Does the law have a common sense clause/approach?
Discussion
Over 40,000 fined for going over Lendal Bridge in York in 4 months:
http://www.yorkpress.co.uk/news/10941124.40_000_dr...
Seems to me that the signs must not be that obvious for that number of drivers to go over the bridge.
So as per the thread title is there a common sense approach to these things when going to appeal or is it just a case of you broke the law?
Before you ask, yes I do have a vested interest!
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.yorkpress.co.uk/news/10941124.40_000_dr...
Seems to me that the signs must not be that obvious for that number of drivers to go over the bridge.
So as per the thread title is there a common sense approach to these things when going to appeal or is it just a case of you broke the law?
Before you ask, yes I do have a vested interest!
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
How many of those are just arses who think the rules don't apply.
You see it all the time. Just like people who want to turn right at this roundabout - but who intentionally get in the left lane because the queue is shorter - then try to cut in on the roundabout itself causing chaos in the mornings.
http://goo.gl/maps/SxvJF
I'd be all for cameras at junctions like this.
You see it all the time. Just like people who want to turn right at this roundabout - but who intentionally get in the left lane because the queue is shorter - then try to cut in on the roundabout itself causing chaos in the mornings.
http://goo.gl/maps/SxvJF
I'd be all for cameras at junctions like this.
Breadvan72 said:
Some might even say that it is common sense to look at a sign that says something like "don't drive over this bridge" before driving over that bridge.
Trouble is the signs are not like that. My wife drove over it, following other cars (there are 4 in the photo), but didn't realise that it was Lendal Bridge she was crossing.As to the common sense side of it, I meant that if over 40,000 people have crossed the bridge does common sense not say that something fundamental must be wrong with the signage?
I accept that some people will ignore road signs but surely not over 40,000 in 4 months?
ATG - yes I think with that amount of extra £ York CC might well make extend the trial!
Oh and thanks Mr Breadvan for the Marx brothers clip - from days when the script meant more than the special effects. Are you a member of a club?

There was a junction near where I used to live that had magical powers.
Drivers who had driven sensibly and within the law for hours, days, weeks, months and years before would come to it and be converted to inattentive, stupid, selfish criminals who had no right to be on the road, at least according to the police inspector interviewed. Actually, he said unattentive, but this was before 1975 so was to be expected.
However, road engineers were able to defeat the mystical abilities of the location be removing some signs, placing others in a different location and modifying some white lines. Then drivers who had been law abiding were able to continue being so.
If a number of drivers who drive sensibly unintentionally break the law then there is something wrong with regards the signing or engineering at the location. This is a given.
Or rather, given the nice little earner it has become, something very right from the point of view of the beneficiaries.
Drivers who had driven sensibly and within the law for hours, days, weeks, months and years before would come to it and be converted to inattentive, stupid, selfish criminals who had no right to be on the road, at least according to the police inspector interviewed. Actually, he said unattentive, but this was before 1975 so was to be expected.
However, road engineers were able to defeat the mystical abilities of the location be removing some signs, placing others in a different location and modifying some white lines. Then drivers who had been law abiding were able to continue being so.
If a number of drivers who drive sensibly unintentionally break the law then there is something wrong with regards the signing or engineering at the location. This is a given.
Or rather, given the nice little earner it has become, something very right from the point of view of the beneficiaries.
mybrainhurts said:
Sheffield City Council had to refund fines after a bus gate's signs were deemed inadequate, but it took a long time and a lot of effort to happen.
This was going to be the gist of my reply too. The signs on The Wicker out of city were accidently difficult to see. Their hand was forced though.Strange considering how easy going they had always been about the tram/bus gate at Hillsborough Corner.
TooMany2cvs said:
Anybody nearby fancy posting a pic of the signage for this restriction? The Google streetview pics predate it.
This, please.I'm wondering why, if cars aren't allowed over it, that it's not bollarded or no entry.
Is it a bus lane or something?
To out it in context.
I wonder how many people drove into the Slough Bus lane in the last 4 months.
Is 40000 a lot in relative terms?
Snowboy said:
I'm wondering why, if cars aren't allowed over it, that it's not bollarded or no entry.
Is it a bus lane or something?
A quick google suggests it's a six-month "experiment". IOW people have got used to driving over it perfectly legally with brain firmly in neutral, and haven't bothered to notice the new signs...Is it a bus lane or something?
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


