RTA liability dispute
Author
Discussion

welshjon81

Original Poster:

742 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Hi all,

I was involved in a prang this morning on the way into work where the other driver was 100% to blame but he is disputing it.

Here's what happened:

We both tried to exit a round about at the same time onto the same road. The exit from the round about had two lanes, left and right. I exited from the left hand lane of the roundabout into the left hand lane of the exit and the other guy exited from the right hand lane of the round about but instead of exiting into the right hand lane of the exit, cut straight across and into my car damaging the wing mirror and causing scratches and a big dent to my drivers side door and wheel arch.

He is disputing this by saying HE was in the left lane??

But if HE was in the left lane then where was I and how have I got scratches and damage to the drivers side of my car??

Anyway my question is have any of you been involved in an accident where it was clearly the other persons fault but they have argued the case? I'm just after a bit of experience and knowledge of what to expect.

Thanks,

Jon

iva cosworth

44,044 posts

194 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Speed plod and law forum required here.smile

Magic919

14,590 posts

232 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
And a map/picture. Red car versus blue car.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Any witnesses ?

welshjon81

Original Poster:

742 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
The only witnesses were other drivers and none stuck around as were busy with their own problems.. frown

LeeMad

1,098 posts

184 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
it'll go 50/50 I'm afraid

JohnSW20

886 posts

268 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Had a similar one, I was in the right hand lane he was in the left on a straight road. Up ahead it goes down to one lane. He decides I may pass him bare in mind this was central London so only doing 20 mph max. he just pulled into the right hand lane pushing me on to a traffic island and hitting my front wing.

I took pictures of the road impact point showing his rear light glass on my side of the road impact point on traffic island road layout everything I could.

He said it was my fault I said his the insurance in these cases tend to just go knock for knock. I didn't claim as it was only scratches to mine but his rear end was ruined!!

TLandCruiser

2,885 posts

229 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I think what compels the problem more these days is so many insurance companies are all part of the same broker so where as insurance companies use to seem to want to argue about it they seem more than happy to just settle 50/50. Maybe cheaper for them with dealing the issue too...who knows! biggrin

dazzztay

447 posts

212 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
So while a decent chap was going about his morning commute, negotiating a roundabout you caned it underneath him on his exit, misjudging his speed and smashed into the left hand side of his car?

Sounds 50/50
50% your fault / 50% not his fault!

Learn to drive, asshole!

smile

edcs

1,452 posts

201 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
It sounds like you found out why it's a bad idea to undertake/overtake/pass someone on a roundabout.

To answer your question though, someone drove into me at a roundabout and disputed it trying to argue 50/50. They soon gave up when they received a court summons as I was suing him for my uninsured losses and my insurance company was suing him for the repair costs to my car.

Boydie88

3,283 posts

180 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
In a similar situation that seems like it will end up in court. Waiting at some lights to join a roundabout, they go green, I proceed, see a guy jump the lights to my right and hit the back quarter of my driver side. His insurance have made up their own statement as he can't be arsed to make one and completely ignored the fact the traffic lights were in operation. I'm going to be livid when it ends up 50/50... this is now 17 months after the incident too.

Good luck.

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

188 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Do I understand this correctly?

You were going left to right, he was going right to left, and you met in the middle?

If so, 50:50.

welshjon81

Original Poster:

742 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Boydie88 said:
In a similar situation that seems like it will end up in court. Waiting at some lights to join a roundabout, they go green, I proceed, see a guy jump the lights to my right and hit the back quarter of my driver side. His insurance have made up their own statement as he can't be arsed to make one and completely ignored the fact the traffic lights were in operation. I'm going to be livid when it ends up 50/50... this is now 17 months after the incident too.

Good luck.
Yeah pretty much this but without the lights.



Me exiting in the left lane, him in the right but he smashes straight into the side of me...

Good luck too!

The Nur

9,168 posts

216 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Is that the Asda roundabout in Swansea? They have really screwed that one up lately, wasn't at all surprised when I scrolled down and saw the picture.

Hope it gets sorted for you.

welshjon81

Original Poster:

742 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
The Nur said:
Is that the Asda roundabout in Swansea? They have really screwed that one up lately, wasn't at all surprised when I scrolled down and saw the picture.

Hope it gets sorted for you.
Ah a fellow Welshman! Yes it is. I work in Llansamlet. Thanks.

The Nur

9,168 posts

216 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
welshjon81 said:
Ah a fellow Welshman! Yes it is. I work in Llansamlet. Thanks.
No problem, if you see a blue e36 with a lacquer peel bonnet give me a beep and a wave biggrin

What car were you driving when you had the incident?

welshjon81

Original Poster:

742 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
The Nur said:
welshjon81 said:
Ah a fellow Welshman! Yes it is. I work in Llansamlet. Thanks.
No problem, if you see a blue e36 with a lacquer peel bonnet give me a beep and a wave biggrin

What car were you driving when you had the incident?
Will do. I was in a black 09 Fiesta Zetec S.. I like to keep it clean but now its a mess frown

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Ive been in an almost identical situation and had it called 50-50 by the insurers.
It is utterly infuriating and I can relate to your forthcoming frustration

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I'd put money on the story changing to "I was in the right-hand lane exiting the roundabout when Welshjon drove into me".

50-50 I reckon with no witnesses.

Osito

56 posts

175 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I had an accident where I was on a roundabout and someone hit the rear of my car as they were changing lane to get off the roundabout. How they did that I have no idea. However, they simply said that I had changed lane and drove into them. Blatant lie. The damage seemed consistent with either explanation, and if I'm honest, the third party's position seems more believable, because it's hard to believe that ANYONE would drive they way this guy did.

Anyway, there were no witnesses, and my insurance company advised me to accept 50-50, which I did.