Closed nursery - no refund?
Closed nursery - no refund?
Author
Discussion

iwantagta

Original Poster:

1,324 posts

176 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Hi all,
A friend uses a nursery that is on the employers premises, however she is a contractor not own staff,
Last week a burst watermain on the employers site meant the site had no water so they closed the nursery for 2 days (but kept the offices open).
She had to then take this time off work as no alternate childcare was available.
I assumed that in these circumstances the nursery would refund the 2 days – however they are saying no they will not, all they will offer is she can put the child in for 2 other days but this is no use really as she already has cover on those days.
I have looked through the contract and this appears to be the pertinent section;
No refunds will be given for any non-use by you of any booked session and/or any nursery closure. “Non-use” of a session shall include, without limitation, non-use due to holiday or sickness. “Nursery closure” shall include, limitation, closure of the nursery due to a Bank Holiday, a Public Holiday or inclement weather.
Reading this I take it she is up a creek without a paddle?
Irritatingly for her the actual employees or the main company are getting refunded by the employer but obviously nothing for contractors.
Its only £100 odd but it seems harsh that you end up paying for a service that isn’t provided for by no fault of your own.

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
iwantagta said:
Hi all,
A friend uses a nursery that is on the employers premises, however she is a contractor not own staff,
Last week a burst watermain on the employers site meant the site had no water so they closed the nursery for 2 days (but kept the offices open).
She had to then take this time off work as no alternate childcare was available.
I assumed that in these circumstances the nursery would refund the 2 days – however they are saying no they will not, all they will offer is she can put the child in for 2 other days but this is no use really as she already has cover on those days.
I have looked through the contract and this appears to be the pertinent section;
No refunds will be given for any non-use by you of any booked session and/or any nursery closure. “Non-use” of a session shall include, without limitation, non-use due to holiday or sickness. “Nursery closure” shall include, limitation, closure of the nursery due to a Bank Holiday, a Public Holiday or inclement weather.
Reading this I take it she is up a creek without a paddle?
Irritatingly for her the actual employees or the main company are getting refunded by the employer but obviously nothing for contractors.
Its only £100 odd but it seems harsh that you end up paying for a service that isn’t provided for by no fault of your own.
She's a contractor (as am I), with all the benefits that entails. She is lucky she is afforded use of facilities made available to her clients employees. Not worth rocking the boat for all sorts of reasons...

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
just because the terms and conditions say they don't have to give a refund even if they close the nursery, doesn't make it legal for them to do so

if you are not likely to use that nursery again soon then tell them to pay up

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
How does a burst water main come under the reasons for closure stated in their terms? If it was due to the cold then this isn't inclement unless it is far outside of what you would expect for the time of year. Freezing conditions are known as 'Winter'.

I would argue this one if it were me. They will argue that the closure wasn't their fault, which is true, but they should reclaim the sum from the property owner.

London John

341 posts

171 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
FM, end of.

adrewleck

11 posts

155 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
£100+ for 2 days?? I'm in the wrong job frown

tbc

3,017 posts

206 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
adrewleck said:
£100+ for 2 days?? I'm in the wrong job frown
two true, a colleague of mine put his kids into one of those 'posh' nurseries

the manager/owner of it drives a Quattroporte

make of that what you will

NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
tbc said:
make of that what you will
She's selling pictures of the kids on the internet?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
tbc said:
adrewleck said:
£100+ for 2 days?? I'm in the wrong job frown
two true, a colleague of mine put his kids into one of those 'posh' nurseries

the manager/owner of it drives a Quattroporte

make of that what you will
He spends most of his time in a courtesy car ?

98elise

32,891 posts

192 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
adrewleck said:
£100+ for 2 days?? I'm in the wrong job frown
Mental isn't it. The staff will be on minumum wage.

iwantagta

Original Poster:

1,324 posts

176 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
London John said:
FM, end of.
Must be being slow - what does FM mean?

iwantagta

Original Poster:

1,324 posts

176 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
How does a burst water main come under the reasons for closure stated in their terms? If it was due to the cold then this isn't inclement unless it is far outside of what you would expect for the time of year. Freezing conditions are known as 'Winter'.

I would argue this one if it were me. They will argue that the closure wasn't their fault, which is true, but they should reclaim the sum from the property owner.
This is how I see it. Unfortunately she has now decided that it isn't worth rocking the boat as it is the most convenient nursery and she doesn't want to ruin her relationship with the local staff for £100.

Thanks for all responses.