlady refused to return the deposit, would I have to go to court to have it returned to me?

Would my inaction (not raising a dispute under the TDS scheme) reduce the amount of deposit paid back to me if I won some sort of decision?

I don't think small claims courts deal with property matters, so I'd probably need some sort of professional used to cour proceedings to do the work if it got that far -- or perhaps something like a letter before action might sort it out (although my landlady would probably have a heart attack).

Does anyone have an idea of the cost of:
  • a letter (the cost of which I assume would be lost forever) - assuming this is even applicable to this sort of dispute
  • court proceedings, and would that be likely refunded back to me, or would it be lost forever?
I need to speak to a solicitor, but they don't work the hours I'm available this week!

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
You could sue the landlord for the return of a deposit. TDS can resolve the dispute if the parties agree to use TDS as alternative dispute resolution. County Courts deal with property matters all the time.

Worry not.

No need for a solicitor at the moment. The sky is not falling. Solicitors cost what they cost, and cheap ones are to be avoided, but you are unlikely to need one.

skeggysteve

5,724 posts

248 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
.....Motorsport in any given summer month....
That got my attention! If you need any help give me a shout.

Firstly I'd contact the TDS and explain the situation I'm sure you will not be the first person to be in this situation.

Secondly, listen to Breadvan, he is a lawyer type so trust him.

Don't worry it I'm sure it will all work out fine.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
skeggysteve said:
... listen to Breadvan, he is a lawyer type so trust him.

...
mwahahahahahahahahahahahahaha! Another one reeled in!

Please sign here.

Gareth79

9,177 posts

277 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Why is the TDS saying the deposit won't be protected from Feb 14th? Some of them work where the actual cash is deposited with them, the others work where a fee is paid to insure the deposit amount. Possibly it's the latter and a fee needs to be paid to renew this?

Regardless it's 100% not your problem, I'd agree with the others and sit back and relax.


surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
You don't need to worry about it until you leave.

Your landlady probably needs to do something to re-protect it....

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Out of curiosity this wouldn't be in Dorset would it? Specifically, Shaftesbury?

CraigyMc

Original Poster:

18,374 posts

267 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Durzel said:
Out of curiosity this wouldn't be in Dorset would it? Specifically, Shaftesbury?
No. Hampshire.

Triumph Man

9,654 posts

199 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Durzel said:
Out of curiosity this wouldn't be in Dorset would it? Specifically, Shaftesbury?
Ah yes the infamous whatsername. I work just across the courtyard from that place, they still seem to be going...

Fish

4,064 posts

313 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
If the Landlady changes agents and the deposit is held in the deposit protection scheme then it's control is just passed to the new agents and it really isn't a problem. I think there is some notifying to do to the TDs but that is it. It is certainly what we did when we bought a block of flats which the landlord had gone bust and we bought it off the administrators.

The only potential issue is one of the about 4 protection schemes that is approved doesn't physically rely on holding the money they allow the agent to keep it and they provide an insurance if they go bust, HOWEVER the insurance payout terms are quite crap and you have to move out etc etc to get it back.

But from what you have said the money is probably in the protection account and you should have been given details when you moved in.. just a case of assigning it to the new agent.

I shouldn't worry too much, just speak to them

CraigyMc

Original Poster:

18,374 posts

267 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Gareth79 said:
Why is the TDS saying the deposit won't be protected from Feb 14th?
The letting agent that has done a runner was kicked out of the TDS scheme by the TDS administrator.
They actually sent me a letter to that effect on 14th November 2013 - it was my first sign that something was going wrong with the letting agent.

Gareth79 said:
Some of them work where the actual cash is deposited with them, the others work where a fee is paid to insure the deposit amount. Possibly it's the latter and a fee needs to be paid to renew this?
The TDS is one of the ones that doesn't actually hold deposits itself - in this case the letting agent was supposed to have them in a separate account from the general day-to-day business expenses. I'd not be surprised if the money was now somewhere on the costa del sol alond with the director of the lettings agency.

As I understand it (I've been reading about this quite a bit, obviously) - there are only three tenancy approved deposit schemes in the UK (there were four, but the one operated by Capita is closed to new customers and shuts down completely for any remaining customers in September this year). Of the three that are still open (Tenancy Deposit Scheme, MyDeposits, Deposit Protection Service), only the latter (the DPS) actually holds the money itself in a sort of escrow account away from landlord, agent and tenant. The TDS and MyDeposits ones recommend that the deposit is kept somewhere safe (in a landlord or agent account).

My arrangement was set up under the TDS, which the now-long-gone lettings agent were a member of.
As I said, the TDS themselves sent letters to all the tenants telling me that the agent were being struck off their scheme.

Edited by CraigyMc on Wednesday 15th January 22:06

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
how exactly do they suggest the deposit is protected until feb?

NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
If the new agency thought there was a problem then surely they'd be pressing you to pay another deposit - has there been any suggestion of that?

You seem to be in some degree of contact with the landlady - what's her attitude to this situation? She might be horrified that you're thinking you'll lose out.

CraigyMc

Original Poster:

18,374 posts

267 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
pork911 said:
how exactly do they suggest the deposit is protected until feb?
Basically, if I devide to move out and there's some disagreement between the landlord and I over the amount of deposit I should get back (for example, if I think I should have £1200 and she decides she thinks £800 is fair) -- then the TDP arbitrate the disagreement to keep things out of court.

As I understand it, that's the "protection" they provide. I don't know for sure what happens in the case where a letting agent ceases responding to any communications.

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
pork911 said:
how exactly do they suggest the deposit is protected until feb?
Basically, if I devide to move out and there's some disagreement between the landlord and I over the amount of deposit I should get back (for example, if I think I should have £1200 and she decides she thinks £800 is fair) -- then the TDP arbitrate the disagreement to keep things out of court.

As I understand it, that's the "protection" they provide. I don't know for sure what happens in the case where a letting agent ceases responding to any communications.
what's the point in arbitrating if as you appear to think the money has gone?

you need to specifically ask them 'do you hold the money or did the agent? if the agent, how am I still protected?'

it may well be that you've fallen into a regulatory gap but perhaps not