Civil law - appeals
Author
Discussion

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Person A wants to sue Company B.

The case goes to the county court (small claims track or whatever).

Person A wins but there is a debate over interpretation of law so Company B appeals.

In this case, is it possible if Person A loses in the higher court they will have to pay Company B's legal costs?

I spose what I am asking in a roundabout way is, if Person A takes an unclear legal point to court and wins but then Company wins the appeal can Person A end up liable for costs even though they mdo not want the appeal and it would be the county courts fault for getting it wrong - after all if Person A lost at county court they would at worse be liable for limited costs. Or is there protection against this so small timers do not have to take a risk when making a small claim?

Conversley I spose it is a given if Person A loses in small claims and appeals they are liable for costs if they lose in the appeal too?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
In answer to your question, costs in small claims appeals are limited by Civil Procedure Rule 27.14

http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/c...


To broaden the topic somewhat, outside the small claims track, on appeal from a County Court costs will ordinarily follow the event, so the loser pays. Costs orders are, however, discretionary and not automatic. The risk that the Court will make an appealable error is inherent in any system which allows a right of appeal. As the old adage goes "everyone is presumed to know the law, except the Judge, from whom there is a right of appeal".

In some circumstances, where a party seeks to raise a question of general public importance, the Court can at the outset of the case grant a Protective Costs Order, so that exposure to the opposing party's costs will be limited. This happens in public law cases, and would rarely if ever happen in a boggo A vs B civil dispute.

Costs risks put a brake on litigation. In the US, the loser rarely has to pay the winner's costs (they call loser pays "the English rule"), and look what happens there.



Edited by anonymous-user on Thursday 16th January 09:51

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
I suppose the question for Person A then is how much risk do they want to take in suing Company B if there is a chance they could end up in a higher court. Company B are likely to appeal if they lose as it would affect their business model if they lost - I appreciate county courts are not binding but still worth soemthing.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
The costs risk is modest if the case is allocated to the small claim track, even if there is an appeal.

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
I have read that if you are in the county court and there is an appeal it can be heard by a district judge and then the high court.

I spose if you appeal from the county court and it is heard by a district judge who is still in the county court it is not binding? it only would be if it went up to the high court.

thanks

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
You would never appeal to a District Judge as that is the lowest tier in the court. You can appeal from a DJ to a Circuit Judge. Some appeals can go from County Court to High Court.

Any decision on appeal binds the parties to the appeal (subject to any further appeal, if such is possible).

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
You would never appeal to a District Judge as that is the lowest tier in the court. You can appeal from a DJ to a Circuit Judge. Some appeals can go from County Court to High Court.

Any decision on appeal binds the parties to the appeal (subject to any further appeal, if such is possible).
Thanks - I meant Circuit not District.

In terms of binding - as this is an area where the law is not clear it would be useful to have a precedent binding all county courts (not just the people in this case). but this would need to ocme from High Court not County Court even if circuit judge?

I think it would make a difference because Person A would welcoem a binding precedent even if they lost but Company B probably wouldn't if they lost as it could affect them and many other businesses.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
No county court decision sets a precedent or binds anyone other than the parties to it. A High Court decision binds every County Court, but one High Court Judge is not bound by the decision of another, although he or she will likely be persuaded by that decision. The Court of Appeal binds every Court below it. The Supreme Court likewise.

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
OK one more.

The case is heard by the district judge and is appealed - it could go to the circuit judge or the high court.

Iguess going to the circuit judge would limit costs but going to the high court will get a better legal result as it will set a precedent and create case law.

Does the district judge where the appeal goes? (I presume a circuit judge is not binding like the high court or can it be?)

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
As indicated above, a decision by a circuit judge in a county court binds only the parties to it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
For appeal routes, see Table 1 in this Practice Direction.

http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/c...