Minor RTA.....easy case of their fault?
Minor RTA.....easy case of their fault?
Author
Discussion

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
had a very minor bump.... Believe I am in the right, but you never know with these things.... Any possible reason why an insurance company could argue I am partially ( or otherwise) at fault....


Driving along a 30 mph road. Ahead of me is a mini raised roundabout and a left turn. I intend to proceed across the roundabout.

As I approach a car also approaches from the left turn. We both slow...... I assume she is doing so as I have right of way, I am slowing because the raised roundabout requires a small amount of negotiation ( it can't be straight lined)

As I enter onto the roundabout she pulls out with the intention of turning right ( to go down the road I had just driven along) - I had no time to break whatsoever but was not going quickly and struck her right in the middle of her car.

We both parked, exchange details and off we go.

Her car didn't look too bad but ( as is the way with crumple zones) neither her offside doors would open.... My car has front bumper damage and the bonnet struggles to open ( so maybe a bit bending somewhere)

So..... Give way to the right, she didn't - I'm in the clear?

TwigtheWonderkid

49,284 posts

181 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
Sounds like it, but don't use the phrase "I assume" when you report to insurers. Just stick to facts, you were already on the roundabout when she pulled out in front of you. keep it brief and to the point.

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
too wordy?


I (xxxxx, driving Ford xxx) was travelling along xxxxx Way in the direction of travel indicated by the red arrow (on attached diagram)
As I approached the roundabout I could see it was clear for me to proceed across as I had right of way over the vehicle approaching from xxxxx Drive to my left. As indicated by the blue arrow.
The roundabout is slightly raised and so cannot be driven straight across. As such, I was traveling significantly below the posted 30 mph speed limit in order to negotiate it.
I had already entered the roundabout when the car to my left accelerated into my path with the intention of turning right in order to proceed down xxxx Way (in the direction from which I had just come)
Although I was travelling at a low speed, the car entering from my left and crossing my path left me with very little time to brake. As a result, I struck the car at roughly its halfway point.
Both cars were able to leave the roundabout and park further down xxxxx Way.
The driver of the other car confirmed that she was not hurt nor injured and I did likewise.
Details were exchanged and the driver provide the following information:

xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx

xxxxx

I regard the other driver to be entirely at fault. They did not give way to my vehicle approaching from the right and my vehicle had already entered the roundabout at the time they decided to drive across it. This can be evidenced by the distance my car had travelled beyond the give way markings versus the distance their car traveled. In fact, their car had hardly crossed their own give way markings at all. Hence the ease with which they could (after the accident) simply steer left and drive in the opposite direction along xxxx Way to that which way intended (in order to exchange details)


SK425

1,034 posts

180 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
I think the question of who was on the roundabout first might have some relevance to priority, rather than just who was approaching from whose right.

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
...and she may claim that she was on the roundabout first.

SK425

1,034 posts

180 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
Tiggsy said:
too wordy?


I (xxxxx, driving Ford xxx) was travelling along xxxxx Way in the direction of travel indicated by the red arrow (on attached diagram)
As I approached the roundabout I could see it was clear for me to proceed across as I had right of way over the vehicle approaching from xxxxx Drive to my left. As indicated by the blue arrow.
Don't say that, for two reasons. Firstly, it's not right of way, it's priority. And secondly, having priority is not the same as it being clear to proceed. You don't want to give the impression that you made an unreasonable assumption that it would be safe to continue purely on the basis that you had priority.

[EDIT: Sorry - and thirdly, as above, approaching from her right might not have given you priority anyway]

Tiggsy said:
The roundabout is slightly raised and so cannot be driven straight across.
Don't say that either. Raised or otherwise, driving straight across is an offence. You don't want to give the impression that you don't know the rules of the road.


Edited by SK425 on Monday 20th January 12:03

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
So just say "it was clear for me to cross"?



Because of where I hit her it seems clear (to me!) that I was on the roundabout first (me blue)


SK425

1,034 posts

180 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
Tiggsy said:
Because of where I hit her it seems clear (to me!) that I was on the roundabout first (me blue)

I think it's perhaps less clear than if, for example, you'd got all the way in front of her and she'd hit the nearside of your car. But from the way you've drawn it you had travelled further onto the roundabout at the point of collision so the only way she could have entered first is if you were going faster than her.

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
What is it with women and mini-roundabouts. Twice recently when turning right at one I've had them coming from the opposite direction drive straight on across me. First time was bit of a shocker - second time I was half expecting it after noticing her "closing speed" Do they really not know what the roundabouts are for, or why other driver indicate to show where they are going.

(Male rant over)

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
You possibly don't want to say that she was intending to come down 'your' road.
You don't know that.

You just know she was indicating right.
She may have been planning to turn all the way round or planning to turn left but indicating incorrectly.


blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
Im not an insurance person but I feel sure this is being over thought.
Very few accidents could ever occur where liability is clearer than this, surely?

TwigtheWonderkid

49,284 posts

181 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
covboy said:
What is it with women and mini-roundabouts. Twice recently...
Twice eh...and both times women!! Well that's pretty conclusive. Two sounds like a pretty large sample to me. rolleyes

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Twice eh...and both times women!! Well that's pretty conclusive. Two sounds like a pretty large sample to me. rolleyes
Three timees if you count the one in the original post biggrin

motco

17,670 posts

277 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
Bitter experience suggests that you should expect her version of events to be radically different; i.e. she will most probably lie. Something along the lines of "...he beckoned me to go ahead of him...".

TwigtheWonderkid

49,284 posts

181 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
covboy said:
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Twice eh...and both times women!! Well that's pretty conclusive. Two sounds like a pretty large sample to me. rolleyes
Three timees if you count the one in the original post biggrin
I take it all back. Ban them all.

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
SK425 said:
I think it's perhaps less clear than if, for example, you'd got all the way in front of her and she'd hit the nearside of your car. But from the way you've drawn it you had travelled further onto the roundabout at the point of collision so the only way she could have entered first is if you were going faster than her.
I was thinking along these lines and to me it looks like it could have been an avoidable accident on the OP's part.

SydneyBridge

11,945 posts

189 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
What was said by the woman straight after the accident?

I take a lot of notice of what is immediately said, before people get home, calm down and think about things

Any witnesses?

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
I had exactly the same situation today, nothing to my right or ahead so went straight ahead, the road to my left comes from round a bend and as I entered the mini roundabout this woman in a 4x4 comes barreling up from the left, it was one of those WTF moments, surely she is going to slow down even if I was not there. She saw me at the very last second and slammed on, if I hadn't of noticed what was going on and took avoiding action ending up on the wrong side of the road I would have had 2 less doors tonight. As I gave here the evils she was muttering and swearing to herself like when you have been inconvenienced and drove off, obviously it was all my fault.

blank

3,767 posts

219 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm betting on 50/50.

It all comes down to who was on the roundabout first, and even from the diagrams it's very difficult to call.



That's the issue with mini roundabouts... If it's one of those where you can see there is nothing approaching from the right so carry on at 37mph then someone might (legally) enter the roundabout from your left, before you get there.

MonTheF1sh

241 posts

210 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
And that's one of the reasons I stuck some cash down on a camera.