Vehicle damage from roof tiles (storm damage)
Vehicle damage from roof tiles (storm damage)
Author
Discussion

braddo

Original Poster:

12,417 posts

219 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
I have a scooter that is parked at the end of my street and during the big windy storms a few weeks ago, some roof tiles were blown off the nearest building and landed on my scooter. It has caused some damage that could potentially be expensive to fix (it's a 60s Vespa and the tiles punctured and dented some of the pressed steel chassis).

Is it feasible to claim for any repair cost through the building owner's buildings insurance?

I don't know the building owner(s); the building is a Victorian terrace comprising 2 flats so it is possible the building freehold owner does not live at the address and/or is someone separate to the flat owners/leaseholders.

My guess is that the building owner will be reluctant to put in a claim on their insurance for the damaged caused to my scooter. I could start with asking nicely but if they say no (or more likely try to ignore me and not respond) would I have to threaten going through the small claims court or something?


Thanks

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Unless the tiles blew off because of some carelessness on the part of the owner of the house (eg failure to maintain the roof), the owner has no liability to you. The owner's insurance will only pay out if the insurer has a liability to you, and none arises from a mere accident caused by bad weather.

braddo

Original Poster:

12,417 posts

219 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Ah, thanks. beer

I knew I should have organised getting rid of the ludicrously big excess on my scooter insurance. banghead


roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Unless the tiles blew off because of some carelessness on the part of the owner of the house (eg failure to maintain the roof)
Very likely BV? Victorian House should have slate on it, so nail sick springs to mind. If the OP see's some Roofers up there repairing it, a few pics would help.

stewjohnst

2,479 posts

192 months

Saturday 18th January 2014
quotequote all
I've got a company car I'm bored of with 18 months left to run on it. I also have a 150 year old beech tree on the drive and every time it's stormy I park under it hoping a few limbs will fall and crush the car.

Even with the storms of late God has not seen fit to unleash timber related destruction on the car...who can I sue for this failure to deliver?

bimsb6

8,811 posts

252 months

Saturday 18th January 2014
quotequote all
stewjohnst said:
I've got a company car I'm bored of with 18 months left to run on it. I also have a 150 year old beech tree on the drive and every time it's stormy I park under it hoping a few limbs will fall and crush the car.

Even with the storms of late God has not seen fit to unleash timber related destruction on the car...who can I sue for this failure to deliver?
The problem as i see it is which god to sue ?

wibble cb

4,182 posts

238 months

Saturday 18th January 2014
quotequote all
stewjohnst said:
I've got a company car I'm bored of with 18 months left to run on it. I also have a 150 year old beech tree on the drive and every time it's stormy I park under it hoping a few limbs will fall and crush the car.

Even with the storms of late God has not seen fit to unleash timber related destruction on the car...who can I sue for this failure to deliver?
This was actually your fault, you don't live in Toronto:




Some trees came down recently...eek